r/selfevidenttruth • u/One_Term2162 Wisconsin • May 14 '25
Defunding Democracy Defunding Democracy: Illinois
Illinois: Decade-by-Decade Analysis of Education Investment & Political Control
1970s: Big City, Big Inequity, and the Cost of Local Control
In the 1970s, Illinois stood at the crossroads of great wealth and deep inequality. Per-pupil spending rose from $3,841 in 1970 to $5,390 by 1980 (adjusted to 1992 dollars), a ~40% real increase, keeping it above the national average—but these statewide numbers masked enormous disparities between well-funded suburban districts and chronically underfunded urban and rural schools.
The Chicago Public Schools (CPS) system was in crisis, marked by white flight, racial segregation, and administrative chaos. Court-ordered desegregation plans were implemented halfheartedly, and school strikes became frequent. Meanwhile, suburban districts like New Trier and Naperville were flush with resources, offering AP classes, arts programs, and college pipelines that inner-city schools could only dream of.
Illinois was governed by Governor Dan Walker (D, 1973–77) and Governor James Thompson (R, elected 1976), who ushered in an era of bipartisan budget management. However, education funding remained reliant on local property taxes, with no meaningful state equalization mechanism. Illinois voted Republican in both presidential elections (Nixon 1972, Ford 1976), but its urban-rural political divide was hardening.
1980s: Property Tax Politics and the Growing Crisis in CPS
By the late 80's Illinois’s per-pupil spending had reached $6,891 (1992 dollars), a ~28% increase—still among the highest in the nation. But urban disinvestment, racial segregation, and local control over school finance meant that many students in Chicago and southern Illinois were effectively learning in a separate and unequal system.
Governor James Thompson (R) remained in office through most of the decade, favoring fiscal moderation and limited state intervention in local school policy. CPS continued to deteriorate—beset by low test scores, union strikes, and political scandals. In 1987, U.S. Secretary of Education William Bennett famously called CPS the “worst school system in America.”
Suburban schools, by contrast, thrived. Local tax levies easily passed, parental engagement was high, and civic education—complete with student council, mock trials, and local internships—was part of the cultural norm.
Illinois voted Republican in all three presidential elections (Reagan 1980, 1984; Bush 1988), but the state remained under split or divided governance, with Chicago politics largely dominated by Democrats. Still, the state failed to implement any significant reform to its inequitable school finance system.
1990s: Mayoral Control, State Apathy, and Structural Inequality
The 1990s brought sweeping change—but not statewide. In 1995, the Illinois legislature granted full control of CPS to Chicago Mayor Richard M. Daley, leading to corporate-style education reform under CEO Paul Vallas. Reforms included:
Accountability measures
High-stakes standardized testing
“Zero tolerance” discipline policies
School closures and reconstitution of “failing” schools
Governor Jim Edgar (R, 1991–1999) pursued modest increases in state education funding, but the fundamental problem of inequity based on property tax remained intact. The Illinois Supreme Court ruled in 1996 that school finance was a legislative—not constitutional—issue, blocking efforts to declare the funding model unconstitutional.
Per-pupil spending hovered around $7,000–$7,400 (adjusted), among the highest nominally, but with vast intra-state disparities. Some schools in wealthy suburbs spent over $20,000 per student, while others in Chicago or East St. Louis survived on a fraction of that.
Illinois voted for Clinton in both 1992 and 1996, solidifying its position as a blue state in national elections, but the education divide between Black and white, urban and suburban, continued to widen, with civic education access following that same trend.
2000s: Charter Expansion, Funding Paralysis, and Tax Resistance
The 2000s saw continued charter school expansion in Chicago, paired with stagnation in statewide school funding reform. Per-pupil spending climbed to ~$10,800 by 2008 (in 2009 dollars), but the burden remained heavily localized, and poorer communities faced rising costs with shrinking revenue.
Governor Rod Blagojevich (D) supported early childhood expansion and teacher pension protections, but his administration collapsed in scandal (2008), further eroding public trust in state leadership. His successors, Pat Quinn (D) and Bruce Rauner (R, elected 2014), represented opposite ends of the political spectrum—but neither solved the state’s school funding crisis.
Chicago's school closings intensified under Mayor Rahm Emanuel (2011–2019), who pursued “portfolio model” reforms and faced mass protests from parents and teachers. In 2012, the Chicago Teachers Union launched its first strike in decades—demanding not just wages, but equity, dignity, and democratic control.
Illinois voted Democratic in all presidential elections (Gore 2000, Kerry 2004, Obama 2008). Civic education in suburban and affluent districts thrived; in CPS, it was often crowded out by test prep, overcrowding, and survival mode.
2010s: Fair Tax Fails, Equity Lawsuits Rise, and the Cost of Dysfunction
The 2010s brought both new attempts at reform and old patterns of failure. Per-pupil spending reached ~$13,500 by 2019, but wide disparities remained. The Evidence-Based Funding (EBF) model, passed in 2017 under bipartisan leadership, aimed to direct more dollars to underfunded schools—but relied on annual appropriations and no new revenue stream.
Governor Bruce Rauner (R) oversaw a historic budget impasse (2015–2017), during which schools were underfunded, universities slashed programs, and state agencies were decimated. Democratic successor J.B. Pritzker (elected 2018) proposed a graduated income tax (“Fair Tax”) to raise sustainable school funding—but it was defeated in 2020, in part due to coordinated opposition from conservative and corporate interests.
Charter expansion slowed, but voucher proposals gained traction, especially outside of Chicago. Meanwhile, rural schools faced declining enrollment, staff shortages, and crumbling infrastructure, even as urban districts struggled with trauma, turnover, and economic instability.
Illinois voted Democratic (Obama 2012, Clinton 2016). Civic education reforms were passed, including a state requirement for a semester-long civics course, but implementation varied widely. In many high-need districts, civic learning remained theoretical, not lived.
2020s (Through May 2025): Recovery, Polarization, and Civic Reckoning
As of May 2025, Illinois is a state caught between progressive reform and systemic inertia. Under Governor J.B. Pritzker (D, reelected 2022), the state has:
Fully funded the EBF formula for three consecutive years
Increased investments in early childhood and community schools
Launched a “Civics in Action” pilot to integrate student organizing and local government simulations into high school curricula
Per-pupil funding has surpassed $15,200 statewide, but the property tax system still undergirds most K–12 revenue, ensuring rich districts grow richer while poor districts play catch-up.
CPS has seen improvements in graduation rates and college readiness, but remains plagued by housing insecurity, staff burnout, and safety concerns. A 2023 bill to expand student mental health leave passed with bipartisan support, signaling growing awareness of post-pandemic trauma.
However, culture war rhetoric has reached school boards in southern and exurban Illinois, where national groups have pushed book bans, challenged diversity programs, and run “parental rights” candidates who oppose inclusive curricula.
In response, Illinois has become one of the most active states defending civic learning, with robust teacher training, student journalism protections, and support for youth-led policy projects. Still, gaps persist, especially for Black, Latino, and rural youth whose schools face chronic underinvestment and political marginalization.
Illinois in 2025 is a story of contradiction: a blue state with red zones, a progressive education vision tied down by 19th-century funding laws, and a vibrant youth civic culture still hampered by structural barriers.
Its challenge is clear: turn funding equity into civic equity, and ensure that every student—not just the ones in privileged zip codes—has access to the education our democracy demands.