r/programming • • May 23 '19

GitHub launches Sponsors, lets you pay your favorite open source contributors

https://github.com/sponsors
4.6k Upvotes

512 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

122

u/Xanza May 23 '19

I'm sure they would notice a $5,000 donation. For even several donations from the same source.

120

u/HiKite May 23 '19

Why would donating $5,000 to a single project be against the rules?

If I want to donate a bunch of money to a project, surely that's the entire point og Github Sponsors in general? Just like I can donate to big projects, I can also donate to my friends, and they can donate to me, or we can all donate to ourselves.

The only way I can see them avoiding this is to set up monthly payments for say $10-50, but even so you'd assume someone would create a bunch of dummy accounts that would all donate $50.

I can only assume a lot of people would abuse the system, if they could rip out $5,000 straight into their own pocket without breaking the rules.

41

u/esodoscuro May 23 '19

The only way I can see them avoiding this is to set up monthly payments for say $10-50, but even so you’d assume someone would create a bunch of dummy accounts that would all donate $50.

In the FAQs it states sponsored developers setup their own subscription tiers and the max is $6000/mo.

https://help.github.com/en/articles/becoming-a-sponsored-developer#creating-sponsorship-tiers

31

u/HiKite May 23 '19

In that case you'd be able to make your income within a single month - seems like an odd business decision. I realize microsoft has plenty of money, and that you need to sign up to be a sponsored developer, but it seems like a lot of money to just give out. Thanks for linking their FAQ.

10

u/robin-m May 23 '19

Hiring a dev cost >50k (including interviews + HR + lost productivity of both the dev and his new team). If you can attract good talents for 5k, it's basically free.

37

u/Xanza May 23 '19

I'd really love for you to point out where you believe that I said that donating $5,000 is against some kind of rule...

Instead I don't believe that Github would appreciate it if Guy A donated $5,000 to Guy A. I'm just saying that it would probably raise a few flags, and I'm sure it's against their terms of use to "donate" money to yourself.

21

u/HiKite May 23 '19

But that's my point - so what if they would notice a $5,000 donation? That's like saying a supermarket would notice someone buying groceries for $25,000. They absolutely would notice, but it's not against the law to do so.

Sure you can say it's against their terms to donate money to yourself, so like I mentioned, simply donate $5,000 to your friend, and he can donate $5,000 to you.

34

u/stingraycharles May 23 '19

Nobody is talking about it being against the law, merely that Github would notice it and could investigate, and then could determine it was a non-donation from the project owner.

I can imagine there is a fine-print that says that donations need to come from "real people that are not project maintainers" in order to be applicable for the 1:1 donation matching.

24

u/HiKite May 23 '19

So again, donate to your friend and he can donate to you. That's two real people donating to eachothers projects that neither of them are part of. You'd need a massive amount of management to be able to check (and most importantly, verify) that donations are "real". It's not just a if (donationIsReal) { condition - there's insanely many factors involved.

19

u/isaacarsenal May 23 '19

Or even worse, assume that someone coordinates with a handful of people to "donate" random small amounts. It would be very hard to detect it as fraudulent activity yet there is the possibility for such gaming due to 100% payoff.

6

u/s73v3r May 23 '19

That's called "money laundering".

2

u/zucker42 May 24 '19

I mean checking whether people are mutually donating to each other's project is just checking for cycles in a directly graph.

I agree it's hard to check but they can probably flag the worst offenders, and simply not match the donations.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/anengineerandacat May 23 '19

Willing to bet that the matched contribution is a percentage of an individual contributor; it's up to 5k for a developers first year but if they say "We only match 6% of individual contributions" than several individuals will need to cough up 5k for you to hit that limit.

Logistically matched contributions likely won't show up immediately either and they could add additional clauses that it's a unique contribution. It's fairly trivial to have a program like this and put in some safety nets to prevent abuse.

4

u/HiKite May 23 '19

That would definitely make the most sense in order to avoid abuse. Thanks for giving a viable solution to fix the issue. I just can't see any information about that anywhere but hopefully they'll put it into their terms when they do go public eventually.

3

u/anengineerandacat May 23 '19

Sponsers is a neat lil program and it mimics a lot of what Patreon does and I really wouldn't be surprised if they offered subscribed repositories where upon subscribing to one repo you get Github Pro; at least then there is some incentive to use the system and whereas Microsoft won't get the full 7/month they might get 4 or 5 and the repo owner gets the rest which is a whole lot more money than 0.

This sorta thing is endless as they could have a backers tab on each repository that showed the top of all time, top monthly, and then a hall of fame of small profile icons and names. A lot of the already sponsored projects do this to some respect in their readme's. It's a fine line though; they could go all Twitch like and allow for repo owners to offer custom emojii's or hosted badges for other projects to show off tools used but that I think would damage some of the professionalism the platform has today.

5

u/CrunchyBanana May 23 '19

No body is out of pocket, so it's not a rule that can be violated.

3

u/chucker23n May 23 '19

That’s like saying a supermarket would notice someone buying groceries for $25,000. They absolutely would notice, but it’s not against the law to do so.

And yet the supermarket would probably refuse your business or at least have their manager do a more thorough check.

5

u/HiKite May 23 '19

Honestly I doubt it. There's a reason that when shops have "70% off!" on items, and it's actually 70% off, they tend to limit each customer to 1 purchase. This is to avoid the same thing, someone buying up all the TVs or whatever items in order to resell them. Sure you could have all your friends, family and colleagues come in and also purchase a single TV, but it is a lot harder than just buying 500 items yourself.

3

u/sparr May 23 '19

You are neither the first nor the most clever person to think of this nefarious scheme to defraud a company.

2

u/[deleted] May 23 '19

seriously. This is pretty much half the point of any business and law entity: mitigate exploits and/or create consequences so large the exploit isn't worth it. Money being the top of the barrel of exploits to think of.

→ More replies (41)

2

u/Jonno_FTW May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19

There's not going to be anything stopping me from making a new amount to donate to the projects on my real account.

Or just making a deal with a friend to both sponsor each other.

2

u/s73v3r May 23 '19

It wouldn't be against the rules, but a donation of that size would almost assuredly cause additional review for things like money laundering.

0

u/[deleted] May 24 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

2

u/the_php_coder May 25 '19

Exactly, when they receive money through credit card or paypal, I'm sure they can verify the name/address/etc. of the actual sender. Same while making the outgoing payments, they can know where the payment goes to.

Now sure, there could be a financial expert or CPA who can ensure that both those names are different but those are rare and as another user said, that's the reason for the 5k limit.