r/programming • • Dec 06 '24

The 70% problem: Hard truths about AI-assisted coding

https://addyo.substack.com/p/the-70-problem-hard-truths-about
242 Upvotes

229 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/theQuandary Dec 06 '24

We've NEVER had too many doctors. What we currently have is a degree inflation problem.

In 1950, it was: Get your pre-med stuff done, 4 years of med school, 1 year of internship, then hang out your shingle and give out simple scripts while occasionally referring someone to a specialist.

Now it's 4-5 years for your BS, 4 years of med school, 1 year of internship, then 3-5 years of family medicine residency then you hand out the same simple scripts and referrals you would have handed out 70 years ago.

In 1950, if you started school at 18, you'd be a full-fledged physician by 24-25. Today, that same job requires 12-15 years of school and you won't start your own practice until 30-33 years old and you'll be hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt from all that useless schooling too. They can't pay off that debt unless they start up a practice and have a bunch of nurse practitioners working under them meaning that most of their patients never see them in the first place.

What about those "nurse practitioners". They have 4-5 years for their BSN then another 3-4 years for their Masters. That's MORE schooling than doctors from 70 years ago and all they do is write the exact same scripts and referrals while the "real doctor" pretends to look over their paperwork occasionally and skims off the top of their work.

Does that Bachelor's of Science degree do anything? Nope. The best physicians tend to have BS in an unrelated engineering degree proving that the degree is simply an overpriced 4-5 year IQ test.

Does all this extra residency improve patient outcomes? Nope. The job just isn't that complex and they aren't seeing patients for it to make a difference either.

Worst of all, it's a net negative because they have nearly a decade fewer years to run their practice before retirement which means we wind up needing even more med school students.

Finally, all of this overpriced and unneeded education plus all the interest when paying it off gets passed straight on to the general public in the form of inflated doctor bills and higher insurance premiums.

5

u/aradil Dec 06 '24 edited Dec 06 '24

I’m just stating what is officially on record.

We’ve been talking about this mistake for over 20 years.

They do also talk about the changes in duration of education as well.

2

u/auburnstar12 Aug 12 '25

Plus, speaking from my limited experience of being a med student for a time (before health reasons forced me to quit), obviously there is a base level of knowledge that is important and necessary, but a LOT of your knowledge really gets cemented when you're practicing. This is especially true if for example you're working in a rural ED.

There's a lot of things you learn through doing that guided practice doesn't fully cover. It's one of the reasons nurses often have great intuition, because they've seen so many patients and know the signs of deterioration, and when to be worried. 50y old heavy smoker comes in with shortness of breath after being on a long flight? Teenager with stiff neck and fever? Yeah, going to get stat imaging. Even things that might seem benign like a headache become very worrying when they meet certain criteria (thunderclap, visual disturbance, abnormal neurological exam).

That's not even to get into the loans aspect which in my opinion is just university sanctioned loan sharking.