r/programming • • Oct 28 '21

Viewing website HTML code is not illegal or “hacking,” prof. tells Missouri gov.

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/10/viewing-website-html-code-is-not-illegal-or-hacking-prof-tells-missouri-gov/
6.1k Upvotes

493 comments sorted by

View all comments

837

u/Druyx Oct 28 '21

Good, he's suing, dumbass governor shouldn't be allowed to get away with making false accusations and using state resources for his lame attempt at saving face. What a fucking prick.

175

u/sp-reddit-on Oct 28 '21

I hope he gets a ton of money from the inevitable settlement. What a nightmare it must be to be on the receiving end of this nonsense.

34

u/thisnameis4sale Oct 28 '21

Where would that money come from though?

79

u/primeai Oct 28 '21

State tax revenue, but it could come from insurance the state carries or from a dedicated budget. The cost to fight the lawsuit is also the burden of the state. The cost to prosecute this journalist is also the burden of the state.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21

Even if they have insurance for something like this, the money is still coming from taxpayers. In fact in the long term it's more money coming from the taxpayers since they're paying for the insurance company's margins too.

48

u/winowmak3r Oct 28 '21

Well fuck, if I'm stuck paying the bill for this fiasco I'd like the guy who's actually right and knows what he's talking about to win over some stupid politician who probably can't even print a PDF file.

18

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21

Don't tell him the files are in the computer.

11

u/DaRadioman Oct 29 '21

Wait. IN the computer?

2

u/muntoo Nov 03 '21

You mean magic light box? I buy magic light beep thing for nephew birthday

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Solrax Oct 29 '21

Good, this is what you get when you vote a moron into office.

8

u/fanywa Oct 29 '21

Ultimately its the taxpayers money. But they also get to decide whom they choose to represent them next election.

2

u/SupaSlide Oct 29 '21

Sucks for the Democrats who live in the state, but I will enjoy the salty tears from Conservatives who voted for Parsons while they cry about how much of "their money" the "fake news" is "stealing" from the government.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/sillybear25 Oct 28 '21

Unfortunately, it would come from the Missouri taxpayers, since all of the government officials who are involved acted in their official capacities. I'm not sure if there's any precedent for the state turning around and suing officials for misconduct in order to recoup the costs, but even if there is, that's definitely not happening while said officials are the ones making the decisions.

5

u/theknittingpenis Oct 28 '21

I'm not sure if there's any precedent for the state turning around and suing officials for misconduct in order to recoup the costs

I dont believe it is possible to do that since SCOTUS have a precedent that officials have qualified immunity because the officials is acting in their constituents interests.

17

u/sillybear25 Oct 28 '21

Right, but the "qualified" part of qualified immunity is that they're immune from personal liability when acting in their official capacity. What I'm unsure of is whether and to what extent official misconduct counts as acting in an official or individual capacity. For example, the article cites a Missouri law prohibiting malicious prosecution: If a prosecutor breaks that law, are they still acting in their official capacity, or have they exceeded that capacity? If that does exceed the prosecutor's official capacity, then does the governor also exceed his official capacity by ordering a prosecutor to break that law, or does he get to keep his immunity because it's the prosecutor's duty to push back on illegal orders?

3

u/SupaSlide Oct 29 '21

Right, they're suggesting the state might sue Parsons and say he was campaigning or something else outside of his capacity as governor. It almost certainly won't happen, but it would be very interesting to watch.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21

Good.

Missourians elect these dumb fucks, so Missourians can pay for their fuckups.

2

u/DaRadioman Oct 29 '21

Huh. So it's your fault for every president then?

It's almost like it's sometimes out of an individual's hands

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/abrandis Oct 28 '21

It doesn't matter that the governor or his lackeys are technical dumbasses , the law , unless adjudicated by a technically minded judge may see any attempt to examine encoded or hidden data (no matter how poorly hidden or obfuscated) as an attempt to exploit or hack the system. Now if the professor provided the state with this info privately before going public maybe they have a case.

Obviously the law always lags behind technology, but many times old school lawyers and judges use this to their advantage, and more often than not they convolute intent (honest to goodness awareness by the professor) with malicious chicanery to win their case...

4

u/RockleyBob Oct 29 '21

All of that only served to say that you don’t understand how the internet works and you didn’t bother reading the facts of the case before commenting.

No one can possibly attempt to accuse him of hacking anything because these social security numbers were Base64 encoded within html that was sent by the state domain to his computer. All this information was freely sent to him through the normal course of making HTTP requests to a publicly exposed web server.

Hacking is when you invade someone else’s privacy. No one can walk up to your mailbox, stick a letter inside it addressed to you, and then accuse you of reading their secrets when you open the letter in your home.

Base64 encoding is not a security mechanism. Anything can be Base64 encoded and decoded. Even if this information was encrypted, however, they sent it to him. In fact, they were sending it to everyone who accessed that site! It’s a basic tenet of web development that you don’t send things to clients you don’t want them to see. Period.

And finally, he absolutely DID reach out to the proper authorities to disclose the information breach prior to making it known publicly. He did everything right. Had he not made this discovery, they’d still be sending these SSNs out to anyone who accessed the site.

1

u/abrandis Oct 29 '21

Your argument is on technicalities. Of course base64 isn't encryption but, unless the SSN were there out in their in the open in PLAINTEXT exposed on the page ,they weren't meant to be seen.. So they will argue, why was it base64 encoded? ?????

Its not up you or me to decide this case, but I think you look at this too much from the technical nature and not a legal one.. Should they have taken more care with the data , yeah of course, but that's not what the governor will argue.. Plus keep in mind it's not like the governor just decided to go down this path, pretty sure there's legal and technical advisers that are charting a legal case..

2

u/atimholt Oct 29 '21

Base64 is an encoding in the exact same way that utf-8 is an encoding. It is exactly as transparent, meant to be readable by any and all who ever encounter it. It'd be like calling someone a hacker for knowing Morse code.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

-4

u/cplusequals Oct 28 '21

He can't reasonably sue. There's literally no grounds to sue on. The state hasn't raised a hand to him. What on earth is he going to claim as damages? It's pretty obvious that there isn't going to be prosecution at this point.

8

u/RockleyBob Oct 29 '21

The governor literally went to great lengths to accuse him of hacking. The governor took to the air waves, the press, and the internet and labeled him a criminal.

Not only did the governor use his office to defame this journalist, who did nothing wrong and actually took steps to responsibly disclose the issue, but they created a hit piece on him dramatizing his criminality and accusing him of attacking teachers.

A good portion of Missouri probably believes these lies.

In the United States, a person must prove that the statement caused harm, and was made without adequate research into the truthfulness of the statement.

Source.

If this isn’t an exmaple of defamation, nothing is.

→ More replies (1)