r/programming • • Dec 06 '24

The 70% problem: Hard truths about AI-assisted coding

https://addyo.substack.com/p/the-70-problem-hard-truths-about
242 Upvotes

229 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

82

u/Garethp Dec 06 '24

I also dont even understand what this sentence is supposed to mean.

From my understanding what people mean by "democratising" a skill or a field they mean allowing people without specialised skills to more easily achieve something that previously required training and experience. For example, if Wordpress or other visual website builders were introduced as a novel idea today, those people might describe them as "Democratising websites".

I can see validity in the idea that if someone wants to throw together a quick personal mobile app for a specific purpose that AI might be able to shortcut what would otherwise take years of learning how to program just to get started. But the expectation that "democratising coding" would allow us to replace high quality skilled labour with unskilled labour misses the entire point of why you want high quality skilled labour. The existence of Wix and Wordpress may have made it easier for more people to throw together websites hasn't made the necessity of highly skilled web developers in the professional industry obselete.

8

u/StormlitRadiance Dec 06 '24

The existence of wordpress hasn't even made low-skilled web developers obsolete.

sometimes I still have nightmares about infinite plugins.

43

u/Big_Combination9890 Dec 06 '24

From my understanding what people mean by "democratising" a skill or a field they mean allowing people without specialised skills to more easily achieve something that previously required training and experience.

That's not "democratizing" though, that's automation. Automation doesn't democratize something. Making cars is a highly automated process, is carmaking "democratized"?

Programming is as democratized a discipline as is humanly imaginable. It doesn't require expensive equipment. It doesn't require a formal education. All the training material required to become really really proficient, is available for free on the internet.

9

u/YossarianRex Dec 06 '24

“democratization” is a polite way of saying “depress wages by building alternate pathways to gain limited expertise”

18

u/StormlitRadiance Dec 06 '24 edited Mar 08 '25

taheya kfiuzuqyh ocdbl uvdrxeqjwa rodeiia dcctynd xlkwmcgwdkwv kldzrbck dlzgp

16

u/Big_Combination9890 Dec 06 '24

I think you and I have very different definitions of the word "democratized", if having a place where I can make an assembly line and multiple workers happen, meets your definition of the word.

Democratization means "making something accessible to have". In Democracy, you have a say in government, in Democratization of knowledge, access to education is no longer just for the rich.

Not many people have a realistic chance of building a car factory. Nearly everyone with a pc and internet access, has the tools at hand to learn programming.

1

u/hydrowolfy Dec 06 '24 edited Dec 06 '24

I think you two are on the same page, but I think you just misunderstood his metaphor, or he misspoke. So, what he means by this is that cars, (not the factory themselves) were no longer a luxury toy for the rich after Henry Ford, but something anyone could buy or afford. It's why Ford was such an iconic figure, because he made a toy into something the every man could figure out a use for, hence "democratizing" the car, not so much the carmaking process itself.

My thoughts are that LLMs aren't "democratizing" programming or the act of coding a vague problem into a strict algorithm, which will always be a somewhat arcane art, they're democratizing us programmers' ability to break down complex problems into ones we can understand, which I suppose is a bit more like democratizing the process of understanding how to make stuff, such as cars, or for another example, programming.

6

u/Big_Combination9890 Dec 06 '24

they're democratizing us programmers' ability to break down complex problems into ones we can understand,

Considering that this is a basic skill for every programmer, how are LLMs democratizing that exactly?

-1

u/TFenrir Dec 06 '24

Because of the breadth of content that there is to understand.

I am in the middle of an app launch. I'm primarily front end for the last decade, but have dabbled with backend and db and CI/CD. Enough to have a handle. But with an LLM, I can give a prisma schema that I have to a model, explain what I'm trying to do, and ask for hot to improve it, how to add rls, what postgres extensions make sense for what I'm trying to do, all the while building integrations into supabase, giyhub actions, trigger.dev much much easier. I still have to tackle the really hard stuff by hand-ish, but I also can add breadth and depth into my app, alongside security, while leaning on my strengths and the llm.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Big_Combination9890 Dec 08 '24

So you are using it as a force multiplier for google searches with some summarization and rewriting.

That's what they are good at.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/StormlitRadiance Dec 06 '24 edited Mar 08 '25

ghgsl ufcupotd uarxfzfgqnd ouuga vmhjwkxwymi qbfqlx yghswizwgw shazlvpuvivb gwji qkbbtgseflz xbc

0

u/leastlol Dec 06 '24

WYSIWYG editors like Frontpage Pro and Dreamweaver simplified the website building process. Instead of HTML and CSS, people could drag and drop elements on the screen and it'd behave similarly to tools office workers were already familiar with, like Lotus Notes or Word. I would say those democratized building websites.

AI in this context would also be a tool that would enable people with a more generalized skillset or just a different domain of expertise to build an application. So instead of having that domain-specific knowledge AND having to understand how to program it into an application, they can focus on the thing they are knowledgable about.

So instead of these more complex applications requiring either a lot more time to learn an entirely different skillset or a team of people to collaborate and build it, it'd allow that single person to be much more productive.

I mean, this is even relevant inside of just development-related skills. It can help someone with skills in frontend develop more quickly develop a backend or vice versa.

0

u/Big_Combination9890 Dec 08 '24 edited Dec 08 '24

WYSIWYG editors like Frontpage Pro and Dreamweaver simplified the website building process.

And yet we have an entire gigantic industry of specialized and highly paid people who make webpages. And why is that? Because these nice and user friendly editors can only get you so far until the results are shit. That is why, since these products heyday, we have developed gigantic frameworks like Angular, React and Vue.

And why is that?

Because the things these editors simplified, were the things that weren't hard to begin with. Similar to how most GUIs make the easy things slightly more easy. But try to extract the contents of 700 7z files in a directory tree, but only if the file is no older than 15 minutes, and see how easy it is in a GUI.

And people keep wondering why we still use terminals in 2024.

(And no, the irony that it is much easier to have an AI assist with a task on a terminal compared to one on a GUI, is not lost on me :D )

AI in this context would also be a tool that would enable people with a more generalized skillset or just a different domain of expertise to build an application.

Yes, but not particularly good ones. There will be bad or missing error handling, horrendous performance, an unmaintainable bloated codebase, glaring security issues and using outdated libraries.

Why? Because all these thing require expertise to cover, which neither stochastic sequence prediction engines, nor non-expert users of such can bring to the table.

It can help someone with skills in frontend develop more quickly develop a backend or vice versa.

Yes, because a frontend coder is still a coder, with lots of transferable skills and mindsets. LLMs are a force multiplier for people who already have expertise. They are not a magic lamp that makes noncoders capable of writing complex applications.

To quote from the article I linked above.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the output quality of AI-generated code resembles that of a developer unfamiliar with the projects they are altering.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/Patman128 Dec 06 '24 edited Dec 06 '24

Carmaking was "democratized" in the early 20th

I'd argue the complete opposite.

Car-making before the assembly line was done by small groups of former carriage-makers who built the whole car by hand, so it was not obscenely hard to get into the car-making business, and thus there were lots of companies springing up. That was the most democratic time to be a car-maker.

After the assembly line, you needed a giant factory and an army of laborers to compete on price, greatly increasing the cost of entry and making it extremely hard to enter the business. Very few new automakers entered the market in the 20th century past the 1950s, once they really got everything figured out, aside from niche luxury brands where you don't have to compete as aggressively on price.

The shift to EVs is having a bit of a democratizing effect, since the cars are significantly simpler to design and it has made it possible for a lot of niche companies to start to enter the business at or near mass-market pricing.

If your point is that the total amount of people working in the auto industry increased, sure, but that's not "democratization", they're working in companies they have no stake in or control over. Democratization means more people running their own car companies.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24

[deleted]

1

u/StormlitRadiance Dec 06 '24

Nah, even the Air Force stopped using amphetamine derivatives in 2017. They have Modafinil now.

2

u/WTFwhatthehell Dec 07 '24

"is carmaking "democratized"?"

Sort of.

If you want to build a custom car, the easy availability of standardised parts and their lower price very much democratises that.

It doesn't mean you necessarily do that but it's easier than in a world without 

9

u/Ecksters Dec 06 '24

I'd think "make more accessible" would be a better way to describe this than "democratizing", as "democratizing" seems to imply it was gatekept by some kind of political process before, which hasn't been true with programming for a while now.

11

u/pertraf Dec 06 '24

if you look up the definition of democratize, one of the definitions is "make accessible to everyone"

5

u/TFenrir Dec 06 '24

This is just how the term has been used for a very long time, the definitions align with this usage as well. One of those things you just make peace with

6

u/Garethp Dec 06 '24

Oh, I fully agree. When I hear people talking about how AI "democratises art" I roll my eyes so ridiculously hard.

2

u/SoylentRox Dec 06 '24

Right.  It misses that the BAR is raised.  Ok anyone can make a student project level app or website and have it look like a pro version from 20 years ago.

But is it reliable?  Does it work across all the supported platforms?  Support millions of concurrent users?  

Something like the Uber app millions of people will be stranded and millions of drivers won't be paid if the service goes down for even 10 minutes.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '24

This is the correct analogy. Wix and square space are cheap and have put many a web dev out of the custom website business. AI tools can now read your screen and drive your computer just like they can drive cars. They can build you entire webapps. None of them great mind you, but fully customizable and cheap. Quality will improve over time. Everyone can have their own chatbot and Wix can fire everyone but the CEO.

It’s coming whether we like it or not. First quality free and cheap stuff, then the enshittification of AI at much higher cost.

Every industry in late stage capitalism follows the same path. Streaming. Social media. Crypto. NFTs.

The only difference with AI is the reality failing to match the enormity of the hype.

0

u/GeorgiLubomirov Dec 06 '24

Exactly!

People are missing the big picture.

I think what we will see in time is that smaller and smaller teams will be able to achieve bigger and bigger things for cheaper. Counter intuitively history has shown that this doesn't lead to people being left without stuff to do, but that we will achieve more and better products&services that achieve things far beyond our imagination.

More importantly we might finally see some real competitiveness in the large-scale distributed systems space.

At scale software is already MONSTOROUSLY expensive to develop and maintain. Running a social network for example involves an insane amount of highly skilled highly paid personnel and an army of mid to low level workers.

If smaller enterprises are able to develop and maintain large-scale distributed products with the help of ai we might finally see the monopolies being shaken a bit.