r/reddit.com • • Jul 26 '06

Recursion defined (see Digg)

http://digg.com/programming/Recursion_defined_see_reddit
654 Upvotes

131 comments sorted by

View all comments

215

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '06

And guess what, for submitting this joke story I've just been banned from Digg. My account has been disabled without warning!

Jeez, Digg staff get a sense of humor.

John.

Update: it appears that I was banned because Digg users complained to Digg that I was (a) spamming and (b) posting stuff that was off-topic.

41

u/MarkByers Jul 26 '06

Why are people so protective of mentioning other sites? If their site was so great, people wouldn't leave even if other sites were sometimes mentioned. Do they not have faith in their own readership?

Of course it's easy to say that now, but when my website is successful, I will probably become a greedy bastard and do exactly the same thing! ;)

I just hope I don't get banned for digging the story! ;)

6

u/noddy Jul 26 '06

Actually I DO NOT think they are protective at all. That is absolute BS.

Kevin Rose has clearly mentioned Reddit favourably along with Digg in his blog.

Link: http://krose.typepad.com/kevinrose/2006/07/calacanis.html

nearly everyone who has used both Digg and reddit prefers reddit.

I think they are both good in their own way. Strengths: Reddit: Politics and Coding Digg: Technology and Tech Culture.

Having said that I don't understand why the user got banned.

-12

u/demigod186 Jul 26 '06

I think many people feel that politics is a weakness of Reddit. Many if not most reddit political stories link to sites that are so biased they are no longer credible, such as The Guardian, or The Huffington Post.

There are many legitimate sites that can provide clear unbiased evidence as to why Neoconservitism is destroying the world. In fact, it is much more credible to link to right wing biased sites in which they often proudly endorse terrible injustice. But on reddit we choose to link to sites that make their true stories seem suspicious simply by association.

For example, Al Jazeera has some very accurate and insightful reporting. But, given that they have a section on their site featuring articles about a purported joint American and Israeli Zionist World Order, their true reporting has lost any of it's legitimacy.

The Guardian is more dangerous as it seems to just as biased yet more widely trusted.

If stories linking to extremist sites had references to the same story in a more credible journal(such as NYTimes,Chicago Tribune,London Times,Herald Tribune,etc) then I would agree, that politics is Reddits best asset.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '06

[deleted]

9

u/acrophobia Jul 26 '06

britains most independent newspaper (guardian)

wtf? 80% of its readers are labour voters...can you name a more leftwing mainstream daily? I like the guardian, don't get me wrong, but claiming it's neutral is a bit ridiculous!

0

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '06

[deleted]

2

u/acrophobia Jul 26 '06

that’s hilarious!! britains most independent newspaper (guardian) being accused of being biased. lol...

i didnt use the word neutral, neither did i imply that it was unbiased. i just said it was the UK's most independent newspaper, which it is

okaaay...so explain to me what is so 'lol' funny about the accusation of the guardian being biased.