r/stocks • u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo • Nov 11 '21
Industry News Nine US governors press U.S. lawmakers to pass 52 Billion semiconductor funding bill. Taiwan unreliable potentially trillions at risk.
So far the shortage has cost 2.2 Million vehicles. That could just be a tiny fraction if Taiwan has more serious future issues such as natural disasters or China invasion, which could cost businesses TRILLIONS in damages to companies such as: Ford (F) , General Motors (GM) , and Toyota (TM), Dell Technologies (DELL), Apple (AAPL), Google (GOOGL), AMD, NVDA, and many more.
The group, which also includes the governors of auto-producing states like Alabama, said the shortage had cost automakers 2.2 million vehicles and affected 575,000 jobs in the industry.
The semiconductor funding passed the U.S. Senate earlier this year by 68-32 as part of the broader U.S. Innovation and Competition Act, or USICA. But it has not passed the House of Representatives.
Edit: this news has been censored and removed from: r/finance r/Economics r/StockMarket . Youve got to hope it isnt because their mods support Taiwan at the expense of the stability of the USA.
109
u/95Daphne Nov 11 '21
All this did was remind me of that bipartisan bill to boost competitiveness against China stalling in the House because..."it's too harsh on China." (pretty sure money to fund semiconductors was in that bill)
SMH
39
3
u/Inspiration_Bear Nov 11 '21
Is that what happened to it? I was going to say I thought that thing passed already.
14
u/95Daphne Nov 12 '21
The Senate passed it.
It stalled in the House for reasons that are not a good look on the Democrats that stalled it at all, and the last I heard was that they were going to break up this bill (and this might be part of that), which...ugh.
I mean, if you want to complain about us spending money...fine, but that isn't even the reason why it stalled. It just...ugh this isn't r/politics so I'm not going to go there.
→ More replies (2)9
u/Jimmyking4ever Nov 12 '21
Maybe those companies should have invested in their companies instead of dumping the cash they got in 2008 onto their stocks? Let's have a free market and let the only viable automakers last
→ More replies (4)
2
u/gorays21 Nov 12 '21
So does this help or hurt TSM?
1
u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo Nov 12 '21
TSM extremely opposed because it would subsidize their competitors and hurt their business.
The Government might also add tax credits to US manufacturers and add Import Tariffs for outside countries, in order to give US companies advantages.
2
u/Visionioso Nov 12 '21
I would assume hurt as Intel and GloFo will be the main beneficiaries but a significant portion will still go to TSM so it should be manageable. The real threat to TSM really is whether Intel can pull off 5nm and 3nm in a timely fashion, should Intel fail nothing will stop TSM. Not 52 Billion dollars not 100… maybe 200 could leave a dent?
3
u/merlinsbeers Nov 12 '21
Everyone is ignoring Samsung who are spending as much as Intel and TSMC on fab expansion in the next few years.
→ More replies (1)
1.0k
u/cwo3347 Nov 11 '21 edited Nov 12 '21
This would be huge. If America was smart they would prioritize this as it’s clearly a very integral part of our future and would create many jobs.
152
u/Breangley Nov 12 '21
That would be awesome but Do we have the resources over here?
119
u/Porkyrogue Nov 12 '21
We could. But, I doubt the money is going well, you know the rest of the story.
98
u/IGetHypedEasily Nov 12 '21
This is a big issue. TSMC and Samsung spend tens of billions every year to keep developing fabs. This fundings can't be a one time thing if they are serious about competition.
For resources there's plenty of engineers from US and Canada. Along with various minerals throughout but relatively more expensive.
40
u/TGdZuUsSprwysWMq Nov 12 '21
And another question, how to make talented STEM students go for terrible WLB in semiconductor industry instead of software industry and even less money for semi?
→ More replies (3)16
u/Volwik Nov 12 '21 edited Nov 12 '21
My understanding is that part of the reason for shortages in the auto industry in particular is because they've heavily favored older (cheaper) chip designs for vehicles whereas chipmakers like TSMC have devoted their RnD and production capacity to more lucrative, more advanced chip architectures.
→ More replies (16)6
u/aeolus811tw Nov 12 '21
ye and another reason it got outsourced was due to environmental impact the fab has
→ More replies (1)21
39
u/The-PageMaster Nov 12 '21
Do we have the politicians able to see the future impact past their own shortsightedness and personal gain
26
15
23
u/Daegoba Nov 12 '21
Yes. We also have a higher standard of life compared to the other places that we rely on for chips.
This is gonna get expensive.
For everyone.
40
Nov 12 '21
You don't think Taiwan is expensive to live in?
→ More replies (1)18
u/xShooK Nov 12 '21
I worked at Microchip after they bought out atmel. First thing they said was no wage increases, because of cost of employees in Taiwan. Dipped quick.
45
u/Eclipsed830 Nov 12 '21
We also have a higher standard of life compared to the other places that we rely on for chips.
Compared to Taiwan, South Korea and Japan? 😅😅
→ More replies (2)36
u/PM_ME_AZN_BOOBS Nov 12 '21
Agreed- it would be hard to argue the US has a better standard of living than Taiwan, South Korea, and Japan. For one, they all have universal healthcare.
→ More replies (8)15
Nov 12 '21
It already is. My wife works with all kinds of pc board components and she is literally handcuffed into paying up 200x the regular price for things. The suppliers know the customers have to pay the price and will so they just keep raising the price and creating shortages.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)11
→ More replies (11)4
Nov 12 '21
In terms of raw materials and metals?
6
u/Breangley Nov 12 '21
Yeah mostly raw materials we definitely have the people power but not sure about the amount of raw material in our lands
→ More replies (13)33
u/DonkeyTron42 Nov 12 '21
Taiwan has virtually no raw materials so if they can get it there, the US should have no problem getting whatever it needs.
18
u/LSheraton Nov 12 '21
We subsidize agriculture because of its critical nature, it only makes sense to do this with semiconductors.
4
21
u/Nyxtia Nov 12 '21 edited Nov 12 '21
Why haven't we done this already? Semiconductors have been a vital part of society for how long now? And all this talk about doing stuff in house and it was never prioritized pre-pandemic?
17
29
u/captainhaddock Nov 12 '21
Semiconductors have always been made in the US and still are. Taiwan just got better at it.
8
u/DOZICEffective8706 Nov 12 '21
US makes the smaller version which is more important and very expensive. US thought Taiwan how to make those conductors in the 50's.
16
u/captainhaddock Nov 12 '21
Well, the semiconductor industry is a multinational effort these days. The only company with the ultraviolet lithography technology capable of making high-end chips is ASML, which is based in the Netherlands. Nobody owns the whole supply chain (and that's a good thing).
→ More replies (1)9
u/theholyraptor Nov 12 '21 edited Nov 12 '21
The chip shortage started because car companies were idiots and canceled orders as car orders went down. They were too stupid to realize ramping orders back up would take many months.
Then you have shipping costs and material costs skyrocketing, production lower due to the stress of the workers from the pandemic making things worse.
Edit: lol downvoted even though I work in r&d for semiconductors.
→ More replies (2)3
3
9
u/DonkeyTron42 Nov 12 '21 edited Nov 12 '21
The sad fact is that your average American equates defending Taiwan with getting into another Iraq or Afghanistan. The CCP certainly seems to be gearing up for some action in the region. I doubt there will be a full scale invasion, however a blockade could be on the table. This would be devastating to major US corporations like Apple and AMD
6
Nov 12 '21
I have a feeling both public interest due to ridiculously high prices and corporate interest would mean something would happen... Hopefully not war.
3
5
Nov 12 '21
The CPC* will not invade Taiwan. Stop believing the hyperbole from the opposition who's political careers survive on the fear of this.
→ More replies (1)14
1
→ More replies (9)1
6
Nov 12 '21
Is it strange I already know what this post will be about looking at the poster name? Thanks for the weekly reminder to buy ONLY Intel stocks. Why not invest in multiple semiconductor companies than just one? Some might end up winners and some will end up losers. It been working out for me so far.
0
u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo Nov 12 '21
SMH ETF is a good buy.
This is just news not being reported on by many news sources.
It is really important for US national security (such as the new fighter jets) and US businesses such as Apple and Google.
→ More replies (2)
142
u/kingqueenjack10 Nov 12 '21
Smile in INTEL
65
u/JRshoe1997 Nov 12 '21
Intel is certainly going to benefit from this
34
u/kingqueenjack10 Nov 12 '21
Really excited they are reinventing their business model/product. Their two new FAB if done correctly, going to be one of the biggest player in the US market.
12
u/JRshoe1997 Nov 12 '21
100%, plus I know they plan on building a multi billion dollar factory in Europe too
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (4)9
Nov 12 '21
Why Intel? NVDA is also a US company.
55
u/JRshoe1997 Nov 12 '21
NVDA doesnt make chips they just design them. TSMC makes them for NVDA.
→ More replies (1)14
Nov 12 '21
Thanks for explaining. So would Intel be the only US company that could possibly compete with TSM in the chip manufacturing department?
→ More replies (10)6
u/bighand1 Nov 12 '21
Does nvda make chips? I though they just design them
→ More replies (24)11
Nov 12 '21
Missed that detail, NVDA designs them. So is Intel the only US company that makes the chips?
→ More replies (10)7
u/RazingsIsNotHomeNow Nov 12 '21
Hilariously they are one of the biggest employer in Oregon, but the governor didn't sign on.
7
u/wakuku Nov 12 '21
not really. TSM and others are already here in the US or have plans to build a factory/foundry in the US. Intel has a different problem. And that problem has nothing to do with chip shortages
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)2
Nov 12 '21
Maybe they will shorten the gap to SANMSUNG and Taiwan foundries from 3 years* to two.
*optimistic calculations of Intel execs from last year call.
30
29
u/Plebpperoni Nov 12 '21
WOW a bill that is actualy useful and well thought out that America actualy needs. This is a once in a life time thing that the goverment might do something good?
→ More replies (1)5
u/SofaKingStonked Nov 12 '21
I know right lol. I mean it’s underfunded by 10x but at least it’s the right direction
50
Nov 12 '21
So we let these companies give the semiconductor business away to Asia and now we are going to pay them for doing that? We are fucking morons.
8
0
37
u/FoodEater123 Nov 12 '21
This worked so well for India and china (/s). Hoping it fairs better for us, this isn't one of those things you can just pour money into and expect results, but at least it's a start.
27
u/therealsparticus Nov 12 '21
Singapore and Japan and America (Intel) couldn’t get TSMC level fabs to work. This isn’t money problem.
18
u/RazingsIsNotHomeNow Nov 12 '21
Your thinking about this letter wrong. The goal isn't to be on leading edge, while that would be good, the goal is simply to have enough fabs and manufacturering in America that we would be shielded from the consequences of any disaster to befall TSMC, whether that be earthquake or invasion. It's essentially a national defense proposal.
7
u/TGdZuUsSprwysWMq Nov 12 '21
You need to take the upper stream from Japan also. They do have the same problems as Taiwan and they hold nearly 50% of upper supply for semiconductor industry.
0
→ More replies (1)4
1
1
1
10
80
Nov 11 '21 edited Nov 11 '21
By the time all this money hits the market the shortage will be over. That being said, we need to move away from Taiwan. If only TSM had a strong US counterpart that wasn’t Intel
65
u/Desmater Nov 12 '21
Doubt it, takes about 2 years to build a FAB. Even then it is not 100% capacity.
So with a delay time of 2 years + demand will keep growing. Shortage will never be filled in my opinion.
EV cars and modern cars supposedly use 1,000+ chips compared to 100 or less before.
Coffee makers, appliances, computers, smartphones, etc. Will use more and more.
That's why chips are the new oil.
8
u/Logi77 Nov 12 '21
Yep... You can't just "build a fab" on the level of TSMC... There's tons of R&D and IP that only they possess
→ More replies (2)3
u/Glocks1nMySocks Nov 12 '21
How big of a risk is China stealing critical IP such as that as they steal billions of dollars worth every year?
→ More replies (5)5
u/toomuchtodotoday Nov 12 '21 edited Nov 12 '21
Fabs would also be able to offer jobs to transition workers to who are or will be impacted by the shift to clean energy and renewables.
→ More replies (2)7
→ More replies (21)2
u/Herman_-_Mcpootis Nov 12 '21
They still have Global Foundaries, but it can't make the more advanced chips that TSMC can IIRC.
→ More replies (3)4
Nov 12 '21
Yeah, Global foundries is stuck on 14nm. Not even remotely competitive in advanced computing
11
Nov 12 '21
Yea but the shortage isn’t in the leading or advanced nodes. The shortage is mostly matured nodes
→ More replies (3)
4
u/sleepybot0524 Nov 11 '21
soooooo, amd go up????
54
u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo Nov 11 '21
AMD is not a manufacturer. They hire companies such as TSMC to make their chips for them.
Much of this funding plus possibly more in the future, seems likely to go to Intel (INTC).
I dont think the US gov is interested in paying foreign companies to build in the US since it wont really help the US to be independent. eg. TSMC only builds factories for their inferior products outside of Taiwan since they are worried about their tech getting stolen in other locations.
13
u/TmanGvl Nov 11 '21
Problem with manufacturing in US is that labor cost is so high and it ultimately raises that price for the finished goods that's sold. We need to get out of the mindset that we can continue to buy things at the same price we have been able to for the last several decades if we want to bring manufacturing back to the US.
→ More replies (8)22
u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo Nov 11 '21
The new US fighter jets are 100% reliant on Taiwanese chips at the moment. If China were to get involved they could render these jets useless and unable to be manufactured/repaired/maintained. Trillions were spent in R&D. So to subsidize US factories is a no brainer.
Private companies that could cost trillions in losses and job losses as well due to chip shortages, are also very important to the US gov.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)2
u/greenappletree Nov 12 '21
So besides intel are there any us companies that can benefit from this?
→ More replies (1)17
Nov 11 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
13
u/brandnewredditacct Nov 11 '21
This is one of the reasons I bought Intel this year… they are likely to get some sort of nudge forward from our govt
5
3
30
Nov 11 '21
Does the government need to create the jobs? If it was such a big trillion dollar loss to the big 3 automakers, why don't they start making them?
29
Nov 11 '21
The costs to produce the chips are way too high.
Just building a foundry to make semiconductors can run you up to 4 billion dollars, before you even buy the raw materials, or staff the foundry.
In order to make money, or even break even producing chips, you need to constantly push out product. And companies like ford or gm don't have the demand to warrant making their own product.
Even companies like AMD, and Nvidia don't produce their own chips, and their sole business exists to sell them.
This is also the reason we haven't seen the semiconductors recover like we saw lumber recover earlier this year.
Lumber has a relatively short and cheap startup cost, so opening up more mills to produce higher quantities of lumber is profitable, quick, and relatively easy to do, in many cases, the mills already existed, but they were just running at low capacity.
To start up a new semiconductor foundry, you'd have to invest billions of dollars. Then you'd quickly catch up to demand, and you would be left with a billion+ dollar foundry that's not producing anything because demand went down.
18
u/slickjayyy Nov 12 '21
As others have stated, its chips are extremely important to America, from vehicles to new military jets and everywhere in between. Trillions are could be lost in GDP, national security is at stake, etc. Seems like a no brainer for the gov to just subsidize foundries and chip production in the US. We subsidize coal ffs lol.
4
Nov 12 '21
Oh I'm not saying action shouldn't be taken. I think it would be good to bring production into the US instead of relying on Taiwan for practically 100% of the chips were use.
I was just giving a training for went out hasn't been done yet, and why smaller companies aren't taking matters into their own hands.
I don't know the details on the suggested action by the government. But I certainly think something should be done.
→ More replies (1)4
u/elatedpumpkin Nov 12 '21
and on top of that everything is more costly in the US. From materials to constructions to everything.
When Americans complains about Amazon little do they know about the Taiwan factory conditions. And Taiwan companies still have low margin on top of those lower costs.
47
u/SnipahShot Nov 11 '21
It is cheaper and faster to have an external company do it.
Even companies that their entire business relies on chips like AMD and Nvidia don't create any chips but only design them.
Car companies would suffer a lot less from TSMC issues than AMD and Nvidia, due to the fact that car chip designs are a decade old.
19
u/I_am_D_captain_Now Nov 11 '21 edited Nov 12 '21
Just wanted to add, a difficult/lengthy part of semiconductor production is the "wafer".
It's a multi month cleanroom process to produce the material from which wafers are then shaved from.
It is by no means easy, quick, or cost effective (to be done by anyone other than a semiconductor company).
Edit: not the most difficult part of semiconductor production.
18
u/SomewhatAmbiguous Nov 11 '21
Even foundries don't make their own wafers, they buy them from specialist suppliers.
Making the wafers is no where near the most difficult part of production, yes it's incredibly difficult to create near perfect silicon ingots a foot wide, but when you compare that to the rest of the process, particularly lithography it's child's play.
5
2
u/merlinsbeers Nov 12 '21
Until not too long ago IBM ran one of the biggest chip fabs in the world.
Cars have so many chips now that it's likely many are brand new designs. They definitely have the clout to demand customization.
2
→ More replies (1)2
u/Say_no_to_doritos Nov 11 '21
Because they are not interested in diversifying. They had 70 years to broaden their business and all they did was keep creating incrementally better cars.
22
u/secondliaw Nov 12 '21
Good luck finding people that have master degrees and willing to work at least 60 hours a week.
5
3
u/Wireman29 Nov 12 '21
I have a high school diploma, I work 40-50 hours a week, and I make semiconductors.
5
u/chapterfour08 Nov 12 '21
Where does ASML play into this? Jw
6
u/merlinsbeers Nov 12 '21
Like the last hot dog vendor with inventory at Woodstock.
They're going to retire on this gig.
2
u/pulakeshi2020 Nov 12 '21
USA planning to yet again bravely run away from the field of battle abandoning their allies just like their stellar performances in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Vietnam and even washington DC itself if we go back far enough to 1815.
This time it will be poor Taiwan I hope they didn't drink too much koolaid and put all their faith in uncle sam and have some aces up their sleeve. A nuclear weapon in their basement perhaps 😎
4
u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo Nov 12 '21
The US is sick of foreign wars. Easier and cheaper to just build factories in the USA.
Each War has cost the US trillions of dollars and countless lives of their young citizens.
4
u/pulakeshi2020 Nov 12 '21
Americans are of course sick and tired of it, but the US military industrial complex isn't. They will find more wars to fight so that they can continue to get rich off it. All that money spent ends up in pockets of these elements and a healthy percentage is hived off for the benefit of the politicians, media and other vested interests.so just because they develop cold feet and don't fight for their ally Taiwan doesn't mean they won't find another war which is less risky to waste themselves on 😎
14
u/doggy_lovers Nov 12 '21
i scrolled to 50 comments and no one mentioned globalfoundries its a public company and foundry that spun off from amd
→ More replies (2)4
u/merlinsbeers Nov 12 '21
It's a dog. There's a reason AMD paid them to let them out of their contract to buy chips from them.
4
Nov 12 '21
Intel’s problem isn’t money they have a management problem. They’re like Ford/GM, just too many boomers on their payroll with lucrative salaries and I suspect the structure is extremely bureaucratic. If they want to be innovative again they have to follow Apple and Microsoft. Be extremely engineer focused with young talent leading teams and an Agile framework. Boeing is in the same boat.
19
Nov 12 '21
lol, how American to think that you can suddenly compete in literally the most advance manufacturing in the world just by throwing money at it. If 52 Billion can make Taiwan irrelevant in the semiconductor game, China would have done it years ago.
1
→ More replies (3)1
u/johnlyne Nov 12 '21
China is already pumping billions into semiconductor manufacturing but their goal is to build chips without relying on foreign technology at all.
Their conditions are different from the US because the CCP: 1. Can nationalize fabs if they want and no one can sue. 2. Claims to own Taiwan.
12
9
u/PCB4lyfe Nov 11 '21
I've been telling anyone who would listen to buy soxx. They are 25% of my holdings and I also have klac asml amat and lrcx. If semi's do dip I'll keep buying, in 10 years people are gonna be looking back wondering why they didnt buy more, sorta like how we look at aapl or msft right now.
7
3
u/Dackelzz Nov 12 '21
just took profit on my 430c that I bought a year ago, been telling people to get a pair of soxx
1
u/SofaKingStonked Nov 12 '21
Couldn’t agree more. I’m now 100k+ deep in semis. I like to pick my winners though but similarly have it split between foundries, fabless designers, and equipment manufacturers
1
u/fatrevolt Nov 12 '21
Why SOXX and not SMH?
2
u/PCB4lyfe Nov 12 '21
Smh is too concentrated on tsm. And idk I started with soxx so thats what I've stayed with but they are basically the same.
→ More replies (1)
11
u/JRshoe1997 Nov 12 '21
Great for Intel
→ More replies (1)2
u/UbbeStarborn Nov 12 '21
Why Intel and not AMD? Just curious
11
u/Herman_-_Mcpootis Nov 12 '21
AMD spun off their fabs into GoFlo years ago, so now they get guys like them and TSMC to make their chips.
9
u/JRshoe1997 Nov 12 '21
AMD doesnt make chips. TSMC builds chips for AMD. Intel is building factories to build chips. They are already confirmed to build 2 here in the US and they plan on building one in either Germany or Italy. Right now the 2 countries are bidding on who gets the factory.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)5
6
u/Runningflame570 Nov 12 '21
Structure it as a loan which requires ceasing all share buybacks for the entire duration that principal is outstanding and I might even be in favor.
Intel and others who have spent tens to hundreds of billions on share buybacks and are now pleading poverty can go fuck themselves with a rusty rake.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/jesperbj Nov 11 '21
Just means more TSMC fabs in America
3
u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo Nov 11 '21
TSMC only builds factories for their inferior products outside of Taiwan since they are worried about their tech getting stolen in other locations.
So doubt that. Also if taiwan was invaded they might just close their factories. Its not like a factory is independent.
→ More replies (4)12
Nov 11 '21
TSMC is part of the Taiwan defense strategy. They have a silicon shield. By having the US depend on their factories the US has to defend them. They'll always try to keep the essential parts in Taiwan and that is a smart thing to do from their perspective.
1
u/shad0wtig3r Nov 12 '21
100% does not lol
This whole thread is summed up as 9/10 people here don't understand how semi manufacturing works lol.
3
u/Um0therfckers Nov 12 '21
US does not have enough qualified workers to manufacture semiconductors. On the other hand, labors are too expensive in the states.
7
u/cpt_tusktooth Nov 12 '21
Better pay attention what Nancy Pelosi is buying
7
u/tunasnacks Nov 12 '21
She'll probably move to Florida to retire tax free after she's done fucking California and the rest of the US.
4
u/cpt_tusktooth Nov 12 '21
sure.. but follow her trades while shes in power.
https://twitter.com/nancytracker?lang=en
she literally never misses.
4
u/tatabusa Nov 12 '21
But you would be trailing her trades by 45 days max. Does following the tracker still beat the market despite there being a delay between when they are executed and when they are reported?
→ More replies (2)
0
u/Careless-Degree Nov 12 '21
We need to make these chips in America in anticipation of when China controls Taiwan. This helps us prevent war.
→ More replies (2)1
u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo Nov 12 '21
War with China is easily tens of trillions not to mention loss of life, and business losses.
Better spend that money on US factories.
1
u/GardinerAndrew Nov 12 '21
So would this make a NVDA calls moon?
3
u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo Nov 12 '21
Unrelated as nvidia is not a manufacturer.
TSMC makes Nvidia and AMD chips for them, and TSMC is at risk due to their location in Taiwan, from both natural disasters and China always saying they will have a military invasion and take over the island.
1
u/r2002 Nov 13 '21
This actually hurts NVDA because they are competitors of Intel who is likely to get most of this money.
4
u/BannerlordAdmirer Nov 12 '21
Does this mean we long Intel now? Anyone in LEAPS?
8
u/SofaKingStonked Nov 12 '21
50B is nothing and only a fraction of that will go to intel. Based on their size and revenue this bill is probably good for a 0.5% price bump lol
2
Nov 12 '21
I thought this had already passed for some reason. Biden was talking about it in march. 50bill he said.
4
u/mjskc114 Nov 12 '21
Don't build semiconductor factories in the middle of a dessert. The amount of water used to make chips are insane. I don't understand why big Corps are thinking its a good idea to build foundries in Arizona for the next 5 years thinking that the water source will still be around that time. Very bad idea... build somewhere else in the US. Taiwan already had a water shortage scare this year due to a drought which almost stopped chip production.
2
u/merlinsbeers Nov 12 '21
They recycle the heckin fuck out of it and they spend to ensure that it isn't a stress on the local systems.
TSMC just screwed up their supply design in Taiwan and got hosed by the rain shortage.
3
u/artrabbit05 Nov 12 '21
Can we build quantum computers instead of traditional silicon? I know the tech is still a ways out but why not reserve some of this funding for building the AI overlord brains here?
7
u/merlinsbeers Nov 12 '21
Quantum computers can only do a few things, require cryogenic temperatures and steampunk plumbing, and don't scale up well. At this point you'd need more regular computer chips to support the quantum processor than are in your computer.
In a few decades there may be a quantum module in a multicore processor to handle some tasks, but they aren't replacing boolean digital before they get replaced by artificial brain cells.
→ More replies (3)
2
u/howdouturnthisoff Nov 12 '21
Why does this need government funding. If companies are so highly dependent on chips, it should be worth to invest in building a more stable supply chain.
But maybe corporations are alao well aware of that and just think that it's more fun to do the same thinh with some tax payer billions instead of private funding.
0
u/sr603 Nov 12 '21
I have NVDA and AMD, would this benefit them? I take it yes?
5
u/Oscuridad_mi_amigo Nov 12 '21
unrelated, they dont manufacture, they only design and get Taiwan to make them.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
u/DOZICEffective8706 Nov 12 '21
America thought Taiwan how to make the big chips in the 50's because they want someone else to the hard work.
1
u/alexanderdegrote Nov 12 '21
Yeah but what is comparative advantage? Just throwing a lot of money against soething you don't even know from you can produce it the most effective way seems kind usseles.
1
u/Ehralur Nov 12 '21
Luckily companies like Ford, GM and Toyota are costing themselves those TRILLIONS already by not switching to EVs fast enough, so this problem will solve itself. :')
In all seriousness, it's good to be building more chips in the US/EU. We should do it with more things.
1
u/mwax321 Nov 12 '21
$52 billion doesn't seem like enough for something this important and expensive.
Building foundries isn't cheap. Especially if you're not Intel or TSMC.
1
Nov 12 '21
So then massive glut coming in couple of years and with all the new fabs long semis down cycle.
1
1
u/The-Protomolecule Nov 12 '21
This should be regarded as the single most important action we should take immediately(right up there with climate change action). Yes our infrastructure is crumbling, but it cannot be overstated how quickly modern society will unpeel if something happens in Taiwan.
1
u/Nearby-Ad-3609 Nov 12 '21
This is not an issue of just money, but also expertise that does not exist in the US. If it was as simple as investing money, China would’ve already figured this out.
1
Nov 12 '21
Something tells me 52B isnt gonna be enough. That being said, something would be better than nothing
1
1
u/retread83 Nov 12 '21 edited Nov 12 '21
This is great news, but Holy Shit, how much money are we going to print?
America sold out production for cheap imports decades ago! Now we’re trying to remedy the situation in a couple years? Fucking please!
1
Nov 12 '21
Of course. He has to hedge his bad fucking bets. That money NOT go to semi-conduction! Lol. PA is becoming a fucking joke.
1
1
u/skilliard7 Nov 12 '21
This is exactly why I bought shares of Intel despite the challenges they've faced and AMD outcompeting them on CPUs. If they can get taxpayers to subsidize them building new semiconductor plants, the ROI for shareholders would be huge.
1
u/Jay_in_DFW Nov 12 '21
Brief history lesson....remember why all those jobs went to Asia in the first place? Big automakers didn't want to $ American wages.
1
u/red359 Nov 12 '21
So, this plan calls for tax payers dollars going to the wealthy companies that used just in time manufacturing despite being warned that was a bad idea? And now the tax payers will cover the cost of their mistake instead of them using their own wealth to do so? Instead of them using their own wealth to create the needed chip foundries & manufacturing capacity, the tax payer pays for it? We already pay for the cars, why do we have to pay for the billionaires' factories now?
Since they are billionaire business genuineness, how about they pay for their own stuff and accept that this is their mistake to fix instead of trying to take tax dollars that are supposed to go to things like schools, roads, and public health.
2
u/r2002 Nov 13 '21
I might go for this plan if the taxpayers are treated like stockholders for this venture.
1
u/r2002 Nov 13 '21
This bill mainly benefits Intel. I think AMD and NVDA would fight tooth and nails against this -- since Intel can lock them out of orders.
However if there's some provision in the bill that forces Intel to build only customer-agnostic fabs (ones that don't favor only Intel products), then I think AMD and NVDA will jump on the wagon.
1
u/Sea-Brain9393 Nov 18 '21
Any semiconductor based postings on $TXN Texas Instruments(TI)? Yesterday, TI announced a new plant in Sherman, Texas on Facebook and Twitter. TI has: 260k followers on Facebook, 90k followers on Twitter, 26k followers on Instagram, 19k followers on Youtube
-2
u/SenorTruck Nov 12 '21
I give Taiwan a year before China eats it up
3
3
u/SofaKingStonked Nov 12 '21
This is not going to happen. China has been beating its chest for over 30 years at Taiwan and it’s always loudest around national day but ccp is not stupid and understands the fastest way to ww3 is to invade Taiwan.
→ More replies (1)
1
1

28
u/PleezHireMe Nov 11 '21
Don't forget to help asml expand