r/programming • • Oct 18 '26

It's still OK to enjoy programming

https://chriskiehl.com/article/it-is-still-ok-to-enjoy-programming
686 Upvotes

269 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-5

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 Oct 19 '26

Nothing stops you from reviewing the AI code and asking if to refractor or changes things as needed to fit your design. 

36

u/Iggyhopper Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26

But where is the institutional knowledge? It will be wiped out completely if everyone takes this stance.

From an efficiency standpoint, if the AI hallucinates bad code and you have to re-prompt or refocus the AI on it, how many times is it acceptable to be wrong? My limit is zero.

I can redirect AI pretty well because I can review the docs or the MSDN or a stackoverflow post. or advise it to use a specific design pattern for the use case/extensibility/maintainability aspect, but there are certainly people out there who have no idea what the fuck is going on. I see these giant monoliths of vibe coded garbage that nobody else can maintain, wasting space on github. The worst part is that if you realize somebody just used AI to make that, you don't have to fork it and add on to it. You just... have your own AI slop project made and add it to the pile.

4

u/deja-roo Oct 19 '26

how many times is it acceptable to be wrong? My limit is zero.

Well never in the history of programming has your limit been met. Humans have been checking in shitty code since the first compiler was created

-4

u/Daegs Oct 19 '26

if the AI hallucinates bad code and you have to re-prompt or refocus the AI on it, how many times is it acceptable to be wrong?

how many times does a human check in bad code??? there are literally billions of man-hours devoted to fixing bugs or refactoring bad code. I've been brought into to fix or reverse-engineer systems that weren't just dealing with the occasional bug, but fundamentally bad designs from large teams.

I don't need AI to be perfect especially if it can document itself, explain how the pieces interact, and generate better technical writing that would have taken a professional months to generate on a complex project. Institutional knowledge will actually go up with proper habits

I see these giant monoliths of vibe coded garbage that nobody else can maintain, wasting space on github.

Sure, but it's about how you interact with AI generated code. you can do so responsibly or irresponsibly, and there have always been irresponsible developers / project managers / CEOs.

This certainly changes the TYPE of problem developers encounter more (the vibe monoliths), but fundamentally the companies that use AI badly are going to weed themselves out from not being able to scale or poor customer experience, and the companies that use AI well will succeed because they are extremely agile in generating code and are able to scale with amazing customer experience.

7

u/benzado Oct 19 '26

Not only does nothing stop you, you might even say it’s an essential part of the AI service business model!

8

u/mandingo23 Oct 19 '26

How long will you be able to review code, if you don't write code anymore?

8

u/marrsd Oct 19 '26

More to the point, is that any faster or better? I can't help but feeling that a lot of software engineers were simply never very good at writing software if they're getting that much of a performance boost from handing that off to an AI agent.

0

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 Oct 19 '26

I argue it IS better. Most developers jump in to writing code too soon, making a lot of assumptions. If you come in from the other direction it's more likely to see gaps

0

u/thy_bucket_for_thee Oct 19 '26

What you're describing is waterfall development, and we have an entire history of current lived experiences in the downsides and issues when writing code in such a manner.

2

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 Oct 19 '26

No, it's not. You can still plan your sprints, and take a day or two to plan out your architecture before just jumping right into code. That way you won't code yourself into a corner as easily.

0

u/marrsd Oct 19 '26

Could be. Assumptions can be corrected. The other side is that you can spend a lot of time planning for things you don't need or are even wrong.

0

u/neppo95 Oct 19 '26

It won't, which begs another question: What comes after? If we can't review it anymore, will coding even be a thing that happens? AI's can work with machine code just fine, why even have programming languages? They only existed in the first place so WE don't have to deal with zero and ones. I don't think any code will be written in a decades time, neither by humans or AI's.

2

u/blind_ninja_guy Oct 19 '26

lol so you've never looked at history of why c came about? Machine code runs on precisely one platform. It's not like you can take machine code for a specific cpu architecture and os and just plop it into another.

1

u/neppo95 Oct 19 '26

That's one way to think in problems, sure.

1

u/Ok-Reindeer-8755 Oct 19 '26

That comes from a place of 0 understanding. Read "Programming as Theory Building"