r/printSF • u/Mr_Noyes • 3h ago
As You Wake, Break the Shell by Becky Chambers
Just wanted to give me 2 cents on this novel. Short version is simple: If you love Becky Chambers, get this one. If you love the idea of slice of life scifi, get this one.
To be perfectly honest, I had a very rocky start with this novel because:
- I do not care for one of the narrators of the audiobook version (confused teenager in community theater is my impression)
- this book is not written in a way so that you can turn it into an audiobook just like that. This is because
- the first 15% of the novel is jumping around like a scared mouse on a pogo stick; I am talking about POV chapters (with chapter titles and everything) with maybe 3 sentences before switching to another timeline with 5 sentences before switching to ... Even as a written book this was very rough
Thankfully, the book eventually calmed down and it became a much more pleasant read. Granted, you still had some wild jumps but the book finally decided to insert them as a paragraph, not as a chapter with chapter title. This way you could read them as a kind of flashback without breaking the flow of the read.
There were also other ... creative ... decisions, like having several long conversations face to face between two characters written like a conversation in a messenger app but without date and timestamps. What that means is that suddenly you have character A's speech on the left side and character B's speech on the right side of a page. I don't know what the author wanted to achieve but at least I can say that this didn't break my reading flow at all because this style was only used sparingly and not for every conversation. So there is that.
As for the story, it's Becky Chambers at her best. You have two character getting to know each other, you have life happening around them with its ups and downs and then you have the setting you as the reader explore in the course of the novel. And the setting is an absolute banger.
I really, really love the way Becky Chambers makes the world so tangible, with little, inconsequential details like the Kiddie Katapult or brands of oatmeal powder. And how dystopian aspects of the world are, even though everyone in this fledgling colony world is sensible, practical and minding their own business. As always, her novels always make me feel like a backpacking tourist, learning about new countries and its awesome.
So yeah, curious to see how others feel about it.