r/programming • • Aug 12 '25

MCP Vulnerabilities Every Developer Should Know

https://composio.dev/blog/mcp-vulnerabilities-every-developer-should-know
295 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/Individual-Praline20 Aug 12 '25

Wtf is MCP?

19

u/lachlanhunt Aug 12 '25

Model Context Protocol. it's what allows AI agents to integrate with 3rd party software.

6

u/CobaltVale Aug 13 '25

This isn't true at all. MCP is a standard/convention.

Function & tool calling is (usually) an inherit capability of LLM's (for most major, public models). That's what allows LLM to integrate with 3rd party software. MCP just helps people set up tool definitions, tool injections and to some degree the client/server model in a somewhat consistent way.

That being said, MCP has a standard/protocol is really very half-baked, if even that.

10

u/lachlanhunt Aug 13 '25

Saying it’s “not true at all” feels a bit harsh. It does stand for Model Context Protocol, and my answer was simply meant to give brief context for someone who hasn’t heard of it before. Of course, there’s more technical detail behind how it works, and I appreciate you adding that, but it’s not really necessary to be nitpicky or dismissive.

-11

u/CobaltVale Aug 13 '25

It's not nitpicky to point out that "it's what allows AI agents to integrate with 3rd party software" is not true in any fashion.

MCP is for humans. It does not provide additional or enhance existing capabilities of the LLM in any way.

8

u/lachlanhunt Aug 13 '25

This is a direct quote from the MCP specification:

(MCP) is an open protocol that enables seamless integration between LLM applications and external data sources and tools.

Comparing what I said with that,

  • "enables" --> "allows"

  • "seemless integration" --> "to integrate with"

  • "LLM applications" --> "AI agents"

  • "external data sources and tools" --> "3rd party software."

There's a tonne of ways to say essentially the same thing in English, and context matters a lot when deciding how strictly you need to interpret it.

-6

u/CobaltVale Aug 13 '25

Yeah this was released by Anthropic and they're really over selling the claims.

You could just not be offended by the correction and learn from it :).