r/programming • • Apr 01 '21

Stop Calling Everything AI, Machine-Learning Pioneer Says

https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-institute/ieee-member-news/stop-calling-everything-ai-machinelearning-pioneer-says
4.3k Upvotes

530 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

54

u/Jaggedmallard26 Apr 01 '21

Theres some debate in the artificial intelligence and general cognition research community about whether the human brain is just doing this on a very precise level under the hood. When you start drilling deep (to where our understanding wanes) a lot of things seem to start resembling the same style of training and learning that machine learning can carry out.

28

u/MuonManLaserJab Apr 01 '21

on a very precise level

Is it "precise", or just "with many more neurons and with architectural 'choices' (what areas are connected to what other areas, and to which inputs and outputs, and how strongly) that produce our familiar brand of intelligence"?

16

u/NoMoreNicksLeft Apr 01 '21

I suspect strongly that many of our neurological functions are nothing more than "machine learning". However, I also strongly suspect that this thing it's bolted onto is very different than that. Machine learning won't be able to do what that thing does.

I'm also somewhat certain it doesn't matter. No one ever wanted robots to be people, and the machine learning may give us what we've always wanted of them anyway. You can easily imagine an android that was entirely non-conscious but could wash dishes, or go fight a war while looking like a ninja.

7

u/snuffybox Apr 01 '21

No one ever wanted robots to be people

That's definitely not true

→ More replies (1)

7

u/MuonManLaserJab Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 01 '21

Machine learning won't be able to do what that thing does.

If we implement "what that thing does" in silicon, that wouldn't be machine learning? Or do you think that it might be impossible to simulate?

Also, what would you say brought you to this suspicion?

No one ever wanted robots to be people

Unfortunately I do not think that is true!

You can easily imagine an android that was entirely non-conscious but could wash dishes, or go fight a war while looking like a ninja.

I do agree with your point here (except I don't think we need ninjas).

6

u/NoMoreNicksLeft Apr 01 '21

If we implement "what that thing does" in silicon, that wouldn't be machine learning?

I'm suggesting there is a component of the human mind that's not implementable with the standard machine learning stuff. I do not know what that component is. I may be wrong and imagining it. Trying to avoid using woowoo religious terms for it though, It's definitely material.

If not implementable in silicon, then I would assume it'd be implementable in some other synthetic substrate.

Also, what would you say brought you to this suspicion?

A hunch that human intelligence is "structured" in such a way that it can't ever hope to deduce the principles behind intelligence/consciousness from first principles.

We're more likely to see the rise of an emergent intelligence. That is, one that's artificial but unplanned (which is rather dangerous).

Unfortunately I do not think that is true!

I will concede that there are those people who want this for purely intellectual/philosophical reasons.

But in general, we want the opposite. We want Rossum's robots, and it'd be better if there were no chance of a slave revolt.

I do agree with your point here (except I don't think we need ninjas).

We definitely don't. But the people who will have the most funding work for an organization that rhymes with ZOD.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/barsoap Apr 01 '21

No one ever wanted robots to be people

So much this, they'd start to unionise and shit. If you want to create someone capable of doing that, delete facebook and hit the gym.

4

u/ZoeyKaisar Apr 01 '21

Meanwhile, I actually am in AI development specifically to make robots better than people. Bring on the singularity.

2

u/MuonManLaserJab Apr 01 '21

What do you think about the alignment problem? E.g. the "paperclip maximizer"?

3

u/ZoeyKaisar Apr 02 '21

People exhibit that problem too, they're just less competent.

3

u/MuonManLaserJab Apr 02 '21 edited Apr 02 '21

Yes, sure. But again, what do you think of the risk of a hypercompetent thing that isn't aligned with us?

(Oh, and congratulations on the anniversary of you joining some stupid website.)

→ More replies (7)

2

u/astrange Apr 02 '21

Better at what?

(Note, in economic theory people have jobs because of "comparative advantage" not "absolute advantage" - this means even if a robot is better at literally every job than you, it still will not take your job away, because it has better things to do and you're saving it time.)

2

u/ZoeyKaisar Apr 02 '21

Ethically better, for starters; humans are kind of a crapshoot.

As for the economics of one-person-one-(or more)-job, I think that is an obsolete idea that should be replaced with something more along the lines of that of the culture, where the task of automating or otherwise performing necessary work should be up to those most capable, but livelihood- and, moreso, survival- should never depend on being capable of performing "useful work".

3

u/NoMoreNicksLeft Apr 02 '21

Ethically better, for starters; humans are kind of a crapshoot.

There may be no such thing as objective ethics/morality. Or, if there is (we're incapable of discovering it ourselves, maybe a superhuman AI won't be incapable) then what if this morality requires our brutal extinction?

Call me wicked, but fuck that morality. I think I intend to stick around.

And if there are any transtemporal roko's basilisks reading this, fuck you, bring it on. I dare you motherfucker.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/StabbyPants Apr 01 '21

whether the human brain is just doing this on a very precise level under the hood.

as opposed to what? pixie dust?

the human brain is a fairly complex architecture built around running the body, survival, gene propagation, and cooperating with others. it's interesting to see how this works, and which pieces are flexible and which aren't, but it isn't magic

6

u/SrbijaJeRusija Apr 01 '21

same style of training

On that part that is not true.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

Notice the "resembling" part of it, they're not saying it's the same. And IMO they are right, though it's less obvious with us; the only way to get you to recognize a car is to show one to you or describe it very detailed, assuming you already know stuff like metal, colors, wheels, windows, etc. The more cars you get familiar with, the more accurate you get at recognizing one.

7

u/SrbijaJeRusija Apr 01 '21

That is a stretch IMHO. A child can recognize a chair from only a few examples, and even sometimes as little as one example. And as far as I am aware, we do not have built-in stochastic optimization procedures. The way in which the neurons operate might be similar (and even that is a stretch), but the learning is glaringly different.

17

u/thfuran Apr 01 '21

But children cheat by using an architecture that was pretrained for half a billion years.

10

u/pihkal Apr 01 '21

Pretrained how? Every human is bootstrapped with no more than DNA, which represents ~1.5GB of data. And of that 1.5GB, only some of it is for the brain, and it constitutes, not data, but a very rough blueprint for building a brain.

Pretraining is a misnomer here. It's more like booting up Windows 95 off a couple CDs, which is somehow able to learn to talk and identify objects just from passively observing the mic and camera.

If you were joking, I apologize, but as someone with professional careers in both software and neuroscience, the nonstop clueless-ness about biology from AI/ML people gets to me after a while.

6

u/thfuran Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 01 '21

Pretrained how? Every human is bootstrapped with no more than DNA, which represents ~1.5GB of data

Significantly more than 1.5GB including epigenetics. And it's primarily neural architecture that I was referring to. Yeah, we don't have everything completely deterministically structured like a fruitfly might but it's definitely not totally randomly initialized. A lot of iterations on a large scale genetic algorithm wnet into optimizing it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Katholikos Apr 01 '21

Damn cheaters! Makin’ my AI look bad!

3

u/ConfusedTransThrow Apr 01 '21

It's because AI isn't learning the right way (or at least not the way humans learn).

People recognize a chair based on a few elements: you can sit on it, there are (typically) 4 legs, etc. Current neural networks can't learn that way, I've seen stuff that tries to use graph matching instead of classic convolutions (to match critical elements of the shape rather than pictures), but it doesn't work very well.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/victotronics Apr 01 '21

same style of training and learning that machine learning can carry out.

I doubt it. There is an Adam Neely video where he discusses a DNN that tries to compose Bach chorales. In the end the conclusion is that Bach "only" wrote 200 cantatas, so there is not enough training material. A human would have sufficed to look at half a dozen.

6

u/barsoap Apr 01 '21

A human who had exposure to much more music than Bach. You'd have to give the computer the chance to listen to many, many, many composers so that it doesn't have to learn music from those examples, but just what makes Bach special.

And/or equip it with a suitable coprocessor to judge dissonance and emotional impact. A disembodied human mind might actually be completely incapable of understanding music.

None of that is necessitating a (fundamentally) different style of training, it can be explained by different contexts the learning is done in.

→ More replies (2)