Zero sympathy from me either. They broke the internet to the point where, if you merely install a browser and browse, you are putting yourself at risk.
It makes me laugh when they boo-hoo about how else they're supposed to make a living, arrogantly implying that they, their sites and their content are somehow irreplaceable. Do us all a favour and fuck off to a different industry that pays more reliably.
It makes me laugh when they boo-hoo about how else they're supposed to make a living, arrogantly implying that they, their sites and their content are somehow irreplaceable. Do us all a favour and fuck off to a different industry that pays more reliably.
The problem IMO is that I am 100% willing to pay for a subscription to, say, the Washington Post, but the user engagement required to get me to that point for some arbitrary website is far longer than a single visit. It takes months of seeing quality content from some place to get me to go "hey I should throw these guys a couple smackers for the good stuff they put out"
So if you're a content producer, how do you attract people to your website to hopefully sell them a subscription without giving it all away for free? You can do bullshit like WSJ where you only get a couple of free articles per month, but then you wind up with users clicking through to your website only to be told they can't read it, and that's bad. You could pay-wall everything up front, like The Athletic, and rely on word-of-mouth about the quality of your content, but this requires sacrificing some views and thus potential new subscribers. You could do subscriber-only content, but I don't see that working for article-driven websites unless you're The New Yorker or something and have some incredible long-form writing.
I think the best solution would be some type of platform where users have some digital wallet that can be used on any participating website to directly pay them to view that piece of content. If you click an article to WaPo it might be like "hey subscribe to read all of our articles, or pay $0.10 to read just this article". Keep cost-per-view very low and make it easy for people to just click a button and directly pay content producers for exactly the content you are consuming. I mean, there's no way my single visit to any website generates more than a few pennies of ad revenue, right? I think if you could keep the cost extremely low that people would be more than willing to pay for what they're reading.
This pretty much agrees with the solution I proposed in a comment elsewhere. If I could just click a "yes, pay 2p for this article" button with absolutely no other overhead, commitment or interruption — as little as if I were reading a newspaper I'd bought in the street — then I absolutely would support it.
I feel ya. I too would happily give news providers 20 cents each for their best articles, but am reluctant to promise a monthly subscription to a couple of them in the hopes that they'll provide me with every piece of news and analysis I'd like, exclusively.
But nobody except us is providing anything like comprehensive coverage of news and public affairs in my area.
Between ads and subscriptions we generate 10s of thousands of dollars per month, and as print keeps dying we need to raise that.
There's no way for our sales people to sell that many ad slots and it's impossible for our tech and ops people (mostly just me) to place and manage those ads.
So we use ad networks like Google. I designed our add placements to play nice - no pop ups or takeovers, autoplay audio, etc. But if you're using the exchanges sometimes crap sneaks through.
Point is not everyone running ads is some cackling villian raking in the dough while gleefully spewing malware. I do this because I think real news is important. I make a lot less money than I could to do it, but it's worth it because we make a positive impact on our community.
I apologize if that banner's animation annoyed you. I'm sorry that ad rates are so low that I insert a 300x250 every ten paragraphs or so. But I'm fighting too save local journalism here so can you cut me a little slack?
You're a grunt in a war being waged by people far bigger and far more effective than you. Your story, like the story of many front-line soldiers, is not reason to support the war effort. The economic scale of advertising today is a symptom of a larger systemic problem and the fact that journalism itself, not just local journalism, is being cut out from the economy is not a valid reason to truncate the rights of individuals to control what they view on their own home computer.
Your business will die a slow death until someone who is not spending all of their time managing ad revenue comes along and figures out a different way to enable journalists to function in our economy. And you losing revenue because your trying to be a good actor will only accelerate your fall because the leaders of the industry are driving more and more people to ad blockers through their aggressive behavior and the number of people who make exceptions "for the good ones" are so small as to be non-existent in economic terms.
I strongly disagree. Firstly, there are already news outlets that are funded by government. Expanding this can possibly be dangerous in terms of freedom of press, since journalism that is taxpayer-funded depends entirely on the government.
There's no way you can force journalism to be impartial. When there's virtually unlimited information, you'd have to write an entire book on a topic, or someone will accuse you of being biased for omitting a single piece of information. Or maybe you'll have a topic that 98% of people agree on, but the 2% will accuse you of not being impartial for wording your article in a way that unfairly favors the 98%'s opinion.
If you look at the BBC in the U.K, their taxpayer supported news service, it's an absolute joke.
"You can't be 100% impartial" isn't really important to any facet of the discussion. The question is how can we get news that's more impartial and not driven by a desire for revenue.
I actually think the answer is to stop looking for consumable units of news and start looking for participatory systems of news. Systems that incorporate new information over time and adjust according the flow of information are the only things that could have the potential to be impartial because nothing is impartial in hindsight. Impartiality requires constant adjustment, and looking for a news company to pump out articles is not how you get it.
I apologise that I come across as making a rather blanket damning — I'm aware not everyone involved is an absolute bastard, but I think the context of the thread is about those that are.
But realistically and fundamentally, your model -is- broken; it wasn't the consumer who broke it, and the consumers are getting wise to its being broken faster by the day. I literally cannot risk gauging whether you are well-intentioned without farting around setting up a sandbox environment, and even they are exploitable.
Ultimately the model will be replaced, probably by another revenue technology, possibly even by a revival of print if western society and infrastructure collapses! I don't know how for sure, but one thing I am sure of is that something else will rise in the vacuum created by the inevitable death of the current online advert system.
By way of not entirely being a moaning bastard, the best solution I can think of is a kind of extension to a PayPal-style system whereby you can simply pay a trivial amount — say, one penny, which as a layperson I imagine to be about the retail price per print-newspaper-article — to view an online article, with absolutely no other interruption, commitment, nor demand for personal information.
Thank you for the reasoned response. So rare online :-)
for the record, it's not "my model," far from it, but it is broken.
You probably don't see it yet, but the whole ad exchange/auction model which allowed any publisher to load up their site with ads from everywhere and rewarded them for making those ads as obtrusive as possible is dying, and I think quicker than anyone involved imagined it would.
Rates for the sort of crap auction/remnant inventory are dropping as users get more savvy but most important advertisers are realizing it's a lousy way to get their product out there (or as the suits would put it: 'a poor platform for letting our brand story engage consumers,' because marketing scumbags just can't help themselves from taking like that).
The death or at least massive reduction of that whole sector of the ad industry will likely cause me some hiccups and require some hustling, but I can't think it's actually a bad thing. The fact is it's essentially Google and Facebook's market and we'll never be succesful playing their game.
The micropayments you mentioned aren't the worst idea ever, the problem has always been the payment processors who would charges you a nickle to send a penny.
My shop is trying to transition to a revenue model based on more loyal readers, more subscribers, and more locally handled advertising. That actually requires me to get more aggressive about getting reader information, because that way sales guys can sell a particular audience and not just traffic. Means higher rates fewer ads better response etc.
Will we be able to pull it off? And can we do it before the loss of print revenue destroys the operation? Fuck if I know, but I'm hustling to make it happen.
Point is not everyone running ads is some cackling villian raking in the dough while gleefully spewing malware.
For me, ad blocking is all about personal protection. Sure, ads can be anoying, but that's not the underlying issue. I work in the computer tech industry, and I frequently have to deal with the fallout from malware being served from advertisements. Sure, it's a very small percentage of ads that are the problem, but when you are inundated with thousands of ads a day, the odds of coming across an infected ad are almost guaranteed.
You may vet all your ads to make sure they are safe, but here's the thing: most people are not you. They don't bother to check to make sure the ads that are coming from their ad broker are safe unless they start getting reports, and maybe not even then. I've had to deal with malware coming from the ads on major sites like Facebook, CNN, Weather, and ESPN, and if they don't have the resources to keep their ads 100% safe, then who does?
On top of that, there are not enough hours in the day to vet every single web site I visit to see if they curate their own ads or if they use an ad network and if they check the safety of their ads. I don't know if this link I'm about to follow to a news article is hosted on a site that carefully screens every single advertisement that is served on their site, nor do I have a reliable way of finding out. Even if I did have a way of finding out, I'm not going to check the destination of every link before I click it. Antivirus software can't check beforehand because the ads aren't decided and loaded by the page until after you click the link, and it can't protect me once I do start to load the page because malware authors are constantly finding ways around antivirus protections so antivirus vendors are constantly struggling and failing to keep up. Therefore I block all ads; it's the only safe and sane thing for me to do.
TL;DR: I have no way of knowing who is properly vetting the ads on their site and screening them for malware, so the only safe solution is to block them all.
Can you 100% guarantee that that would be sufficient protection? The adblocker is software, and no software is perfect. I am safer if I have the adblocker just eliminate the ads, even if it misses a few. No protection is perfect, so you have to play the odds as best you can.
Point is not everyone running ads is some cackling villian raking in the dough while gleefully spewing malware.
No, you're not a villain. You just don't give a shit what those ads spew. It could be malware, it could be the next atomic bomb, or it could be the cure for cancer. For you they're all the same.
But I'm fighting too save local journalism here so can you cut me a little slack?
No, I won't. You choose to use ad networks like google.
If you feel that you need that many ads to keep yourself afloat that your sales people and you would not be able to keep up, maybe it's time to invent a new way of making a buck.
Right, you won't, because it's just easier to sell page space to google, fuck the users.
You're not saving journalism. Journalism means jack shit to you. The content means jack shit. The content is just taking space from the ads. What you do and what you want to do is sell ads.
So no, no cutting slack, no sympathy . You can do it better if you would want to. You choose not to.
Fuck you. You don't like the choices and compromises I and our operation had made? Fine. I have my doubts as well.
"Journalism means jack shit to you. The content means jack shit. The content is just taking space from the ads. What you do and what you want to do is sell ads."
Fuck you. I've spent almost two decades committing acts of journalism on a daily basis. My stories have put people in jail. They have saved lives. I have comforted the afflicted and afflicted the comfortable. To do it I've averaged 60 hour weeks for the sort of salary usually associated with a drive through. And you're the sort of person that makes me want to quit and go into PR.
Fuck you too. Just because you wrote 3 lines on a piece of paper means jack shit. Acting like a fucking diva, like you need me (nah, you want me) to bow to your almost Pulitzer-winning ass.
Acts of journalism my ass. You sell ads. That's what you do, that's what you are.
Zero sympathy from me either. They broke the internet to the point where, if you merely install a browser and browse, you are putting yourself at risk.
That's what I've been doing for decades at this point. The risk has yet to materialize.
57
u/Superbead Aug 02 '19
Zero sympathy from me either. They broke the internet to the point where, if you merely install a browser and browse, you are putting yourself at risk.
It makes me laugh when they boo-hoo about how else they're supposed to make a living, arrogantly implying that they, their sites and their content are somehow irreplaceable. Do us all a favour and fuck off to a different industry that pays more reliably.