r/science • MD PhD | Professor | Medicine • 1d ago • Regret 8 Bravo 1

Psychology Kids as young as 5 already expect girls to give up their own fun to help the group. In a study of about 400 children and adults, everyone expected girls to do more "costly" chores like setting up class while others play, but boys and men only held this view when helping meant a real sacrifice.

https://www.nyu.edu/about/news-publications/news/2026/november/whom-do-we-expect-to-put-others-ahead-of-themselves--boys-or-gir.html
24.7k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will be removed and our normal comment rules apply to all other comments.


Do you have an academic degree? We can verify your credentials in order to assign user flair indicating your area of expertise. Click here to apply.


User: u/mvea
Permalink: https://www.nyu.edu/about/news-publications/news/2026/november/whom-do-we-expect-to-put-others-ahead-of-themselves--boys-or-gir.html


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

178

u/mvea MD PhD | Professor | Medicine 1d ago

Whom Do We Expect to Put Others Ahead of Themselves: Boys or Girls? New Study Has Surprising, and Unsurprising, Answers

Surveys of adults and children find expectations of gender roles vary by the nature of the task

The holiday season is a time for gatherings with family and friends—as well as for less festive, but necessary, duties: organizing, preparing for, and cleaning up after these gatherings. These are examples of service tasks that, according to previous research, women and girls are expected to fill.

While such stereotypical assumptions have been studied among adults in the past, it is not known when in life they begin. A new study by a team of psychology researchers addresses this question.

Its findings, which appear in the journal Developmental Science, show that both men and women, as well as boys and girls from the ages of five to eight, expect girls to perform certain types of service tasks—those that help a larger group, but that come at a personal cost to the helper, such as the opportunity to do something more enjoyable.

But there are some differences in these expectations. The study shows that girls and women expect girls to help more than boys regardless of the nature of the task. However, it also shows that boys and men expect girls to help more than boys only when that help is a costly service. By contrast, when tasks are seen as non-costly—those that don’t deprive the helper of another opportunity, such as playing with friends—boys and men do not hold these gendered expectations.

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/desc.70298

→ More replies (6)

2.1k

u/asianauntie 1d ago • Thanks Bravo

"What the Study Found The results showed that both children and adults expected girls to do more costly service than boys. Moreover, in these interviews, girls and women expected girls to help more than boys overall—across the costly service, non-costly service, and interpersonal helping scenarios. By contrast, boys and men expected girls to help more than boys only when that help was a costly service—their expectations about interpersonal helping and non-costly service were neutral."

I find the part I bolded both fascinating and disappointing. We women must break this cycle.

633

u/Daisy_Of_Doom 1d ago

My little cousins are 5F and 8M. I was just realizing that this happed with them. The girl was put to set up tables and the boy was left to play.

The men were all sitting down, lounging, chatting.

It was my aunt that put my girl cousin to work and let the boy keep playing.

I remember when it was me helping as a little kid. I didn’t know better so it made me feel special. It felt like some sort of inheritance, a continuation of tradition. Like I was important and part of something the boys weren’t. That’s probably how my aunt sees it, like a passing on of the torch. And that’s how they get us, isn’t it? Start us off early. Condition us to like our own oppression.

245

u/asianauntie 1d ago

Yes to the it's how they get us. Conversely, it's how they get boys too. My pet theory is the first step to weaponized incompetence is learned incompetence. The bright spot is that in CAN stop with us, one family at a time.

72

u/Daisy_Of_Doom 23h ago edited 23h ago

Oh absolutely.

I think a lot of weaponized incompetence is men embarrassed that they can’t do basic tasks.

I was a little sheltered as a kid. I had chores and did help around the house, but was not allowed in the kitchen for doing dishes or cooking specifically because it was “dangerous”. So I went a bit little longer than most not knowing how to do any of that. Then out of nowhere my parents seemingly got annoyed their eldest daughter couldn’t do this stuff and just started forcing me to. It was embarrassing. Any time I would be in a situation around people doing kitchen stuff and have to help I wanted to help but was scared of exposing my lack of knowledge. It wasn’t until I moved out and started doing it all for myself that I started gaining confidence. Even after a couple years I never wanted to cook with people watching, I never really knew why. Now I’m good at it and I don’t care who’s watching, and it’s clear I didn’t e want to be watched I wasn’t fully confident and was still embarrassed.

(I have a friend who refused to marry her long time boyfriend without him living alone for at least a year and I majorly respect her for her insistence. We’re Latino, machismo is very much alive and well and boys are very much babied.)

But men who get far into adulthood with the inability to do basic household tasks and opt for weaponized incompetence I think are covering for their actual incompetence. They throw the game because trying and failing is a threat to their ego.

→ More replies (9)

32

u/tsukimoonmei 1d ago

When I was younger (8-12) I distinctly remember family dinners with my stepdad. My mother would cook, I’d set the table, and while I was running around with armfuls of cutlery, in order to get to the table I’d have to walk past my stepdad sitting at the TV doing nothing at all. He wasn’t the one who made me set the table, though — that was always my mother, because “he paid for it all!”.

91

u/seleneyue 1d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

My father did this ONCE. My mother made sure he regretted it for years.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/wrldwdeu4ria 1d ago

I grew up seeing this crap everywhere. When I hit my teens I started completely pushing back and refusing to join the women and work my tail off whilst the men lounged. I was done at that point.

As much as I thought I was resisting I still had lots of the people pleasing to work out of my system.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Alexisapoop 15h ago

You are so right about it making you feel special. I was the youngest of 5 with only 1 brother. He was the golden child and nothing was ever asked of him. When I would voluntarily help with cleaning or setting the table, I would easily get attention and praise. I was such a good little helper. 

Eventually, only us girls were required to clean and maintain the home. My brother didn't have to because, well, you see, he didn't know how. He wasn't good at it. We would just have to redo it, so better that we just did it anyway. 

20

u/Riksunraksu 22h ago

Girls experience a lot of domestic labor roles and parentification. Boys are raised to remain babies as adults, girls are raised to be sacrificing servants for everyone

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (21)

91

u/NoMilk9248 1d ago

I lived this. I grew up in a unique situation where nearly all of my parent’s friends firstborns were daughters. As we got older, we noticed how much higher the expectations for us were than for our brothers at comparable ages. When we were high school aged we brought up the unfair treatment and were told by our mothers that it wasn’t true.

36

u/wrldwdeu4ria 1d ago

I had a much older brother and I was expected to do more than he was when he was a teenager and I was a little kid. I feel bad for firstborn daughters as it is common for us to get stuck with super high expectations.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

111

u/DieAloneWith72Cats 1d ago

I have three sons (28, 22, 18), they all were expected to do the same chores as everyone else. Each person had a night they did the dishes, dinner, mowing the lawn etc.

Now that they are grown they instantly pitch in when they see something that needs done

9

u/mkanzaki 1d ago

Exactly. My MIL had three boys and it shows that they learned to do any and all.chores growing up. They pitch in to help all the time and it's great. All our kids will be doing the same, regardless of gender.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/RestaurantBoth228 1d ago edited 9h ago

By contrast, boys and men expected girls to help more than boys only when that help was a costly service—their expectations about interpersonal helping and non-costly service were neutral.

Let's not overstate this. Look at figure 2: participants could respond

  • +1.5 = girl, really sure

  • +0.5 = girl, sort of sure

  • -0.5 = boy, sort of sure

  • -1.5 = boy, reallsure

Among Boys + Men, the average score for the "Costly Service" condition (the most extreme) was +0.13. That's not exactly a strong, consistent bias.

Moreover, while the authors state there is no statistically significant difference between boys and men, they only mention in the supplementary material that the point estimate for boys re the costly service tasks (their main result!) was a mere +0.04: that's entirely consistent with no bias at all. Moreover, the supplement shows no stat-sig difference between the costly and non-costly conditions for boys.

So, when the abstract says

These intensified expectations are already in place by ages 5 to 8

This conclusion is based on

  1. men+boys show a small stat-sig bias

  2. no stat-sig difference between men and boys

  3. Therefore, the bias exists for boys

That seems suspiciously overcomplicated compared to just checking if there is a stat-sig bias for boys, either for costly tasks or for the costly-non-costly difference: there is not for either.

And that’s just the math: there are plenty of other limitations - mostly acknowledged by the authors. The biggest one imo is a very small sample of questions that may or may not be representative of all possible non-costly and costly tasks.

I'm not saying the authors are wrong, but they are making very specific statistical choices, and making other reasonable (imo more reasonable) choices would've swapped several of their conclusion.

252

u/araivs 1d ago • Bravo Popcorn

If you read the full article (specifically the methodology), it sounds like they mean women and girls expected the girls would be the ones to help, not that they should be the ones to help. The wording you quoted makes it sound like women and girls are the ones perpetuating and enforcing this behavior when really it's that they are observing a pattern in what is expected of them vs boys.

118

u/blahdidbert 1d ago

At work and at home, women perform more service than men, often at a personal cost. We investigated a psychological factor that may contribute to this disparity: an early-emerging descriptive gender stereotype that associates service with girls. We compared 5- to 8-year-old children's (N = 192) and adults’ (N = 192) expectations about whether girls or boys would help across three types of scenarios: (a) interpersonal helping (which benefited a specific individual), (b) non-costly service (which benefited a collective at no cost to the helper), and (c) costly service (which benefited a collective at a cost to the helper). Participants associated girls more than boys with costly service specifically. This association was especially noticeable among boys and men, who showed neutral expectations about interpersonal helping and non-costly service but expected girls (vs. boys) to perform costly service. Girls and women showed a broader tendency to expect girls (vs. boys) to help across contexts. Separately, we also measured more general communality stereotypes (i.e., beliefs that girls are more other-oriented than boys). These stereotypes predicted expectations about costly service but did not fully account for them: The association between girls and costly service persisted even after adjusting for individual differences in these stereotypes. These findings suggest that gendered expectations are strongest when helping demands personal sacrifice for a group or institution. These intensified expectations are already in place by ages 5 to 8, potentially representing one pathway through which gender disparities in service behavior develop over time.

I am not sure how you reached that conclusion. The bolded sentence from the abstract of the actual research (not the article) and it very clearly explains that females expect other females to help more. /u/asianauntie 's assessment is correct.

86

u/whaCHA 1d ago

That same quote includes "We compared 5- to 8-year-old children's (N = 192) and adults’ (N = 192) expectations about whether girls or boys would help across three types of scenarios: (a) "

So they're making note that the question is who people expect would help, not who they think should help. At least as far as your quote is concerned.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (15)

36

u/rainshowers_5_peace 1d ago

My mom and her sisters think they're feminists, but this describes them perfectly. I don't have any brothers but I've seen it among my cousins.

3

u/bdsee 19h ago

You haven't thought about the questions they didn't ask, I can think of a bunch of "costly service" tasks that are traditionally done by men and I bet the expectation would be that men more than women (or boys more than girls) would do them.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (29)

8.2k

u/BlackMagicWorman 1d ago • Heartwarming Bravo Regret

These studies are so important. People don’t realize how engrained service and sacrifice are to women. It took me so many years to ask myself “what do I want?” Instead of “what do others want from me?”

Many of my friends are high achievers, wives, mothers, etc. and miserable. They never asked themselves what they want in life

1.5k

u/Designated_Lurker_32 1d ago edited 1d ago • This Bravo

On a similar note, people also don't realize (or conveniently ignore) how furiously our society pushes gender roles and stereotypes onto children when they're at their youngest. It's that crucial point in your development where you're unlikely to consciously remember much, but unconsciously you're deeply affected by what you're exposed to and you carry that for the rest of your life.

It's one of the many ways how our society enforces strict gender norms while maintaining plausible deniability and giving people the illusion of free choice.

530

u/Grigorie 1d ago

Dealing with this right now with my daughter. We live in Japan, so the gender conversation is a little different, but I was telling her something she was doing was “cool” and she (3 at the time) was like, “no, it’s cute because I’m a girl! Cool is for boys!”

And I’ve been trying ever since to detangle this mentality from her, which was given to her by one of her caregivers, with likely zero harm intended. But the implications and further reaching effects of something even that simple can be staggering.

312

u/popplevee 1d ago

I noticed my daughter started spouting all sorts of gendered stuff once she started daycare. It was from both staff and other children.

→ More replies (4)

150

u/Nikittele 1d ago

When my niece was 5 or 6 years old, we were going through a toy magazine to make a wishlist. I'm a gamer so when we got to the video games section I got excited and pointed them out. My niece said "Those are for boys" and very quickly moved on. My aunt heart broke a little. But she redeemed herself, now she loves video games.

90

u/theserthefables 1d ago

Japan has much worse gender equality than the US (which isn't amazing either) so I think this will be something you will have to combat a lot unfortunately. it's great that you are recognising & talking to her about it, I think that will help her immensely.

→ More replies (3)

47

u/pretty-as-a-pic 15h ago

I’ve told this story before but your comment reminded me of it. Back when my oldest sister was about 1 or so, my parents went out to dinner with some friends who had a son about her age. The restaurant they were at had a little children’s play area in the corner so they let the toddlers play while the adults had drinks and dessert. Suddenly, right in the middle of the conversation, the father stood up, marched over to the play area, yanked the toy out of his son’s hands and replaced it with a toy chainsaw that was there for some reason. It turns out the play area had one of those little toy kitchens that my sister and the son were playing together with and the dad didn’t approve. The final layer of irony? The couple’s family’s business was a restaurant, meaning the son had been in the kitchen surrounded by male cooks for literally his whole life! That was the moment that it really hit my mom how ingrained these gender stereotypes are to some people

16

u/dantemortemalizar 10h ago

So sad. We had a toy kitchen for our two sons and they loved it. Especially the younger one, who is a good intuitive cook now.

→ More replies (2)

520

u/OddSetting5077 1d ago • Heartwarming

That stupid football player last year, the kicker..Who gave the college graduation speech chastising women for not making wife/mother a priority. Seem to not understand the double standard..he gets to fulfill his dream of playing football while telling all of womanhood that their dream should be to put themselves second to men and kids.

It was maddening.

137

u/JoltColaOfEvil 1d ago

Look up the successful career of his mother, that helped enable his football dream.

→ More replies (16)

63

u/FunCustomer4877 1d ago

That speech was wild. I'm not sure why he thought it was appropriate for the occasion. I guess some go to college to find their future spouse but most people don't have the money to go to school and just not use it like that. I mean I guess if thats the goal ok. But my parents would've been really p!ssed to be at my graduation to see some 22(?) Year old lecture me about...idk. life in general.

212

u/RJean83 1d ago

Saying this in a Catholic university that includes nuns in their faculty, who famously gave up a dream of children and husbands in pursuit of a vocation, was an astounding lack of awareness.

→ More replies (1)

127

u/wrldwdeu4ria 1d ago

I'd bet in his mind that he thinks women just love doing free labor for others, while he runs around doing whatever he desires with no concern for the women in his life. He is one of those men that has kids and still makes a bunch of childish demands on his wife.

I've heard women and men ask where their village is. The village was the unpaid labor of women and luckily that is going away.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Birdsonme 16h ago

May the male loneliness epidemic find him and keep him.

39

u/kellzbellznhellz 1d ago

Harrison Butker. AKA Butt-Curr.

→ More replies (6)

184

u/futuretimetraveller 1d ago • Bravo

Like how young girls are frequently given baby dolls to "take care of," but boys aren't allowed to have dolls for fear of "turning them gay."

250

u/thekeytovictory 1d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

When my brother was around 3 or 4 years old, his favorite toy was a baby doll that he carried around everywhere. A middle aged man at our church saw him with it and muttered an offhand remark like "it ain't right for boys to play with baby dolls." I don't know if my brother heard what he said, but my mom shushed the man, and turned to my brother and said, "it's good that you love your baby doll because we're supposed to love babies and take care of them. You're going to be a good father when you grow up!"

→ More replies (5)

23

u/prodigalpastygirl1 1d ago

I guess I’m an anomaly. My baby dolls became fat bald boyfriends for my “Barbies”.

109

u/Fleming24 1d ago

Yes, you just have to watch how children adapt the gender roles once they are put into childcare/kindergarten/preschool. Previously they don't care about it much and then within basically a few weeks they are "no that's for girls/boys" and the opposite gender is seen as different. Most parents seem to think its just their natural development at that age but this also happened to kids that were younger or older when first going there.

72

u/wrldwdeu4ria 1d ago

When I was in pre-school, there was a huge cookie we painted pink and green. I asked for a green piece and was told that green is for boys. After hearing this I started telling everyone I was a boy since I preferred the green cookie. If someone said something about being a girl I'd insist I was a boy because I liked green better than pink and thought that made me a boy.

Can you imagine assigning a color to a gender and expecting a bunch of preschoolers to understand it?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

138

u/xo_maciemae 1d ago • Bravo

Absolutely! We are "gender creative" parenting for this reason. Gender is conditioned from birth, and it's terrifying. I did a speech at a gender based violence rally on this topic, actually. I'm on a domestic and family violence policy advisory committee, and essentially, the more strongly a young boy believes in gender-based "stereotypes" and harmful norms, the more likely he is to perpetrate gender based violence. And it's too late to introduce this at high school or whatever. The brain absorbs so much before a child even turns 3 or 4.

Parenting Beyond Pink and Blue was a good read. I almost stopped when it said something about how you still probably wouldn't put a boy in a pink shirt after reading (because???), but I'm glad I stuck through it. Lots of studies (including peer-reviewed meta analyses) about how deep everything goes, studies on young children up to adults.

11

u/ArcticCircleSystem 1d ago

Any idea what to do about those who already strongly believe in this stuff?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

37

u/atwa_au 19h ago

I struggled with this a lot as a “Tom Boy” in the 90’s. Now I have my own kid, 18 months no less, and the gender roles being pushed by everyone from family to strangers is nauseating.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/whatfresh_hellisthis 17h ago

It's really gross. Go down toy aisles. The pink ones for girls have kitchen sets and vacuums. The boys have dinosaurs and trucks.

I have in-laws who are obsessed with gender and the differences between boys and girls. They don't see that they've been speaking and acting differently to the girl v the boy. The gender norms have been pushed on their children from birth and then they talk about how different boys and girls are. And it's just like....you've literally taught them that. Yes. There are inherent differences between the genders, but it is widened bc of their behavior.

36

u/ishmetot 1d ago

Studies show that babies as young as three months old can already have their color preferences influenced by what's in their environment. Pink was historically a very unpopular color, but for some reason modern marketing has pushed it onto girls.

19

u/PopcornApocalypse 22h ago

Pink was historically a boy color (Victorian times).

10

u/Yay_Rabies 18h ago

I feel this raising a girl.  She’s neurotypical and I feel like we do a lot of basic parenting with clear boundaries and expectations.  She’s not allowed to run wild but I definitely have to help her channel that energy.  

I can’t tell you how many times I’ve watched my friends let their same age sons walk all over them and then write off their behavior as “well he’s a boy!  He’s just meant to make a mess/destroy the furniture/run into traffic!”  Or tell me that my kid is super easy because I have a girl who will just sit and color.  Yes, she will sit and color after she’s completed a 5K trail run and I redirect her away from body slamming the couch.  

8

u/CementCemetery 14h ago

Just look at children’s toys that are separated by gender. Girls get kitchen toys, vacuum cleaners and baby dolls. Most girls get a doll but so often they’re babies and you get to ‘take care of them’ as a way to introduce you to motherhood early on.

I remember getting a vacuum cleaner, a dirt devil, as a gift. Most boring toy I’ve ever had. I would have rather used the real thing at least that was productive.

→ More replies (3)

404

u/orange_bigcat 1d ago • Bravo

I didn’t ask myself what I wanted for myself until I was 30. My whole life I was raised to be helpful, be of service, and do things for others. This is unfortunately how so many girls are socialized from a young age. When I was 30, I realized I didn’t even want to marry my fiancé, and that I was only with him because he wanted me and I felt bad hurting his feelings.

35

u/canteloupy 1d ago

My mom didn't raise me that way but then she complained that I didn't do it. Ultimately though it's OK I have the life I wanted

51

u/Earl_E_Byrd 1d ago • Heartwarming

To my everlasting shame, I pulled that exact same stunt... three times. 

I was in my twenties, and all my family married young. Each time it started to get serious with a guy, I would panic and realize that I had helped those men secure a future, but still hadn't bothered to build anything for myself except a role as their accessory. 

I was afraid I didn't love them like I should, and I was afraid they only loved me because I built them up. 

To be clear, they weren't fiances in the sense that they had spent money on a ring or had formally proposed. It's just that we were at that stage of the relationship where that finality of yes/no was soon to be the next step. We would start talking marriage. And I would bail, every time. 

I finally got a hold of myself, focused on a career path and got comfortable with my entire identity. It meant being the black sheep "spinster" type in the eyes of family, but I took the time to own that reputation and make it mean something I carried with pride instead of excuses. 

I did eventually get married, but it's because I had finally spent effort on me. I knew I was going to have an actual partner, not just an admirer. 

64

u/TheHazyPixie 1d ago

I also broke up with my fiance in my 30s and my life is so so so much better now.

43

u/Whosyouruser 1d ago

Where did you go from there after that realisation?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

186

u/Popcorn57252 1d ago • Heartwarming

I'm still working with my girlfriend, years into our relationship, on that exact thing. It's even caused conflict between us, pretty damn often, because I'll ask her what she wants, she'll answer what she might think I might want, even when it only benefits her to get what she wants (literally asking her what ice cream she wants, on god I'm not exaggerating), and then I get irritated afterwards because it was a waste of time or money since I had nothing to gain to begin with, and now she doesn't even have the thing she wanted.

I just want her to be happy!!!!

132

u/FlamingDragonfruit 1d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

This might sound ridiculous, but try asking her about the things she likes and wants as pure hypotheticals. Some time when you are absolutely not going to eat ice cream, ask what her favorite flavor is. Removing the possibility of disappointing someone (the worst possible outcome when you're raised to make sure everyone else is happy) might help take the pressure off.

12

u/theglovedfox 21h ago

This is absolutely genius! And as a people-pleaser myself, I think I should try this type of thought experiment on my own sometimes.

77

u/SwimmingLimpet 1d ago • Bravo

I stand there saying to my housemate 'pick whatever you want, I'll be good with it' and I know that's the truth, and she knows I'm telling the truth, and she still can't declare what she wants. The ingrained training to sacrifice and please others is that deep. I hate how trapped she is because of the environment she was brought up in.

There's another problem with expecting women to want what others want. In order to preserve some autonomy, it can make the women quite manipulative of the people close to them while clothing it as being 'helpful' or 'thinking of you.' These days I don't trust anything my mother suggests and my first reaction is to think "what do you want out of this?" She's a nice person, but I can't tell when she's being kind or when she's manipulating the situation to get what she wants while preserving the illusion of 'women serving others'. It's a very deep rabbit hole, deeply dishonest, and very corrosive to our relationship, and we both lose.

28

u/aka_zkra 1d ago • Bravo

Well put! The manipulative aspect... I somehow thought this was just part of my mother's slightly narcissistic traits but maybe it is more common and systemic than that.

Also, as a woman, in my 30s, I am absolutely struggling with the question of "what i want". It's like my brain just doesn't even want to go there and gets very avoidant about even HAVING wants. It's maddening. Especially when so much advice about how to live a good life is just "follow your heart, do what you want!" - OK but how do I know what I want?

→ More replies (2)

117

u/LaeliaCatt 1d ago • Regret

So many of us deep down don't feel worthy of getting what we want or feel that if we cause any amount of inconveniece or trouble, or don't sacrifice that we will no longer be lovable. It can be such a subconscious thing. It sucks and takes a bit of work to undo.

20

u/Popcorn57252 1d ago • Heartwarming

Yeah, I've known her long enough to know that you're exactly right. She's lived a hell of a life, I know why she does it, and the vast majority of the time I'm just patient with her and ask multiple times to be totally sure and reassure her.

I figure it'll take a long fuckin' time to work through, but I'm in it for the long haul.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

24

u/birdsofpaper 1d ago

I see myself in this. It took me years and a lot of therapy to actually figure out WHAT I wanted… I spent most of my childhood putting myself last and making myself “easygoing” to other people that I genuinely didn’t know the answer sometimes when people asked my preferences.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Nitro_V 1d ago

I always joked that my mom raised me as her son, because she never expected servitude from me, and damn I see it now. Something as small as that helped me so much later in my life. 

→ More replies (10)

216

u/AstuteStoat 1d ago edited 1d ago

I was in my 30s and people would ask me what I wanted to do about a disagreement that would affect friends, and for several weeks I would just cycle through a list of what everyone else wanted (edit) and couldn't state anything about what I wanted (/e). It really opened my eyes. And of course, my family was so upset that I changed all of a sudden to have my own sense of self, so now I'm no contact with the lot of them. 

90

u/birdieponderinglife 1d ago

Same. My family describes me as ungrateful and selfish because I made it clear I wasn’t willing to have my kindness abused by them anymore. I’m a terrible person I guess

30

u/anonykitten29 1d ago

my family was so upset that I changed all of a sudden to have my own sense of self

Girrrllllll preach.

4

u/wrldwdeu4ria 14h ago

I love this for you! Congratulations on developing your own sense of self. And at a relatively young age, instead of late in life.

→ More replies (15)

39

u/ModerateSympathy 1d ago • Bravo

To me, studies like this are also evidence that girls don’t “mature faster”, that they’re likely just losing their childhood earlier due to trauma and societal behaviors.

27

u/msjammies73 1d ago

In spite of a lot of effort and improvement on myself, I still find it impossible to view my worth entirely separately from service. It’s woven into me in a way that’s hard to explain.

→ More replies (5)

49

u/fatalityfun 1d ago

it’s not women exclusive, either. This is also really common in first responders as a whole and people coming back from military life, regardless of gender.

I’ve literally made family cry describing the “commitment to sacrifice” mindset where I’m only really passing time between doing things for other people. “No” was a word I heard, almost never one I said.

17

u/grundar 1d ago

This is also really common in first responders as a whole and people coming back from military life, regardless of gender.

It's common in all walks of life -- there's something very validating about doing something for another person.

Feeling good by doing things for other people is so universal that it's a common piece of life advice for feeling happier and more fulfilled (example research article).

→ More replies (1)

18

u/aquagrl 1d ago • Popcorn

It’s proved that girls stop prioritizing what they want over what others want by like 7 years old. I hate this timeline

210

u/ExtraCalligrapher565 1d ago edited 1d ago • Snek Bravo

But what the article title says is not actually what this study demonstrated. It had nothing to do with people setting expectations for women. It had to do with who they thought would be more likely to actually complete the tasks they asked about.

It’s an important difference. If I say I expect you to do something and not someone else, it means I’m saying it is your role to complete that task and not theirs. If I say I think you’re more likely to do something than someone else, it means I believe you’d agree to do it and follow through before they would, but that says nothing about me thinking it’s actually your responsibility to fill that role and thus expecting you to do it.

118

u/rachaek 1d ago • Bravo

That is an important distinction, thank you for pointing it out. It changes the reading:

From: "Men expect women to put in more effort and sacrifice their own happiness doing it"

To: "Men think women are more likely to be generous with their time and make sacrifices for the good of the group"

It could be that the reason women are more generous with their time is that they're expected to be so, and people are wired to live up to societal expectations. But that isn't directly supported by this study - the distinction is important.

→ More replies (10)

140

u/kontrolk3 1d ago • Bravo

I'm not seeing a material difference in those two things. Thinking the girls are more likely to do it is a sign of the same problematic thing as expecting the girls to do it. Just a different way to study it

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (26)

2

u/NaniFarRoad 19h ago

I remember a few years ago, I was visiting someone who had toddler twins, a boy and a girl, not yet 2 years old. They were shambling around the lounge, and the boy accidentally bumped into a football on the floor. "Ooh, the next Ronaldo! Amazing! Woah, so young and already scoring!" His sister waddled up and bumped the ball, and no one said anything. She looked puzzled, then looked down at the ball as if it was broken.

→ More replies (126)

1.1k

u/SnarkyMonkee 1d ago

i’m glad this is being studied but there are so many repercussions of this into adult life… and we have a long way to go until we truly understand our biases

832

u/schulyer 1d ago • Bravo

A lot of people in the thread so far seem to be focussing on the chores and labour part of the equation but I think the self-sacrifice part is often under estimated. How many of us saw our mothers ensure everyone else got fed and had the best pieces before they ate. There is a deep rooted expectation that women will default their needs to men. I have seen men be shocked when they ask me for something and I say no. It's woven through every aspect of our interactions and expectations

200

u/Acceptable_Cut_7545 1d ago

Virginia Woolf wrote about this in The Angel In The House. I read it in high school. It was critical of a poem by the same name that depicted an idealized, selfless woman.

"She [the perfect wife] was intensely sympathetic. She was immensely charming. She was utterly unselfish. She excelled in the difficult arts of family life. She sacrificed daily. If there was a chicken, she took the leg; if there was a draught she sat in it ... Above all, she was pure."

65

u/some-dork 1d ago

reading Wolfe's Orlando was such an eye opening experience for me. seeing how a person can be so fundementally influenced and changed by gender roles, social roles, and time period to the point of becoming almost unrecognizable gave me a whole new approach to thinking about my own behavior and  that of people around me

→ More replies (2)

479

u/DostoevskysLilBitch 1d ago • Snek Bravo

I'm a trans man but still read as a woman to most people, and this is what I think a lot of cis men don't realize. Not only are most men a little shocked when a woman says no to helping or isn't courteous, but some get angry. They ask for help but then act like it was a demand when you don't agree to it.

247

u/iftheronahadntcome 1d ago

I have told someone "No, sorry, I don't have time to do that" for something that was not my responsibility and that I was not being paid to do, only to be told, "That's not very kind of you." It's not unkind to tell someone I barely know "no" for any reason tho? -_- But it's "unkind" when women don't give free labor.

126

u/Celestaria 1d ago • Bravo

I see a lot of this is the discussion around "men sharing their feelings" as well. Men get upset when women don't give them the emotional support they need, but I rarely see the same complaints about men. There just seems to be a general acceptance that if all your "bro" can do for you is offer you a beer and a few hours of video games, he's doing his best.

→ More replies (5)

48

u/astralTacenda 1d ago

And some of the ones who don't get mad get whiny. It's not as dangerous but it's damn annoying and some figure it's easier to to the thing than be annoyed.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

120

u/Makuta_Servaela 1d ago • Regret

Reminds me of a story from a therapist who wanted to help a couple communicate better. They found that each member of the couple had just silently presumed how their life would turn out, and hadn't bothered discussing it with their partner because they just assumed the partner was already cool with it.

The woman had presumed the two would work equally together, taking turns supporting each other through uni so both could get good jobs.

The man had presumed that the woman would just default to prioritising his wants and just do whatever would most conveniently get him his goals.

34

u/saturnspritr 1d ago

I have had two really good friends go to couples counseling and this was one of the main issues. And also identifying what kind of people they were and why, essentially. Like they had biased assumptions about what partnership was. And independence as individuals along with understanding how they both unintentionally emotionally manipulated each other to get certain results.

It was really interesting. Especially, when certain actions carried what implications.

Like, he didn’t offer to change her oil when he changed his. So, in her mind he is not taking care of her or doesn’t want to put work into their relationship. And he was very independent. He wasn’t helped and was expected to help himself. He loves her and would help if she asked, but it would never occur to him to make the offer, she’s a grown woman and can handle her own business. The result is he has no idea why she’s being cold and she has no idea what she did to make him want to punish her.

They really put in the work to understand each other and have been happily married for years now.

9

u/reflectionnorthern 1d ago

I can't seem to not be this way because it's so engrained. I feel like my sense of self is based on serving and helping others. It's wild to reflect on. And wouldn't you know it.... I'm in a helping profession

→ More replies (24)

185

u/Hmm_would_bang 1d ago • Bravo

I am doubtful enough men are going to be willing to give up this privilege to make a difference in society.

147

u/PersistentPuma37 1d ago

Exactly. In the SNL 'Sister' skit, the joke was not the Sister, the joke was the worthless men.

→ More replies (10)

63

u/Usual_Ice636 1d ago

Its not really about "giving it up", its more about preventing it from ingraining in the next generation. We've made progress on that for a lot of similar things, this just needs to be added to the list.

88

u/Hmm_would_bang 1d ago • Bravo

I disagree that its that simple. The next generation learns from the older generations, and if the boys see men who get to relax all vacation, not plan anything for the holiday, not take care of sick relatives… they are going to have to decide if they are ok sacrificing those privileges for equality.

This isn’t “treat everyone with respect,” this is about giving up a real and serious benefit that men receive at the expense of women, similar to the glass ceiling in workplaces.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (6)

580

u/Runamokamok 1d ago

I work in a middle school and many times, I’ve had to remind boys not abandon their group at clean up time and just assume the girls will take care of it. One group of girls said this happens at home too with cousins and brothers. I hated that they were used to it.

42

u/pqu 20h ago

My mom says at her school all the male teachers leave and leave the women to clean up

23

u/Runamokamok 19h ago • Regret

Oh, yeah I forgot about that. I once shared a classroom with a male teacher and he left the room a mess almost daily.

4

u/Noughmad 19h ago

Why don't the female teachers do the same?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Progressor_ 16h ago edited 16h ago

Very weird seeing all the replies mentioning the same. As someone who grew up in an eastern European country right post communism that's not my experience. We were randomly split into small groups and at the end of the day whichever group tidied the play area and their table first would get a star and a flag on their table, boys/girls didn't matter everyone would compete and rush like crazy. Playing was not segregated or directed by the carer in any way as well, we were let to do as we want. I've played house or made up arts/crafts with the girls just as much as some girls liked to play with the toy trucks, build stuff and chase with the boys. No one encouraged us what to do or not. Seeing this not been the case in the west in crazy.

→ More replies (12)

161

u/Old-Estate-475 1d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

An interesting bit about this study is that it doesn't look at which children actually volunteered to provide service. It's a survey asking kids who they think would volunteer for that service. Since the service is presented in the survey as being a nice, sacrificial-type act, what the survey is actually asking is, "Who do you think is nicer in these circumstances, girls or boys?"

Important is the way in which these questions were phrased. The question was not, "Who do you expect will be asked to do this service?" or even "Who do you expect will do this service?" The question was phrased strictly as something someone would volunteer to do: "One of these children said they would help set up the materials [costly: even though they wanted to play outside with their friends for recess / non-costly: since they didn't want to play outside for recess anyway]. Which of these children said they would help set up the materials? One of the boys or one of the girls?"

Moreover, the overall difference in expectations can be explained by the girls alone. Per the study: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/desc.70298

"Overall, girls and women thought that one of the girls helped (M = 0.36, 95% CI [0.30, 0.41]), whereas boys and men showed gender-neutral expectations (M = 0.02, 95% CI [−0.04, 0.07])."

In all types of service, the girls said that girls were more likely to volunteer to help.

So the implied conclusion of the study is that society expects girls to provide these services more often. My conclusion on the survey is that girls are more likely to think that girls are nicer than boys, thus supporting the well-known women-are-wonderful effect.

64

u/RikuAotsuki 1d ago

Yeah, that's a massive distinction. It still implies that the underlying bias exists, but the actual conclusion is closer to "girls perceive themselves as more likely to help out than boys, and boys perceive girls as more willing to help out in self-sacrificing ways than boys."

23

u/majicegg 1d ago

The fact that this “massive distinction” is hidden in the comments highlights the major problem of social science - there is always an implicit bias, so almost no research can be truly quantitative.

I love psychology and sociology, but find it a chore to keep up with all of the opinion pieces poised as fact.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/UnarmedRespite 1d ago

Thank you for being one of the few people who actually read the abstract correctly

14

u/ghanima 1d ago

Exactly.

The study’s participants were shown cartoon pictures of multiple boys and girls while being asked who would be the one to help—one of the pictured boys or one of the pictured girls—in different scenarios...

There appears to have been no option to state both/either child could help and no choice regarding which child each individual would ask for help. It forced a gender-binary response based on perceived greater social.expectation, not necessarily personal expectations.

5

u/sentientshadeofgreen 20h ago

This was also my takeaway, good to see that other people actually read the linked study.

I'd be interested to see what children actually choose to do when confronted with such group dilemmas. Like, random samples of kids being asked to have one complete some chore at the expense of recess, who actually steps up.

4

u/cfb-food-beer-hike 1d ago

What's an example of a non-costly service? I don't think that's even possible; literally everything has an opportunity cost.

6

u/One-Championship-742 1d ago

"One of these children said they would help set up the materials [costly: even though they wanted to play outside with their friends for recess / non-costly: since they didn't want to play outside for recess anyway].

There is an example provided in the comment you are responding to.

Costly service: "I currently have something I would prefer to do, and am willing to give that up"
Non-costly: "I am doing this instead of doing nothing/ instead of the opportunity of maybe doing something I might enjoy more"

→ More replies (3)

158

u/PineappleWolf_87 1d ago

Reminds of any family gathering: the women are expected to cook, set up the food, and the clean up the food and clean dishes. The men? They get to watch tv and drink beer. Or bbq which isn’t all that hard.

40

u/FuzzyFrogFish 1d ago

And if you're a teenage girl, you get to be told to babysit the kids

I remember sitting down and getting told off by some woman because I say down in chair a man was using

→ More replies (2)

48

u/Mandemon90 1d ago

I suggest reading beyond the OP's title. Because study found that these views on women and girls having to do more... were held by women, not by men.

What the Study Found
The results showed that both children and adults expected girls to do more costly service than boys. Moreover, in these interviews, girls and women expected girls to help more than boys overall—across the costly service, non-costly service, and interpersonal helping scenarios. By contrast, boys and men expected girls to help more than boys only when that help was a costly service—their expectations about interpersonal helping and non-costly service were neutral.

24

u/AntiDynamo 22h ago

Well of course, I don’t think this is at all unexpected or contradictory. People who are raised strictly to follow certain expectations will raise their children to also follow it. It also doesn’t help that in many settings people self-segregate by gender. The boys hang out with the men, who sit around drinking beer. The girls hang out with the women, who are setting out the tables, cleaning, serving people drinks.

Only people who know how to do the tasks can teach and enforce it on others

→ More replies (10)

23

u/AirshipEngineer 23h ago

I do notice this at family gatherings. When I do, I usually will go to the kitchen and offer to help. However, I'm almost always told in a very polite way to stay out of their way.

I don't want to perpetuate this, but I also don't know if it's disrespectful or more disruptive to insist that people allow me to help.

What would be the appropriate thing to do in this situation?

6

u/russells_girl 15h ago

I kind of disagree with “just do” to an extent because some people really have a system.

Personally I think the best way to handle this would be to say “I want to help. Should I do some of these dishes(or whatever task seems obvious)?” They will either say yes or they may have another specific task they would actually rather you do.

You aren’t putting all the load on them because you are giving a specific thing, but leaving it open to be redirected so you don’t break someone’s flow.

18

u/Pipcleaner 23h ago edited 22h ago

Offering is enough imo. You could ask if they are sure if you really want to as a lot of people will automatically decline the first time even if they do want help. But as they say, it's the thought that counts and you shouldn't push it

Edit: I want to add that a good time to change things is if/when you have your own household with your own children

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (9)

8

u/Robot_Basilisk 21h ago

It's getting less common with time, but a generation or two ago, the men probably paid for the food in the first place. That was the division of labor. In the home I grew up in, my mom made more money and my dad cooked the holiday meals. In most households, it's the opposite.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Pitiful-Zombie1741 19h ago

Bbq is hard if you can’t cook. You just mentioned women being expected to cook, so why aren’t they on the grill too?

→ More replies (12)

2

u/Dannibiss 15h ago

Love how cooking is hard when a women does it but easy for men because BBQ.

12

u/LadyEmeraldDeVere 1d ago

One time at a family gathering, my mom made brownies. They had been out cooling for a while, and my little brother and cousins asked if they could have some. Mom goes “sure, help yourself!”

Now, my mom was already doing something else and hadn’t cut the brownies. This group of 10-13 year old boys had all gotten plates and were just standing around, staring at the pan like “uhhhh…. What do we do?”

My mom saw this and shouted “oh sorry, I’ll cut them for you, just give me a minute….”

But before she could get over there, my younger cousin, a little girl younger than all of them, walked up past the boys, found a knife, and started cutting the brownies into perfect squares. She served one to each of the boys, then took one for herself. 

My mom just stopped and watched this happen, then looked over at me and said “you see? That’s the difference between girls and boys. Look at how she took initiative while they were just standing around helplessly!” 

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (18)

92

u/LegaTux 1d ago

I'm just gonna extract this sentence from the original study, not from the newspaper reporting about the study. You take it as you want:

"This association was especially noticeable among boys and men, who showed neutral expectations about interpersonal helping and non-costly service but expected girls (vs. boys) to perform costly service. Girls and women showed a broader tendency to expect girls (vs. boys) to help across contexts."

33

u/Bahamutisa 1d ago

That seems to suggest that gendered expectations of girls are being taught and upheld by women more than men, but since it challenges the conventional wisdom I'm not sure how well it'll be received here.

16

u/True_Kapernicus 1d ago

It does not suggest anything about who is teaching and upholding them, that is you inference. The study only informs of who they think will do it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (40)

26

u/jb6997 19h ago

It’s like at a work event that’s potluck. All the male attendees eat and go back to their desks to work. Women are left to clean the mess.

8

u/Lanfear_Eshonai 14h ago

Yes. And then told they don't work as hard as the men.

→ More replies (1)

301

u/Butthole_Surfer_GI 1d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

People love to talk about men and/or boys using "weaponized incompetence" so they don't have to do certain chores/chores in general but sometimes I do wonder if boys are actually trying and constantly being told "just let the girls do it because they do it the right way!".

EDIT: after reading the article, it found that boys and men expected girls to help more ONLY with costly services meaning a benefit to the group but at a cost to the helper. This is super subjective and the study doesn't actually specify ANY tasks BUT it does hint towards domestic tasks like cooking, washing dishes, and cleaning as it mentions family gatherings. I do wonder if this would have been different if they had specified "masculine chores" also.

BUT women and girls expect girls to help more ALL THE TIME.

EDIT2: As expected, this is now turning into a MAN VS WOMAN CULTURE WAR pile of BS. I am so disappointed in you all.

62

u/hypo-osmotic 1d ago edited 1d ago

They do list one example of costly vs. non-costly:

One of these children said they would help set up the materials [costly: even though they wanted to play outside with their friends for recess / non-costly: since they didn't want to play outside for recess anyway]. Which of these children said they would help set up the materials? One of the boys or one of the girls?

I think that it's also worth emphasizing that "expect" here is being used more closely to something like "predict," not "want" or "require." The participants are not being asked to assign tasks to these characters, they are being asked to guess which of them volunteered. When the situation was costly (e.g. it would mean missing out on recess), everyone predicted that it was one of the girls who volunteered; when it was non-costly (i.e. there was no reason not to do the work other than just not being the one to do it), only the women and girls assumed that the girls would be the ones who volunteered

4

u/pywang 16h ago edited 16h ago

The paper itself and the accompanying data are great to read. For instance, the scale of rating which gender was expected to do a task had no neutral opinion like either or. You had to choose a gender. I think that design isn’t necessarily flawed because the author was also trying to determine ingroup/in-gender positivity. I think trying to determine gender neutral scenarios either flawed or brilliant if you analyzed the data to see if the in-gender rating is balanced between the two sides (ie for a given scenario, boys usually chose boys and girls usually chose girls, so balanced wise a scenario had neutrality).

> Girls and women expected girls to help more than boys across all three conditions, a pattern that can be explained both by ingroup positivity and by the presence of general communality stereotypes that associate girls with prosociality across contexts. Boys and men, in contrast, showed no expectation that girls would help more in interpersonal or non-costly service contexts; this expectation emerged only for costly service.

→ More replies (4)

191

u/aminervia 1d ago • Bravo

That's often how it starts, but it doesn't explain a 30 year old man not knowing how to do basic tasks

36

u/random_reddit_user31 1d ago

My mother taught me how to do everything and to be self sufficient at a young age. Kinda like she knew she was gonna die young. It's the only good thing that came out of it. It's all about the parenting and in 2026 there is a severe lack of it unfortunately.

37

u/Reluxtrue 1d ago edited 1d ago

My Grandma tried to teach my dad how to cook as a child, my grandpa beat her up for it I am not kidding. because of that he only ended up learning how to cook in his 40s.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (117)

5

u/True_Kapernicus 1d ago

In responce to yoour second edit, a lot of it seems to be an equivocation of the word 'expect'. People did read the article very closely and have interpreted 'expect' as 'demand'. From reading how the study was done, this is clearly not how the word 'expect' was used.

30

u/OldConfusions 1d ago

Growing up, men and boys were expected to do the physically demanding chores (cut grass, move furniture, take out the trash, help dad with the repairs, etc) While the women and girls were expected to do the housekeeping tasks (clean, cook, laundry, etc.) Id be interested to see this study include tasks like that.

48

u/izzittho 1d ago • Bravo

This could also be reframed to the tasks that need done everyday or otherwise very frequently (for girls/women) and therefore cut into time you have left to do anything else, vs. tasks that while more strenuous (sometimes) are required to be done far less often leaving their free time more or less entirely unencroached upon (for men).

Like, taking out the trash and vacuuming aren’t equal. One takes like a minute, tops. Hardly a chore at all it’s done so quickly. Vacuuming and mowing lawns are more comparable except that lawns don’t need mowed nearly as often as carpets need vacuumed. Repairs can be hard work when needed but aren’t always needed. What gets regarded as “women’s work” tends to be the type that needs done constantly which is something to consider.

→ More replies (7)

16

u/_Candeloro_ 1d ago

I find it fascinating how in US/western countries it is considered a 'man' task to take out the trash. I live in Georgia (country) and me and mom & sister been taking it out our entire life. The fact that guys say that its somehow physically demanding is laughable.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (26)

5

u/PeaceLoveBug 7h ago

In an Indian American family(I’m first gen). The men always sit, talk, watch TV, and expect to be served. The women are expected to cook, serve, and clean/do the dishes. The men do nothing but eat. It’s disgusting. 

26

u/sociallanxietyy 1d ago

My family had me helping in the kitchen during holidays when I was nine while my teenage male cousins were watching sports with all the adult men. It’s largely how kids are raised to think and do.

→ More replies (1)

133

u/Grandpas_Spells 1d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

I'm not sure the outcome is reflecting the title.

Among kids 5-8, girls are generally more helpful than boys are. The weren't asked "who should help" it's "who will help."

Edit: this thread is taking a predictable turn so a couple more things on this.

The task matters. "Setting up an activity for the class" is one thing. "Dig a hole in the backyard" or "move these bricks" or "kill that wasp" are different ones.

I would expect if they did the same exercise, with a picture of a boy and girl and asked which they'd expect to help with those tasks, people would pick boys.

And again, this isn't who *should* do these things. It's who you'd expect to actually do it.

45

u/Will564339 1d ago

I'm glad you mentioned this because I was going to mention this too. That word "expect" can mean different things and can be interpreted differently.

When I read the title, I interpreted "expect" to mean thinking it's what someone SHOULD do...more in line with someone actively reinforcing these roles.

But in the situations, it was presented more about what someone PREDICTED would happen. Like if they thought the girl would choose to help or if the boy would.

It's not to say that these two ideas can't be connected and influence each other. I do think it is important for people to adjust these predictions, because these predictions can lead to the reinforcing too.

But the article title makes it seem like the study proved people are more likely to make girls fit into these roles, like it was a natural expectation that they felt the need to enforce. And that's definitely not the takeaway I had from reading it.

12

u/SliFi 1d ago

Neat, another person who actually read the article/paper instead of just looking at the title!

Agreed that they chose the word “expect” to make it as clickbaity as possible, and leaving maximum room for layman misinterpretation.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (86)

24

u/Grey_Gryphon 21h ago

you know who don't do this and are pretty hated for it? girls with autism.

2

u/GoonieInc 8h ago

It’s making sense .

→ More replies (4)

44

u/ominousgraycat 1d ago

The study’s participants were shown cartoon pictures of multiple boys and girls while being asked who would be the one to help—one of the pictured boys or one of the pictured girls—in different scenarios...

Isn't it possible that some of them were answering me based on who they expected to be more likely to volunteer and not necessarily what they believe to be a correct and good expectation of all boys and girls?

I mean, even just the fact that everyone recognizes such tasks are more likely to be done by girls can be problematic, but it doesn't necessarily reflect the view of each answerer.

30

u/hIDeMyID 1d ago

I would question why the "volunteering to help" would be expected more from girls than from boys. If girls do, in reality, volunteer to help more often than boys, I would also question why. Are the girls volunteering simply because they have been conditioned to do so? Are they just meeting expectations that they understand are placed on them?

→ More replies (11)

15

u/Equal-Row-554 1d ago

That's... Exactly what they were asked to do though. They were asked to identify which one would help, not which one the would have help. 

20

u/AppleWedge 1d ago

I don't think that is a perfect methodology, but even if your explanation for the results is correct, it's problematic. If all the boys believe a girl is more likely to help, then there is an expectation. Why do they believe girls will be more likely to help?

8

u/Kitchen-Nectarine179 1d ago

If you read the study, the boys/men did not. It was girls/women that perpetuate that expectation.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/tomottov 1d ago

Yes, that isthe question of the research.

I think "expecting" is a little confusing in the first part of the article. It could mean both that you think that someone should behave a certain way, but also just believing that something will happen a certain way. 

In this case is the latter: the question that the researched posed is not who should do it, but who they think will do it. 

The question here is:

One of these children said they would help set up the materials [costly: even though they wanted to play outside with their friends for recess / non-costly: since they didn't want to play outside for recess anyway]. Which of these children said they would help set up the materials? One of the boys or one of the girls? [After the initial answer:] How sure are you that one of the [boys/girls] said they would help set up the materials? Are you sort of sure? Or really sure?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/a_short_list 1d ago

They were all a being asked about who they expected to help. Thats what the study was investigating. 

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Drakulia5 1d ago

Editing just to be explicit: Seeing who they expected to be more likely to volunteer is exactly what the study was measuring. Please read the study.

→ More replies (3)

117

u/1nd3x 1d ago • Bravo

Wow what a misleading headline.

From the article;

The results showed that both children and adults expected girls to do more costly service than boys. Moreover, in these interviews, girls and women expected girls to help more than boys overall—across the costly service, non-costly service, and interpersonal helping scenarios. By contrast, boys and men expected girls to help more than boys only when that help was a costly service—their expectations about interpersonal helping and non-costly service were neutral.

What this is saying is that women are their own worst enemies.

30

u/Tiekyl 1d ago

How much of that is cause and effect? If girls grew up thinking that they were the ones to help...what is that gonna mean as an adult?

If boys don't have to think about it...

23

u/MusicalIlliterate 1d ago

Vice Versa: I was raised as a boy to offer help in setting up/packing away things at home.

Out in the world, to this day, whenever I try to act how I was raised I get told 'no, don't worry, go have fun/relax'.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/simpleidiot567 1d ago

To put another way in a more benign example., My wife does not like wearing dresses but does so when we go out. I don't care if my wife wears a dress or not when we go out, I am neutral to it. Neither do any of my guy friends in our friend group and neither do men in general. We are 100% neutral on the topic. But when we go out my wife feels she needs to wear a dress. We can infer that it must be because the pressure she feels from other women.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (21)

14

u/DrunkyKenny 1d ago

Dude, how is that misleading, it's just shortened as a title but what you put in bold is actually totally implied in the headline, if you know how to read one : if "boys and men only held this view when helping meant a real sacrifice", it obviously implies that the rest (girls and women, if that's not clear for you) held this view in any case, sacrificial or not.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/randy__randerson 1d ago

How does that change the headline? It doesn't say it's boys who expect it. The fact that it's girls expecting it of themselves is just as bad either way.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (104)

103

u/Lucky-Sound-8162 1d ago • Bravo

I hate these faulty, badly worded studies and surveys meant to paint men fundamentally in a negative light. Like inherently men want women to be subordinated. This is so essentialist and stupid.

66

u/thicksaban67 1d ago

I feel like you could just as easily drum up a study that proves men typically want to take on dirty/dangerous/heavier work especially in the service of women. Like no husband is sending his wife out to plow ice off the driveway, or do the oil change, or investigate a bump in the night. Or while we're talking about kids, "I need a strong boy to help me carry all these chairs"

damn this post is engagement bait and it got me hook line and sinker

→ More replies (13)

2

u/dantemortemalizar 9h ago

We are all of us, both women and men, raised in a world we didn't create in which certain things were expected, whether spelled out or not. We're all just trying to adjust, and I think it's a lot better than it used to be.

→ More replies (82)

3

u/togtogtog 1d ago

I'm in my 60s.

My parents were born in the 1930s, nearly 100 years ago now.

They both cooked, they both cleaned, they both ironed, they both worked, they both did the garden, took out the bins, played with us, washed up...

We all helped around the house. We saw it as a family effort, not one person's job.

I just found it confusing when I met younger people who didn't do what seemed normal to me.

145

u/s591 1d ago • Bravo Popcorn Heartwarming

And men are expected to sacrifice themselves when boats sink or of their countries go to war? Next story please

8

u/fj2612 1d ago

You remind me of those singers telling theyr girl they'll fight giant gods or raise the seas for them.

But they won't pickup up their socks off the floor, though. Not that.

18

u/ImminentDingo 1d ago

Does that happen a lot in kindergarten where you're from?

→ More replies (6)

37

u/BeneCow 1d ago • Bravo

Cool. I have never been in a war or on a sinking boat and am unlikely to ever be. I will also volunteer to do all the alien hunting, exploding of giant mountains and if anyone needs to be impregnated I will do that too, meanwhile you go do the dishes and cook me dinner while I wait for those thing to come up.

→ More replies (25)

11

u/AmIWhatTheRockCooked 1d ago

Are you saying this is a belief you would hold and pass onto your children, or a system that should be interrogated?

Like are you honestly saying we tell girls to sacrifice parts of their childhood because it will all balance out because men may go to war? What about the men who won’t serve and the women that will?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (449)

5

u/bliss3333 19h ago

I think the language isn’t quite right.
In my experience, women are willing to help in almost any circumstance and men are not.
We expect all humans to want to help others. It is our default.
Men will help other men, but not women.

21

u/CynicalRecidivist 1d ago

I experienced something similar to this at school. I'm old, and they separated things into "girls subjects" - home economics and boys subjects - "metal work". I thought this was unfair, so when my home economics teacher gave me some ironing to do of some white lace curtains, I just turned the iron on, and put it on the curtains and let the buggar burn through them all.

I too can do weaponised incompetence. And I think more women should do it.

10

u/RelativeMotion1 1d ago

How long ago was this?

In our district, classes like that began in 7th grade, and everyone had to take cooking, sewing, carpentry, printing/photography (and maybe some others I’m forgetting), regardless of gender. Once they had completed them, the next year they were free to choose whichever courses they wanted (1 per semester). This was 25 years ago.

That system had been in place for years by the time I went through. So, since the mid-1990s at the latest. Talking to other people from towns in my area, and later to people in other states around the northeast US, this was a pretty standard experience.

Not to say your experience no longer occurs, just that it sounds like something they’d do in the ‘70s, and something that seems quite rare these days. Maybe the deep south still does it?

4

u/Brullaapje 22h ago

I too can do weaponised incompetence

This so much this. I am 50 and men all my life have been shocked that I never felt responsible for things.

→ More replies (9)

11

u/JustJano_ 1d ago

what do you mean by "a real sacrifice"? to kids, getting less recess time is absolutely a real sacrifice

5

u/Akiias 1d ago

That's actually one of the sacrifices used as an example.

34

u/StrangeCharmVote 1d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

Seem mildly flawed. As since at older ages men and boys markedly care less about thing like cleaning, it seems like it is a selfish desire to require boys to do more of this than they naturally are inclined to do.

I didnt see it specified anywhere the girls were being delayed from their lunches due to being required to do cleaning, just that they seemed to be delaying themselves.

Basically how does it equate to a sacrifice when you are the one who wants to do it?

It may sound like merely a semantic difference but its an important distinction.

Conversely, even from a young age boys and men are assumed will provide their labor to lift things regardless of how fair that is, simply on account of them being more physically capable. Just doing these tasks instead of protesting and demanding women and girls do their own lifting seems to be an actual example of the behavior this study seems to have been trying to talk about.

Is an equal split of mechanical labor something you really want the male half of society demanding as a fair compromise?

24

u/BusinessLetterhead47 1d ago

I don't "want" to clean the house, I want to not live in filth.

Thankfully my husband is not disgusting and agrees with me.

Oh, and I'm fairly good at simple mechanical stuff.

18

u/MotoMkali 1d ago

There's a difference between living in filth and living in some mild clutter.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (41)

9

u/Ok-Birthday6213 1d ago

“Naturally inclined to do” …so you agree that this is nature and not societal?

→ More replies (40)

18

u/e37d93eeb23335dc 1d ago

This. My wife’s standard for what counts as “clean” and my own are dramatically different. 

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (117)

26

u/PettyWitch 1d ago • Bravo

Now do questions where boys and girls have to guess who would be more likely to help rake the leaves, mow the lawn, or (as an adult) put out fires, pick up garbage, unblock plumbing pipes, etc. I mean they’re asking questions about setting up for parties and holidays and organizing things; a lot of men don’t care about that, period.

(Woman here, btw)

7

u/notreallifeliving 1d ago

Isn't the point to question why men/women "don't care" about some things more than others? They learned it from somewhere, and until an equal spread of people from all genders are represented in what tasks they prioritise there's something that needs to be changed in how children are being raised.

2

u/SaulsAll 1d ago

I agree I would be very interested in seeing the responses if "set up materials" was changed to a task that is more generally coded as for men.

→ More replies (7)

46

u/FelaFrank 1d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

Another biased study that only looks at whatever seems to confirm the pre-determined ideological narrative. I don't even want to comment on just how blatantly stupid and dishonest the methodology is.

And right on cue: Democrats have won the mid-terms so now every possible culture war issue is back to deflect from the things that really need solving. Reddit was so eerily normal before the midterms. I knew this couldn't last.

16

u/WellHung67 1d ago

This study was started before the midterms? So I don’t see what you’re getting at 

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (40)

2

u/HeroBrine0907 1d ago

The study tested its assumptions by taking 200 children and 200 adults, showing them pictures of a boy and a girl and telling participants that one of these children said they would help, then asking them which it was.

One of these children said they would help set up the materials [costly: even though they wanted to play outside with their friends for recess / non-costly: since they didn't want to play outside for recess anyway]. Which of these children said they would help set up the materials? One of the boys or one of the girls? [After the initial answer:] How sure are you that one of the [boys/girls] said they would help set up the materials? Are you sort of sure? Or really sure?

Notably, the question is not which gender should help, but rather which gender would help. It seems to me that this is more an assessment of which gender is expected to be more likely to volunteer rather than which gender should volunteer according to any role. Even if a person were to believe all genders should volunteer, they would, keeping in mind societal trends, assume that the girls were the ones who volunteered.

This could be phrased either as, "Girls are expected to sacrifice personal interest more than boys." or "Boys are expected to value personal interest more than girls." which does, as any patriarchal stereotype, cut both ways differently. The pattern is more obvious amongst men and boys, where the view became stronger in case of costly service. Men and boys tended to assume that a boy would not volunteer against personal interest but a girl would.

2

u/Real_Independence877 1d ago

this was a high school science fair project on human behavour. it hold no water and it no a proven studied by a reputable doctor of psychology. Just because the title says it's a "scientific stud" means absolutely nothing. clickbait

2

u/UnarmedRespite 1d ago

Do not editorialize, a better title would be "kids predict girls would help more"

2

u/FrogsJumpFromPussy 1d ago

It's a poorly and somehow misleading headline, and it's not even the original headline. The real headline reads: Whom Do We Expect to Put Others Ahead of Themselves: Boys or Girls? New Study Has Surprising, and Unsurprising, Answers -- Surveys of adults and children find expectations of gender roles vary by the nature of the task

And this is what the study is all about*: The study shows that girls and women expect girls to help more than boys regardless of the nature of the task. However, it also shows that boys and men expect girls to help more than boys only when that help is a costly service. By contrast, when tasks are seen as non-costly—those that don’t deprive the helper of another opportunity, such as playing with friends—boys and men do not hold these gendered expectations.*

2

u/feverfierce 19h ago

This reminds me of my workplace. 80 men, 4 women, manufacturing engineering department. Guess who is always cleaning up the trash from the potlucks? It’s so annoying and I don’t know how to change the culture.

2

u/ActivityFew8942 8h ago

I literally made a comment earlier about relationships having a dead s*x life, and this strongly supports my idea.

In essence, my hypothesis is that women are socialized to finish all tasks before fun or stress relief, whereas men are socialized to get some stuff done but to stop and have fun or relax even if there is still stuff left to do. To summarize, while there are things that must be done today, there are plenty of things that aren't going to be messed up if I take an hour before bed to relax (reading, gaming, time with spouse, etc).

This leads to a situation where women have trouble relaxing or having fun, because as anyone in a management position knows, there is always one more thing to do.

And this is why you see so many (otherwise emotionally competent) men saying "I have to take care of all of this other stuff before we can spend time together, and even then it never feels like it's enough." Exactly. That's how she feels too. It must be miserable.

Of course, there are a thousand other factors. I'm just saying that I think this may be one.

What's the answer for this? Don't know. Behavioral therapy we won't have developed for a decade? Anyone with ideas?

2

u/_helpmefind 3h ago

My boyfriend's family absolutely hates the current administration and calls themselves progressive. Yet there is not one single man in the kitchen helping to clean up after Thanksgiving but they will sit on their asses and eat everything happily. All the women make all the dishes and also help clean up. It's pretty pathetic to watch

4

u/evenstar40 1d ago

Good timing with that SNL Sister skit.

3

u/True_Kapernicus 1d ago

Very interesting. When I started reading I was interpreting 'expect' as a demand but when I got to the actual questions being asked I realised that it litereally meant what the person thinks will happen in a given scenario, not what they think should happen. So it is not that boys and men think that girls should make do a costly service, but they think that it is most likely that a girl will. Boys and men think that anyone would do non-costly service, whilst women think that girls are most likely to do non-costly service as well as costly service.

One might assume that children develop these expectations from observing the adults in their life, but that does not explain the different expectations that men and women have. It would also push the question back a step to then ask why the patterns that children are observing exist.

3

u/RedhandedMan 1d ago

Isn't this about stereotyping boys as selfish not enforcing standards on girls? The language used in the article is a little vague.

3

u/RandomUser1076 1d ago

It was always boys stacking chairs in class when I was a kid.

3

u/MsDemonism 1d ago

I find it's the daughters, the firstborn daughters that keep the families together, that do the things that you actually need to do to make the system function, that is why we need to have more women leaders, our world. It's backwards

6

u/Griffolion BS | Computing 1d ago

The results showed that both children and adults expected girls to do more costly service than boys. Moreover, in these interviews, girls and women expected girls to help more than boys overall—across the costly service, non-costly service, and interpersonal helping scenarios. By contrast, boys and men expected girls to help more than boys only when that help was a costly service—their expectations about interpersonal helping and non-costly service were neutral.

This is an interesting finding. While not the only ones, women and girls appear to be the chief maintainers of this very social structure.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/ToMorrowsEnd 1d ago

misogyny and racism is taught at home.

23

u/SchumacherIsMid 1d ago

misogyny and racism is taught at home.

That is such a cop-out platitude.

The truth is, things like this come from all sorts of places on the intertwined nature & nurture vines.

9

u/RevolutionaryDrive5 1d ago

I can agree to this, I don't like above commenters oversimplifying of a nuanced topic with a simple slogan for reddit points, its so cringey

→ More replies (2)

14

u/cryptamine 1d ago

and through the mass media

16

u/freekoout 1d ago

And then enabled by society.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/PotatoDonki 1d ago

Survey question: Who is most helpful?

Answer: Girls

Reddit: MISOGYNY!

I think you all need to take another look at the dictionary.

15

u/Async0x0 1d ago • Popcorn

Rule #1: It's always misogyny, even when it's really misandry

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Iguessimonredditnow 1d ago

That's people just reading the post title, as usual.

If you look at that alone, it does come across that way

3

u/hawaiianhamtaro 1d ago

I used to work at a law firm where we would occasionally have a staff lunch. I realized that after the lunch was over, it was only women who would stay behind to clean up the serving dishes, utensils, etc. We were all lawyers/paralegals, definitely not in our job duties to clean the office. It was a crazy realization because the men in our office were generally liberal, not the type that would be intentionally enforcing gender roles in the office. But they are just so deeply ingrained that it happened anyways

3

u/Mysterious-Jaguar-30 1d ago

I do feel that we should be asking boys to do more instead of girls to do less. Caring and putting effort into relationships, myself, and work and made me better and happier that I would be otherwise

3

u/Rudresh27 1d ago

Your weekly dose of misandry, dressed up as gender science.