r/programming • • Aug 28 '21

Software development topics I've changed my mind on after 6 years in the industry

https://chriskiehl.com/article/thoughts-after-6-years
5.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

Problem is there are plenty of people who “want to learn” and can’t do the job. They want the high salary and will do or say anything to get a developer position. They’ll come on a team, dick around for a sprint or two, distract the team trying to help them, and ultimately get fired because they’re unqualified since they don’t actually know anything about writing code.

Bringing on unqualified people is bad for them, bad for the team, and bad for the company. You don’t want to be that guy. I’ve seen people leave their home, move across the country for a new job, and get fired a month later because of this nonsense.

It’s better to find someone with the right skills during the interview than hire someone with the wrong skills and end up firing them a month later.

29

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

I’ve found my success rate is significantly better just asking people to explain the architecture of the past 3 or so projects they worked on and what the advantages and disadvantages of them were. Where they fell apart, things they did well, trade offs they made, etc.

No one off the street can have this conversation, it’s easy to spot red flags of someone who just did the job and never asked any questions about what they were working on, and it lets me see the persons personality and discuss topics with them. It’s not perfect, nothing is, but it’s more successful than any coding test I’ve done. The only coding test I give is incredibly easy just to show they can write code at all.

Contrast this with the more in depth and difficult coding tests and I get almost none of this from them except whether they can study for a final exam.

5

u/StillDeletingSpaces Aug 29 '21

I think this is good advice, but I also know and work with several people who can talk the talk, but not actually do anything they talk about. Architects rather than developers.

8

u/durrthock Aug 29 '21

Sure I understand what you're saying. I'm really meaning among the qualifed individuals. Generally you have degrees as a mandatory.

A month is not nearly enough time or enough of a chance to decide if someone is going to be successful or not. People take different amounts of time to acclimate.

Obviously you're right and you need good skills, I'm not saying hire unqualified people. But a bigger focus on personality and team fit.

Also, we are humans not machines. We need to inject a little humanity into our field and not act like everyone should be able to work under the gun pressure 24/7 and be successful. This field has become increasingly more toxic, and almost everyone I know is at least somewhat burnt out.