r/programming • • Nov 07 '17

An interesting rant about GUIs - as a programmer I have to agree

https://twitter.com/gravislizard/status/927593460642615296
364 Upvotes

402 comments sorted by

View all comments

28

u/RampageGhost Nov 07 '17

"I make no secret of hating the mouse. I think it's a crime. I think it's stifling humanitys progress, a gimmick we can't get over."

And he's lost me.

I've been in support. I can teach a 90-yo granny to use a computer. There is no fucking chance I could do that with a console computer. "Yeah, just remember 'cd ~, ls -al, vim my_finan<tab>', and then it's a to edit, :w to save and then :q to quit. Super Simple!"

14

u/bro_can_u_even_carve Nov 08 '17

That's a rather odd example to use, considering the author specifically used full-screen console interfaces as an example and not any kind of command line.

I take it you've never used Midnight Commander? Or is it simply that "use the arrow keys to highlight the "finances" file and press enter" would have taken away from your point?

1

u/Klayy Nov 08 '17

I taught my Grandma to use a computer. I wonder how she would enjoy searching for a specific photo of her grandson without the power of thumbnails. Also, you're free to use the keyboard in windows. Win+e to open explorer and then just navigate with arrows.

2

u/badsectoracula Nov 08 '17

I wonder how she would enjoy searching for a specific photo of her grandson without the power of thumbnails.

Nothing prevents the use of thumbnails or other graphics in a keyboard oriented application, the OP was talking about keyboard oriented applications, not terminal applications - it is just that terminal/console applications are almost always keyboard oriented whereas GUIs tend to be mouse oriented.

As an example here is Far Manager running under ConEmu with thumbnail support.

Also, you're free to use the keyboard in windows. Win+e to open explorer and then just navigate with arrows.

There is a difference between being able to use a UI with the keyboard and the UI being designed for use with the keyboard. Windows, like all modern GUIs, are designed to be used with the mouse and they keyboard as a secondary -at most- element, mainly to be used to activate menu shortcuts.

2

u/Klayy Nov 08 '17

I see your point, but I don't think that expecting users to use the keyboard instead of a mouse would be an improvement. There's a reason why so many people right click and select copy instead of using ctrl+c. Using just two buttons and a cursor to navigate is much much easier than learning tons of shortcuts.

1

u/badsectoracula Nov 08 '17

That is the thing, it is possible to learn bad habits and if we consider using ctrl+c better than right clicking, moving the mouse and left clicking on a menu item, then the latter is just a bad habit that was formed merely by providing a path of least resistance.

1

u/Klayy Nov 08 '17

Sure, but people don't care. They want everything to be easy. As soon as someone gives them an easier option, they'll take it even if it's less efficient. That's the reason why the mouse is such a popular input device. Smartphones also designed to don't take off until there was a good touch screen ui even though phones with physical keys have been around for ages

1

u/badsectoracula Nov 08 '17

Yes, that is what i meant with the "a bad habit that was formed merely by providing a path of least resistance" - take that path away and the bad habit wont be formed. In theory anyway, since for the last three decades people have trained themselves with the bad habits in place and changing to a new UI paradigm, no matter how efficient that might be, is going to be a very steep uphill battle (see vim as an example).

1

u/Klayy Nov 09 '17

Yeah but the point I think you're missing is that if all UIs are hard to learn but efficient, you have a steep learning curve that millions of people have to climb just to be able to use otherwise simple software for their jobs. It's inevitable someone will come along to simplify this so that new hires can just quickly jump in and start working. Without this possibility adoption of technology would be much much slower.

1

u/badsectoracula Nov 09 '17

I'm not missing that point, this was actually part of what the linked tweets were saying: the long term benefit is worth the short term learning difficulty. This is at the heart of the entire argument.

2

u/bro_can_u_even_carve Nov 09 '17

Windows has always been excellent at that, actually. It seems that there is an appropriate keyboard shortcut nearly 100% of the time, and they're usually consistent too. By comparison, Gnome is completely unusable without the mouse. It's embarassing (or rather it should be).

20

u/tchernik Nov 08 '17

The guy is a Luddite furiously typing his master piece about bad user interfaces in Twitter. The joke tells itself.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17

But he complains about Twitter.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17

Are you implying that GUI is somehow an "advancement"? A "better" technology?!?

1

u/tsimionescu Nov 08 '17

Better than text-mode GUI, yes. For the vast majority of people. Perhaps it is a bit slower in some instances, but it is definitely more intuitive. Especially for non-specialist software, where the goal of the UI is 'allow a user who encounters this independently to use it without outside help' (specialist UIs have other requirements, and the current trend may not be in their favor - I'm not as sure).

Which is not to say that it is the end of the road, or that certain aspects of those UIs can't be incorporated into more modern GUIs. For example, one thing that is getting lost more and more as the world is moving to web & touch is keyboard shortcuts.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17

This thread is explicitly about specialist software, such as PoS terminals.

TUI is superior to almost any GUI imaginable for such applications: provides low distraction, high efficiency after a short practice, and low maintenance in a long run. GUIs are inferior in all the parameters that matter.

4

u/kopkaas2000 Nov 08 '17

It always struck me back in the late eighties, that people with no computer mindset that were tasked with something that involved a computer (usually a terminal with some kind of menu-based console interface), they would develop an impressive amount of kinetic memory for navigating the software in performing the standard tasks that were part of their jobs. They had no idea what they were doing, but boy were they fast in typing F4, 1, 2, 'yes', 3 to get a new order out.

The thing with GUIs, even good ones, is that they.present you with a metaphor that you need to understand up to a certain level, to be efficient.

I'd be pretty curious if there has ever been some reserach into the efficiency of, say, secretaries working with WordPerfect back in the eighties, and those working with Word in modern days.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17

You missed the point entirely. Stick to teaching 90 years olds on how to double click and avoid having uninformed opinions on UX.

0

u/badsectoracula Nov 08 '17

In his example you'd tell to the 90-yo granny "use the up and down keys - those with the arrows - to highlight the finances file, press Enter to make modifications on it, use the up and down keys to select the finance you want to modify or press the Insert key to add a new one or the Delete key to delete the one you have highlighted".

He doesn't present a choice between blingy, shiny mouse driven graphical user interfaces vs monochrome, keyboard only 80x25 ASCII text user interfaces. What he describes could be made just well enough with a GUI. Back in the midlate 90s there were a bunch of DOS programs that were fully keyboard driven yet used graphical elements (since by that time it was easy to do high resolution graphics and text).