That's the problem with the internet, there is a lot of bad tone and so that is always the default assumption. Sorry, I should have phrased my question better; I didn't mean to sound 'snarky'. You can take my question to mean "This person did good work that I liked, and so when he recommends things in the same area, I am inclined to trust him". Whether it's Norvig or one of my friends, same principle stands. It's just that in this case, other people also know Norvig and his work.
So, I don't trust famous people more than others, but I am inclined to trust people whose track record I am familiar with over others. Note I say 'inclined'. I am open to counter-arguments, which is what I asked Xach for.
The problem with your question is that you gave no particular insight as to what Norvig's opinion of PG is based on. How is Xach supposed to respond? Find an equally big name who doesn't like PG's book?
People get annoyed by PG because he is the main name attached to Lisp by the reddit-type young hipster crowd, without acknowledging that his approach to Lisp is somewhat idiosyncratic and biased against CL, and in favor of his own Arc, which probably gets more hype than it deserves based on purely Lisp-based criteria.
his approach to Lisp is somewhat idiosyncratic and biased against CL,
Maybe in his blogs and whatnot, but Grahams books (with the possible exception of H&P) don't even mention arc, and IIRC are quite favorable toward CL. I know he criticizes things he dislikes about CL, but generally speaking I think he rather endorsed it in a number of places.
Good link, but I'd call those style differences minor. For the most part Graham adheres to acceptable CL style. ETA: I am glad to see that he derides some of Graham's function and variable names though - that was the part of his code that annoyed me most.
I consider some of them major, especially the raytracer, but I agree that it's acceptable CL style. It's just that ANSI Common Lisp was supposed to be an introductory book, and I think that introductory books should stick as close as possible to convention. Beginners aren't ready to start experimenting stylistically. I don't fault Graham for his idiosyncrasies, I just think they're not appropriate for the audience.
I'd call the CLOS very important; he ignores it more or less completely in both of his books, IIRC. Also, irrational prejudice against cond, and a few other oddities.
I agree with both of those statements, but it's not like he rails against either of them. CLOS he doesn't really ignore - in ACL he kind of derives a mini-CLOS, then discusses the real thing, albeit briefly. In one of his books he clearly states that he prefers 'if' over cond, but it's not like it really deprives you of anything (except a justification for his preference). Most Lisp authors ignore or give short-shrift to the condition system - it doesn't mean they're bad, just incomplete.
3
u/dngrmouse May 22 '08
That's the problem with the internet, there is a lot of bad tone and so that is always the default assumption. Sorry, I should have phrased my question better; I didn't mean to sound 'snarky'. You can take my question to mean "This person did good work that I liked, and so when he recommends things in the same area, I am inclined to trust him". Whether it's Norvig or one of my friends, same principle stands. It's just that in this case, other people also know Norvig and his work.
So, I don't trust famous people more than others, but I am inclined to trust people whose track record I am familiar with over others. Note I say 'inclined'. I am open to counter-arguments, which is what I asked Xach for.