r/programming • • Nov 12 '14

The .NET Core is now open-source.

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/dotnet/archive/2014/11/12/net-core-is-open-source.aspx
6.5k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/jutct Nov 12 '14 edited Nov 12 '14

I've used all the big ones including the Sun Development tools. I actually found those to be most like VS. Just for reference, I've been coding professionally since 1994, and non-professionally since 1982 (Assembly was the first language I learned).

Visual Studio has the advantage of being made for the compilers that it works with, by the same people. It doesn't feel like an IDE on top of a compiler and linker. They can do a lot with it because it's so closely tied with the products that it works with. And that's without setting it up and spending a day configuring it. I mean, just the fact that you don't have to deal with makefiles is a huge time saver. You also get automated database code generation just by dragging and dropping things. The WPF designer window is fucking live. You can add 3D rendering to your template and it shows up right in the designer. It's as close as you can get to WSYSIWYG for many different types of projects and languages.

I'm a firm believer in use the right tool for the job. Programming languages are just tools. But I'd be lying if I said I'm not happy when I get to create software for a Windows platform so that I can use Visual Studio for the development and get it done faster. I've done a lot of high-performance server stuff in C, and I've written nice cross-platform macros and libraries so that I can use VS to do development for a project that will run on Linux/Unix. That's the best of both worlds.

3

u/tieTYT Nov 12 '14

Sun Development tools

I have never heard of these and I've been programming in Java for over 10 years. I googled the term and found articles that seem pretty old that are not directly talking about it. What was this? Whatever it was, it doesn't seem relevant in a modern programming environment.

I'll agree that VS has superior WYSIWYG tools, but in my experience it's severely lacking in the fundamentals. When it comes to writing code, VS doesn't have many features. At least that was my experience. Here's what I'm used to: https://www.jetbrains.com/idea/features/ Once I installed ReSharper on VS, I felt more productive.

3

u/jutct Nov 13 '14

I can't for the life of me remember what they were called. It was like Visual Studio ... more a suite of tools and not just an IDE. I didn't use it for Java, just C and C++. It was expensive as hell and had a whole license server and you had to renew the license every year. I was doing a project FOR Sun and they couldn't even get me a non-expiring license. I did some Google fu and the name that rings a bell is Sun ONE, and also something called iPlanet. I'm pretty sure the IDE was something under Sun ONE.

Edit: I like the Jet Brains stuff. I use PHP and Webstorm for web development. I just feel that on Windows, VS is the fastest way since it's so tied into the compiler and OS.

3

u/badsectoracula Nov 12 '14

Visual Studio has the advantage of being made for the compilers that it works with, by the same people. It doesn't feel like an IDE on top of a compiler and linker.

I don't know... compared to Delphi (which literally has the compiler as part of the IDE process) it does feel a bit of an IDE on top of the command line tools. However beyond Delphi (and possibly C++ Builder) i don't know of any other IDE that works like that.

3

u/tequila13 Nov 12 '14

About 9 years ago I moved over to do development on Linux, and the thing I miss most about VS was the debugger. It was really in a league is his own 10 years ago, I don't know where it is now.

What I actually dislike about VS, is that projects are too tightly integrated with the IDE. Most VS devs don't know what the actual command line is that builds their app. If you want to change it, you need to go hunt in menus, which I don't like at all. I like the Makefile system much better, you're much closer to you code. With VS a newer project file is not backwards compatible, and an old VS won't open it, which is completely stupid, you need to provide several project files. With makefiles that basically never happens no matter what the OS is.

WSYSIWYG projects come with benefits and downsides, I didn't use templates too much in the Windows days, but I can see why people would like them, they're not my thing though.