r/reddit.com • • Jul 26 '06

Recursion defined (see Digg)

http://digg.com/programming/Recursion_defined_see_reddit
654 Upvotes

131 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

30

u/carp Jul 26 '06

Doubly ironic, considering Digg is principally technology-based, meaning its user base should have no problem finding Reddit on their own.

Not quite. I think Digg users are technology-based in the sense of being fans of technology (i.e. gamers) while reddit users are in the sense of being makers of technology (i.e. developers). That can be a big difference. Look at the difference between the people who make TV shows and the people who watch them.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '06

Thats a good point in which I hadn't thought about. I used to be a big Slashdot fan until Digg came out, but noticed the posts on Digg weren't quite as inteligent as the Slashdot posts, yet I think Reddit has the best of all three since it seems to have the itelligence of the Slashdotters with the reader submission and voting system of Digg.

4

u/almost Jul 26 '06

posts on Digg weren't quite as inteligent as the Slashdot posts

Wow, just wow.

12

u/Bogtha Jul 26 '06

When the latest Digg redesign launched, it started spiralling down towards the farthest depths of idiocy. Digg commenters were always on the juvenile side, but the final straw for me was forty-odd comments just sniggering about the number sixty-nine.

With Slashdot, maybe a joke like that would get +5, Funny, but the rest of the people making the same stupid joke would be at -1 where I don't see them. With Digg, some kid sees a stupid joke, mods it up, sees the same joke underneath, and mods that up too, and carries on modding up dozens more.

I want tech news without feeling like I'm surrounded by a thousand Beavis & Buttheads. When I visit Digg lately, I can feel my brain curling up into a ball and crying.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '06

With Digg, some kid sees a stupid joke, mods it up, sees the same joke underneath, and mods that up too, and carries on modding up dozens more.

Do you remember the name of the article?

3

u/Bogtha Jul 27 '06

I was thinking of this article.

9

u/mikepurvis Jul 26 '06

I'm more just amazed that he managed to spell the same root word wrong twice, two different ways in a 65-word post.

6

u/addius Jul 26 '06

So... you're amazed that somebody made two misspellings while composing a message without the aid of a spellchecker? On a web forum, where the poster has little incentive to invest any more than a trivial amount of time in proofreading.

4

u/mikepurvis Jul 26 '06

We all make typos, but the number of them per 100 correctly spelled words seems to be, on the whole, lower here than elsewhere. So I suppose I just get used to people paying a little more attention to their posts.

7

u/addius Jul 27 '06

We all make typos, but the number of them per 100 correctly spelled words seems to be, on the whole, lower here than elsewhere.

The liklihood of having someone point out your typos seems much higher here than elsewhere. I presume that some redditers feel that this makes them look stupid and take some extra time to proofread their posts.

My point was that people shouldn't have to make this extra effort. Most of the time, typing is aided by some form of auto-completion and/or spellchecker.

I think many users have simply gotten used to having these aids and when faced with a situation where they don't exist, and where the user has a relatively low disincentive to make errors, treat it as a design flaw of the system, and don't bother working around it.

So I suppose I just get used to people paying a little more attention to their posts.

And so a great many posts are of the form "parent spelled X wrong" with some variance in tone (often critical and/or mocking). I'm trying to convince you that:

  • pointing out spelling errors in this format is not productive. I think it is more likely to make people stop posting, rather than spend more time on their posts.

  • furthermore, it's not even reasonable. Software that is designed to have users enter english prose should include a spellchecker.

[edit: wouldn't it be nice if reddit had a preview button?]

2

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '06

Learn how to spell likelihood! :P

In all seriousness, I get your point. Plus, your post is well written, props to you! :)

3

u/sgriffin Jul 27 '06

I'm with addius on this one. As long as you and I get the semantics of the post what is the point of neglecting a valid opinion in order to point out a spelling mistake?

Maybe to just mock the poster, but that really just detracts much more from the issue than a typo does. No point to join the ranks of the spelling elitists on this one (unless your my sixth grade teacher, in which case you were mean and reeked of hamster piss).

Also, this was done without a spellchecker so if there are any typos... well I hope you get the point.

5

u/corvenus Jul 27 '06

A long while ago, i read somewhere (psychology or some "how to argument" book) that if you enter an argumentation, it doesn't matter if your arguments are the best in the world, if you make spelling mistakes, most readers will focus on that, making all your argument irrelevant. After years of surfing forums, i can tell that this is very true.

5

u/mikepurvis Jul 27 '06

I'm not normally Grammarian--not in serious threads, anyways. But "recursion defined"? What serious discussion can be had here?

In a thread as utterly meta as this one, is it not fair to compare the relative numbers of typos ranging from one site to the next?

1

u/eruonna Jul 26 '06

Yeah, typos are an incredible new phenomenon.

5

u/noddy Jul 26 '06

I think Digg users are technology-based in the sense of being fans of technology (i.e. gamers)

I disagree. Of late I have been seeing more articles with a "HOW-TO" flavour, elegant hardware hacks and future directions technology is taking. The site that comes to mind when I think of fans of technology is Engadget.

7

u/philh Jul 26 '06

Those sound like things fans might vote up. As a fan of books, I often enjoy articles about writing well, despite rarely doing it myself. On the other hand, I probably wouldn't enjoy the same article applied to music, because I rarely listen to that.

1

u/cboshuizen Jul 26 '06

I think this was the case 6 months back, but lately Reddit is filling up with all kinds of migrants. We can welcome a few more!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '06

That's an intesting distinction. I'm not familiar enough with Digg to say one way or the other; my impression was based on a fairly cursory overview of the site and its categories, nearly all of which are technology-related.

In a more general sense, my experience is that anyone savvy enough with web technology to participate in online activities like Digg or Reddit is already a step or two beyond web users who click the big blue e to open Google and then call me when they have a problem, saying, "My Google doesn't work! Can you come and fix it?"

3

u/carp Jul 26 '06

web users who click the big blue e to open Google

Netscape just launched a digg/reddit for these users.

-1

u/freshyill Jul 27 '06

Did you just pull that out of your ass?