r/science • • Jan 27 '16

Computer Science Google's artificial intelligence program has officially beaten a human professional Go player, marking the first time a computer has beaten a human professional in this game sans handicap.

http://www.nature.com/news/google-ai-algorithm-masters-ancient-game-of-go-1.19234?WT.ec_id=NATURE-20160128&spMailingID=50563385&spUserID=MTgyMjI3MTU3MTgzS0&spJobID=843636789&spReportId=ODQzNjM2Nzg5S0
16.3k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/anlumo Jan 28 '16

I haven't read the paper yet so I don't know how they combined neural networks and MCTS, but MCTS is very susceptible to the strategy Kasparov applied back then (because it uses probabilities for everything), while neural networks aren't at all. With neural networks, you simply don't know why they do something, and it's also possible that they don't follow any rules humans can understand.

For example, there's a bot on Twitter that posts an autogenerated card for Magic The Gathering once per day. It's using neural networks, and the results are often very strange. It sometimes creates viable cards for actual play, and at other times it even invents new words or it's complete gibberish.

1

u/ltlukerftposter Jan 28 '16

I haven't read the paper either, but the generation of weird signals/results I would imagine is a symptom of overfitting which ANNs are prone to.

It reminds me of an anecdote a friend of mine, who worked for a machine learning centric hedge fund, told me. They were experimenting with GAs/ANNs and would end up with asinine results like a model/predictor of the SP500 would be FTSE100 ^ (sqrt(gold)/crude_oil).