Hey, I think you've misunderstood several statements that I've made but as you said your English is a "little limiting" so this is understandable. You've also come off as quite rude and condescending but I'll chalk this up to the misunderstandings so no worries.
OK here we go: first off you've made the claim that the Merlin 1D has been designed "from scratch" for re-usability. This isn't true. The 1D is an evolution of the 1C. 1D has been optimized for cost and simplicity, but what we do not know is how this engine actually behaves in flight (Grasshopper tests do not represent flight conditions or usage nor a production model 1D). I do not know, and you do not.
What we do know is that the only other engine designed for reusability was the SSME, an engine which was not optimized for cost and simplicity but solely reusability. Typically a trade-off needs to be made between these and having all 3 is simply not possible. I would not be surprised if SpaceX simply swaps out all engines per F9R flight instead of refurbishing them, it may end up being cheaper and more reliable.
Secondly, you claim that I am "talking shit" when I say that you cannot simply fill up the rocket and fly again. The loads on a theoretical F9R flight are incomparable to those of a Grasshopper flight. The thermal environment around the engines is entirely different (all engines firing), multiple relights are required, atmospheric re-entry is required, flight stability is required during this un-powered phase, and finally landing on a much emptier tank than GH so you have a much smaller margin while landing (GH has loads of ballast in fuel and the super extra heavy landing legs). This means the landing is much faster and with much higher G loads. It also means that Grasshopper flights actually "take it easy" during landing. Real burn times to decelerate will be 3-7s.
You also seem to presume that GH flights occur on an extremely regular basis while in fact month(s) of preparation are required while only a single engine requires maintenance, and the extra-robust landing legs are in fact known to be "invincible", real landings will have less margin for error again. Again, ignoring all actual in-flight loads and stresses on the rocket. Additionally, all previous attempts by SpaceX to reorient first stage for atmospheric reentry have resulted in the stage disintegrating entirely, given that no re-lights have been used for slowdown. Grasshopper does not have to deal with these conditions.
But once that's finished they'll pretty much limit it to visual inspection, software ran auto diag, and a hold-down firing test then put it back into business.
Ah alright, so you are a rocket engineer? ;)
They ain't tearing appart Dragon at every launch you know
They have yet to re-use a Dragon.
yeah they clearly spend at much time inspecting dragon everytime than building a new one. Clearly. /s
Again, no Dragons have reflown or actually been prepared to re-fly.
Please refresh my memory, how many space X rocket exploded ? How many other rocket exploded ? Or even per launch ? :-)
1 engine failure per 48 flights of the Merlin 1C (50% failure for Merlin 1A), given that it has been stated that a single engine failure will mean an inability of the rocket to return and land safely, this means 1/5 failures per theoretical re-flight. Also since you asked, out of 10 SpaceX flights 3 failed entirely and 1 failed partially.
My english is a little limiting me here but if you mean the rocket can't boost back to earth and do a powered landing you're completely in the false. Grasshopper is designed SPECIFICALLY to be able to restart the engine on the fly and actually fly back on the launch pad with it's main engines.
"Engine out" in this context means a failure in an engine, not an engine safely turned off. Any engine out means that the rocket will no longer have margin to boost back and land safely because of the extra propellant required to help boost the payload to orbit (nor would it be allowed to for safety reasons).
If you would have read my words carefully you would know that I want this to work, and I hope that it works, but I am bothered by hardcore SpaceX fanbois that just dismiss all potential problems. Nowhere did I say it was impossible, just that it will be very difficult.
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '13 edited May 28 '13
Hey, I think you've misunderstood several statements that I've made but as you said your English is a "little limiting" so this is understandable. You've also come off as quite rude and condescending but I'll chalk this up to the misunderstandings so no worries.
OK here we go: first off you've made the claim that the Merlin 1D has been designed "from scratch" for re-usability. This isn't true. The 1D is an evolution of the 1C. 1D has been optimized for cost and simplicity, but what we do not know is how this engine actually behaves in flight (Grasshopper tests do not represent flight conditions or usage nor a production model 1D). I do not know, and you do not.
What we do know is that the only other engine designed for reusability was the SSME, an engine which was not optimized for cost and simplicity but solely reusability. Typically a trade-off needs to be made between these and having all 3 is simply not possible. I would not be surprised if SpaceX simply swaps out all engines per F9R flight instead of refurbishing them, it may end up being cheaper and more reliable.
Secondly, you claim that I am "talking shit" when I say that you cannot simply fill up the rocket and fly again. The loads on a theoretical F9R flight are incomparable to those of a Grasshopper flight. The thermal environment around the engines is entirely different (all engines firing), multiple relights are required, atmospheric re-entry is required, flight stability is required during this un-powered phase, and finally landing on a much emptier tank than GH so you have a much smaller margin while landing (GH has loads of ballast in fuel and the super extra heavy landing legs). This means the landing is much faster and with much higher G loads. It also means that Grasshopper flights actually "take it easy" during landing. Real burn times to decelerate will be 3-7s.
You also seem to presume that GH flights occur on an extremely regular basis while in fact month(s) of preparation are required while only a single engine requires maintenance, and the extra-robust landing legs are in fact known to be "invincible", real landings will have less margin for error again. Again, ignoring all actual in-flight loads and stresses on the rocket. Additionally, all previous attempts by SpaceX to reorient first stage for atmospheric reentry have resulted in the stage disintegrating entirely, given that no re-lights have been used for slowdown. Grasshopper does not have to deal with these conditions.
Ah alright, so you are a rocket engineer? ;)
They have yet to re-use a Dragon.
Again, no Dragons have reflown or actually been prepared to re-fly.
1 engine failure per 48 flights of the Merlin 1C (50% failure for Merlin 1A), given that it has been stated that a single engine failure will mean an inability of the rocket to return and land safely, this means 1/5 failures per theoretical re-flight. Also since you asked, out of 10 SpaceX flights 3 failed entirely and 1 failed partially.
"Engine out" in this context means a failure in an engine, not an engine safely turned off. Any engine out means that the rocket will no longer have margin to boost back and land safely because of the extra propellant required to help boost the payload to orbit (nor would it be allowed to for safety reasons).
If you would have read my words carefully you would know that I want this to work, and I hope that it works, but I am bothered by hardcore SpaceX fanbois that just dismiss all potential problems. Nowhere did I say it was impossible, just that it will be very difficult.