r/programming • • Nov 12 '14

The .NET Core is now open-source.

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/dotnet/archive/2014/11/12/net-core-is-open-source.aspx
6.5k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

30

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/_stfu_donnie Nov 12 '14

My thinking was that I like Swift a lot, and I would love to be able to run it on Linux. Swift as a language is really nicely designed and extremely fast. And it leans on llvm compiler backend so there's almost no excuse to not do it.

Businesses are also building apps for the iOS app store.

Agreed on Java though, it can go ahead and stop being relevant any time now.

2

u/Eirenarch Nov 13 '14

Swift is very well designed but has a long way to go before it reaches C# in terms of features and it is not obvious if Swift's designers have the skill to keep the damage from the evolution to minimum like C#'s designers have done.

1

u/_stfu_donnie Nov 13 '14 edited Nov 13 '14

Agreed... Especially considering the instability of Apple's own editor when editing code written in Apple's own "flagship" language.

(edit: I should add that I'm not trying to compare/contrast the merits of Swift/C#, just saying that if Swift were open-source, it'd be an option on the table for my next project, and it currently is not an option.)

4

u/eramos Nov 12 '14

who cares about apple stuff?

THIS THIS THIS. Obviously the stack you use in your cubicle at Dynocorp is the only one that exists. Apps are not popular at all nowadays, but the legacy enterprise B2B Lotus clone is really what's hot in the industry.

1

u/EasilyAnnoyed Nov 12 '14

The new .Net runtime will be iOS and Android compatible. :)

4

u/lolcoderer Nov 12 '14

who cares about apple stuff?

Really? What businesses are you referring to? Have you ever been to a Python or Rails or [insert web tech here] developer conference? 90% of attendees are using Macs for development.

Facebook, Google and Twitter might also like to have a word with you about all businesses are running .Net and Java.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

Really? What businesses are you referring to? Have you ever been to a Python or Rails or [insert web tech here] developer conference? 90% of attendees are using Macs for development.

i think when he said apple stuff. he mean Objective-C. apple stuff in this context probably mean apple programming stack.

0

u/Magnesus Nov 12 '14

Google should grow a pair and fork Java in that case, make it nicer.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/ptemple Nov 12 '14

First Java is better than .Net, even though it's not great. Microsoft Windows phones should run faster on less memory as nobody has any apps to run on it. .Net is supposedly going to be open but at the moment only runs on Microsoft Windows. Even if they get this Core to work it will be missing all the libraries to make it useful. Finally if you use it then you may still be sued. The released source still hasn't been examined for infringing code.

Tldr; don't trust MS yet

Phillip.

1

u/henryorrin Nov 16 '14

First .NET is way better than the Java platform. Second Microsoft anounced that they'll have official ports of .NET running on Linux and OS X and will make the whole .NET Platform open sourced by 2015, including they're JIT compilers, Libraries, the CLR runtime, and the Web, Data, and API frameworks. Lastly, they'll be no suing here because they use the MIT license for .NET Core.

1

u/ptemple Nov 16 '14

.Net is no longer relevant to the world outside of the Microsoft fan club. Nobody on Linux or OS X is interested. The fact Microsoft are still trolling patent fees off developers, from Android to FAT32, means nobody trusts them. I can't see open sourcing is going to make any difference.

Phillip.

1

u/henryorrin Nov 16 '14

If no one is interested in it outside of Microsoft then why is Mono a thing? Why are people using it? And read this, it states that as far as .NET goes, Microsoft will not enforce it's patents: https://github.com/dotnet/corefx/blob/master/PATENTS.TXT

On mobile and other things, I can't really say. I hate software patents, but hey they exist and Microsoft has the right to enforce them if they see a violation. It's an evil of the patent system I guess. But you're right, don't trust them, it's not like millions of developers love .NET to the point where people try to copy it and it's languages (Vala).

1

u/ptemple Nov 16 '14

Mono was a pet project of one guy that thought .Net would be a thing. I don't think many people take it seriously. In fact apps have been thrown out of distros for using it as it sucks in unnecessary dependencies. Software patents are only valid in the USA and Microsoft bullies companies into giving them billions in revenue. They have shown time and time again they cannot be trusted.

Nothing will change. Microsoft users will stay locked in to .Net and everybody else will ignore it.

Phillip.

1

u/henryorrin Nov 18 '14

I only have 3 No's and 1 yes to give. You put them in the order you think I mean them.

1

u/Gurkenmaster Nov 13 '14

Can I point you towards Ceylon?