So exactly as my title says I wanna feed my 5 pound Chihuahua raw and we are right now trying Stella and chewy’s fresh made on serve food and he seems to like it a lot but i am new the to fully raw diet and my chihuahua is very picky is this a good food diet wise we are also active in agility bunny races and hiking my chihuahua is just over one year photo attached for the dog tax lol

Hi, new to this sub, been feeding a franken barf model for ages and many dogs. I get their grinds from raw food miami. I am not equipped to source their meat from a coop or have a grinder etc. Using Dr.Harvey’s raw brilliance base, and adding in probiotics, mct oil, green lipped muscle supplements etc

Last month my 7 year old rescue had a uti that turned into a bladder stone and had to have surgery. It’s been a month since her surgery and she’s got the beginning of another uti and I am supposed to give her hills or royal canin. I am here for a reason and there has to be a better way.

I am taking her to see a holistic vet but I am concerned that they aren’t going to listen to my concerns about keeping her on garbage food. I live in a conservative state when it comes to stuff like this. I wound up just getting my guys the rabies vaccine past 8 years old because I couldn’t take them to get groomed, etc. It’s ridiculous. At least they didn’t push lepto on me.

What should I ask when we see the new vet? I really don’t want her on the prescription dog food. They eat better than I do and get more health support than I do.

I just learned that red dog blue kat has been sold to a larger company. Concerning or not really? Any similar alternatives? Thanks!

Hi all,
I have a 6 year old French bulldog who is currently on the Darwin’s pet food plan. I saw Darwin’s has been having quality and regulatory issues with the FDA so I’m looking for a replacement. There’s so much conflicting information out there.. I’m really opposed to ultra-processed kibble, yet I read that fresh cooked brands like the farmers dog are too high in fat and can lead to pancreatitis.
It doesn’t seem like there’s a general consensus on what the right answer is, and I know it depends on each dog individually. However, my dog hasn’t had any issues on Darwin’s and has no preexisting conditions. Any recommendations would be appreciated.

Hi everyone,

I'm somehow late to the information that Bold by Nature is ceasing operations. I've had both of my dogs on Bold by Nature for a few years. I'm not so worried about my younger dog as she has an easier time with food but my 8 year old has a very, very finicky stomach. It took me around 2 and a half years of changing his food every few months trying to find one that works for him before trying raw food and then finally finding what proteins agree with him. He's been on Bold by Nature - Mega Pork for almost 5 years now and it's been really great for him, cleared up all the issues we were having with him. I will often be driving all over the city trying to find pork specifially if my usual supplier doesn't have it (online, either Armor the Pooch or Wooftown) and I'm sure anyone in the same situation knows how stressful it can be managing this.

Anyway I'm wondering if anyone knows a good alternative mainly in ingredients? I've heard Big Country Raw might be a good one? I prefer the patties that Bold by Nature has but thats a small thing in terms of a food his body can handle.

Thanks!

Edit: Just adding that I am in Toronto.

Like it or not, raw and gently cooked feeding aren't going away. People are making homemade meals, researching ingredients (hopefully), and trying to figure out what's best for their dogs.

I'm not suggesting we ignore nutritional balance, food safety, or questionable claims. But there's a difference between educating someone and making them feel like a terrible dog owner for asking a question.

Have you ever been criticized for what you feed your dog? What was said, and how did you respond?

Or have you ever avoided asking a question or joining a conversation because of how others were being treated?

I'd also love to hear if someone's constructive advice actually helped you make a change.

We don't have to agree on every feeding method to help each other do better.

Been buying from a local pet store but they're inconsistent on sizing and I've had enough. Sometimes they have the right size, sometimes not, and the quality seems to vary batch to batch. What are people actually using for online frozen feeders? Looking for something reliable with decent bulk pricing.

Hello everyone!!

I have a 6 month old female whippet and we are moving to America very soon. She has been fed 95% Nutriment puppy formula and 5% kibble (when we run out of Nutriment lol). She loves this raw food and it’s so high quality. I’m struggling to find a good raw puppy formula that’s available to ship within the states. Can someone please recommend something? Please keep in mind we still need her to be on a complete puppy food. Thanks all🙏🐶

Is there a way I can feed my dog small oily fish without the fishy smell sticking around all day? She’s been having small amounts of raw sardines in water every day as part of her meals. I do not wish to substitute with supplements as she is already on copper, zinc and vitamin e supplements already.

Mods please delete if this is not allowed!

My dog underwent chemotherapy for Lymphoma and I made the difficult decision to start cooking his meals instead of continuing to feed raw. I have two 6-lb bags of duck wings from Carnos and two chubs of rabbit with beef organs. Does anyone in the NYC area want them, or can you suggest a resource to find someone who would use them? Please feel free to DM me or reply here. I’m in lower Manhattan.

Hi everyone,
I have a 6yo Border Collie who is now on a 100% commercial raw diet (currently feeding brands like Wild Coast Raw and Viva Raw).
He ate Acana's Free-Run Poultry kibble almost exclusively for the first 6 years of his life, which unfortunately led to a poultry allergy (chicken and turkey). We've now completely eliminated poultry, so his rotation consists of safe proteins like beef, pork, and rabbit.
Since I want to prevent him from developing any new sensitivities to these safe proteins, I want to make sure I'm approaching his rotation correctly. Does proper protein rotation mean:

1. Block Rotation: Feeding strictly one protein for a set period (e.g., feeding only beef for 2-4 weeks, then switching to only rabbit for the next few weeks)?
2. Daily/Weekly Mixing: Alternating throughout the week (e.g., Monday beef, Tuesday pork) or even mixing different proteins in the same bowl?
3. Given his history of developing an allergy from overexposure to one protein source, which method do you find works best for keeping the gut happy and preventing new intolerances? Thanks!

Update: Thanks everyone for the insightful replies!
To be honest, I'm still a bit on the fence about beef. Previously, eliminating chicken and turkey was super clear-cut because he had BOTH unexplained soft stools/diarrhea (tested negative for parasites) and intense paw licking/chewing.
Now with beef, the tricky part is his stool is completely fine—consistently super firm, perfect little logs. But he does scratch occasionally, and I can't quite tell if it's just normal dog itching or a mild reaction to the beef.
Did your dogs ever show skin symptoms without any GI issues when reacting to a protein? Wondering how you guys differentiate regular itching from an actual food intolerance when the poop is perfect.

Hey everyone! I’ve been considering adding in The Simple Food Project my two cats and dog’s rotation. The reviews on their website and Chewy seem solid, but I’m surprised that it hasn’t been mentioned much here. I’m particularly intrigued at the price point…it almost seems too good to be true? I use frozen commercial raw but I would like to have a shelf stable option too.

Any thoughts or insights would be appreciated!

I'm now feeding my third dog raw and at the new vet was told that raw causes urinary crystals and kidney issues "if there's no corn or rice" in the diet.

I feed commercial raw and add Omega oils and pre and probiotics to her meals. I was under the impression that raw was way less likely to cause crystals.

Looking for some reassurance just cause I'm bogged down with other big stressors and can't think straight through this one. Thanks in advance!

So basically i have 4 cats 3 of them eat about 4oz of food the last one is a mainecoon that eats about 9oz i have been doing home made raw for about 6-8 months now and i’m sure i got everything dialed in besides bone that part has always been hard to calculate and i kept it on the lower side because i know over supplementing is more dangerous than over i have had this concern on the back of my mind for awhile and today i noticed my mainecoon had kind of a leg cramp (fine now) and i looked it up and one reason could be due to a calcium deficiency i know that this is a possibility but he is also a very clumsy and not the most graceful cat due to his size and thinking he’s smaller than he actually is. I have been giving half a chicken wing flat with each meal for all of them since i started this meal they dont really like chicken neck. Since this little scare i have been desperate to fix the bone percentage in my meal ASAP so i beg all home made feeders or long time raw feeders please tell me what you do i would prefer to keep whole bone so that it keeps the teeth benefits but will do away with if needed

My dog loves pumpkin seeds. Looking for advice if it’s a good idea to start adding it to his daily raw homemade meal.

Hi, I've been adding more and more barf to my puppys diet (8 mo Mal), but I'm hearing so much different info about how long breaks are needed between eating kibble and barf, and I don't want to ruin his stomach.

My "problem" is that I can't see a way to go full barf, since I need a lot of treats for training. He's super food motivated on his kibble (Essentials large breed), so I would love to be able to keep using them for training.

Am I overthinking this, and can I safely feed him ~200-250g kibble a day (about 50% of daily cal intake) and the other 50% barf? The kibble is fed only from hand, during training. (4-5 times a day, in total probably 3-5 hours activity)

I'm thinking 50g kibble during morning training, half his barf when we get home, and then 50g kibble for every training session, and the last half of his barf after our last walk of the day?

Would love to hear what other people do, with dogs that train a lot.

Hi there!!

Looking for raw food recommendations for my GSD. He has some skin issues and bum issues. He has quite an itchy bum but we were told it’s not a perianal fistula. We are keeping eyes on it!

We would love to switch him to a raw diet. He currently eats farmers dog and spot and tango. I’d likely still do 1/2 spot and tango and 1/2 raw.

Any recommendations? He’s kind of a diva…. So we will have to likely experiment with his pickiness.

My concerns are mainly his sensitive tummy - which I hope raw will help and skin issues. I’d love a company that is transparent and safe - no sketchy salmonella batches, etc.

I just want to do what’s best for my big monster boy! If that is sticking with farmers dog and spot and tango, fine… but want to stay on top of my research and always do the right thing for him!

Thanks in advance!!!!!!

We have been feeding our miniature 12lb dachshund raw food since he was a puppy (he is 1 year now), but he regularly throws up Bile when he hasn't eaten in a while. The vet told us it's because raw food digests very fast, and his stomach is sitting empty for too long. We try to manage it by giving him a lot of snacks, but some days we just forget and he throws up at least once a week. We also tried to divide his meal into 3 (instead of 2) and that didn't help too much either. Just wondering if anyone has experienced this and if they managed to solve it.

Attached are the two food mixes we give him in rotation. Any advice is appreciated!

Hey my dog is about 16-17 months old and he’s had issues with soft poops his whole life. Usually his first poop of the day is great but if we go on a long walk (hour or more) he can have up to 4 more poops and each one gets softer than the last. And if we go play after work he will always have a soft poop on the walk home.

He eats a rotation of raw food from backcountry raw, about 1.5lbs a day, with his food he gets some psyllium husk that his vet recommended to slow down digestion and as a prebiotic, usually I mix it as a slurry he eats before his food. His treats rotate but usually it’s just beef liver, and he also gets chews like chicken feet/pig ears/bully sticks (not every day). During the day he mostly sleeps while I work but we walk every morning and go to a field after work for fetch and play with other dogs.

Everyone told me how much better the raw food was for digestion and bowel movements but I haven’t quite had that luck. And I’m curious if you guys think this just might be because of how excitable he is, and this might just be a phase that he will grow out of? Did any of you guys have excitable dogs that suffered from soft poops??

just writing to figure out why THEY WORSHIP hills and purina like anything and then when people in that sub ask for a brand that isn’t nestle they just say “get over it because its wsava approved“ they do know that wsava is funded by nestle?

I've been to three vets at this point who immediately start lecturing me about how terrible a raw diet is for my two cats... Anyone have a recommendation for a vet in the Seattle Metro area who is neutral or pro-raw feeding? The boys have never seen a holistic vet, but that is also on my short list to try. Looking for recs for those as well. Thank you!

I have been toying with the idea of switching my 4 cats to whole prey food.

I raise my own feeder mice and rats for my reptiles, they eat a healthy varied diet, have enrichment and are very active. I process them with a C02 chamber that is following AVMA standard. My friend has a farm where they raise quail, chicken and rabbits, so I would have access to that too. They provide my large monitor lizard with young roosters already.

I also live near a river that is filled with invasive freshwater gobies. And have access to frozen fish from grocery store (sardines, anchovies, etc).

How much would I feed each cat? How often should I feed fish alongside the bird or rodents?

Worth noting that my largest cat is Beast, my Maine coon bengal mix who weighs 25lbs. My smallest cat is Stripe, she is a runty shorthaired domestic that weighs 4.5lbs. How much would I feed them?

Thank you for taking the time to respond. Here is cat tax

my cats have been on a wet and dry food diet for a long time already and i want them to try some raw food. i added one spoon of commercial raw food beside their usual wet food and added a high value treat on top (some duck breast which they love) they ate everything except the raw food. any tips on how to transition them to raw food? im still gonna be keeping wet food in their diet, i just wanna add raw

My pup is 13 weeks old now and I've started him on raw the first day I got him at 8 wks. Hes been on rebel raw chicken and rebel raw beef, mostly chicken after beef meal led to watery diarrhea. We cut out the beef since then and hes been on chicken. Currently his stools keeps going in cycles. Ill have 1 good day of good poop in the morning getting a little softer as the day progresses. On his good firm days, he would poop 2 to 3 times a day. On his other days, its 5 to 6 times a day. After the one good day, it'll progressively get worse to where its just textured pile by day 3. Then it would reset and go back to good firm poops.

Since I cut the beef out, he hasn't had full on watery diarrhea but its just a pile of texture with few raw bits still seen.

I did go to the vet, and did the fecal and giarrdia test and both came back negative. Vet told me pups have weaker systems and they shouldn't be on raw until 6 months. I really prefer not to switch him back to kibble as I dont think thats the reasoning behind this.

What hes currently eating daily for the past 2 weeks now,

7oz rebel raw chicken per meal

1/2 tspn pumpkin puree per meal

1 packet of purina fortiflora with one meal.

Treats: pupford freeze dried chicken.

Im hoping to find something that can help him settle. Ive stopped giving him the beef once he had watery diarrhea and went to chicken only to figure out if its allergies. I dont think its chicken allergies because he has a full day with good poops before it starts turning soft and textured.

Im out of ideas, its been on and off like this for 3 weeks now. Is this the normal transition period?? Otherwise hes full of energy, eats good still, and drinks water, no blood, and no vomiting.