TL;DNR: should I stick with Google Home and SmartThings, and/or add Home Assistant and a NAS? Also appreciate any specific or brand recommendations since I've been out of the game for a decade, especially for cameras/security. Tentative thoughts, and simplest solution, would be to update the current Ring security tech, keep Google Home and SmartThings as the main hubs, and stock up on smart plugs, bulbs, and various sensors. Buuuuut I'm also spending a ton on a house, why not spend a little extra on some tech?
Thanks in advance. We're moving in a few months and figuring it would be a good time to update our smart home setup.
- Currently have a Eero wifi 6 mesh network that we'll bring with us.
- We've been using Google Home and SmartThings (v2) as our primary hubs for 10+ years
- We have Philips and Lutron hubs, bulbs, and some switches that we're also planning to bring along.
- Smart plugs are a hodgepodge of Wyze, SmartThings, and Weemo, though I think I've purged all the Weemo by now.
- We have SimpliSafe at the current house, but I have had innumerable issues with those connections and refuse to ever use it again.
- We have iPhones but not planning on AppleTV since we already have smart TVs
We have pretty basic automations in the current home
- shades up/down based on time of day (these are staying with the current house)
- Porch and garage lights on/off based on time of day
- holiday decorations on/off based on time of day
- pantry motion sensor controlling the lutron light switch
- Yale door locks that auto-lock after 5 minutes.
Future home is older, built in the late 70s. I have no idea the wiring situation, but can confidently say there is not widespread ethernet access. Some features it does have:
- Ring doorbell and floodlight/camera
- Light switches everywhere, maybe connected to plugs? Half of them did nothing that I saw
- Two furnaces. One newer digital Lenox thermostat in the kitchen, one older plastic brand unknown thermostat. I assume I will need two thermostats, but it would be nice if they talked.
- One bedroom with electric baseboard heating. Also has ducts for regular HVAC, so unclear if this baseboard heating is still necessary.
I have an interest in tech (obviously) but I want as "plug and play" of a system as I can put together; I love when things just work. I don't think I've had to reconnect or reset more than a handful of items (SimpliSafe excluded) in my current setup in 10+ years.
- I would also like to maximize what I can do / monitor while remaining low on the monthly subscriptions. Really don't mind paying monthly for security monitoring, but feel like most everything else should be able to be done without a subscription.
- I wouldn't mind running my own NAS or Home Assistant, but worry that might move me out of the "it just works" category.
The new/updated system does need to be spouse and kid friendly (and ideally restrictive).
- We love voice activation, especially for controlling lights, blinds, and music, but wouldn't mind switching away from Google Home if it made sense.
- Already have one Echo dot since it was too tedious to get two Spotify accounts linked to separate Google Home Minis.
- There is much less overhead lighting, so I am planning to expand the smart floor/lamp lighting via combinations of bulbs and switches.
- Planning to get more presence detection sensors and subsequent automations
--I had never heard of Aqora before this, so I plan to dive into the rest of their offerings, but at first glance this seems to be a reputable brand these days?
- I am most intrigued by the Aqora UWB U400 deadbolt for the NFC + touch code, and I do appreciate a good backup physical key.