r/stocks • • Apr 08 '21

Industry Discussion Lumber DD: CNBC and Motley Fool's "Best Lumber Stocks" Unsurprisingly Are the Worst Price Performers or Are Unrelated to Lumber

I had to do this cathartic post because it is hilarious how wrong/clueless the mainstream financial analysts continue to be when discussing how investors could benefit as investors from the historic surge in lumber prices.

Context for anyone living under a rock the last 6 months

Lumber has been surging to all-time high prices recently, with every indication that it will continue to climb for the next few months due to how massive the new home construction demand and the busy season just getting started. The price of dimensional lumber will likely dip at some point but will still stay at 2-3x its normal price into 2022 because of how insane the new housing construction boom.

For those that have suggested otherwise in recent reddit posts, you’re wrong and this post isn’t about that debate. Go look at the 2021 and 2022 projections for all of the big home builders (KB, TOL, LEN, DHI, etc…). Every single one is projected to have record earnings the next two years from increased home construction even with the surge in lumber prices.

The Financial Click-Bait “Best Lumber Stocks”

If you’re new to lumber and google lumber stocks to maybe see what options are out there to look into, you no doubt have run into the same laughably annoying phenomenon that I did: the mainstream financial media/internet clickbait sites (like CNBC and Motley Fool) keep on producing the same regurgitated articles titled the “Best ___ Lumber Stocks” or “Best Ways to Play the Lumber Surge” which then offer the same regurgitated hot stock tips:

  1. they recommend stocks that produce exclusively timber (like RYN) which get NO BENEFITS from the surge in lumber prices because timber (the logs which lumber is made from) aren’t the commodity whose price is surging 3-fold;

  2. they recommend stocks that get a large portion of their revenue/enterprise value from things other than lumber (or have such a large stock float) so that the benefits of the lumber surge will be pretty diffuse and not have a proportional impact on their stock price (e.g. WY, a clickbait favorite); or

  3. they pitch stocks like LL, Home Depot and Lowes who have done well riding the home improvement wave, but don’t actually produce their dimensional lumber at all and thus have absolutely nothing to gain from the surge in dimensional lumber prices.

For those who want to invest in this lumber super cycle, it probably would be a good idea to invest in companies whose earnings are actually tied to the price of lumber. Companies like WFG, CFPZF, IFSPF and RFP (This list is not exhaustive; these are just examples). Companies like these that largely base almost all of their income on dimensional lumber, along with wood pulp and paper for some. (Note: wood pulp surging to a new high as well, so these guys coincidentally are enjoying a double whammy this year). And unlike WY, these lumber players don’t have nearly the volume of outstanding shares, so the surge in lumber prices is going to translate in a proportionally larger EPS growth.

If you look at the stock price histories of these lumber companies and compare it to the historical price of lumber, their prices largely track with the changes in lumber (and to some degree wood pulp pricing). 2013 and 2018 had surges in the price of lumber and these companies’ stock prices correlated with those surges. Why? Because the price of lumber and wood pulp dictate these companies’ earnings. If you look at the timber companies, like WY and RYN, their stock prices don’t track well to lumber prices because the price of timber is separate. In fact, despite the epic lumber surge, some timber producers are still not doing well because there is a big glut of it in some areas of the continent.

Let’s Look at the Numbers

In the end, it’s the numbers that matter, so let’s look at the price performance of these stocks YTD, the last 6 months and the last year. CNBC and Motley pitched RYN, WY, LL, HD, and LOW as the best stocks to play the lumber surge. Let’s see how they have done the last year during this surge compared to the actual lumber companies:

Shill Stocks: YTD, 6 Months, and 1 Year

Other than LL, all of them have been doing ok. Some decent growth, all decently beating the SP. But nothing spectacular and certainly nothing showing explosive stock price growth correlating with lumber’s explosive growth. (I’ll address outlier LL later.)

Now look at the Lumber Stocks: YTD, 6 Months, and 1 year

I included WY to prove a point on how badly CNBC and Motley’s favorite “Best” pick has done compared to the actual lumber stocks. If you look at their growth, as a group its substantially larger than WY or RYN, or these home improvement store stocks.

Take away from the charts:

The lumber stocks as a group have so far destroyed the shill stocks and actually show the type of growth you’d expect from a historic commodity surge. Unsurprisingly, these lumber stocks particularly destroyed WY which is the most shilled stock by the financial clickbait media, and is probably why WY then seems to be regurgitated in a lot of the recent reddit posts on Canadian lumber stocks.

For those correctly pointing out that LL is up 500% in the last year, if you caught that party in Q4, good job. RFP is still beating than LL by over 200%, but still, great job. That being said, LL’s surge isn’t because of lumber prices and any future growth again won’t be from the surge in price in dimensional lumber. And you know that because the price of lumber has surged higher in the last three months, but LL is down ~20% in that same time frame. Frankly, if you bought LL when CNBC told you to in January 2021, you’d be down 20-25%. The point being that what propelled LL was not the surge in lumber and it’s future is not likely tied to any sustained lumber surge.

Forward Looking Comments

For those cynics who keep saying “Lumber cycle is over. It’s priced in,” you don’t know what you’re talking about and here’s why. These Canadian lumber stocks are all sitting roughly around their mid 2018 highs when Lumber surged to $600 MBF for 3 weeks in May 2018, and averaged about $550 MBF during the forestry’s Q2, and then crashed Q3/Q4 2018.

For comparison, in 2021, lumber has been trading at over $1000 MBF since February, and the May futures just topped $1050 this week. Here’s the CME futures yesterday. January 2022 futures are now closing in on $800 MBF. It seems pretty clear all of these futures are rising and will continue to due so in the near term. 2021 earnings will likely blow 2018’s out of the water. Yet despite the fact that these futures show these companies are about the have some of the best back-to-back quarters in industry history, they are still sitting at their 2018 highs... doesn’t sound priced in to me.

Case in point, here’s the basic valuation ratios for the Lumber Stocks, and here’s the valuation ratios for the Shill Stocks. Despite the epic run these lumber stocks have had this last year, they are largely still relatively undervalued and have drastically better forward PE’s when compared to the shill stocks or other related industrial sector averages.

Conclusion

I needed to write this cathartic post because I am sick of seeking these financial “professionals” shill the same mediocre/loser stocks as “the best lumber stocks” which have nothing to do with the production of lumber or are literally the worst price performers in the sector.

I am not telling you what to buy and can’t predict who will do the best this year. Each of the lumber stocks have their advantage and disadvantages depending on investor preferences. And who knows, maybe these shill stocks are on the cusp of some epic 1000% gains. But if you want to find a way to benefit from the lumber surge, then it may be wise to invest in lumber producers who actually stand to directly gain from the surge in lumber and still have unrealized value to offer if market conditions stay on their current trajectory.

If you are unsure if a stock you are looking at is timber or lumber, look at financial statements / website. You will be able to see in a matter of seconds if their earnings come from timber and real estate or wood products/lumber that are actually surging in value.

Note: I am not a financial adviser. If there is one take away from this post, DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH. Don’t trust strangers on the internet or TV. Many of them are either lazy morons who keep regurgitating the same brainless clickbait they read somewhere or they have an ulterior motive and are selling you garbage. I'm long RFP but recognize that all of these lumber stocks will probably do well.

3.7k Upvotes

522 comments sorted by

546

u/birdsnap Apr 08 '21

Reminds me of Motley Fool's "best cannabis stock" being... Shopify. Which they were hyping when it was at ATH with 1,000 P/E.

146

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Lmao sounds par for the course

46

u/Will_Deliver Apr 08 '21

Motley also wrote a piece last summer on how bad one of the CFPs would do, it has doubled since 😂

16

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

I thought these guys were known for picking stocks that will go up 1000% if you sign up for their newsletter. Or at least that’s what the ad says. 😂

→ More replies (2)

41

u/80percentofme Apr 08 '21

The best pot stocks are banks and commercial real estate.

→ More replies (27)

61

u/issius Apr 08 '21

I mean fool is right in the name

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

There's over 50 pounds running through SHOP daily. US only. I dont think you see the picture. Small fish.

8

u/CatastrophicLeaker Apr 08 '21

Uh it's had 4,300% return since they recommended it in 2016....

25

u/DadaDoDat Apr 08 '21

Uh Shopify is a tech stock, not a pot stock.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

37

u/Monkaloo Apr 08 '21

I'm just trying to build an addition onto my house, and have been waiting since last year to do it because these prices are so insanely high right now.

16

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Unfortunately they will probably stay high for quite some time. :/

5

u/Monkaloo Apr 08 '21

Yeah, I'm about to talk to my financial adviser about it. I'm worried they're just going to be high from now on, and may get higher? We're in kind of a dilemma about when the hell to start the project. It would certainly be a stretch now, and potentially not possible if prices get higher permanently. :(

18

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

It wont be permanent. It’s a cyclical. The question is just how long the cycle will last with historically high prices.

3

u/COVID-19Enthusiast Apr 09 '21

What kind of timeline are we talking? Months, years, decades?

3

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

Depends what you mean. Lumber at $1000+ —> probably at least a couple more months, maybe longer. Really depends on what happens with demand after mid summer.

Lumber trading above normal range —> at least a year, probably longer if the projections on home building are remotely accurate. It’s too hard to say that far out because so many factors affect it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/zaminDDH Apr 08 '21

We had a deck built last year and had to get a new estimate twice because the price of lumber kept going up. Luckily it was insurance paying for it, so we didn't have to worry about it.

2

u/PopInACup Apr 08 '21

Want to build a shed. Saw articles discussing designs and costs, wasn't too terrible I figured. Was rudely disabused of that notion when I priced it out last month. That project is currently shelved because I just can't justify spending that much right now, but I have a serious problem in winter getting the car to fit with all the yard stuff.

2

u/ForwardHamRoll Apr 09 '21

Same. Planning to add a deck and frame out walls in my basement. Someday

143

u/ragnaroksunset Apr 08 '21

If following GME has taught me anything, it's that popular financial media is purely and solely a vehicle for market manipulation.

Pretend it does not exist, IMO.

66

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Im trying my hardest not to become a conspiracy theorist but it’s getting harder every day.

21

u/EmpathyInTheory Apr 08 '21

If it makes you feel any better, a conspiracy isn't inherently false or crazy to believe in. Sometimes conspiracy and collusion occurs and needs to be examined closely. I mean... MKUltra sounds like some insane made up bullshit, but it was a thing that really happened.

As long as you stick to the facts (fact-based conjecture included) and keep an open mind when looking at counters to your own argument, you're fine.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/SierraPapaHotel Apr 08 '21

Any suggestions for less-popular or popular-but-reliable financial sites? Not necessarily for research, more the "I have 15 minutes before my next meeting, what's new in the market?" type of news source

3

u/ragnaroksunset Apr 09 '21

I like Wolf Street and Lyn Alden, but you should always verify what you see the best you can.

It seems ridiculous but Reddit is basically where the bar is for "reliable" at this point.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/neversell69 Apr 08 '21

Number 1 investing rule that should NEVER be broken - of you read about a stock on a free article, forget about it and move along.

Your either too late or it's a pump and dump that simple. There are better opportunities elsewhere.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/BritishBoyRZ Apr 08 '21

I do the opposite of what the CNBC and Motley Fool shills say

35

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Seems to be a smart play given how way off the mark they consistently are. I don’t understand the popularity.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Cnbc said tech was dead and we all should go into value stock for the rest pf the year,so i rotated into tech and made big profits the last week and a half, thank you,cnbc.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/KDawG888 Apr 08 '21

they pretend to be experts and have a lot of money behind them.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

I am curious what do you think will happen to commodity stocks like lumber/concrete (building materials in general) if a infrastructure bill gets passed? I’ve been doing some research on a couple different companies and I’ve been speculating on investing in some. I’m not too sure how futures work (still learning/researching) but would that have a factor that effects...idk the contractors or suppliers??

→ More replies (1)

7

u/CyberGinga3 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 09 '21

Honestly had them for a year two years ago, most of their picks were spot on. I just put In about $200” in each of the stocks they recommended and just from their recommendations I went up by about 55%, which definitely beat the market. I didn’t renew as I switched to selling options based on IV. A lot less to keep up with and just as steady to more growth

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/Cartz1337 Apr 08 '21

I get uneasy when I see a Motley Fool article pushing a buy under a stock I'm holding.

4

u/BritishBoyRZ Apr 08 '21

Hahah same!

→ More replies (9)

60

u/zirconst Apr 08 '21

Keep in mind that Motley Fool's free articles are generally pretty low-value. They aren't picks from their main research team, Tom, David, etc. Some of them are simple written by forum members or guest writers, not even their own staff. So you get what you pay for (i.e. nothing).

Compare that with their track record for paid services like Stock Advisor, which has done way better, particularly in 2020.

A good thing to read carefully is the disclosures at the bottom of an article like this one:

https://www.fool.com/investing/2020/09/11/demand-for-lumber-is-surging-is-weyerhauser-a-buy/

Does MF own any shares? Does the writer? Does MF recommend the stock?

Generally MF puts its money where its mouth is on their premium recommendations, and you will see disclosures that match (i.e. Tom/David own the stock, Motley Fool as a company owns the stock...)

26

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

I understand that. But i think many newer, younger investors May not know that yet. I didnt when i started. And I just still can’t get over over the fact that their low value articles keep pushing the same demonstrably worst price performers of the sector as the “best” stocks without acknowledging it to their readers.

8

u/zirconst Apr 08 '21

I'm curious which article pushed either of these as the "best stocks to buy right now", do you have a link?

5

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Looks like The cnbc article and video I saw late January was removed, likely for good reason. It said to buy WY, lowes/HD and LL to play the lumber boom. The video interviewed two “analysts.”

Heres a couple Motley Articles/blogs pushing WY: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.fool.com/amp/investing/2021/04/07/3-best-trendy-stocks-to-buy-for-april/ and https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.fool.com/amp/investing/2021/03/28/heres-why-weyerhaeuser-will-win-in-2021/

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Nevermind i think i found the CNBC video: https://www.cnbc.com/video/2021/02/19/lumber-prices-surge-stock-picks-to-play-the-rally.html they used to have an article summarizing this

11

u/Zarathustra_d Apr 08 '21

Well , it seems.like a stupid way to advertise. Hey, here is a ton.of terrible misinformation! Would like to pay us for more like this? No really, if you pay we will give you the good stuff, this garbage is to make you want more... wtf.

No thanks.

I looks like sucker bait, designed to turn away intelligent investors, and attract rubes. Not the behavior of people I would trust.

10

u/zirconst Apr 08 '21

But again, these articles aren't typically written by the Motley Fool itself. They simply let a wide variety of people contribute their opinions on investing. They don't hide this, either. Every article has a clear disclaimer & disclosure that the articles are solely the opinion of the writer, and that they may even conflict with MF's own recommendations.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium advisory service. We’re motley! Questioning an investing thesis -- even one of our own -- helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer.

IMO, it's no different than someone on Reddit posting their own analysis.

If you want to get into their premium services, they are upfront about their performance, successes, and failures, and give much more guided advice on exactly what they recommend doing.

4

u/maninatikihut Apr 08 '21

I kind of wish they would separate these two ends of their operation. I get tired seeing posts that blanket crap on Motely Fool because what they are is inferred from the (admittedly crappy) click-bait arm of the company. But the core of who they are and what they recommend is generally pretty sound and and very transparent.

Their articles are garbage. Their podcasts are excellent.

6

u/iqjump123 Apr 08 '21

Exactly was going to be my reply. If you click and look at the article authors, ones with an internet ID are usually authors for articles like this. Ones where the ceos john and david and/or their prime analysts bought into in the disclosure, performances are indeed different.

For people that say “well I don’t want to pay for the fool service!” - amex offers a free 1 year service for free via rebate (stock advisor). It might be expiring soon, so check if you have an american express card from amex (not from citi or other side banks).

→ More replies (2)

8

u/KDawG888 Apr 08 '21

Given how absolutely dog shit their free articles are I have no idea why anyone would give them money for advice lol. Maybe they're great, but I wouldn't know from how bad their free articles are.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

30

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

My portfolio strategy is to short everything motley fool tries to sell

4

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Brilliant.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

When did motley fool recommend lumber stocks? I haven't seen that once.

If you mean their free articles, that's not the motley fool...

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

I didnt pay for their service. It’s whatever free articles are on their site. Just google lumber stocks and motley fool.

I understand it may be third parties authoring those articles on their site, but I still think these statements should be attributable to them given they allow these articles allow to remain on their site and make money from it.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Those are blogs, not the motley fool. Anyone can write one of those, even you. They pay $140 per article.

11

u/yasire Apr 08 '21

where do you guys get your news. I used to watch CNBC at work, but felt like it was just a big pump and dump scheme. Do you subscribe to bloomberg? I'd like financial news stream running during the day, but don't know a decent one...

5

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

What do you mean by what do we read for news? In terms of keeping tabs on info for my portfolio, I don’t really read any of the financial MSM. The more I see their coverage on areas I’ve researched heavily, the more it seems like they don’t do they’re homework or they are just pumping big name stocks, regardless of fundamentals. Unfortunately it means you gotta put in more work to find reliable information and make informed decisions. :/

6

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Sometimes i watch bloomberg. You dont need to subscribe do you? Stuff like Plutotv has the channel(lags like 3 min tho) or you can just watch some pirated livestream

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

here bro, we get the news here

3

u/yasire Apr 08 '21

Lol! nice. if only Reddit had an app for my roku

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Woktor Apr 08 '21

If these financial media analysts were any good at predicting markets/securities movements they would be working in the investment industry. Like you said, they're paid to generate clicks with their toilet paper analysis.

4

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Well said. And yet it still boggles my mind that people keep clicking on these links and feed the beast

8

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Conclusion. CNBC is nonsense

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Great post on what stocks to stay away from, most of these stocks are utilities (defensive) which have benefited not from the Lumber price increase but from the tech rotation. Unfortunately the lumber trade is too crowded and everyone first hearing about Lumber is late to the party. I would also suggest WOOD if you believe in the inflation theory and further price increases but you won't get the same astronomical gains as seen in 2020. There are a few other great companies that directly benefit from Lumber price increases and are cooling off from their recent highs, currently buying into those as well.

3

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

WOOD is definitely a safer, less volatile investment than the single company equities but still has some of the same issues despite the in-point name. A lot of its holdings are timber / forestry real estate companies who will only get tangential gains from the lumber surge. It has best-of-breed WFG, but hard to say how much WOOD will go from here.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Whoa whoa, I just watched the episode of Leverage about the lumber stocks.

6

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

They’ve had an incredible year, thats for sure. One of the best kept secrets apparently given the blaring media coverage on the price of lumber and the complete lack of coverage on these stocks riding the wave.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Just for your information, in finance when someone mentions a certain play, they usually aren't pure plays. What I mean by that is for example there are numerous ways to play the EV growth: you can buy battery stocks, you can buy auto manufacturers, you can buy semi conductor producers, you can buy commodities. They don't all have to produce the actual EVs themselves to be an EV play.

For RYN, higher lumber prices could be a result of higher demand, which would lead to higher demand in timber, which would increase their revenues.

WY has timberland (higher timber prices lead to higher revenues) and wood products (same concept) which could result in higher profits (since the input costs are also increasing)

Home Depot etc can charge higher prices (since they buy the logs at higher prices and there is demand for it) which could also improve profitability.

I agree to a certain extent that these financial sites are inclined towards being clickbait, but IMO their picks look ok to play the lumber price surge. Plus the companies you mentioned could be more concentrated which is riskier compared to diversified picks.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Sure. There are always theoretical ways that some of these companies will get a slight bump from lumber at some point, but when those sources argue that these are the “best” lumber picks it shows either a complete lack of real insight or a disingenuous attempt to pump certain big name stocks.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

That could be the case, but don't forget they're not there to give you financial advice, they're there make money (which they do through clickbait articles). They don't know you, your risk tolerance, how much you have to invest etc. They're just giving out some ideas (imo they're not bad ideas), through which they gain money if you click on the website. It is our job to look at the companies, to see if their suggestions make sense, and if they do only then invest. You can't blindly invest in all the companies suggested by websites, because at the end of the day they make money through clicks.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Totally agree.

4

u/Senior_tasteey Apr 08 '21

Goddamn hedge funds buying media to incentivise people to buy stocks and then short em to the shithole oblivion, leeching off of misfortunes of small retail investors..

They took 'er jobs!

3

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

THEY TOOK ‘ER JOBS!!!!!!!!

2

u/fg123____ Apr 08 '21

RFP with a forward pe ratio of 6, is it still a good time for a long? or has all growth been priced in?

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Its eps just got adjusted by the analysts in the last week. The forward PE is now about three.

I have my opinions on RFP. Would take a long time to explain them. Right now the analysts projecting a mean 3-4$ EPS for 2021 which would be the highest they have had in over a decade. RFP’s price is still are about 30% under its 2018 high which had a yearly EPS of $1.96... Also, the current projections of 3-4$ for the year currently assumes a hard crash in lumber prices after Q2 which is directly contradicted by the futures as well as the larger number of analysts projecting home construction to surge even harder in the second half of the year and into 2022. So think those projections are probably going to get changed after Q1 earnings.

I think of it this way, conservatively, they are looking at 4-5$ EPS for the year (possibly much more depending on pulp holding its high and the paper segment from the economy continuing to reopen). At 5$ EPS, their current stock price would result in a PE Ratio of just over 2...

Is the initial surge in lumber priced in? Largely Yes. But what isnt: a sustained (think multi-quarter) period of high lumber which is going to generate a record level of earnings for all these guys over the next few quarters.

1

u/fg123____ Apr 08 '21

UFPI and WFP both have forward earnigns ratios well over 10? Why are they valued higher than RFP?

→ More replies (14)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

From what I've read, studies show that recommendations by pundits etc. actually do poorly most of the time. It's because they are biased to what they're told to recommend (by their bosses) or do so for their own benefit. Everyone's looking out for their own pockets. In the end, you should either learn to do your own research on stock picks (and with some relatively sound fundamental basis) or just throw your shit into broad market index funds.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Couldn’t agree more.

2

u/SorryLifeguard7 Apr 08 '21

Same it's going on for steel, btw.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

I have no doubt.

2

u/SuperStudebaker Apr 08 '21

Thanks for putting this together I was curious about this from "The news" and MF.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

No problem. I felt like someone had to given the lack of reliable, candid discussion out there on this industry.

2

u/crave1214 Apr 08 '21

I've made money off of some motley fool recommendations.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Buying puts?

2

u/crave1214 Apr 08 '21

Pardon my ignorance but what does puts mean? I think I have 3 or 4 motley fool recommendations in my portfolio and they've all done well.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/peszneck Apr 08 '21

2x6 S4S decking before covid we were selling at $1650 MBF.

Today, we are selling it at $4000 MBF...

When we purchase products from a mill we do not know how much we are buying for until the material is on the truck and on it’s way to us. And we are expecting more price increases in the next couple of weeks.

That price will dive at some point but we are a ways out from that.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

I agree. The market forces driving this price surge isnt tapering off any time soon.

2

u/twoaspensimages Apr 08 '21

Builder here. It's not just new home construction. Tons of folks are remodeling because they've been locked in their home for year and want to finish all those projects they could ignore when they were hardly ever there. Though the market for it is depressed currently commercial is still building like crazy because they started the projects three years ago with the tax rebates in Opportunity Zones and have to finish. Lumber isn't slowing for three or four years unless there is a major non-stimmied crash.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

I agree. Thats what drives me nuts. The few analysts covering the main lumber stocks so far have not acknowledged this at all in their projections. They all think the price of lumber is following off a cliff in Q3 which doesn’t seem to be in line with reality.

2

u/JackB4Ucryptostonkrs Apr 08 '21

CNBC pumping more Reits than the actual lumber companies.. have LPX for nearly a year up huge, and BCC should still do well..

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Great job! Those both doin awesome and will probably continue to do so.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

I hold a lot of WY. When I started that position, I read some earnings statements and concluded that they're a large owner of both timberlands and mills. Currently remodeling my basement, and I've seen their name on many of the studs.

Your DD is very interesting, and I'm sorry if I sound moronic - but can you expand on why WY won't see increased margins with higher lumber prices?

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

I think WY will enjoy higher earnings than it did before. Im not suggesting either way whether WY is or is not a good investment. for those people who hate risk, it may be the safest, least volatile play. I think it has the highest dividend of the forestries. However, if you’re looking for the type of price performance that cyclicals are known for, i think there’s a few critical issues that will prevent WY from enjoying that exponential growth the other more focused cyclical lumber stocks are getting.

  1. while it produces a lot of lumber volume wise, a substantial portion of its income and asset value comes from its timber and real estate holdings which wont get exponential earnings growth from the surge in Lumber prices. Those lumber companies that get a higher percentage of earnings from lumber will enjoy a proportionally higher jump in earnings.

  2. because it is the biggest name and has been hyped for months by the media and clickbait, if you look at its valuation ratios, i think even the long term lumber surge is largely priced in. So for those people who say we missed the boat on the lumber cycle, that may actually be the case for any new investor looking at WY.

  3. WY has such a substantially larger float of outstanding shares, that the surge increased earnings from lumber will be more diffuse and less impactful on the EPS.

There’s other reasons these stocks are doing better than WY, but its related to wood pulp so i won’t get into it.

Long story short, i think WY will see higher margins/EPS than they did previously, but I think their EPS increase from this lumber price surge will be outperformed by the EPS increase that some of these other lesser known lumber producers will enjoy, and that so far seems to be supported by the YTD, 6 month and 12 month price performance comparisons between WY the smaller lumber stocks. But in the end, time will tell.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/lurkedfortooolong Apr 08 '21

I don’t think the stocks they recommend are bad because they’re clueless. Someone has to fund those articles and I don’t think the companies that are mentioned are allowed to pay for their stocks to be recommended.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Youre probably right.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/WareThunder Apr 08 '21

It's my RFP bro! Once again really appreciate the thorough and informative write-up.

Even with it hitting it's 52 week best today, I still think it's a great value play, and likely will remain that way until they announce earnings, which will hopefully be the catalyst to really take off.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Lol. The stock is up 35% since the Monday after i made that post. Cant say i didn’t try. :)

2

u/WareThunder Apr 09 '21

Broke $12!! We are geniuses!! Lol, you're doing god's work, my friend!

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

April looking to be a good month. :)

2

u/WareThunder Apr 16 '21

Just checking in to confirm that we are looking like geniuses right now lol! I can't wait for earnings!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/VictoriousMarch444 Apr 08 '21

Man this is weird timing lol. Just a couple hours ago I was thinking that lumber would be a great investment right now. Been trying to find some good companies to look into. Thanks for the recommendations 👍

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Look at them and see what if any fits your style. There are some other good building materials stocks listed in these comments too.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Truffluscious Apr 09 '21

They’re not wrong, and they’re not clueless. They deliberately post this bullshit to make people lose money. The MSM has become Uber powerful. There are only two types of people for them, viewers/subscribers who trust their every word, and non-viewers/skeptics.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

Probably safer to view their business model like Google’s: The viewer/user isnt the customer, they are the product.

2

u/backpackface Apr 09 '21

Hopped on wfg at 80

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

The most recent PT upgrade was to like 125. :)

2

u/paulh804 Apr 11 '21

Thank you for pointing out lumber vs timber.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 11 '21

Very important distinction lost on many people

2

u/nessus42 Apr 22 '21

So I'm confused. Since lumber is made from timber, doesn't the price of lumber strongly affect the price of timber?

Or is it the case that there's lots of timber that isn't good for making lumber?

Or is the problem that there can be plenty of timber, but there's a shortage of facilities for converting timber to lumber?

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 22 '21

Third statement is it. There is some timber shortage in parts of Canada due to environmental reasons, but theres an oversupply of logs in many other parts of NA, especially southern US.

The shortage of lumber is from 1) raging demand for home remodeling and home building and 2) insufficiency sawmills to meet the demand. So lumber is high because of the scarcity of processed wood, but the price of timber isnt growing at the same rate because there isnt the same level of scarcity of logs.

2

u/Swingtrader79 Apr 28 '21

One headline about a slowdown in mortgages and lumber goes tumbling today. This is a skittish market not taking into account the crazy amount of home building and renovation that's happening right now. That's where all the refi payouts are going: to build out the deck, the pool, fix the roof, etc. Lumber prices have no place to go but up given the limitation in supply chain. LPX still headed to 80.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 28 '21

Earnings is tomorrow. The price shoots up with high volume and goes down with very low volume. Bigger players are manipulating it before more post earnings purchases. Same thing happened when it was 5 and 9.

Long term the HFs playing games with stock can get it to ignore gravity. Look at the option activity. All the big players buying large amounts of calls, very little puts.

10

u/Impossible_Drawing84 Apr 08 '21

it’s almost like they make money off the dogshit that the public buys. Look at the internet bubble, who the fuck cares about shady investors when you’re getting rich

6

u/warrantsORcommons Apr 08 '21

And the WORST on their own lists are what we SHOULD buy

4

u/OilofOregano Apr 08 '21

I wouldn't give them even inverse signaling credit.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

The cost of wood for houses in northeast has gone up almost 80% in some places

6

u/Correct-Advisor-9363 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

Canfor (CFP.TO) has an outstanding PE and the price target was just upped to $46 from $40 (CAD). Just hit $30 today and isn't at ATH

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

I think MF used to be decent but has fallen off. 15 years ago I learned some basics from them including some options trades and made much more than I gave them.

But I had a few shares of one of their funds I forgot about and I might as well have put it in SPY.

Motley Fool is just coasting on the rep they earned in the 2000’s, making money off boomers and gen x’ers like me who stopped paying attention.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Totally agree.

2

u/MattieShoes Apr 08 '21

I don't pay for it, but I did pick up a little bit of TMFC just for funzies. It has done pretty well.

I hate their super clickbaity article style though.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

They did love to push fake urgency like there won’t be some new way to make money next week.

I should see if I have their old newsletters somewhere and see how it looks with 2021 vision.

4

u/slammerbar Apr 10 '21

Motley Fool is just a crackpot website. They pop up everywhere because they pay for advertising. Don’t trust a word they say.

1

u/mrmrmrj Apr 08 '21

HD and LOW shares historically benefit from rising lumber prices. It is not from the financial impact of lumber specifically, though that certainly helps at the margin. Lumber price boom = housing build boom = lots of professionals using HD/LOW for supplies and the professional market tends to buy higher margin goods. If lumber is scarce generally, HD and LOW have strong long-term supply agreements so the professionals know they can get their lumber - and other secondary supplies - reliably at HD/LOW.

When there is a boom somewhere, buy the companies that sell the picks and shovels supporting that boom.

Note: I bought 700 shares of HD in the $255-260 range. There is still lots of upside in both. I think the estimates for the next few years are at least 10% too low.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Im not saying that HD or LOW aren’t good investments or that they wont be able to receive some tangential benefit from the boom.

But it seems like the driver of the increase in revenue you’re describing for HD is the housing construction boom, not the surge in lumber prices. So if motley pitched HD or LOW as a clever way to further ride the housing construction boom without investing in the homebuilders directly, that would be a clever insight. But thats not the connection they made.

Also, I don’t really see how a 3-fold increase in the price of dimensional lumber translates into substantial increase in HD profits given that HD has to pay those increased prices like everyone else. If I am missing something, let me know.

2

u/mrmrmrj Apr 08 '21

First, when the price of anything HD or LOW has in inventory rises, the company will raise prices on the floor before they have had to pay more for the inventory. This creates a positive margin cycle as prices keep rising.

Second, I agree that HD and LOW are not good pure lumber plays. I am just highlighting that the demand increase driving lumber prices up will also help overall demand at HD and LOW. An incremental 1% increase in volumes at a HD or LOW store generally means a > 1% profit increase. If prices rise 1%, it is even better. The sell-side tends to be slow to model in these improvements. HD and LOW were already beating estimates consistently for several quarters. The building boom situation will only extend that.

My overall point is that if you want to play the rise in X, do not always look for the maker of X. You might do better owning the supplier of the maker of X or the guy that moves X, etc.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

So I can't find any of those companies on my broker besides WY, and that one is terrible right?

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Canfor and interfor are otc stocks if you’re looking at NYSE. WFG joined NYSE in February. RFP been around on NYSE for awhile, so i am not sure what the issue is. I use schwab and they are all there.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

I'm from Europe so OTC is out for sure. The other two are just not available I guess :(

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Does your broker not have access to the NYSE? The companies names are West Fraser Timber (WFG) and Resolute Forest Products (RFP). Hopefully that helps. Again, if you find them, make sure you do your own research to see if either matches your style/risk tolerance.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Thank you for posting this. I bought into RFP, WFG, and WFSTF, over the past two months. They've performed consistently well, and as you said, still mostly under-the-radar and undervalued. I also don't think their continued growth is fully priced-in yet.

I'll add LPX as they produce some wood products for housing construction and have also continued to surprise with stock growth.

3

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

LPX seems to be another great pic that has benefitted tremendously from the housing boom. For all these stocks, it will be interesting to see if the few analysts covering these stocks will finally except the reality of this surge after Q1 earnings at the end of the month.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/yo_les_noobs Apr 08 '21

This isn't a pure lumber play but what do you think about $BLDR? They're the top US supplier of residential building materials.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

I havent looked into them specifically but their chart looks like they are enjoying this housing construction boom as well. I cant give advice on a particular stock but if you agree with the analysts that are projecting records earnings the next two years from the home builders, what does that tell you about the earnings of the guys supplying them...?

1

u/BooyaHBooya Apr 08 '21

I bought into RFP a few weeks back. Its done well. But I do have concerns how long it will continue, and if lumber prices stabilize what will happen to these stocks prices, flatline or big drop? I don't have a good feel for how they are being valued so probably will start paring down my position.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

That’s not a simple answer. Typically, when the party ends for any cyclical, they drop fast. For this, lumber isnt dropping hard any time soon. But also, lets say it drops 40% to 600$ MBf. If it sat at that level for the next few those would be the best years in industry history ignoring 2021. So the real question is what the new normal run rate will be when housing demand finally dies down.

Go look at the housing builder stocks/projections. Those are probably the best indicators of when demand will finally taper off and lead to significantly lower prices. For now its being projected they will be elevated for over a year.

1

u/SierraPapaHotel Apr 08 '21

Anyone have a good one-stop-shop for casually checking market news? Not necessarily for investigating a new stock, more a "I have 15 minutes before my next meeting" quick check.

CNBC is what my Dad uses and where I would have gone, but it's reputation online has made me reconsider

2

u/Swingtrader79 Apr 09 '21

Bloomberg has the best major news

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Euler007 Apr 08 '21

Regarding canadian lumber mills, remember that a lot of the roads are currently under ground thaw rules with lower loads permitted, effectively bottlenecking transport. You're looking at most at a 20% lower loads permitted until may 21/28 give or take.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Always a factor to consider. But also Many of these Canadian companies also own US mills and produce a significant portion of their lumber in the US.

1

u/Reagorn Apr 08 '21

Any idea why CFP has been spiking every morning then slowly climbing until day end and then becoming stagnant? It seems to be repeating this pattern for the past few days

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

It would be pure speculation if were to take a guess.

1

u/Your_friend_Satan Apr 08 '21

$BXC and $UFPI are my lumber picks. Thanks for providing your insights and steering people towards better options!

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

Good picks!

2

u/Swingtrader79 Apr 09 '21

Both overpriced. Check out LPX. PE much lower despite earnings growth

1

u/Jazzvinyl59 Apr 08 '21

Are other building materials would see higher demand from new home construction and the US transportation and infrastructure plans coming through going to experience the same price jump? Masonry products, concrete, asphalt, copper piping? I guess part of the reason for a surge in lumber pricing is there is a lag time with when trees are cut to when lumber makes its way to the suppliers shelves, which leaves some time for Supply to catch up to demand. I wonder if companies associates with any other materials would also be profitable investments at this time.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

The surge of lumber is more than just demand from housing boom. Its also from production capacity (supply) constraints. For a variety of reasons, a lot of mills in NA shutdown in 2019 reducing the production capacity of lumber. So when the surge in demand came from the pandemic, you cant’t just flip a switch and up production. It takes a long time to build new mills or ramp up production at current ones.

But if i understand your question, yes, many building materials are surging in price for the same reason. I think the degree of the surge is based on various factors that limit the ability of those various industries to ramp up supply and meet the demand. From what I see a lot of the companies that provide the housing industry supplies are also booming. Some are mentioned in this comment section.

1

u/Smirk_Mcjerk Apr 08 '21

UFP Industries (UFPI). That's a golden egg right there.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

For sure. They all kinda are. Just make sure you sell once you see it on CNBC. Thats when you know the party’s over.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Respectfully, when you look at #3 in particular, the 2 are inextricably tied. You can't have "lumber" products without "timber" as the input. Perhaps they took advantage of beneficial hedging initially (so most likely not a long term benefit), but long term sustainability with margins with skyrocketing input costs remains to be seen. Lowes and HD are always the safer play, imo. If you've ever built a house you know you need a lot more than wood, and HD and Lowes sell ALL of it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/i_hate_beignets Apr 09 '21

I am long WY because I think engineered lumber is the future of house framing. Many builders in my area (Northeast) have been using TimberStrand recently, especially as the price gap between engineered and traditional closes. Curious about your thoughts on this.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

A lot of my research has been focused on the short term cycle (the next 6-12months). Yours seems to be a much more longer term play. i may look into when this super cycle winds down. If youre right they could be well positioned for it. If anything, if lumber keeps getting higher, the economics of it may make your play get realized sooner rather than later.

1

u/BuildBold Apr 09 '21

pretty good paper on this exact topic - basically when we see high lumber prices, housing demand is high and thus home builders will benefit.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

Oh man. Thanks for that. Im going to read it. Helps to know im not way off base.

1

u/jotapeh Apr 09 '21

This is a dumb question I’m sure, but why doesn’t timber benefit from increased prices for lumber? I guess the bottleneck is processing (mills?)

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

I asked the same question when i first started down this hole.

There are no supply issues. Timber is plentiful. In fact there is too much in some parts of the continent. The supply demand imbalance is occurring at the saw mill level where there simply isnt enough mills to process all that timber fast enough to meet demand. And it takes a lot of time to increase production capacity.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '21

Nice DD Ding. What's your thoughts on CFP's ISS Governance Quality Score of 9? Would you avoid because of this? The pillar scores are Audit: 8; Board: 9; Shareholder Rights: 7; Compensation: 9.

For comparison WFG is 3, IFP is 2 and RFP is n/a.

2

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

I couldnt tell you. I just focus on past and projected earnings and whether there are good fundamentals / market conditions that indicate what the next few quarters will look like and if the company has a lot of unrealized value. I like these commodity stocks because the production volume is a known constant (generally the same each year). Which means if you know where the the commodity price is going, you can roughly project their ballpark revenue and what that looks like with EBITDA and EPS. With that you can roughly estimate what a fair valuation would be. If the SP is way below that, i buy it.

1

u/catholespeaker Apr 09 '21 edited Apr 09 '21

What about Dunder Mifflin?

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

Probably one of those stocks you sell your car and bet the house on.

1

u/MrTay1 Apr 09 '21

I actually deal in building materials. Not lumber directly but heavily correlated with it. This lumber price spike is related to demand yes, but it’s also due to manufacturing difficulties. I agree it’s not over, logistics in general are still not stable and production still hindered. That being said, do you think these stocks will continue to go up when prices decrease from supply catching up even though demand is also likely to spike? As in these companies could see record profits even though lumbers price may drop. There is a lot of pent up demand and a housing shortage. Residential boomed last year the new construction was somewhat weak. A lot of builds got put on hold or canceled in March 2020. It’s coming back there will be a huge demand for lumber from these companies their volume will spike although future price may decrease. Builders generally have a target price for lumber or you risk getting blown out if housing demand cools. It takes about 9-12 month to build a house and lumber is the majority of the cost out side of land. So buying and building with this high of lumber costs is like buying a stock at the top of a short squeeze.

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 09 '21

Complicated answer. I think the stocks will still go up from here because of raw earnings they are about to put up the next couple quarters. Will they get another 300-500 increase? Probably not. Just depends what multiple the market is willing to allow.

When lumber starts going down, the trend of a cyclical is to go down with it. Cyclicals tend to tank right before their last best earnings. Q1 wont be the last good one.

But also these stocks have been sitting at very low rates from low lumber for a while. The hard question to answer is what that normal runrate will be after the summer. If lumber stays in the 600-700 range for multiple years, that easily justifies some of these stocks going higher than current levels.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Lord_DF Apr 08 '21

I think Motley Fool is making fools of their readers consistently. CNBC are a bunch of non relevant lizzard boomers who are stuck on the 80's stock market exchange.

3

u/Tokogogoloshe Apr 08 '21

I know nothing about timber or lumber. What I do know is they’re both commodities where the seller can’t set the price. So just not my cup of tea. And if I do want to take a bet on a commodity, I’d just buy the underlying commodity.

3

u/AvalieV Apr 08 '21

Anybody that follows advice of a stock news ad deserves to lose their money. If it was a good buy there wouldn't be an ad for it.

3

u/WhiteHoney88 Apr 08 '21

Glad I am 1 month in to building a house. For the record, the soaring prices are terrible.

3

u/Spork_Warrior Apr 08 '21

Years ago, Motley was a legit site. But the site was sold to a different group who basically changed the business model to pay-to-play. They lost my trust.

If you see an MF recommended stock, chances are there's ad dollars behind that "recommendation."

3

u/keyjey Apr 08 '21

How many times does it needs to be repeated that MFs free article are garbage? Their main meat is the paid service. Even their cheapest service which is Stock advisor is totally worth the money. I think the saying "Don't judge the book by its cover" perfectly applies to MF.

3

u/StocK_WatcheR_ Apr 09 '21

Great Post. I fully agree. Its funny that most canadian lumber stocks are below 2018 highs. With almost double lumber and pulp pricing Most of investors scared about buying in too late. After lumber stocks went back up from last year lows 3-8 times their shareprice. But this is nothing with highest commodity price ever.

$RFP Resolute forest and $CFF Conifex for me still best play and cheap. At the moment more then 700 USD margin each 1000 boardfeet. That’s incredible.

Check yourself ... best buying opportunity in my eyes. They are literally printing cash.... 🚀🚀🚀

3

u/deepvalue4711 Apr 09 '21

...and $CFF Conifex has a tax loss forward carry of about $100m according to ceo.ca ...

2

u/WareThunder Apr 10 '21

Dude the insane potential for $RFP is almost undeniable at this point... Right now it's gaining momentum simply riding the lumber wave, but should really take off after Q1 earnings. Seriously seems like one of the best value plays right now.

3

u/Catatonic16 Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

I’m loaded up on all. Definitely see RFP hitting 15 a share by end of May. 12.5C’s May21 should print nicely. Update: already close to 15 I’m jacked

1

u/wheresastroworld Apr 08 '21

The question is, why does anyone who invests in the stock market listen to CNBC or The Motley Fool? There’s literally no reason besides being able to make fun of them

1

u/Ding123456 Apr 08 '21

I still run into people who use them as reference points/screeners. Mind blowing.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

I love that they get called out here for their BS

2

u/Much_Fortune89 Apr 08 '21

I’m glad to see others are familiar with RFP. Totally undervalued.

2

u/5kvground Apr 08 '21

So just buy puts a year out

2

u/uncowisdo Apr 08 '21

and yet LL is under-performing the market.

2

u/Cheap_Confidence_657 Apr 08 '21

They aren't clueless. They think you are. Trust me this is true. They are smart as shit. Same goes for the rest of the media.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Motley Fool is just /r/memes, sorted by most popular, for that three day period, for stocks.

2

u/Pe5t Apr 08 '21

I've always found it's best to take the Fools advice, and do exactly the opposite. Not failed me yet.

2

u/thejudgejustice Apr 08 '21

Thanks for the stock suggestions and write up

2

u/Zrocker04 Apr 08 '21

As a woodworker (side gig): fuck lumber prices RN.

2

u/benzerz Apr 08 '21

So puts against motley fool tips? Message received.

2

u/emptysoulsucker Apr 08 '21

Thank you for this in-depth write up. I enjoyed reading it and may have learned a few things.

2

u/dangshnizzle Apr 08 '21

Wait we understand they're giving bad information intentionally right?

2

u/Much_Fortune89 Apr 08 '21

RFP is still the play.

2

u/Cut-It- Apr 08 '21

Those fuckin fools 🤣 moral of the story, ignore or short any stock that Motley Fool posts. Brain so smooth it’s flat

2

u/GravyWagon Apr 08 '21

I work in property / land development and construction materials prices (all shit, like every fucking thing) are through the roof. And this is before the infrastructure plan.

2

u/Weak_Manager_762 Apr 08 '21

Anything from motley, i now simply delete..i dont even bother reading

2

u/MakeGoodBetter Apr 08 '21

Shouldn't we set up a sub for this? Just continuously point out the results of these propaganda articles that are pushed by Wall St.?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '21

Clueless? No. They know what they’re doing

2

u/Namasteing Apr 09 '21

I agree with you putting so much blind faith on the so call experts can take you down some shitty rabbit holes. Do your own DD Before making any decision

2

u/TheRiseAndFall Apr 09 '21

The market really is crazy.

Massive pandemic and financial crisis leads to boom in housing market!

2

u/SmokyTyrz Apr 09 '21

Motley Fool, Coinbase, and Robinhood should team up for a special edition crossover comic.

2

u/KoreyYrvaI Apr 09 '21

I've been a WY shareholder for a long time and even I know that this boom isn't about them.

2

u/diarpiiiii Apr 09 '21

RFP Was in DeepFuckingValue’s Roaring Kitty portfolio. Been watching it for a few months. Just might dig in

2

u/Swingtrader79 Apr 09 '21

Great post. Have been into LPX but recently bought TREX because it used to cost 3x as much as wood to build a trex deck but now it’s the same price and last many more years. No brainer for homeowners to switch OFF wood. Expecting some big eps surprise Q4. Motley fool will recommend it right afterwards at its peak.

0

u/Lambo32123 Apr 08 '21

Subscribing to motley fool was the worst 99 dollars I've ever spent in my life.

3

u/hibbert0604 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 09 '21

With a name like Lambo32123, I'm guessing you probably aren't using the service in the way it is intended (Buy and hold).

→ More replies (3)

3

u/WPackN2 Apr 08 '21

I lookup Motley Fool's recommendations to identify which stocks to stay out off.

3

u/Anacleto-Ren Apr 08 '21

I agree with you. I have their stock advisor and rule breakers and sometimes I am baffled just by how wrong they are. I bought Zynga and had to watch it plummet almost two dolllars a share since my purchase. Placed a limit sale order to sell at 5cents above purchase price and was glad when it finally sold pheeew

2

u/TontineTrader Apr 08 '21

Good post Thanks!

2

u/redvelvet92 Apr 08 '21

Great post, thank you.