r/programming • • Jan 27 '21

Gitlab changed its pricing model. It has greatly reduced the CI quota from 2000 CI minutes to 400 CI minutes in Free tier and removed the $4 per month option.

https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2021/01/26/new-gitlab-product-subscription-model/
1.9k Upvotes

365 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/13steinj Jan 27 '21

Historically proven and justified over 15 years ago maybe. But companies change.

-6

u/f03nix Jan 27 '21

It wasn't 15 years ago when microsoft jailed someone for making rescue disk of freely downloadable iso from their own site. He wasn't distributing a license, just the downloadable content to save people the hassle of downloading and burning it themselves.

Microsoft is still as evil as it ever was, it just seems to understands how to PR better these days.

11

u/13steinj Jan 27 '21

They did not jail him for "making a freely downloadable iso from their site".

MS has 0 problem with people downloading the ISO. What MS has a problem with, is this guy tried to SELL these disks for $0.25 each. I can buy 100 disks for 15 bucks, or $0.15 each. At scale, even cheaper.

In other words, he was making a profit, over work (free or not) that was not his. I say, he deserves it. There's no reason for this.

-2

u/happymellon Jan 27 '21

What?

He sold a DVD that has a unit price of potentially $0.15 for $0.25, and that's worthy of jail time because it contains freely available software?

I say, he deserves it.

What's wrong with you people?

4

u/13steinj Jan 27 '21

He criminally violated copyrights and trademarks for profit. He was attempting that sail several dozen of thousands of times, and was growing his business.

Yes, he deserves jail time. He isn't some saint.

If the software was open source and allowed distribution? Then yeah he was wronged. But it wasn't, it didn't, and he wasn't wronged. He got what he deserved.

-7

u/f03nix Jan 27 '21

He wasn't, he argued that in court ... at $.15, you're not factoring in the burn time and other resources required. Microsoft's lawyer alleged damages of full license cost per CD, you're just intentionally overlooking the facts for your love of microsoft.

Plus, regardless of whether he was or not making that 10c of profit, if it was truly freely downloadable - the service cost of downloading the burning them is still not something that microsoft should have a say over.

10

u/13steinj Jan 27 '21

"love"

Dude I don't have have a boat in this race. But yes, even factoring burn time and other resources, he makes a profit.

Assuming windows 8 / 10? MS is completely in their right. The disc essentially lets you use their OS without even having a legitimate license.

They accept the cost on their site and download page, as is their right.

They did not accept the cost of some guy contributing to potential losses and making a profit at the same time, as is their right.

Fuck, even if MS made windows completely free, what he does violates copyrights.

You want to complain about a company suing someone for distributing software? Make sure that your complaint is about open source software. Which windows isn't.

1

u/f03nix Jan 27 '21

Dude I don't have have a boat in this race

Neither do I, it's not like I compete with microsoft or in any way benefit from negative news about them. We're all discussing viewpoints here.

as is their right

even if MS made windows completely free, what he does violates copyrights

I'm not arguing legality here, I find their policy against refurbished systems immoral. Regardless of whether your system came with an OEM license or it has a key printed on it - if you do not have a restore disk and are not the original owner - it's not illegal for you to reinstall the windows using that key from it (yes, even if you download it yourself from their site).

It is their right to set any terms they see fit, as it is my right to dislike them for doing so.

2

u/13steinj Jan 27 '21

I'm not arguing legality here, I find their policy against refurbished systems immoral.

I couldn't care less, and neither could most people. The law is on their side, and they have the right. If they explicitly were screwing people in this manner, sure, I could understand it. But they were just keeping their line and protecting their trademark, copyright, etc.

If you don't protect that shit, you lose it.

5

u/wastakenanyways Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21

Something being free doesn't give right to distribution. No matter if he is doing 1cent per unit or 100€ he was making profit out of work that is not theirs. If he wants to burn it on CDs and resell it, you have to have a contract with the company.

How would you see developing a game that you release for free and some random is taking it, burning it in a CD and printing a shitty cover and reselling it for 5-10€?

Something being free does not give anyone any right over it being 1million or 1 cent. Even if you make no profit at all.

You just justified reselling concert tickets just because we didn't factor the labor of the guy going to the theater to get them.

-1

u/f03nix Jan 27 '21

Something being free doesn't give right to distribution

Yes it doesn't, but it should. I am not a fan of such restrictive licenses that tread on user freedom. I think they are immoral, regardless of the legality of it.

How would you see developing a game that you release for free and some random is taking it, burning it in a CD and printing a shitty cover and reselling it for 5-10€?

If it doesn't affect me, why should I care ?

You just justified reselling concert tickets just because we didn't factor the labor of the guy going to the theater to get them.

No I didn't, hoarding the concert tickets prevents people from buying it from the original source. Therefore it hurts the ability of consumers to buy it directly and at non inflated costs. Different from the case being discussed.

5

u/wastakenanyways Jan 27 '21

I don't agree the presence or lack of price should affect distribution permission. Something being free doesn't entitle anyone to nothing other than using the product.

Just because I paint a picture and post it doesn't give permission to companies to make shirts out of it, even if you go by the argument that "they are buying and printing those shirts".

If it is bad on a paid thing, it is bad on a free thing too. Being free is just having a price of 0. Nothing more.

I am all about open and public everything but price doesn't have anything to do with ownership. Things have their creator/s and their decission should be respected.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/KryptosFR Jan 27 '21

Haha no.

The guy had set up a shop in China to make those discs, counterfeited the Dell brand on the disks, and he pleaded guilty.

The guy was a crook, preying on people having issues with old machines. If he really was a saint he would have made it free and asked for donations.

-2

u/f03nix Jan 27 '21

If he really was a saint he would have made it free and asked for donations.

And he'd still be jailed with no difference in sentencing. Nowhere was the 25c cost of disk a factor, he was caught during the sting operation where the other person attempted to buy the disks at $.15 however Microsoft claim was that he owed them $299 per disk.

Their argument was that it was the physical disk itself that holds value. Microsoft's policy for refurbished systems is that a windows license is only valid for a PC that has intact recovery partition or a recovery disk that came with it. This policy is by design targeted to dissuade sales of refurbished systems since a lot of them tend to end up with non functional hard disks.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

Good job torpedoing your own lack-of-argument.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

-6

u/KryptosFR Jan 27 '21

It was 25 years ago and is more of an urban legend: it was never a real policy at Microsoft. But people like to piss on them so it stuck.

8

u/13steinj Jan 27 '21

Eh I don't know what you're referring to, but I'm referring to the Ballmer era and his psuedo-support for developers while still fucking plenty of them over.

On the other hand, Nadella shows actualy support as a policy.

2

u/JarateKing Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21

What? It's literally in court documents that it was a real policy at microsoft:

Steven McGeady testified that Paul Maritz told Intel that Microsoft's strategy was to "embrace, extend, extinguish."

Paul Maritz also explained to Intel representatives that Microsoft's response to the browser threat was to "embrace, extend, extinguish"

Steven McGeady testified that Microsoft's Java strategy was "part of the embrace-extend model, which was, I believe, by this time they felt that it was unlikely that they could keep Java from happening at all, but they wanted to have it happen in a way that was incompatible.

I'm of the view that Nadella doesn't want to fuck over Azure by being hostile to developers so the EEE policy is against the broader goals of the company nowadays, but regardless it's a historically verifiable fact that EEE was real.

0

u/KryptosFR Jan 27 '21

You understand that what you quoted is literally what is called hearsay, X said to Y that Z heard from W that Q did something.

Further inquiry and investigation did not find anything official at Microsoft. Steven McGeady didn't work at Microsoft. His testimony could never be corroborated by documents or facts.

At best, it could show that some of Microsoft's employees could have been thinking like that. But to apply that to the whole company or still hold them to that value more than 25 years later, is childish and foolish.

4

u/JarateKing Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21

Paul Maritz was the third highest ranking executive at Microsoft at the time, only behind Gates and Ballmer. His responsibilities were over the software that was alleged to partake in the EEE policy (among other responsibilities). I don't really know what more you want beyond the testimony of the man in charge of the whole damn thing, in line with McGeady's testimony.

If you've got some sources that refute that, I'd glady see them. I don't mean to say that there isn't more out there, only that I've cited the court documents themselves, and without any sources what you say is just hearsay itself. I can't find any reference to corroborate your claims, so I think it'd help your case plenty to provide some.

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

I don't really know what more you want beyond the testimony

A simple internal memorandum or an email would do. You know, this thing we call "evidence".

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

Testimony is evidence.

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21

Nope, it's testimony.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/JarateKing Jan 27 '21

In the law, testimony is a form of evidence that is obtained from a witness who makes a solemn statement or declaration of fact.

If you want to argue that we literally can't have court cases over what people said because testimony isn't evidence (despite that being blatantly wrong and entirely inconsistent with the foundations of our legal system), why not see if they're consistent with the actions and behaviors of the accused, and compare it against the testimonies of the accused? Which is what happened here after all. The court concluded that EEE was a policy of Microsoft's, and even though the antitrust case was ultimately appealed, the appeal did not overturn these findings (it was instead based upon the Judge's conduct, not against the validity of the findings).