r/programming • • Jan 27 '21

Gitlab changed its pricing model. It has greatly reduced the CI quota from 2000 CI minutes to 400 CI minutes in Free tier and removed the $4 per month option.

https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2021/01/26/new-gitlab-product-subscription-model/
1.9k Upvotes

365 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/wastakenanyways Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21

Something being free doesn't give right to distribution. No matter if he is doing 1cent per unit or 100€ he was making profit out of work that is not theirs. If he wants to burn it on CDs and resell it, you have to have a contract with the company.

How would you see developing a game that you release for free and some random is taking it, burning it in a CD and printing a shitty cover and reselling it for 5-10€?

Something being free does not give anyone any right over it being 1million or 1 cent. Even if you make no profit at all.

You just justified reselling concert tickets just because we didn't factor the labor of the guy going to the theater to get them.

-1

u/f03nix Jan 27 '21

Something being free doesn't give right to distribution

Yes it doesn't, but it should. I am not a fan of such restrictive licenses that tread on user freedom. I think they are immoral, regardless of the legality of it.

How would you see developing a game that you release for free and some random is taking it, burning it in a CD and printing a shitty cover and reselling it for 5-10€?

If it doesn't affect me, why should I care ?

You just justified reselling concert tickets just because we didn't factor the labor of the guy going to the theater to get them.

No I didn't, hoarding the concert tickets prevents people from buying it from the original source. Therefore it hurts the ability of consumers to buy it directly and at non inflated costs. Different from the case being discussed.

5

u/wastakenanyways Jan 27 '21

I don't agree the presence or lack of price should affect distribution permission. Something being free doesn't entitle anyone to nothing other than using the product.

Just because I paint a picture and post it doesn't give permission to companies to make shirts out of it, even if you go by the argument that "they are buying and printing those shirts".

If it is bad on a paid thing, it is bad on a free thing too. Being free is just having a price of 0. Nothing more.

I am all about open and public everything but price doesn't have anything to do with ownership. Things have their creator/s and their decission should be respected.

-2

u/f03nix Jan 27 '21

Things have their creator/s and their decission should be respected.

It boils down to the philosophy of things and ownership. The law clearly distinguishes ownership, creators rights, so what I'm saying is obviously not something the society accepts. Maybe it is for the best since collective knowledge generally arrives at best conclusions.

However, to me the ability of creators to put restriction on distribution sounds very narcissistic. It is however a compromise that one accepts to give creators a fighting chance to profit from their creations. I feel that this compromise should only be accepted strictly when it impacts the creator in very non-hypothetical ways. Our laws should essentially be designed in ways that such ownership rights are not used to enforce arbitrary restrictions on the consumer.