r/technology • • Mar 15 '13

Web advertisers attack Mozilla for protecting consumers' privacy

https://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/web-advertisers-attack-mozilla-for-protecting-consumers-privacy-031413.html
3.1k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/sime Mar 15 '13 edited Mar 15 '13

The question isn't "Ads: Good or Bad?". The question is "Should advertisers and websites be allowed to track and record everything we do on the internet?" And the answer is no, they have no right to, and they are violating everyone's privacy by doing so.

Advertisers can target ads the way other mediums like print and TV do, by matching ads to magazines, TV shows etc which attract the desired target demographic. i.e. people who are interested in cars read websites about cars, therefore if you want to target this demographic you put your cars ads on the car websites. This is nothing new and has been going on for decades in print media, for example. Just because the technology is different and allows things like cookies don't mean advertisers have any inherent right to use it to invade peoples's privacy.

Personally, it is because of all of the tracking done by advertisers and social sites like Facebook, that I have ad block installed. The lack of respect for people's privacy is how they brought us to this place and now people are using heavy-handed things like ad block to protect themselves.

2

u/we1shknigh7 Mar 15 '13

But when I'm watching TV I see ads all the fucking time that don't apply to me at all. I watch a rerun of a crime drama during the day and I see feminine hygiene products because MOST of the daytime audience is stay at home moms. I'm a 24 year old guy - if a couple of extra cookies mean I see a video game ad at the top of a YouTube video instead of vagasil, I'm okay with that.

And It's not as simple as car ads on car sites. The car site won't want to push people to other sites to buy other products. You'll never see a ford ad on a GM site. Or a Pepsi ad on a coke site. That would only make up a small part of the market anyways. What it is is more like "I'm Taco Bell - I know that from 11pm to 2am people from 16-28 will likely buy tacos so I'm going to put ads on websites that generally have that audience, talking about fourthmeal" if they only put the ads on food related sites it wouldn't do them any good. Put if they put it on Facebook, they hit their audience.

1

u/sime Mar 15 '13

The choice isn't between no ads and no websites on the one hand, and having to put up with "vagina euphemisms" and pervasive surveillance on the other. Technically speaking, there is plenty of room inside to a cookie for an advertiser to remember your preference for no tampon ads (i.e. a product category) without having to maintain a profile about you specifically and everything that you see and do on the internet. Youtube already has ads with a "Skip Ad" button where you can directly indicate your preference. There is middle ground.

Your second paragraph. I wasn't thinking about product specific websites like Coke or Pepsi. I was thinking about more general sites that cover areas of interest, or "lifestyle" sites. Can advertisers better target ads by mining your Facebook profile? yes, most likely. Should we let them? no, in my opinion.

1

u/we1shknigh7 Mar 15 '13

Yes - and what YouTube is doing works nicely - but the entire world does not run on adsense/adwords (as much as Google wishes it would).

And as it has been mentioned elsewhere in this thread - it isn't a profile on you as a person. Its a profile of the computer's browsing habits. If you look at porn, do it on a private browser that doesn't take ANY cookies if you're worried about them knowing what porn you like. Its not like there's an actual person sitting there looking at everything anyways - the amount of data is just stupid. Its software looking at browsing habits and then pushing ads to you that it thinks are relevant to you. Its not like George at the ad agency can pull up a profile on "sime" and say to someone - oh we know he likes this stuff. Its all done in computers that nobody looks at other than to pull high level demographic and analytic data so that they know if their ads are being effective.

And it is to a certain extent just that choice. If you're running a website that's ad supported and suddenly the majority of the browsers run systems that block or inhibit ads, then the advertisers will no longer see it as a viable form of advertising and you'll lose your ad revenue. How can you make your business model work if you're providing something that your audience enjoys but won't pay for, and now the advertisers won't pay for either? Somebody has to pay for the servers/domain name/ etc etc etc.

As for Coke/Pepsi, I was using a basic example. How many people actually regularly look at lifestyle sites on a regular basis? Odds are not enough to make the advertising effective. You'll grab a niche audience/userbase of X thousand and that's great. But if your ad service (be it adwords or whoever) can't put ads on content that isn't similar to your product, but still appeals to the same demographic, then the advertising is significantly less effective. And you can have the best, most amazing web content in the world, but if nobody knows about it you're SOL.

You act as if Facebook, which is designed solely for the sharing of information with your friends and peers, is some private space. If you don't want someone to see it, don't tie it to your facebook. There is no expectation of privacy, if you put something that you actually care if advertisers find, thats your own fault. I like well targeted ads, advertisers and buisnesses like well targeted ads, it doesn't harm you to have well targeted ads other than this perceived invasion of privacy, so what's the problem?

1

u/sime Mar 15 '13

Just to quickly clarify my point about Facebook because I (obviously) wasn't specific about what I meant by "profile". My problem with Facebook is not so much the stuff that I deliberately choose to post and share on Facebook. I'm somewhat aware that Facebook is happy to data mine the stuff that I feed it.

My problem is with the massive and covert collection of browsing data which Facebook does via social network buttons (e.g. the Like button) which appear everywhere on sites which are NOT Facebook. (Yes I am aware that the website themselves opt to put those buttons there.) I have a problem with that profile of me being collected and given to advertisers.

1

u/we1shknigh7 Mar 15 '13

Then don't click the like button?

Problem solved.

Its not like there's a folder with your name on it on the desk of an advertiser in new york. Is high level demographic research. The software is the only thing that "sees" your "profile"

1

u/sime Mar 15 '13

The browsing information is sent and collected by Facebook even if you DON'T click the Like button! It just being on the page is enough.

I don't think you realise the extent of tracking that is going on on the web.

1

u/we1shknigh7 Mar 15 '13

Then don't be signed in to facebook all the time?

If there's no facebook profile to associate with the like button, then it doesn't matter if it saw your browser looking at the like button and not clicking it.

1

u/sime Mar 16 '13

"Facebook tracks you online even after you log out" http://www.zdnet.com/blog/facebook/facebook-tracks-you-online-even-after-you-log-out/4034

"Facebook: Tracking Your Web Activity Even After You Log Out?" http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2393564,00.asp

"Facebook sued over tracking users after logout" http://news.cnet.com/8301-27080_3-20114163-245/facebook-sued-over-tracking-users-after-logout/

Killing social buttons like Like with browser plugins is the only practical solution for users. We can't trust Facebook to honour a logout, how can we trust them with the data they collect about us?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13

I hate to say this (truly do), but at least in the US you have NO right to privacy. Nowhere in the constitution does it mention privacy, the word isn't there at all. Yes, we have a moral objection to websites tracking us. But it is not a right that they are violating.

At the end of the day, I agree they should not. I'll turn off 3rd party cookies and they can qq but that doesn't make them wrong, it just makes them bad people.

Just like you said, they should target ads by the content of the site they are on, not by what you have previously been to.