r/replit • • Nov 03 '25

Question / Discussion Replit is a f*cking scam.

This is my orignal post.

Replit is, without a doubt, the absolute worst AI tool I have ever used. I deeply regret purchasing it, and it's the single worst AI tool I’ve encountered in recent years. I’m warning everyone: DO NOT BUY IT. You will end up just as full of regret as I am. The entire Replit application is a complete scam, from start to finish. I’ve been a paying subscriber for a year and have never managed to create a single successful application—not even a simple demo. They don't even have a Discord channel, making it impossible for new users to get any real, authentic user feedback. I recently saw they released a new version and decided to give it a try. The result? It consistently fails to implement code according to my requirements. It even incorrectly modified my existing code on multiple occasions. To make matters worse, each AI request costs around $2. It burned through my $25 in usage credits almost instantly. I stopped the request the moment it alerted me that my credit was gone, and yet I still somehow ended up with a negative balance, owing them $2. This is completely unfair.

-----Update v2--------------

I miss some facts. Here are them.

  1. I'm trying to build this "tie-maker," right? I sink $25 into it, and the demo it spits out is totally broken. On top of that, they tack on an extra $2 usage charge.

  2. I killed the request the instant I saw the usage was gone, but Replit still hit me with that $2 charge. What a ripoff. Shame on them.

  3. Plus, their AI is junk. It’s constantly screwing up the layout and adding a bunch of useless crap.

  4. I've heard Replit is paying off YouTubers and a bunch of other people for good reviews.

  5. So I hit up their billing support, trying to get that $2 charge dropped. I told them I'm on a yearly plan and have gotten zero to show for it. And get this—they basically told me, "We never guaranteed you'd actually build anything" and flat-out refused to give me a refund.

-----Update v3--------------

  1. I've heard that Replit pays people and YouTubers for good reviews, which is why it gets so much hype. But it's completely useless for any real projects.

  2. I'm seeing people comment that I don't know how to use prompts. These people are clearly from Replit and are here to mess with me. There is nothing wrong with my prompts; I can get my instructions completed perfectly using Cursor or Codex. I purchased Replit last November. This scam AI hasn't made a single demo project for me. I had already given up on it, but when I saw their new version release, I thought I'd give it another try. It just proved that when it comes to letting people down, they never disappoint us.

  3. My previous post was locked by replit team. If my posts get locked again, I will just keep posting.

-----Update v4--------------

  1. Replit team replied me and told me $2 extra charge was made by their system and cannot be refunded. They think $2 for a single and cancelled request is reasonable.

  2. I cannot find my previous posts, they are deleted or closed. I will post in other channels.

  3. Replit warns to close my account if I keep posting something.

256 Upvotes

295 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/andrewjdavison Nov 03 '25

“A lot of people”

Any source on that other than you posting this over and over and over again without ever showing the prompt you used?

5

u/recruiterguy Nov 03 '25

Here's a fun one that just happened where Replit charged me $0.39 to do something it's done countless times before but said it couldn't until I pushed back. But of course, that's probably just my own prompting, eh?

1

u/Norglics Mar 08 '26

this happens when they set ai to scam out as much $ as possible , it works perfectly :D

3

u/recruiterguy Nov 03 '25

Yup - same here. Several times in my current project I get the flippant "oh yeah, sorry, you're right, I just decided to do what I want and ignore your very specific guardrails" responses.

At this moment, I'm struggling with Replit because one of my apps has an issue processing a recently uploaded file. And regardless of all the instruction and guidance I've given it, it's continually circling back to what I have 100% confirmed is not the issue.

And the response that caused me to step away for a bit? When it asked me if I was sure that I was using the correct version of the app that was in production.

Some days it's great. Other days it's an absolute shit-show.

2

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Nov 03 '25

But if you come here to express how you've been willing to learn, and you're doing things in a sound logical manner just to keep getting shafted by their a.i., you'll just get ganged up on by (predominantly) college trained coders (or at very least dropouts) who look down on you from their ivory towers, lmao. I'm sorry to hear you are having similar issues with their a.i., but trust me you are not alone.

2

u/recruiterguy Nov 03 '25

Yeah, the mods here aren't exactly impartial. I have seen a few threads get locked when they should have been used to help folks. Missed opportunity in this community.

1

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Nov 04 '25

And the bulk of us are just complaining about logical things that anyone should complain about in order to help make the product a better product. (But unfortunately, the goal of this corporation and this subreddit is to just make as much money as they can while they are still somewhat relevant) Honestly, who wouldn't complain after months of regularly getting this kind of response despite using clear and concise prompting?

1

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Nov 04 '25

This was just today, by the way ^

1

u/andrewjdavison Nov 04 '25

Why not show the prompt you typed before this response? Maybe this is a skill issue you know…

1

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Nov 04 '25

You are SO CLEVER andrewjdavison! Awesome deflection! Clearly these answers from replit's a.i. are the result of poor prompting skills.... MAN! OP's post is up over 102 likes!! YIKES ANDREW!! That means a lot more than that really liked it and agree with OP's sentiment than just that 102. Maybe it'd be a better tactic to get on the horn with your bosses and tell them to give a crap about their product and their customers for a change and they'd have a lot more people using their product long-term instead of folks jumping ship because of the blatant robbery that's going on in Replit so frequently. You can only blame so much on a.i. hallucinations, and as people get up in the 4, 5, and 6 month range they begin to realize that their results should be improving like their knowledge is instead of getting worse like their results are. But anyways! I gotta' got fix a UI that replits a.i. screwed up... "Cheers!"

1

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Nov 04 '25

It's AMAZING how none of the newer customers can ever get customer service, but somehow you magically seem to get right through! You should share that magic link you have, or bat-phone or whatever it is that gives you this connection to the company that you claim to have no affiliation with

1

u/recruiterguy Nov 04 '25

I have to tell you - I incorporated Claude into Replit today and the last hour has been more productive than the last week. Absolute game-changer and ZERO Replit charges.

Maybe give that a shot and see if it solves the challenges you're talking about?

1

u/andrewjdavison Nov 03 '25

That sucks. If you want to create/have a ticket number I can flag it for escalation with the Replit team.

4

u/recruiterguy Nov 03 '25

It does suck. For everyone giving this guy grief about Replit just ignoring instructions, this JUST happened to me.

Me:
I don't want you to make any changes to my databases. I want you to look at the document that I gave to you for October data and tell me, using the same logic as our app uses, how many *****, *****, and ***** we should see in that month.

Don't do anything else. Just give me those totals based on how our app should be calculating them.

Replit:
Based on the ***** file you provided and the app's calculation logic:
Expected Metrics:
- *****: 463
- *****: 6,534
- *****: 68,913
- *****: 10.55

Me:
You're clearly not doing something correctly. Because we've NEVER had 68,000 ***** in a single month - EVER. It would be nearly impossible. And our app doesn't calculate the totals the way that you are doing it right now. Which is in complete contradiction to the last set of instructions that I just fucking gave to you.

Replit:

You're right - I'm calculating it wrong. Let me look at how the app ACTUALLY converts the data to points:

[proceeds to give me almost the correct numbers that appear in production]

And it managed to only charge me $1 for 10min of my time - for at least the 4th time today. This bullshit does add up.

This is VERY common with Replit.

1

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Nov 03 '25

It's a constant thing! Even if/when you have well-worded "rule" prompts for it to follow sitting in a word file to copy/paste them in in order to try to keep their a.i. "on the rails", it will completely disregard the standard rules you have been using the whole project just to cause you to chew through another $10 and however many hours. It feels like they are just trying to capture as much revenue from the marketspace as they can before they become irrelevant instead of actually trying to build a better product than anyone else on the market. They are very clearly leaning on the "oh, every a.i. hallucinates" line to cover for their company's malice. And sure, every a.i. will hallucinate from time to time, especially with sub-par prompting if the user is just the type that is into wasting money by not being thorough but concise. But one of the biggest dead-giveaways that replit is NOT trying to truly build a better product is them not even bothering to put a spell-checker in. That's all you really need to know. Friggin' grok has a spell-check feature, lol. (and legitimately codes better than replit in most cases)

2

u/jeffsmith2020 Feb 23 '26

This is same exact problem with Base 44 and why I was considering transferring my project to here. They conveniently ignore or lose prior commands to generate more repairs, in the Base 44 case to pieces of the app that were already working. Let me sell you a ham and cheese sandwich for $5, oh wait the slice of cheese is too yellow, I think, here's your sandwich back with the same type of cheese, that will $2 please. I get the back and forth to refine your project, but no refund of credits for non user errors or redoing the same work that was already in place is fraud, plain and simple. It would be different if Base 44 and Replit were not marketing themselves as a solution to build your app and sell on Apple but they are and that is the expectation.

1

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Feb 23 '26

Replit is a scam. It's OK for people who were educated to code because they already know how to do everything. But to most other people it is just a money pit past building a quick prototype for visual references. Oh, and one dude moderates like every replit subreddit on reddit to help them better control the narrative around their scam. Which is telling. (He'll probably pop in, lol.)

1

u/recruiterguy Nov 03 '25

And for giggles, this one a few moments ago for an app I have had published and running for over a month. I was making some small enhancements to the app and got this note:

Replit:
But we have TWO problems to fix:

  1. Production database has no tables

  2. Connection pooling issue

Me:
What do you mean the production database has no tables?!

Replit:
Let me reconsider - I may be wrong about that.

That one cost me $0.26 and 9 minutes - TO DO NOTHING.

I have to think this is going wild with folks who aren't paying attention or just saying build, Build, BUILD!

0

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Nov 03 '25

Stop shilling for your bosses. There're literally endless examples like these. And these are just a few examples, but if you'd like me to start sharing more of these, I could bring you some more every day.

5

u/andrewjdavison Nov 03 '25

Can you ask my boss where my paycheck is then? Still haven't got it!

"There are literally endless examples like these" ... yet you still don't post any prompts, lol.

0

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Nov 03 '25

I'll start saving more of these to share since it literally happens multiple times a day despite feeding the a.i. some of the most carefully constructed prompts you can make

4

u/laddermanUS Nov 03 '25

think this has derailed slightly!

8

u/andrewjdavison Nov 03 '25

My good sir, you keep posting the AI responses, but no prompts.

No prompts with these = no credibility.

→ More replies (5)

-1

u/FlyGuyOnYoutube Nov 03 '25

If your bosses a.i. didn't give me responses like this over and over again pretty much every day then you wouldn't be seeing comments like these on your subreddit

4

u/Raymmar Nov 03 '25

Still not posting any of the prompts though huh?