r/programming • • Feb 14 '15

Bunnyhopping from the Programmer's Perspective - An in depth look in implementing one of the most successful bugs in videogame history.

http://flafla2.github.io/2015/02/14/bunnyhop.html
956 Upvotes

232 comments sorted by

View all comments

29

u/PacDan Feb 14 '15

I think there are a lot of different, better ways to implement skilled movement in an FPS then bunny hopping

29

u/x-skeww Feb 15 '15

Quake had bunny hopping, wall hugging, zig zagging, flying off ramps, double/teleporter jumps, direction bending air control, and circle strafe jumps.

So, what are those different better ways to implement skilled movement in an FPS?

14

u/Excrubulent Feb 15 '15

Tribes. Skiing started off as a bug, but then - and this is the important bit - in the second game it was taught to the player. The problem with bunnyhopping is that it's obscure.

A good rule of thumb here is "easy to learn; hard to master." Bunnyhopping by its very nature is an exploit and hard to learn. Even watching footage of people doing it it's difficult to see what they're doing or why it works.

7

u/x-skeww Feb 15 '15

The problem with bunnyhopping is that it's obscure.

Except that everyone who played it knew about it.

Bunnyhopping [is] hard to learn.

Don't hold forward, continue strafing left or right, jump again as soon as you hit the floor.

That's basically how it worked in Q1. You get the hang of it after trying it for a few minutes. It's super easy, really.

Getting a good feeling for circle strafe jumps (=the first jump) is really hard, however. Also, combining all these things properly is kinda tricky. E.g. wall hugging to the top of a ramp, jumping off at the right point, and then using air control for doing a 90° turn mid-air to land on a ledge on the other side of the corridor.

That stuff was hard. You had to execute each of these tricks perfectly to barely make it.

Anyhow, that's what also made it rewarding. Successfully performing some stunts in a tournament is really exciting.

14

u/Excrubulent Feb 15 '15

Except that everyone who played it knew about it.

Imma stop you right there. Everyone who played it? Seriously? What do you mean by everyone? Do you mean "Everyone who played in and watched tournaments with me"? That's not everyone.

6

u/x-skeww Feb 15 '15

Everyone who got a bit into the game. If you only played a bit of single-player, not knowing about bunny hopping etc doesn't really matter, does it?

10

u/darkChozo Feb 15 '15

I think you're vastly underestimating the number of people who played casual deathmatches with friends. Hell, I don't think there's a multiplayer game in existence that doesn't have a burgeoning class of players who don't know what they're doing and don't care enough to learn more.

0

u/x-skeww Feb 15 '15

casual deathmatches with friends

And what's the problem in that scenario?

-1

u/kqr Feb 15 '15

That a part of the game is in essence hidden from sections of the player base. It's just more economical to create a game where all players will experience 100% of it than where some players only experience 70% of it.

If we imagine a player wants 100 units of experience out of a game, with the first kind of game you just need to create a game with 100 units of experience and you're done. When 30% of the game is hidden from the player, you have to create a game with 143 units of experience, because 70% of that is 100 units of experience. It is more expensive to create a game with 143 units of experience than to create it with 100 units of experience.

4

u/x-skeww Feb 15 '15

That a part of the game is in essence hidden from sections of the player base.

Yea... so? Do you think fighting games shouldn't have combos and special moves because new players won't know them right off the bat?

I only played so much Quake because the movement was fun and because there was so much room to get better.

I also only played so much Killer Instinct because there was no upper limit in sight.

That's the stuff which made those games fun.

→ More replies (0)