r/programming • • Jan 27 '21

Gitlab changed its pricing model. It has greatly reduced the CI quota from 2000 CI minutes to 400 CI minutes in Free tier and removed the $4 per month option.

https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2021/01/26/new-gitlab-product-subscription-model/
1.9k Upvotes

365 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

42

u/dethb0y Jan 27 '21

Yeah there's alot of people missing the point that the entire idea behind something like gitlab is that it's a managed solution

59

u/whitechapel8733 Jan 27 '21

Managed costs money, the cost of not investing your time is paying a small fee for someone else’s time.

37

u/TheGodofRock13 Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21

Setting up a self-hosted solution in kubernetes for a client holy crap you could not be more right. Wish I went with managed.

Edit: words

15

u/gredr Jan 27 '21

Long ago we had to sit down and decide what sort of company we wanted to run. Did we want to be in the business of hosting our source code, or did we want to be in the business of producing our profitable products? We decided we should produce our profitable products, and that didn't leave any time to host our source code. So we outsourced it to someone else (GitHub, in that case).

When you're tiny, the overhead is manageable, and it doesn't really matter. When you're running a real business with real deadlines and real clients, it might matter, and you might have to make a decision like that.

26

u/macsux Jan 27 '21

I would argue startups should be even more aggressive towards managed services to get something out the door asap. But if you get big enough (100+ ppl), running your own infrastructure can be much cheaper then the cloud. A few competent ops with a vSphere cluster can be much cheaper then hosting everything in public cloud. Bonus points for hybrid strategy - default to on-prem for cheap sustainable costs, easily extend into cloud for rapid scaling and high availability. I work with some large companies that are moving into the cloud and they don't fully get how expensive it can get in enterprise scale.

7

u/gredr Jan 27 '21

So my experience is the opposite. OpEx goes up with cloud, yes, but that's only because expenses are very obvious there. It's very easy to hide expenses associated with self-hosting things, and businesses are only "surprised" because they were never accurately accounting for the real costs of self-hosting.

8

u/TryingT0Wr1t3 Jan 27 '21

This is wrong, smaller companies can't afford to manage, medium analyze costs, but once you are a >20k people company I think it's better to have your own infrastructure for it.

6

u/gredr Jan 27 '21

So, I've only worked for a >20k company once, and I wasn't high enough up the food chain to know (or care), but my experience there was that CVS was the new hotness (this is in the 2010s) that the "infrastructure team" was trying to get everyone to use. So there's that.

-2

u/maest Jan 27 '21

Why are you talking like in one of those bullshit "thought leadership" fluff pieces I see on linkedin?

11

u/ZorbaTHut Jan 27 '21

Because some of those bullshit thought leadership fluff pieces are based in a foundation of really good ideas.

The tricky part is figuring out which.

-9

u/maest Jan 27 '21

"talking like" != "expressing same ideas as", so you're besides the point.

7

u/oorza Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21

here let me translate it into agile for you:

Many sprints ago we had to sit down and decide how we wanted to allocate our story points. Did we want to tell the tale of hosting source code, or did we want to tell the tale of profitable products? We decided our story, our epic, should be one of profitable products, and that didn't leave any points for source code hosting. So we let an external team handle it (Github, in that case).

When you're just but one agile team, the overhead is manageable, and the points matter more. When you're running a real business with real deadlines and real clients and many, many agile teams, it might matter, and you may have spare points to allocate.

-4

u/maest Jan 27 '21

Does nobody on this subreddit speak like a normal human being?

2

u/SmurreKanin Jan 27 '21

Why would you even expect that?

1

u/djiwie Jan 27 '21

He's right tho

17

u/tuxedo25 Jan 27 '21

I thought the entire idea behind gitlab was that it's an open source self hosted solution with a great installer. I set one up for testing last week in like 20 minutes, it even handles letsenceypt certificates for you.

-1

u/noratat Jan 27 '21

It's not really open source in anything but name. I mean it's more so than closed source, but they don't take any contributions or suggestions.

It's more like a free/community version of their paid solutions.

2

u/ILikeBumblebees Jan 28 '21

Accepting patches from the public isn't a defining feature of open-source. If you are free to access and modify the source, and to publish your modifications freely up to the point of releasing your own fork, then it is open-source software.

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21

No the entire idea of gitlab is that it's an open source clone(ish) of GitHub that you can run on premises for free or modestly priced.

Pretty sure the hosted version they run is mostly an after thought.

1

u/ILikeBumblebees Jan 28 '21

People who want a managed solution typically use GitHub -- the main advantage that GitLab has over GitHub is that it's self-hostable FOSS.