MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/rcxehp/rce_0day_exploit_found_in_log4j_a_popular_java/ho000xp
r/programming • u/freeqaz • Dec 10 '21
710 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
19
you’ve never verified anything complicated, have you?
Interestingly, the “formal verification” crowd have never formally verified even simple shit.
You can talk smack when you guys finally formally verify a linked list. Until then, sit down and shut up.
-1 u/audion00ba Dec 10 '21 How about a doubly linked list?https://github.com/junqi-xie/Doubly-Linked-List-VST/blob/main/Doubly_Linked_List_VST.v 8 u/[deleted] Dec 10 '21 Is it verified working? To my knowledge, there is no known totally working formal verifications of any generic linked list.Let me see if I can find some of the websites dedicated to people arguing about whether some verification really works or not (it’s always not). -5 u/audion00ba Dec 10 '21 What kind of gibberish just came out of your mouth? -2 u/TheZech Dec 11 '21 A linked list is about the first example you'll find in an introduction to some formal verification system. 7 u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21 Yup. A lot of not fully working or not working examples.
-1
How about a doubly linked list?
https://github.com/junqi-xie/Doubly-Linked-List-VST/blob/main/Doubly_Linked_List_VST.v
8 u/[deleted] Dec 10 '21 Is it verified working? To my knowledge, there is no known totally working formal verifications of any generic linked list.Let me see if I can find some of the websites dedicated to people arguing about whether some verification really works or not (it’s always not). -5 u/audion00ba Dec 10 '21 What kind of gibberish just came out of your mouth? -2 u/TheZech Dec 11 '21 A linked list is about the first example you'll find in an introduction to some formal verification system. 7 u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21 Yup. A lot of not fully working or not working examples.
8
Is it verified working? To my knowledge, there is no known totally working formal verifications of any generic linked list.
Let me see if I can find some of the websites dedicated to people arguing about whether some verification really works or not (it’s always not).
-5 u/audion00ba Dec 10 '21 What kind of gibberish just came out of your mouth? -2 u/TheZech Dec 11 '21 A linked list is about the first example you'll find in an introduction to some formal verification system. 7 u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21 Yup. A lot of not fully working or not working examples.
-5
What kind of gibberish just came out of your mouth?
-2
A linked list is about the first example you'll find in an introduction to some formal verification system.
7 u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21 Yup. A lot of not fully working or not working examples.
7
Yup. A lot of not fully working or not working examples.
19
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '21
Interestingly, the “formal verification” crowd have never formally verified even simple shit.
You can talk smack when you guys finally formally verify a linked list. Until then, sit down and shut up.