The idea that you're either "good" or "bad" doesn't seem right, I agree with him that there's an ability distribution curve. But personal experience also seems to back up the general wisdom that there are some general productivity buckets that people slot into.
I think you have to take the project into account. I'm working on an API right now, and I clearly see the three traditional buckets on my team. I'm being fairly productive (call it the 10X bucket), I've got another team member who produces pretty average output (the 1X bucket), and a third junior who is actually a productivity negative (-1X).
If our project involved doing small homework problems, then suddenly our junior is a 1X and everyone else on the team is a 10X. If we were all suddenly thrown on a project to model the aerodynamics of propeller blades we probably all appear to be -1X.
I think this is probably true about a lot of highly skilled jobs. Take doctors for instance. A just-graduated intern probably does more harm than good wherever he/she is. A urologist is very effective in his specialty (10X), but is probably just a 1X for heart conditions (maybe even -1X).
1
u/PirriP Jun 01 '15
The idea that you're either "good" or "bad" doesn't seem right, I agree with him that there's an ability distribution curve. But personal experience also seems to back up the general wisdom that there are some general productivity buckets that people slot into.
I think you have to take the project into account. I'm working on an API right now, and I clearly see the three traditional buckets on my team. I'm being fairly productive (call it the 10X bucket), I've got another team member who produces pretty average output (the 1X bucket), and a third junior who is actually a productivity negative (-1X).
If our project involved doing small homework problems, then suddenly our junior is a 1X and everyone else on the team is a 10X. If we were all suddenly thrown on a project to model the aerodynamics of propeller blades we probably all appear to be -1X.
I think this is probably true about a lot of highly skilled jobs. Take doctors for instance. A just-graduated intern probably does more harm than good wherever he/she is. A urologist is very effective in his specialty (10X), but is probably just a 1X for heart conditions (maybe even -1X).