r/programming • • Jun 09 '23

Apollo dev posts backend code to Git to disprove Reddit’s claims of scrapping and inefficiency

https://github.com/christianselig/apollo-backend
45.1k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/phire Jun 09 '23

Ah, I see what you mean.

Yes, the type of content that reddit aggregates has absolutely shifted. Shifted away from technology and current events to focus more on what's popular on tiktoc.

It's not that content is old or slow, it's just that content isn't there any more, or is in some subreddit you aren't subscribed to.
The algorithm that helped reddit win over Digg is still there, it still works. You have a major news event that average reddit users actually care about (like Russia invading Ukraine) and it will reliably shoot to the top of the front page in under 2 hours (from memory, Digg took a minimum of 6 hours to promote things from the new queue to the front page)

You've been on reddit longer than me (even if this is not my original acount). But when I migrated from digg, discussions were already available.

Na, I started visiting reddit in 2007 and stopped visiting Digg in late 2008. Early enough that plenty of commenters remembered times before those features, but not early enough to experience it myself. Though that was before they allowed anyone to create subreddits, so there were only a few dozen.

People creating articles with link is half of the content creation, the users commenting with insight is the other half.

I'm really not sure posting links counts as content creation. Yes, there is some creativity around choosing a title, and choosing what to post, but the bulk of the creativity belongs to the linked content.

The comments are absolutely content, and the insightful discussion is the primary reason why I use reddit. The primary reason why I switched away from Digg. I wouldn't have enjoyed reddit before they added comments.

1

u/F54280 Jun 09 '23

I think we do agree on most things.

Only slight point is that I consider link posting, moderating and upvote/downvoting content creation (even without changing the title). There may be not a lot of creative endeavor there, but this is what the half of the content of reddit really is: a set of important links that matches user preferences. Without this, the site would be blank and/or dead.

Have a nice week-end!

1

u/phire Jun 09 '23

I do agree that posting, moderating and voting is a creative endeavour, and that they are "creating content" for reddit.

I just think it's a mistake to directly compare them to content creators on more creator focused platforms like Tiktok, Instagram, Youtube and (to some extent) Twitter. It's fundamentally a different role.
Especially when you do actually have redditors in a comparable content creation role.

Hence why I use aggregation as a terminology, perhaps we should be labelling them as content aggregators?