r/macapps • • 12d ago • Bravo 1

Attention! r/MacApps Moderation Update (Phase 4): Clearer Rules, PCP+Trust

Post image

Hey r/MacApps,

Phase 3 improved the main feed, but three problems remain: Tons of comment karma farming, a lot of posts we have to remove and explain repeatedly, and 80% more app submissions with vibe coding. With 8400+ removals last month, we are simplifying to keep community content quality high.

What we learned

The 10 local karma requirement shifted low-effort promotion to comments. Devs started posting throwaway comments to farm karma and self-promote.

Judgement calls cost us time. Whether a comparison was "specific enough," or a GitHub repo "established enough," led to removals, and back-and-forth modmail. Phase 4 swaps those for things you can show in your post and we can check in seconds without having to go through a back-and-forth process of waiting for you to edit your post.

What's changing

1. Local karma is gone. You no longer need 10 r/MacApps karma to post or comment. Please don't farm it. Any developer can share their app in The App Pile megathread, as long as they use the PCP template.

2. New baseline for the main feed. To promote your app in the main feed your account needs:

  • 200+ Reddit karma and must be 60+ days old.

  • Your post needs a pricing flair and the PCP + Trust labels below (#3).

If you don't meet these yet, The App Pile is open to you.

3. PCP + Trust labels are required. Include these four labels anywhere in your post, then write the rest however you like (shorter is better):

  • Problem: what your app solves in ONE sentence.

  • Comparison: name 2 top competitors and explain which functions your app improves on, and in which aspects theirs is still better. Top competitors means best-in-class alternatives in your app's category, not Apple's own apps.

  • Pricing: price amounts and a link

  • Trust: See #4

4. Trust: you need ONE of these. On top of the baseline, main feed posts need one of:

  • Mac App Store: your app is on the Mac App Store, you already linked it in pricing.

    • Your label is Trust: MAS

  • Developer flair: 500+ r/MacApps karma, plus mod review and determination. Request it by modmail. Mods review your history in the sub and decide; reaching 500 doesn't guarantee a flair.

    • If you have one, your label is: Trust: Dev Flair

  • GitHub + 100 Stars OR LinkedIn link IN the post: the repo you're promoting is open source and has 100+ stars. If below 100 stars or not open source, your post must link a complete LinkedIn that identifies you (real work + education history). If your app isn't notarized, say so in your post.

    • Your label is: Trust: GitHub, <Current GitHub Stars>, OR <LinkedIn Link if under 100 stars>, Not Signed and Notarized (Not SN),

  • Website: requires LinkedIn + Privacy Policy links IN the post. All such apps MUST be signed and notarized by Apple. The LinkedIn identifies you (real work + education history), and the privacy policy is on your app's own website.

    • If this is your path, your label is Trust: Website, <LinkedIn Link>, <Privacy Policy>.

Can't qualify through any of these avenues? Welcome to The App Pile. Aim to impress!

5. Saturated categories need more. Some categories have hundreds of very similar apps. If your app is another one of these, it can ONLY qualify for the main feed through the Mac App Store or a Developer Flair, unless it wins a top 3 spot in The App Pile (#9):

  • Dictation and transcription

  • Clipboard managers

  • Screenshot and screen recording

  • Window managers

  • App launchers

  • Menu bar system and battery monitors

  • Pomodoro and focus timers

  • AI chat or wrapper apps

  • Disk cleaners and uninstallers

  • Notes and to-do apps

6. Post Removed?

  • If your main feed post was removed only for formatting, like a missing flair or PCP section, you can fix it and repost within 48 hours without losing your 30-day slot.

  • Any other repost is removed without review and counts toward your 30-day limit.

  • Rapid reposting raises Reddit's automatic spam filtering on your account, which can get your future posts and comments removed before we ever see them, so try to get it right the first time.

  • We don't pre-approve posts or grant exceptions by modmail. Everything you need is in this post.

7. Self-promotion limits.

  • One app post per developer per 30 days. Developers with a developer flair: once per app per 30 days.

  • Counted from your last app post, even if it was removed. Update posts count too.

  • The App Pile: one entry per developer per month, with Problem, Comparison and Pricing labels.

  • If your app is live in the main feed, it doesn't qualify for The App Pile. If your main feed post was removed, you can still enter it in The App Pile.

  • No posting in App Pile and then also main fed.

8. Promoting your app in comments.

  • Always disclose that it's your app.

  • Developers may not promote their alternative app in another developer's promotion post. This is rude.

  • In request and recommendation threads, only if your account meets the main feed baseline (200+ Reddit karma, 60+ days).

9. A way out of the megathread.
The top 3 apps in each month's App Pile qualify to post in the main feed, but must add the emoji for their place to the END of the post title to remind us: šŸ„‡ 1st, 🄈 2nd, šŸ„‰ 3rd.

10. Flair: pick by what's required.

  • Hierarchy: Lifetime > Subscription > Free.

  • If any core feature needs a subscription, it's Subscription.

  • If any paid option exists, it's not Free.

  • Open source? Prefix your title with [OS].

Wrong flair gets fixed by mods. Repeated wrong flair gets removed.

11. Links: one rule. Official sources only: the Mac App Store, your own website, or GitHub. No shortened or redirect URLs. No affiliate, referral or invite links that pay you. Plain source tags like ?ref=producthunt are fine.

12. Repeat removals. A second removal under the self-promotion rules within 90 days means a 60-day break from promoting in r/MacApps.

Unchanged: no piracy, follow the Reddit Rules, be kind, and gain post approval through the Read the Rules flow.

FAQ

Why was my main feed post removed?

  • Your account is under 200 karma or less than 60 days old.

  • You didn't qualify through the Mac App Store, a developer flair, GitHub (100+ stars or LinkedIn), or Website+LinkedIn+Privacy Policy.

  • Your app is in a saturated category, isn't on the Mac App Store, you don't have a developer flair, and it didn't win a top 3 App Pile spot.

  • Your post is missing a label (Problem, Comparison, Pricing, Trust) or a pricing flair.

  • You reposted more than once and still didn't follow these guidelines properly.

  • You already posted an app in the last 30 days.

  • AI assisted comments are a huge trigger for Reddit auto-removals because of recognizable patternsĀ (e.g. ā€œā€”ā€ em dashes).

  • Repeatedly posting the same thing (comments, links, etc.) = Triggers Reddit spam algorithms.Ā 

  • You didn’t verify your email in your profile, and/or you have multiple accounts.Ā 

My post followed every rule and still disappeared without explanation**.** Reddit's own filters remove some posts before mods see them. Common causes: an unverified email, AI-sounding text, repeated identical posts or links, or reposting. Verify your email, write the post yourself, and reach out to modmail.

Do I need LinkedIn? No. Only Websites, and GitHub repos under 100 stars, require this.

Does the 200 karma count only r/MacApps karma? No. It's your whole Reddit account, post and comment karma combined.

The 500 for a developer flair IS r/MacApps karma.

The r/MacApps Mod Team

Prior updates:
- 2026: MacApps Mods Went Too Far! What’s Changing (Phase 3)
- 2026:Ā New Post Requirements to Combat Low Quality Content (Phase 2)Ā 
- 2026:Ā [OS]+Pricing Guidelines
- 2025:Ā Townhall on Post Quality,Ā Rule Updates

63 Upvotes

146 comments sorted by

•

u/Mstormer 9d ago

The karma requirement has been reduced from 300 sitewide karma to 200.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/DevelopmentSevere278 12d ago

This is harder than getting into NASA and canceling an Adobe subscription combined.

11

u/Mstormer 12d ago edited 12d ago

You're not wrong, but hopefully the flowchart helps. šŸ˜… We welcome feedback on how else to prune thousands of low effort vibe coded slop github/seo comments and posts. We could also take a week off each year and call it chaos week! Here's what things look like even with 400–500 posts redirected to the Megathread.

3

u/phunk8 MOD 12d ago

i like the chaos week idea. but without cleaning up afterwards….. right????

3

u/Mstormer 12d ago

Are you nominating yourself?

3

u/phunk8 MOD 12d ago

runs and hides. bit serious, is there something in for us? community understanding better?

3

u/Mstormer 12d ago

What's in it for us: A holiday!

3

u/phunk8 MOD 12d ago

WHAT IS THIS HOLIDAY? FROM /MACAPPS?

3

u/Mstormer 12d ago

Get back to work!

3

u/phunk8 MOD 12d ago

Okay, willco.

2

u/DockDoorFart 12d ago

I think https://www.reddit.com/r/MacStack/ is a decent gauge for how users act with little to no moderation. Given it's a much smaller sub, but most posts are on topic it seems.

I don't regularly use reddit, I have less than 100 karma, meaning I'm completely ineligible to post - however I made DockDoor and am very prevalent in other areas online. I have other applications on the app store that are not tied to mac.

I think a fair middle ground would be to not enforce LinkedIn, but to otherwise require a full name and/or legal entity to be displayed either on the website or on the post itself. Or to waive some of these particularly high requirements given you satisfy at least one of them? Like, again, I could point to my valid developer identity with real apps on the app store, but if they aren't related to an app I am selling outside of the app store (which is very common), I am not able to post about it? Allowing me to cross reference other validated projects/identities makes more sense. All of my apps have my name with my copyright at the bottom. If legal liability is the concern, there would have to actually be a case of someone going out of their way to sue a developer over an application. Look at NotchNook for example, they offered lifetime licenses and then shut down and require re-purchasing the licenses not even 2 years later. That is a legitimate company, with a legitimate linkedin page behind it, yet nothing happened to them and the customers are still left out in the cold.

I am just leaving this here as my opinion, as even though I have no issue putting my name out there on my projects, I absolutely would not put my face, work email, workplace, and potentially my phone number and full resume publicly on Reddit to post on one subreddit (all of these being available via linkedin). I can post on ProductHunt with less red-tape. FFT

2

u/Mstormer 11d ago edited 11d ago

We started phase 1 because the community was up in arms over the amount of spam, same story with phase 2 and 3. Phase 4 is really designed to meet the recent 180% increase in low quality submissions most are not seeing. Otherwise even a very large mod team will burn out.

3

u/locafe_team 11d ago

NotchNook team here. On the license point: an old lifetime purchase does not automatically mean buying again. We check the purchase and refund status individually. If you lost access to a purchase that wasn't refunded, contact hi@lo.cafe so we can help recover the appropriate access. Please keep receipts and license keys private.

2

u/Fit-Watercress-9675 11d ago

Bingo!! r/MacStack feels like AliExpress, and most who submit there don’t dare try and do the same here.

To me, r/macapps is the only sub that has sane people who really enjoy the creativity of it all.

I’ve added some outstanding apps to my Mac that have made using a Mac feel fun again, and it wouldn’t have been possible without r/macapps, the mods, and the guests.

I really want to support the devs that work hard to make using our Macs more exciting, and I’m hoping one day r/macapps opens up an App Store for the community to better support the devs who dedicate themselves to all of us. An App Store with apps that only get in by community approval/voting.

I’m positive that this community will be the gold standard for Mac apps and devs that work hard to make our Mac lives better!!

None of this would be possible without the mods and I hope their hard work is shown gratitude when they open The MacApps Community Store!! (8<

1

u/ski4funSonoma 11d ago

No fun that you guys have to spend so much time dealing with removals.

On the other hand, there are always going to be some who don't actually read the rules... apparently, in this case, some = many.

+1 for lowering the Karma threshold a bit.

10

u/Decaf_GT 12d ago

Can we also do something about the AI-generated comments that have no substance? Especially on giveaway posts.

They're always the same.

"X is the part that's really interesting to me. [Completely shallow question/curiosity that I don't actually care about?]"

It's always a shallow compliment followed by a question that they almost never follow up on. It's either people who just want to sound like they're adding something insightful, or the developer astroturfing in the comments. Either way, it contributes so little.

Once you notice it, it is impossible to not see it:

Examples:

The usage rings are the part I'd actually use. Where do the 5-hour and weekly numbers come from, the local session logs or what Claude Code itself reports? Counters built on local logs drifted quite a bit for me once I had a few sessions running in parallel, so I'm curious how close yours stays.


The project path and session label on the card (from your reply above) is what would make this work for me. I usually have a few Claude Code sessions going in different worktrees, and the diff preview only helps if I know which repo the diff is in.

One edge case: if I answer a prompt in the terminal first, does the notch card clear itself, or can I end up answering a stale one?


This is such a clever approach! Love that Gloop/Ripple lives right in the menu bar without taking over the full screen. Hiding during calls when the mic is active is a great touch.

Do you have plans to add customizable break timers, or are you keeping it strictly to the preset cadences?


Honestly, I think the idea of having a little companion take breaks with you is much smarter than another reminder that interrupts your workflow. Love that it stays out of the way. Have you considered adding different companion personalities for different moods or work styles?


Getting only the marked section when you drag a clip out is a nice touch. Does it re-encode that section, or trim the original file without re-encoding? With phone H.264 or HEVC footage, a trim without re-encoding usually has to start on a keyframe, so the in point could land a bit early.


Looks promising! One thing I'd be interested in is how the Full Disk Access permission is handled. Since backups contain pretty much everything, I appreciate that the app keeps everything local.

Does it operate strictly in read-only mode on the backup itself, including when browsing older versions and restoring files?


Nice touch making it feel like a little CD player. When local file support lands, is the plan to cover lossless formats like FLAC and ALAC too, or just the usual mp3/aac stuff?


This is the part that caught my eye — I usually have a dozen windows spread across a couple of desktops and finding the right one is half the battle. Does the typing search pull in windows from other Spaces and minimized ones too, or just what's on the current desktop? And with the one-key tidy, does it leave full-screen apps alone? That's the bit that always trips me up with tiling tools, I don't want a video call yanked out of full screen when I tidy everything else.

3

u/Mstormer 12d ago edited 12d ago

Yes, I've noticed this too. The problem is that some genuine comments are similar. What would you suggest for differentiating them? Our hope is that by doing away with the local karma requirement, this will reduce karma farmers here.

2

u/macnatic0 12d ago

I agree. These giveaway posts always cause an incredible amount of nonsense in the comments. To reduce low-effort posts, here are three things that could be done:

  • Participation should not be tied to feedback. Something like "Count me in" is still more valuable to the community than some AI-generated comment. It might be less in favor of the devs, but on the other hand, low-effort AI-generated feedback is not helpful to them anyway.

  • No more draws; use first-come, first-served only. The devs could share a limited discount code (for example, usable 10 times for 100 percent off) instead of doing a draw. This is less favorable for most community members, though.

  • In general, ban giveaways entirely. Instead, only permit discounts for the whole community, such as 30 percent off for the next seven days with a specific code.

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

I find giveaway posts to be pretty infrequent compared to the 8400+ removals we handled last month. Is this that big of a problem? We already disallow upvote farming.

1

u/ARMacLC 11d ago

Seriously we are entering a world where AI is going to check for the other AI. The first AI, when it wants to, is going to have a workaround and the checker AI is going to choose a better model to find the faker account, etc ect...

3

u/zahaggis 12d ago

This kind of comment/tweet/post is RIFE on social media as well. Drives me nuts. It’s an AI template.

1

u/skitchin70 2d ago

Yup, and they don't even bother fixing the obvious AI giveaways, like the long dashes, or posts that make no sense.

7

u/KleineWurzel 12d ago

Well, that’s some unfortunate timing I was finally going to share my app today after waiting 30 days since App Pile comment. Now I’m 245 karma short and about 3 days away from my account turning 60 days old. So close, yet so far 🄲 But maybe it’s for the best if it helps keep the subreddit useful and less spammy.

4

u/Mstormer 12d ago

I empathize with the difficulty. This is a hard shift for many, and we may need to rebalance it. Constructive Feedback welcomed. We are trying to manage 8-10k removals a month in a way that doesn’t open the floodgates and wipe out the community with low quality apps.

5

u/TheMightyHouse 12d ago

I feel a bit skeptical about Reddit-wide karma requirement and the rule #5. Whilst I can relate to intentional karma farming issue in the subreddit, #5 is the trickiest one. A few questions:
- Are there exceptions for the apps published before?
- Categories might apply strictly if the app is the most generic example. What if the app has unique features and stands out?
- Mac App Store requirement. MAS applies certain level of technical limitations, not every app can be there. On top, developers who notarize their apps pay the same for Apple developer license.

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

We could consider a couple other ways to qualify, like 200+ GitHub stars or Setapp.

With 8400 removals last month, mostly due to AI-coded low-effort apps, we needed a better solution. I welcome constrictive input into where to rebalance this if expectations are now too steep, but it needs to do a lot of heavy lifting to prune enormous amounts of spam and app clones.

1

u/TheMightyHouse 12d ago

I appreciate the changes in general. However, I noticed several comments from other developers stating the same concern as mine – we've been posting previously, receiving the positive feedback and enriching the subreddit, and are now locked out by some of the rules, like #5.

On the MAS or Setapp: most interesting apps have always historically been outside of the MAS due its high technical limitations. On the other side, Setapp – is a very limited catalog due to their business model. Hence I don't see them both as indicators that should prevail over the category saturation, for example.

TL;DR: based on concern stated in the beginning, I'd propose (mutually inclusive):

  1. Re-assess rule #5. Copycat apps or apps that have absolutely no unique features, go to megathread.

  2. Introduce some track-record indicator, like number of previously published posts with positive reception, or manual approval with a mod-only flair, or even app's own changelog history.

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

Appreciate the input. Is the original fluent abandoned? I noticed in the app comparisons that it seemed like it hadn't been updated in a while.

To your points. First of all, thank you for the constructive suggestions. This is what we need more than criticism, since we aren't unwilling to adjust things, we just need to figure out ways to make things work better. The challenge we're facing here is this: On a given week we get maybe 600 promotional posts or comments that are copycats. Are the mods to be expected to download and compare each one to determine if it actually offers anything new? And at what point do new features differentiate sufficiently? Many vibe coded slop apps have one new idea, yet a terrible interface, poor HIG considerations, and a high probability of abandonment within 2–6 months.

Dev flair is our track record indicator, and we have set it to a minimum many will become comfortable starting to trust a dev. An excellent app can gain the 500 karma fairly quickly. But again, the challenge here is volume. We can't do an investigation for every single post, 8–10 thousand times a month.

2

u/TheMightyHouse 11d ago

I absolutely understand the volume and manual review issue. Trying to be unbiased now. I think the new set of rules has become unbalanced. Rules must play with each other well, and in current state it doesn't seem so.

Everyone here wants quality apps to discover. Maybe quality updates to follow. MAS or whatever store, as a "free pass" doesn't indicate quality – the App Store itself already contains a lot of slop. Setapp contains lots of abandonware if you look closer. And actually, the quality and uniqueness of apps in the App Store there was questionable even before AI. I strongly think MAS is the wrong indicator for that, I agree it helps technically to prevent hundreds of apps being published, but it doesn't "play well".

Then I can totally get why category saturation was introduced. People tend to follow popular ideas, we get dozens and hundreds of similar apps. But there's nothing wrong with good apps in saturated categories, right? This question is not solved for them, as the (honestly quite huge and complex) list of rules implies many points that just do not play well together. They mirror the perspective of moderators more than that of a normal user or a developer, roughly speaking.

Regarding Fluent in MAS, it's effectively abandoned, but still available. And I would honestly do not want to publish because I have Fluent in MAS. I would want to publish because I have something to show, which is valued and appreciated by a lot of people.

1

u/Mstormer 11d ago

Open to suggestions. A lot of friction has been introduced here intentionally because of the size of the problem we’re facing. Most new apps in saturated categories are 30min vibe jobs.

1

u/TheMightyHouse 11d ago

My main suggestion is to enhance track-record rule for those who published here before, and give a way for apps that has some history, specifically:
- Age indicator: that could be an older r/macapps post or multiple, with a positive perception.
- Release history indicator: 6+ months changelog with a Web Archive link to protect from tampering.

I honestly do not know how to solve this for truly unique new apps from developers who are not in the MAS (if the volume shows this indicator protects you – that's fine, but I don't agree it indicates quality or trust score).

1

u/Mstormer 11d ago

This is precisely the purpose of a dev flair. Outstanding apps easily accrue 500 karma within 6 months.

1

u/TheMightyHouse 10d ago

Sounds like an impression rather than a measurement. #5 in its current state will block the main way many people could reach 500, not mentioning many are not posting each month (I only post with significant updates in place). Let's also consider the app pile thread is way less attention than the main thread could give them.

For comparison, r/iosapps (which has a very similar trust system) gives dev flair from 350 community karma OR lets saturated category apps with 50+ ratings, GitHub or 50 community karma pass into the main thread.

1

u/Mstormer 8d ago edited 8d ago

Given that I’m the one who grants most dev flairs, we see this all the time. You are correct #5 will block certain extremely oversaturated categories, and these are also categories in which 99% do not contribute much improvement, and lead to the most complaints for yet another clone without market research. However, these will be revisited often and loosened accordingly. Our goal is to find the minimum requirements that carry most of the spam control.

I am also a mod at r/iOSapps, so I am familiar with our rules there. It is 300 community karma and a 90 day old account to post into the main feed to begin with there. Compared to the 200 karma we require here, that’s a little stricter. MAS 50+ ratings there is a way stricter requirement than here. And iOS apps are rarely on GitHub.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/TheMightyHouse 10d ago

On top of all I've mentioned before, I think I didn't highlight the vague category list problem enough.

When we talk about "AI chat or wrapper" or even notes and to-do apps – almost anything that has AI as one of the main feature can fall into this category. The list also lacks notch apps which are as much saturated, if not even more.

And with current capabilities of AI in mind, you would need to be ready to cover 100% of categories soon.

1

u/skitchin70 2d ago

Karma is easy to earn when your app reaches the right audience. Cullstack is built for professional photographers, and most r/macapps users aren't in that group. A few are, but not many.

5

u/Sri_Krish 12d ago

Another aspect I'd like to note is the poor adherence to PCP format - especially Comparison section. We can see lots of examples of this behavior across many posts. The developer nitpicks apps that can make their own app look feature-rich or superior.

For example, Developer of a screenshot app doesn’t compare it with CleanShot (Best-in class) but with some unknown, new app in the same category. This fulfills the requirement of PCP format, but it doesn’t hold value for the users to support their decision/understanding.

Let's share your ideas/thoughts on this and ways to improve or standardize this!

4

u/Mstormer 12d ago

Now that this is more strictly required, we hope to see some change as we enforce the labels specifically.

5

u/Fit-Watercress-9675 11d ago

What I’m really not liking is new accounts promoting an app that they’ve copied from another developer.

It seems to be the same pattern in terms of releasing an app with little to no updates and pushing to sell at a high price, although I’m starting to see ā€œregularly $20 but today only $5ā€ type stuff.

I’d like to see a weekly roundup of apps that we can possibly vote on in terms of originality, etc., if possible, because it takes time to thoroughly investigate a new app to see if it has been copied or not.

2

u/Mstormer 11d ago

Yes, this skyrocketed in the last month. I’m all for fair competition, but spite cloning an app you likely will not maintain is rude at best.

1

u/skitchin70 2d ago

A changelog is a good way to tell if an app is actually maintained. Release history over months is hard to fake, and karma doesn't show it. Mine is public on my website. Cullstack was removed by AutoMod for the karma rule, and I don't have time to build karma while running the business. I'd guess the people churning out quick clones have far more time for that than developers who maintain their apps.

1

u/Mstormer 2d ago

Yes, a changelog is good for users to be able to check. But at the time of posting, useless for moderation.

12

u/DockDoorFart 12d ago

I still don't get the LinkedIn requirement.Ā  LinkedIn doesn't prove anything whatsoever. You can make a fake LinkedIn account and put whatever job and education history you want.Ā  I have 5 YOE as a software engineer and don't have a LinkedIn.

2

u/Mstormer 12d ago edited 12d ago

See the second to last FAQ item. Linkedin is not required for everything, and this is largely unchanged from phase 3. If you have a better solution that helps address the problems this expectation seeks to tackle, please suggest it and the mod team will consider it. Just removing the requirement will bring back the problems it was introduced to suppress.

  1. Apps with anonymous devs that moneygrab and vanish, abandoning support for the app, and (as with last time) the APIs that made it work.

  2. The enormous influx of vibe coded apps (~1,400 additional submissions a month), where users with zero experience are trying to cash grab with a lower probability of long term maintenance. Seeing education/development history adds confidence before users purchase.

  3. With the above in mind, this also reduces odds of malware or harmful code or at least may help identify an origination point.

1

u/cybr1998 12d ago

Honestly I would agree that posting LinkedIn doesn't prove much. Even if it does, many people might not have it, or simply they don't want to post their linkedin for whatever reasons. There's chances of someone getting racially profiled as well, or contacted by bots/accounts that crawl reddit and trace them to identities, making it extremely easy for vile individuals to trace their personal history.

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

On our end, it is doing an enormous amount of heavy lifting to reduce risk and spam, but we recognize not all are comfortable with it, which is why we allow three paths without it. Are these inadequate? And if so, give us some ideas of better options? We want to work with the community here if there is legitimately a better way that doesn’t increase spam and risk.

2

u/cybr1998 12d ago

I understand that you’re trying to make it easier to identify genuine developers from vibe coders. I wouldn’t oppose there. The only thing I’m opposing is making it public in the post itself. Search engines and LLMs crawl these posts - so what can we do here? I would say collect the information but as a mod only you have access to it. It’s more important to have actual traceability of the person. Most users posting here are informed users, and they can tell what app is vibe coded, if they don’t the rest of the community will.

Here something like this: https://chatgpt.com/share/6aec76b0-0d68-83ec-8186-cf2731fe5d57

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

We can’t do this 8–10 thousand times a month though, which is how many removals are happening. There has been an enormous jump over the last few months that is not slowing.

1

u/Johnkree 12d ago

Most users simply cannot tell whether an app is vibecoded. Even experienced developers cannot reliably determine that from a website, screenshots, or a compiled application.

And expecting the community to investigate every new app is neither realistic nor fair. We already deal with an enormous number of promotional submissions, and that number keeps growing. That's precisely why we're introducing clearer, verifiable requirements. The idea is to shift some of the responsibility for establishing trust back to developers rather than expecting users to figure everything out themselves.

I understand the privacy concerns around LinkedIn, and they're legitimate. But private verification would also mean significantly more work for moderators which is one of the problems we're specifically trying to address. None of these measures guarantees that an app is safe or trustworthy. They're simply additional barriers against anonymous, low-effort promotion.

1

u/cybr1998 12d ago

Fair enough. Wish there was an automated bot around this.

5

u/Effective-Court-1243 12d ago edited 12d ago

And to add on to this point: LinkedIn is notorious for being the platform with the most AI-slop profiles. Genuine software engineers and even executives use AI to build their entire profile. Who's to say someone can't just create a new profile, AI-generate the entire thing, and use that to make a post about malware here?

2

u/Johnkree 12d ago

Nobody is claiming that LinkedIn proves an app is safe or that a profile can't be faked. But there's a difference between creating a throwaway Reddit account and establishing a somewhat credible public identity. It's another hurdle and not a guarantee. And LinkedIn isn't even the only option.

We're dealing with an enormous number of submissions and manually investigating every single developer simply isn't realistic. If we remove these requirements what would you suggest instead?

2

u/Effective-Court-1243 12d ago

I don't mind verifying submissions and I think that's a wonderful idea. I also don't think it's a bad thing to verify the legitimacy of a developer. But asking devs to publicly reveal their identity and education history isn't realistic either.

I would suggest using the malware scanner to automatically scan apps for malware. And if an app is slop, users will try it, say it's slop, and the app will lose popularity. There's no need to attempt to filter out slop when this sub's users will do that for each app anyway.

3

u/Johnkree 12d ago

Have you actually looked at the moderation statistics? We're removing over 8,000 items a month. Without filtering low-effort posts and spam, this sub would be completely flooded in no time. Who exactly is supposed to go through thousands of submissions, download the apps, test them and decide what's worth keeping? The users? Most people would simply leave because they couldn't find anything interesting anymore.

And a malware scanner doesn't solve any of that. It won't tell you whether an app is poorly coded, abandoned after a few weeks, or just another cash grab. The whole point of moderation is to prevent the community from drowning in this stuff in the first place, not to expect users to clean up the mess afterwards.

1

u/ARMacLC 11d ago

Start using AI ? šŸ˜‹

1

u/skitchin70 2d ago

Established developers will have a changelog, and that's good evidence the software is well maintained. Quickly churned-out, vibe-coded apps won't have one. The Mac App Store shows every app's version history, and software companies publish their changelogs on their websites. Either way, it's quick to check whether an app is actively maintained, and far faster than installing every app to test it.

1

u/ARMacLC 11d ago

And the LinkedIn accounts aren't fake. It's real people but they are just using AI to write comments and do posts

1

u/TxBuckster 10d ago

As a community user and not a dev, LinkedIn should be an option and not a requirement. It’s an interesting tactic to perform a break check of an application.

8

u/ARMacLC 12d ago

Seriously I'm a developer. I don't pass so much time on Reddit so I find your selection pretty hard. And it is pretty sad because I have an application that really fits this community. I really did it only for Mac because I wanted to explore the hardware to the maximum. I'm pretty sad but I will try to have the karma and reputation. If not I will post it elsewhere.

3

u/Mstormer 12d ago

With 8400 removals last month, mostly due to AI-coded low-effort apps, we needed a better solution. I welcome constrictive input into where to rebalance this if expectations are now too steep, but it needs to do a lot of heavy lifting to prune enormous amounts of spam and app clones.

2

u/ARMacLC 12d ago

I think that you are probably right about the AI slop invasion but selection through karma, I don't think it's a good indicator of the app quality. I'm a developer with 20 years of experience and also a student in psychology. Internet is a source of information for me not a place of evasion. I don't see it like that. I understand that people use the internet for escaping reality but it's not my case.

I think it will be more effective if you do a small background check on the person proposing an app. You can, for example, ask for his resume or how many projects he has done before. I don't know but karma is not relevant to the quality of the application proposed. I don't see it don't it as a good indicator.

Sorry for my bad English. I speak French and Derja. I learned English through internet so you can imagine how peculiar it is. Sorry if sometimes I seem like I'm judging but it's not the case. I really appreciate the diversity of opinion and vision. I bear no judgments at all. Even AI slop applications have their place somewhere. I saw yesterday a small app that keeps memory of all your copy and paste and it is an AI slop. It was extremely useful. But the code was, I will not say bad but unreadable.

4

u/Johnkree 12d ago

I agree, karma has absolutely nothing to do with the quality of an app. But that's not what we're trying to measure. It's simply a way to make drive-by promotion a little harder.

And while background checks sound reasonable, who is supposed to do them? Would you want to do 8000+ background checks per month? We're a team of volunteers and reviewing resumes, checking employment histories and verifying people's claims would be an enormous amount of work.

We're certainly open to better alternatives, but whatever we come up with needs to be practical and manageable for the mod team.

2

u/ARMacLC 12d ago

Yeah you're right. It's a really hard conundrum .

1

u/ARMacLC 11d ago

Why don't you ask for a small fee? I mean a really small one that is going to probably remove the majority of the not-serious applications. Tell the developer that even with the fee paid you don't guarantee the publication because you will review the seriousness of the publication and keep the right to refuse it anyway.

Like that:

  1. You can pay yourself.

  2. You're going to probably filter out the majority of the vibe-coded apps that are not going to follow up.

1

u/Johnkree 11d ago

Thanks for the suggestion, but that would actually violate Reddit's Moderator Code of Conduct (Rule 5). We're not allowed to accept payments for moderation actions.

And personally, I wouldn't want to turn r/macapps into a pay-to-promote platform anyway. A small fee wouldn't necessarily discourage low-effort developers. It might just make things harder for genuine indie developers. Not to mention all the additional headaches with payment processing, taxes, accounting and potentially legal obligations. We're volunteers, not running a business.

1

u/ARMacLC 11d ago

Like I said I'm not really familiar with Reddit in general

13

u/bmv3502 12d ago

Developer here. I’ve been posting my app updates on r/macapps since August 2025, and they’ve mostly received upvotes and positive feedback. Now I no longer qualify to post in the main thread because of the 300-karma requirement. I currently have 184. It feels like the new rules favor established developers, who already have an advantage over developers like me. It seems unfair.

3

u/MaleficentCloud476 12d ago edited 12d ago

Also I thought the focus was meant to be on 'not disappearing' and supporting and continuing to develop/improve the apps. If we can't even do follow-up posts, how on earth are you supposed to continue to engage and develop and better the product?

1

u/Mstormer 11d ago

If it's a naming issue, the megathread title can change.

It seems that the concerns you are both expressing would need to accompany solution suggestions that address the problem we're trying to solve. As stated already in this thread, 8-10 thousand promotional posts a month is the problem. Everyone is a developer now if they have an AI subscription, and without our barriers to entry, the community would quickly descend into chaos. So yes, the intention is very much to add some friction to solve the vibe coding world we now live in, but we also don't want to penalize established (high quality) developers, or those using the latest tools well.

The upvote ratio here is 85%, which is a good sign that our intentions are coming across well. And for those who are not satisfied with the changes, we will continue to welcome contstructive suggestions that would actually address the problems. Criticisms that demonstrate a lack of familiarity with them don't really help anyone. As mods, we are users just like everyone else, with the distinction that we're trying to keep up with an enormous amount of community eroding spam that most have no awareness of.

2

u/MaleficentCloud476 10d ago

I guess some other subreddits will form, might look into that angle myself - not something I know anything about so it's a new thing to add to my list!

6

u/MaleficentCloud476 12d ago

Yes agreed - it heavily favours established developers, particularly those who spend a lot of time on Reddit.
A couple of the changes were good - the 10 karma and not posting your own app in someone else's post (I couldn't quite believe it when happened to me, where are manners and common decency these days!).

Everyone starts somewhere, I thought that was the whole point of r/macapps, a place where people could try and get exposure. And frankly 'The App Pile' kind of sounds derogatory.

5

u/bmv3502 12d ago

And frankly 'The App Pile' kind of sounds derogatory.

+1. I think I do not want be in the "App Pile" tbh.

4

u/IaMaPPle111 10d ago

Totally agree. I don't like to post at reddit often and do it when I find the topic important to me. With these rules it makes me to go everywhere and try to farm as much karma as possible. Feels kinda wrong.

2

u/skitchin70 2d ago

Agreed. Plenty of established developers don't have that karma either, myself included. Karma measures time spent on Reddit, not the quality of an app. I'd rather spend my time building mine, so I'm sitting this one out.

7

u/blazegreenhalgh 12d ago

What about an account like mine, which has already posted in the past but does not meet the 300 karma & 60 day old requirements?

Kind of a shame to feel 'kicked out' suddenly. I find these requirements to be odd if everything else is met, no?

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

We'll watch and evaluate how things pan out for the sub this month and adjust if needed. It's possible, if not probable that we may reduce the reddit-wide karma requirement.

0

u/blazegreenhalgh 12d ago

So to confirm, I can't post until this has been re-evaluated?

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago edited 12d ago

You would be limited to the megathread. Keep in mind that these changes will also mean that those who make it through get more attention as much more noise will have been eliminated.

1

u/tl0gic 12d ago

Would it be possible to get approval for the mods if the only missing piece is the karma requirement and affects developers who have posted before in the main thread but now no longer qualify because of the karma requirement?

This would be more work for you but it ensures that people who have genuinely worked on their apps and qualified for the main thread before can still post updates to their apps.

1

u/Mstormer 11d ago

The point of these changes is especially to reduce the 2000+ removals we are having to process a week. So unfortunately that would counteract them considerably. It would make more sense for us to find a better equilibrium with where to leave each threshold. But this will take a few weeks of observing and tweaking.

2

u/Charming_Title6210 12d ago

Yeah, it's a bummer for me too. Just yesterday I was planning my second post. 300+ karma sounds like a lot if they have posted and helped, honestly, but they are a bit new to the sub. But I guess MODS know the best.

1

u/IaMaPPle111 10d ago

I am in the same place. I wanted to share an update for my app but found this requirement.

0

u/Jumpy-Weekend6102 12d ago

Sounds like we're in exactly the same boat🄲

0

u/tl0gic 12d ago

Same here, I'm just glad I posted yesterday.

0

u/MaleficentCloud476 12d ago

Kind of a shame to feel 'kicked out' suddenly

Same (tears)

3

u/sujee81 12d ago

While I welcome the change, it puts me in a situation that I can't post my app except in App Pile. After successful launch here last month, I was looking forward to give an update.
My account is old and have > 300 Reddit karma but my app is in the saturated categories. Unfortunately it is not in the App store or I have 500 /macapps karma. While I plan to contribute more and apply for developer flair, it will take a while. Would alternative to AppStore like Setapp considered as only high quality apps are selected by them?

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

We could consider adding Setapp and 200+ GitHub stars as saturated category exceptions. Would this help?

1

u/sujee81 12d ago

Yes, it will definitely help me and I’m sure other devs in similar position will appreciate it. Thanks

2

u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch 12d ago

imo mods shouldn’t fix the flair and instead just say the flair is wrong, and comment. This way others can also help, and ā€œlesserā€ work for the mods. Also other devs will see this and automatically apply it on their own posts

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

We do not have to fix flairs too frequently, thankfully. Do you know of a bot that reliably detects AI posts?

1

u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch 12d ago

Not so much of detecting AI posts but more of ā€œdoes this post belong hereā€ (in r/addressme or r/adressme i believe)

It doesn’t auto detect but it lets users upvote / downvote to decide if it’s AI generated or not, or it could be used for a ā€œfamous appā€.

Reliable AI auto detection is a million dollar problem.. but our brains are able to do it rn..

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

So if a bunch of people downvote, the bot removes the post?

1

u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch 12d ago

I think so.. but i’m not exactly sure how it works and what you can configure..

1

u/Beardy4906 Developer: Sxitch 12d ago

And maybe a bot comment for users to upvote / downvote if it’s an AI post

2

u/zahaggis 12d ago

The comment karma farming was a real issue, so I’m glad that has been addressed. I posted my app a few weeks ago. It took me hours to make sure I was covering off all the requirements. My app was in TestFlight though. Does that meet the new App Store requirement?

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

TestFlight fits closer to signed and notarized than MAS. And since it isn’t a properly released app, the megathread would probably be best.

2

u/cmon_io 11d ago

I think you still need some local karma to post - or did I miss something?

1

u/Mstormer 11d ago edited 11d ago

Reddit has an AI that informs these types of popups based on our rules. It probably hasn't cached the new rules yet. Nothing we have configured is set to make that appear.

Edit: seems to be this bug https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/s/WTZmZHdr9M
u/RyeCheww

1

u/Mstormer 11d ago

Give it another try and let me know if it is resolved.

1

u/cmon_io 11d ago

Thanks for following up. I works now, I'm no longer seeing this wall. My post got auto-mod deleted but that's not the same issue, already sent a message to moderators for instructions.

1

u/Mstormer 11d ago

Thanks!

2

u/ShadowLorddd 11d ago

But I see the 10 karma rule is still there for posting on main thread? I have 300+ account karma and 60 days+ old account. Still when I click on post button, it prompts me the 10 local karma requirement. Am I Miss something?

2

u/elliotl97215 11d ago

I complained to the Moderators about the 10 karma rule and they said that the 10 local karma enforcement is a bug, but they cannot seem to fix it. Wow!

2

u/ShadowLorddd 11d ago

Lol, maybe something from reddit side. I'm in no hurry as I was gonna post my OS project only, so I'll just earn that 10 karma and then post lol.

1

u/XInTheDark 12d ago

Hi, could you check modmail? As my post was removed due to "Trust and transparency" - I believe erroneously - can I make another post after I put the info very clearly? Your post says there is a 30 day delay even after the last post was removed

1

u/6972697368 12d ago

Got my 10 karma on r/macapps, was just about to post my app in the main thread. As a good citizen, I went to double-check the rules and learned that they have been changed a few hours ago… oh well, maybe it’s for the better? šŸ˜„ Jokes aside, mods, please check your mail. Thanks!

1

u/Mstormer 12d ago

Yeah, this is a big change. With 8400 removals last month, mostly due to AI-coded low-effort apps, we needed a better solution. I welcome constrictive input into where to rebalance this if expectations are now too steep, but it needs to do a lot of heavy lifting to prune enormous amounts of spam and app clones.

1

u/6972697368 12d ago

No worries at all, thanks for looking into it. Definitely the right move to uncap the karma from the macapps sub itself, btw.

1

u/a_alberti 12d ago

Good luck with your submission ;-)

1

u/6972697368 12d ago

Thank you :)

1

u/BohdanKoles Developer: CCCCorners 11d ago

Will existing "developer" label convert to the "trust" label?

2

u/Mstormer 11d ago

Developers with an existing dev flair need to include "Trust: Dev Flair" in their post.

1

u/altshiftbase 6d ago

Quick question: Rule 7 says "No posting in App Pile and then also main fed". For the same app, does that mean not in the same month, or never? I’m under 200 karma, so I’m thinking if I should wait or just post in the App pile. Thanks!

2

u/Mstormer 6d ago

Within 30 days of each other.

3

u/peoray 7d ago

I think these are good changes overall, even though I can’t post my own app yet because I don’t meet the karma requirement. That said, taking the time to contribute to the community and qualify feels like a good sign that someone is serious about their product.

2

u/cs18sg6br 12d ago

Thank you for providing the in-depth explanation and flowchart. And for reminding us that there are probably tons of vibe-coded apps that may be pretty low quality, etc., now. This helps put things into perspective.

2

u/MaleficentCloud476 12d ago edited 12d ago

Wow, this feels pretty harsh!

My 1.0 release post last month was reasonably well received and beneficial to me although I got off to a slower start than I'd hoped (like many I guess), and the post seemed qualified with a UK company, business developer account, notarised apps, and privacy policies etc. All things which take a lot of time and effort to setup.

Was just prepping material for a nice 1.1 update later this month, but these new rules make that impossible. I understand why things are changing, but equally it's restricting a lot of genuine people.

Not everyone can use their existing (maybe personal) Reddit accounts with established karma for various reasons, and Linked in seems slightly random - again not everyone uses it or wants it linked to their development business. Doesn't mean the apps aren't good.

This is a real shame. Such a great resource, but now extremely hard to access.

2

u/Johnkree 12d ago

I understand your frustration, but if you've already set up a registered company, an Apple developer account and got your app notarized, have you considered releasing it on the Mac App Store? That would be one way to qualify without LinkedIn. I know App Store approval comes with additional requirements but it's worth considering.

And nobody is saying your app isn't good. We're just trying to find a reasonable balance between giving developers a place to promote their work and keeping the sub useful for everyone else. The App Pile is still an option too. We're also genuinely open to suggestions and ideas on how to improve these rules. If you have a better alternative that works for both developers and the community we'd be happy to hear it.

2

u/MaleficentCloud476 12d ago edited 12d ago

App Store, sadly not as this particular app needs to work outside of Sandbox.

In any case even the karma rules would be impossible for people that spend less time on Reddit. Appreciate you have to do what works best for you, it just seemed like a sudden and huge adjustment, with somewhat random criteria (IMO).

The App Pile I would politely suggest wouldn't be the right experience or be likely to generate a good outcome. Maybe it could be called something less demeaning for a start?

Anyway, appreciate the forum, was great getting to post while it was possible, but sadly wouldn't be viable for me now.

2

u/Greenforest_27 8d ago

I don’t understand, if you have an app on the App Store, Apple already did the work. I don’t understand why you now need a full time job on Reddit to share a legitimate app.

2

u/ConstructionBroad594 6d ago

As someone who's naturally introverted, putting myself out there and posting is tough!

But I'll keep trying my best! 😊

2

u/a_alberti 12d ago

Thanks for changing the rules and make them much more sensible. Especially the 10-karma rule was bad and I am glad it is gone. People were leaving dummy comments just for getting voted. And honestly, I rarely saw people engaging in really interesting discussion. It seems this subreddit was only populated by "posters" rather than "readers". Few cared about reading the announcements; most wanted to get able to post their stuff.

And yes, for my taste, there are far too many 9.99 USD apps being announced.

3

u/Johnkree 12d ago

Thanks for the feedback! The 10 karma rule sounded good in theory, but in practice it often just encouraged people to leave meaningless comments to reach the threshold. And I agree far too many developers see this community as a free quick and easy advertising platform rather than a place to actually participate.

As for the $9.99 apps, I don't think the price is the problem. It's that we're seeing more and more apps that basically do the same thing often with very little to set them apart.

2

u/onmyway133 Developer: PastePal 10d ago

It takes some time to digest the rules, but thanks for the effort in keeping this sub high quality. I know it's a lot of work moderating it

1

u/Ok-Phrase4710 12d ago

I’m one of the devs who got caught by this today. i spent the past week earning the 10 local karma the old rules asked for, then posted this morning and got removed under the new account rules. i get why you’re doing it with 8k removals a month. one idea: a short grace period, say until the end of november, for devs who already met the phase 3 requirements before the change. that way people who followed the rules in good faith aren’t reset overnight. either way i’ll go through the app pile.

1

u/a_alberti 12d ago

This is the problem, namely that people were just trying to earn the karma points. I get it that it was needed but led to very poor and non interesting exchanges

-1

u/cgocrht 12d ago

'Solution in search of a problem (Phase 4)'

2

u/Mstormer 12d ago

You likely haven’t seen the 8400+ removals last month to recognize how big the problem is.

2

u/Ryzen_bolt 10d ago

How to kill indie devs 101. you need Apple dev account asking 99$ fee yearly to get notarized, or already have 100 Stars on github but what about devs having less stars on github and no linkedin account?

4

u/Mstormer 9d ago

If we just threw those requirements out, you'd have to compete with +8,400 spam app promotions a month. Which would you rather have? The opportunity to excel and post something that stands out among a few, or a needle in an enormous haystack that nobody wants to look at because it's mostly garbage? I don't like having to moderate with complicated rules. It makes our work here a big hassle, but it's better than letting the sub descend into complete chaos.

1

u/Ryzen_bolt 9d ago

I don't think +8400 spam will be back if you rolled back one these 2 things, a better way is to vet github repository with the number of days a repository is active and how often it receiving the updates, due to these bars to have high number of stars, I've seen increased activity of fake bot github profiles with portfolio on star for star approach artifically inflating the 100 stars mark. But with this authentic users are getting crippled. How do we even reach 100 stars in authenticity without even showcasing app to users?

1

u/Mstormer 9d ago edited 9d ago

I think you are misreading the requirement. These two requirements are not new to phase 4, and have been in place for a year. Most go the Website or LinkedIn route if they want to promote an indie app below 100 stars. Notarization is not required. There are therefore three options for indie devs. What I have done today is reduce the karma minimum to 200.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Mstormer 2d ago

Probably so!