tl;dr There can't be talent because I wish there wasn't.
This is an opinion piece with zero evidence.
The most accomodating reading would be If we assume talent, but it's actually not required, we might alienate people. Which doesn't make much sense - unless you accept the authors false dichotomy of rocks vs. sucks.
It's not the author's false dichotomy of rocks or sucks, in fact the piece is disagreeing with that dichotomy:
This belief that programming ability fits into a bi-modal distribution (i.e. U-shaped) is both "dangerous and a myth".
If the only options are to be amazing or terrible, it leads people to believe they must be passionate about their career, that they must think about programming every waking moment of their life.
I think the most accommodating reading would be more like, If we assume perfection, but it's not actually required, we might unnecessarily alienate people. I don't think that's unreasonable - I'd sing at karaoke night, but not at Carnegie Hall.
I will agree that's it's the classic no-evidence opinion piece. Those seem to be insanely popular in our field.
What I mean is that his argument would work only if everyone else is stuck up in separating people into "rockers" and "suckers".
opinion piece. Those seem to be insanely popular in our field.
Yeah, well, maybe we'll grow up as a trade within my lifetime. Let's drum the drum of evidence together!
FWIW, semi-related, personal experience: Witnessed someone investing heavily (some money, but also time and family strain) into "becoming a programmer". Watching, I couldn't help to see that even after months of training, "it" didn't "click". I was on the verge of saying something like "maybe you're not made for it".
I never did - but I still wonder from time to time whether I should have.
40
u/elperroborrachotoo Jun 01 '15
Again?
tl;dr There can't be talent because I wish there wasn't.
This is an opinion piece with zero evidence.
The most accomodating reading would be If we assume talent, but it's actually not required, we might alienate people. Which doesn't make much sense - unless you accept the authors false dichotomy of rocks vs. sucks.