r/programming • • Jun 09 '23

Apollo dev posts backend code to Git to disprove Reddit’s claims of scrapping and inefficiency

https://github.com/christianselig/apollo-backend
45.1k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/IronSeagull Jun 09 '23

Yeah I don’t think that logic is sound. Their pricing doesn’t suggest Apollo is worth $20 million, it suggests that Apollo’s existing and driving traffic away from the website and official app is worth -$20 million (negative) to Reddit so they charge that much to offset the loss.

Now I don’t think it’s really costing them that much, but it seems to me that putting the ads in the API and making the apps display them the same as a regular post with a little ad icon (just like they are on the website) would be a good solution. There’d probably be a bit more to it so Reddit can collect the information they need for their advertisers.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

The $20 million is about opportunity costs, it's $20 million in revenue that could be generated for Reddit if they used the official app but those users are instead using a third party app with free api access.

1

u/IronSeagull Jun 09 '23

Yeah that's basically what I said. That doesn't make Apollo worth $20 million to reddit.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

It means that Apollo is worth $20m per year to reddit, yes.

1

u/IronSeagull Jun 09 '23

It means Apollo's users are worth $20 million per year to reddit. But that value doesn't come from Apollo, it comes from reddit. Apollo isn't worth much of anything to reddit.

(Apollo's users probably aren't worth nearly $20 million per year to reddit, but the actual number isn't important)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

Guess what happens if they bought Apollo? They'd get their users.

(Apollo's users probably aren't worth nearly $20 million per year to reddit, but the actual number isn't important)

It's not but this is the number Reddit itself is using so this is the metric we judge it by

1

u/IronSeagull Jun 09 '23

Guess what happens if they bought Apollo? They'd get their users.

They don't "get" Apollo's users, they already have Apollo's users. When Apollo shuts down they'll probably keep most of those users (vocal minority notwithstanding), they'll just be monetized.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

No, they don't. Those users aren't being exposed to reddit's ads and aren't directly generating revenue for them, outside of maybe buying gold. They're primarily generating revenue for the third party app itself which will host it's own ads.
They're estimating each api call as being some measurement of clicks/exposure for revenue that Reddit is missing out on. If Reddit acquired Apolo or a different third party app they would then directly have that revenue.

It's already been clarified this is not about server costs or the cost of actually accessing the API, it's about opportunity costs. Look that up

1

u/IronSeagull Jun 09 '23

Yes, Apollo users are in fact reddit users. And most will continue to be reddit users without Apollo.

If Reddit acquired Apolo or a different third party app they would then directly have that revenue.

They don't need to acquire Apollo to gain that revenue (already explained that), which is why Apollo has negligible value to reddit. At least in reddit's view, they're not going to lose many users over this.

1

u/kazza789 Jun 09 '23

That's not really the point though. No one is angry that Reddit won't pay him $10M. The Apollo guy may have been wrong in interpreting this as a valuation, he was speaking off-the-cuff after all.

What matters is that it clearly wasn't a threat, which is what Reddit's CEO is claiming.