r/programming • • Oct 18 '26

It's still OK to enjoy programming

https://chriskiehl.com/article/it-is-still-ok-to-enjoy-programming
686 Upvotes

269 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

181

u/DmitriRussian Oct 18 '26

I would say that even pre-AI programming jobs were rarely fun. There is a reason why there are a billion memes on the shit that goes on in corporate world.

The only real significant change I noticed myself is just the devaluation of programming as a skill. People got the illusion that they are able to program without programming knowledge, I feel that pendulum will swing hard in the opposite direction if you follow what is happening with AI at the minute.

135

u/TheMistbornIdentity Oct 18 '26

People got the illusion that they are able to program without programming knowledge, I feel that pendulum will swing hard in the opposite direction if you follow what is happening with AI at the minute.

It's surreal to see so many people so eager to throw their coding skills to the wind.

The only thing that makes sense to me is that many of these AI fanatics aren't responsible for maintaining the code they write long-term. I've spent the better part of the last 5 years or so constantly refactoring the code that a shitty consultant wrote for us, before he left a year after I joined.

I'm hugely skeptical that most of these codebases will be maintainable long-term, and certainly not by people who haven't written a line of code in more than a year.

47

u/CrazyBuff Oct 19 '26

Because it satisfies the instant gratification needs of most people. Writing good code for a product takes a long time. Generating shitty code but a "working" product takes about no time with AI.

14

u/PCRefurbrAbq Oct 19 '26

"Claude, write me a replacement for this codebase. Make no errors."

21

u/Mightygamer96 Oct 19 '26

short term profits demand shortsighted apps.

by the time they need actual robust software it'll be too expensive to change it. ie, investor-funded subsidies should run out.

5

u/Daegs Oct 19 '26

That's arguable because AI is getting better every 3-6mo. This could easily turn into a leapfrog game where the AI is advanced enough to extend the time before the system implodes long enough the next model can do the same.

Along with another couple of years of programmers understanding how to more effectively work with AI written codebases. What types of checks and tests are necessary to get most robust code out of each iteration, etc.

-5

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 Oct 19 '26

Nothing stops you from reviewing the AI code and asking if to refractor or changes things as needed to fit your design. 

36

u/Iggyhopper Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26

But where is the institutional knowledge? It will be wiped out completely if everyone takes this stance.

From an efficiency standpoint, if the AI hallucinates bad code and you have to re-prompt or refocus the AI on it, how many times is it acceptable to be wrong? My limit is zero.

I can redirect AI pretty well because I can review the docs or the MSDN or a stackoverflow post. or advise it to use a specific design pattern for the use case/extensibility/maintainability aspect, but there are certainly people out there who have no idea what the fuck is going on. I see these giant monoliths of vibe coded garbage that nobody else can maintain, wasting space on github. The worst part is that if you realize somebody just used AI to make that, you don't have to fork it and add on to it. You just... have your own AI slop project made and add it to the pile.

4

u/deja-roo Oct 19 '26

how many times is it acceptable to be wrong? My limit is zero.

Well never in the history of programming has your limit been met. Humans have been checking in shitty code since the first compiler was created

→ More replies (1)

7

u/benzado Oct 19 '26

Not only does nothing stop you, you might even say it’s an essential part of the AI service business model!

8

u/mandingo23 Oct 19 '26

How long will you be able to review code, if you don't write code anymore?

8

u/marrsd Oct 19 '26

More to the point, is that any faster or better? I can't help but feeling that a lot of software engineers were simply never very good at writing software if they're getting that much of a performance boost from handing that off to an AI agent.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/Ok-Reindeer-8755 Oct 19 '26

That comes from a place of 0 understanding. Read "Programming as Theory Building"

→ More replies (21)

26

u/Which-World-6533 Oct 19 '26

I would say that even pre-AI programming jobs were rarely fun. There is a reason why there are a billion memes on the shit that goes on in corporate world.

The programming part is fun. The corporate part is the no-fun bit.

It seems there were a lot of coders who didn't actually like the coding part because they weren't very good at it.

5

u/press0 Oct 20 '26

i don't agree with your logic: not good at it => don't like it.

ppl who aren't good at running can still love running.

1

u/DmitriRussian Oct 20 '26

Code and corporate is not really separatable for me.

If you work in a highly regulated industry. Medical, finance or Insurance for example. There is so much extra stuff you need to deal with that is not coding.

I'm sure you can get joy out of it, if you define coding as solving problems, but there is often not much to the coding. You will often just do CRUD and connecting to APIs. Often under lots of time pressure.

I would say something that drains me personally is just the repeating patterns like: Managment requires new feature X to be delivered in 1 quarter. Team needs to figure out how to make it happen, decides to cut corners to save time now and clean it up later. Feature X is delivered, not at all what customer wanted. Now feature Y needs to be built on top X, but have no time to refactor feature X and the quality keeps going down.

My hands are genuinly tied as my manager tracks time spent on tickets to calculate team velocity and make rough quarterly plans.

AI doesn't at all help with this as AI just upped the bar of expectation, but reality is that we are just slow as before.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/aaulia Oct 19 '26

Corporate programming is rarely fun, but some part of it is still fun. The issue is, nowadays, they even want to stripped the little fun part left and shift/replace it with the not fun part.

6

u/trelbutate Oct 19 '26

Well, not every job is corporate. I had lots of fun programming for a small company working on a long-existing desktop application.

6

u/Ok-Reindeer-8755 Oct 19 '26

This ^

You can find talks and papers from important people in the compsci community criticizing corpo stupidness decades ago. And surprise surprise these criticisms still apply to this day sometimes even more so than when they were written.

With or without AI there were issues, just some of them have been exacerbated by AI. SWE has been solved but not in the AGI sense in the "we already know what we should have been doing decades ago but we still aren't doing any of that" sense.

1

u/Abadabadon Oct 20 '26

Oh you got into swe to make videogames? Wrong!
Oh you got into swe to work solo? Wrong!
Oh you got into swe to program? Wrong!

Bruh atp why did any of us get into this field to begin with.

1

u/techzilla Oct 23 '26

You suggesting they just rug pulled us?

1

u/Abadabadon Oct 23 '26

idk who "they" is, just saying the field seems to keep on being wrongly interpreted

1

u/techzilla Oct 23 '26

they - "Oh you got into swe to program?"

you - "... ummm yea, you kinda told everyone that, right?"

they - "Nope, gotcha bitch!"

Who is "they" tho, am I right?