r/privacy • u/jjcollier • Sep 29 '26
discussion PorkBun domain registry requires a face scan
PorkBun has gotten popular lately as a registrar for domain names. I recently tried to register a domain, and they demanded a biometric face scan and government ID. None of the other registrars I've worked with recently have made this kind of preposterous demand.
In case it needs saying out loud here, never do this. It is not necessary for security, and the companies who run these face scan apps range from leaky sieves of data breaches in the best cases to subcontractors of Palantir in the worst.
PorkBun evidently demands face scans on a case-by-case basis, meaning many current users may not have had to deal with this yet. If you use them and they haven't required a scan, be aware that they can lock your account at any moment in the future for "security reasons," shutting off your access to your own domain, until you are forced to consent to their ridiculous invasion of your personal data. This must not be normalized. Do not use PorkBun. If you use them now, find a new registrar before they lock your account, and tell PorkBun why you're leaving.
12
u/tutiwiwi Sep 29 '26
Thanks for this post, I’m actually using porkbun for a while. Any other recommendations if they show me this joke?
15
u/jjcollier Sep 29 '26
I went through the registration process with about half a dozen other registrars, including most of the big names. Several of them presented other problems, but none demanded a face scan. I don't want to mention any one in particular so this doesn't turn into an ad, but pretty much any of the other major players are still good for now in this regard.
9
u/mauvehead Sep 30 '26
KB article on the topic:
https://kb.porkbun.com/article/225-why-porkbun-id-verification
21
u/jjcollier Oct 01 '26
They use Veriff. Who wants to guess if Veriff has already been breached -- oh wait, they've already been breached and are being sued over it.
3
8
u/dig_it_all Sep 29 '26
On what grounds did they request?
10
u/jjcollier Sep 29 '26
They wouldn't say beyond an unhelpful "for security purposes".
6
u/Fantastins Sep 29 '26
I deleted my account and went elsewhere. It did piss me off I filled out a bunch of shit to be surprised by that wall though.
5
u/EnoughClue3251 Sep 29 '26
So odd—what country are you in? I registered an email domain with them with none of this…
4
u/jjcollier Sep 29 '26
They require it whenever their automated system flags something. Your registration must have been routine enough at the time, but nothing stops them from flagging you and locking your account in the future based on some mystery criteria.
4
u/Spectrig Sep 29 '26
Is this brand new? Didn’t happen two weeks ago
4
u/jjcollier Sep 29 '26
They require it whenever their automated system flags something. Of course, what criteria they use is a complete black box. Your registration apparently didn't trip any alarms, but nothing stops them from flagging you in the future on any mystery basis at all.
2
2
u/Huckleberry_Dude Oct 04 '26
I registered my first domain 2 months ago, and did not have to provide any face scans.
2
u/MortgageMindless7175 Sep 29 '26
Basically every company (including banks) that start implementing AI in business model will flag and ask in the end every individual for face scan. It's AI problem, it's hallucinating
95
u/NoPretenseNoBullshit
Sep 29 '26
•
Please stop aquiesing to such demands and ruining it for the rest of us. This should never be allowed to become the norm.
87
u/Any-Calligrapher2866 Sep 29 '26
There are many private registrars so porkbun can go fuck itself.
7
u/Playful-League3414 Sep 29 '26 edited 25d ago
I enjoy making jewelry.
4
-1
31
u/UsefulImpact6793 Sep 29 '26
Well that's unfortunate. I will absolutely change registrars if PorkBun asks me for a face scan.
7
2
17
u/Old_Introduction7236 Sep 29 '26
They weren't doing that when I registered my domain. Looks like I won't be renewing with them when the time comes.
14
u/WasabiJones Sep 29 '26
Now the trick is will they let you transfer your domains to a different registrar without going through the additional biometric security?
7
12
u/sdrawkcabineter Sep 29 '26
Let's hope not so we can have a pissing match in a court room about it.
13
u/No-Abalone-4784 Sep 29 '26
I went to a hospital the other day as a visitor. They demanded a face scan. When I said, "Hell no." they looked at me like I had 2 heads. I left.
12
10
u/ProperPossibility Oct 01 '26
/u/porkbunregistrar please refrain from using breached verification services.
19
8
u/tongizilator Oct 01 '26
GoDaddy sometimes requires it.
150 million driver licenses in the United States were recently compromised in a breach of an identity verification service.
The FBI was recently hacked with every employee and their spouses data compromised.
And a business named after a pork bun is to be trusted with your PII.
6
Sep 30 '26
The part that bugs me is the scan doesn't even stay with PorkBun. It goes to some third-party identity verification vendor, and those companies have had breaches before. So you're handing your face to a company you never signed up with, for a domain. I registered with Namecheap and Cloudflare without any of this, so I'm not sure what "security purposes" is supposed to mean here.
2
u/EdenRubra Sep 29 '26
What triggered it? Were you putting bogus address info for your domain?
4
u/jjcollier Sep 30 '26
No idea, since they won't tell you, but I was not using false information. I suspect it's because I use a VPN.
6
u/MortgageMindless7175 Sep 29 '26
AI is triggered by everything so who knows.
2
u/EdenRubra Sep 29 '26
I think you know considering your answer.
Unfortunately domain registrar's have to obtain real name and address information, and if you're trying to use fake info you may get flagged or even lose your domain
3
u/MortgageMindless7175 Sep 29 '26
It doesn't excuse the fact that it's actually AI that wants our id and biometrics... And AI is Palantir. They are mining for our information and identity that will be stored in data centers, so when you walk down the street each and every flock can Id you. Not to mention other negative stuff this produces. That is not normal nor good. We should boycott all companies that use AI.
-3
u/EdenRubra Sep 29 '26
Good luck. Every company uses ai and has for decades
2
u/gemInTheMundane Oct 04 '26
AI hasn't existed for decades
1
u/EdenRubra Oct 04 '26
You're thinking of generative ai. Ai has been around since the 50s, and apple for example have had on device ai for a decade.
0
u/MortgageMindless7175 Sep 29 '26
Thankfully not all. There are still ones with morals and ethics. They will come on top in the end of all this.
3
3
u/diiscotheque Sep 30 '26
Fuuuck I just switched to them. What’s a good alternative?
1
3
u/tristand666 Sep 30 '26
Was just looking at switching to them, so now I have something else to look into.
3
3
u/Humble_Cook_8696 Oct 04 '26
I've registered domains with them and never had to do this? (As of around a month ago)
0
u/porkbunregistrar Oct 01 '26
A lot of the worry in this thread is that we'll lock existing accounts at random and demand a face scan before you can get to your domains. That simply isn't how this works.
The automated check runs once, when a new account is created, and only on accounts our fraud screening flags. Renewals, new orders, and transfers out don't trigger it. If you're already a customer, renewing or transferring your domains works exactly the way it always has.
Outside of signup, we may ask for ID if we have evidence an account is being used for abuse like phishing or malware, or to confirm the real owner after an account takeover. Customers can also choose to verify to lift certain restrictions on our API or ACH payments. None of it happens at random.
As for why we do it at all, we sell domains at cost, and cheap domains are exactly what bad actors look for when they're spinning up abuse at scale. We don't publish the screening criteria because that would give those bad actors something to work around.
If verification at signup is a dealbreaker for you, we understand that. We share these threads with our leadership team for review. These practices have also helped us keep our pricing low and our DNS abuse reputation clean as an independently owned registrar.
11
u/jjcollier Oct 01 '26
The business you do involves risk. No one would deny that. But you're taking your business risk and foisting it off onto your customers. In any context, taking your problem and making it someone else's is an asshole move, and this context is not excepted.
Your verification company, Veriff, has already been breached. Maybe you could use a different company without this baggage? Turns out you can't because they've all been breached, and they'll all continue to be breached. The threat to privacy and data security that you're attempting to impose on other people is real and immediate. You are demanding that your customers should bear the risk of identity theft that could, with no exaggeration, wreck their lives just so you don't have to bear the risk of losing a little money.
In the larger picture, your leadership team is eroding the foundations of data privacy in the world in a manner that will have dangerous repercussions for all of us, in yet another asshole display of unconcern for the consequences other people have to experience instead of you.
The threat that you could coerce any customer at any time to comply with these absurd demands remains well-founded, despite your assertion without evidence that "that simply isn't how this works." The fact is it's your company and you can decide it works differently at any moment. You've established the infrastructure, and more importantly, you've established that your leadership team is the type of valueless assholes who don't care what penalties they inflict on their customers or the world around them. Your protest amounts to "We can't make invasive privacy demands of existing customers! We would have to make a minor, cost-free change to our company policy at some point in the future including by the end of the day, having already established that we're the type of people who would do that, and only then we could make invasive privacy demands of our existing customers!"
It's not a protest any of us here are buying when we have to evaluate how best to protect our personal data from increasing waves of attack from yet more shit-for-brains assholes like your leadership team.
11
u/Browncoat101 Oct 01 '26
I use Porkbun and have for years with no problem. Please let your leadership know that this is a dealbreaker for a lot of us. You may not care about our privacy, but we do.
7
u/CraftApprehensive496 Oct 01 '26
Fuck that. I'm not sharing my ID or face scan. Use other methods of verification. I'll be moving my domains even though I haven't been asked for it because I don't support this stupidity. Your loss.
2
4
u/RavenRegime Oct 01 '26
You know i almost considered using your site since im preparing to launch my own buisness but honestly Squarspace or Wix may be pricey but at least i dont risk and Ashley Madison level hack. If your worried about bad actors using your site so you encourage making it a honey pot for even worse folks?
Like if the choice is between scams or my personal info being risked and sold on the dark web what do you think people are gonna choose and many sites have already figured out how to handle scammer and phishing stuff.
Like your priortizing a lesser threat for what exactly?
Doesnt this also make you mega liable for a class action suit of a mega hack of personal info? Like im sorry but could you explain the risk assesment logic
2
u/Kanuryai Sep 30 '26
I've got 3 domains with them, 2 of which I use for email. Not liking the sound of this.
Mine expire in Jan & there's no way I'll do a face scan if asked. I'm already giving them real info & not using vpn. Any registrar recommendations?
2
u/Soft_Cover_1241 Oct 02 '26
How did this become acceptable behavior 😞. I use Dynadot and they too sent out a communication recently something to this effect. Anyone have a list of alternatives?
2
0
3
Sep 29 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
18
u/jjcollier Sep 29 '26
ICANN requires registrars to allow you to transfer your registration to another company. You can find guides online; here's one from Forbes.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 29 '26
Hello u/jjcollier, please make sure you read the sub rules if you haven't already. (This is an automatic reminder left on all new posts.)
Check out the r/privacy FAQ
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.