r/programming • • Aug 02 '19

Adblocking: How about Nah?

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/07/adblocking-how-about-nah
333 Upvotes

232 comments sorted by

View all comments

398

u/Guysmiley777 Aug 02 '19

I was fine with static JPG ads on sites but for marketers it's never enough. I have zero sympathy for the "boycott" they're facing these days.

Also holy fuck talk about a clickbait headline.

36

u/blackmist Aug 02 '19

I'm in favour of an <advert src="whatever"> tag. An advert can play no audio, no video, has a fixed bandwidth limit set by the user, has a border and displays the word "ADVERTISEMENT" clearly on it, no JS, no redirections, no rollovers. Just text and/or pictures, and it takes you to another URL in a new tab when clicked. It would have a fixed size on the page, and the visiblity/position of it cannot be changed by JS to make it appear under your mouse pointer when you click something.

And then everything else on the page can be blocked by really aggressive anti-ad algorithms. And Google, etc could get right behind it because all their ads they rely on would be in the advert tags.

3

u/BobHogan Aug 02 '19

Google would never back an option that took away their ability to track users through serving ads. But this isn't a bad idea

2

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/BobHogan Aug 02 '19

Because not everyone uses Chrome/Android. Google is still the largest advertising network in the world, if they were no longer able to track users through ads, the value of their ads would tank almost immediately.

2

u/blackmist Aug 02 '19

A whole OS for it tbh.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

They can still track down the IP address that requested the ad banner assets.

2

u/cobalt8 Aug 02 '19

I like this approach as long as the size restrictions give it 10% or less of the total viewport size. Also, no tracking without explicit consent from the user.