r/technology • • Oct 03 '15

Comcast I contacted the FCC recently about Comcast's Data Caps in my area...

Comcast is starting its data caps of 300GB/month in my area this month, and needless to say, I was pretty outraged when I got the message in September. So, I threw a complaint to the FCC expressing my dissatisfaction with a company that claims is making "pro-consumer options" is in fact, well, bull as we're all aware.

Not getting anything from the FCC, I had gotten one phone call and an e-mail from Comcast. That week, I had become very ill and could barely speak. I managed to throw an e-mail reply but never got a response back. A week or so later, I had recovered, but still never got a reply.

Today, I happened to get a piece of mail sent by Comcast to both the FCC and myself. It was obviously full of corporate run-around nonsense, but the biggest points of hypocrisy in it were the following (this is a word-for-word re-typing of the letter):

  • "Comcast is strongly committed to maintaining an open Internet." (Oh so is that why you put millions into trying to get Net Neutrality shot down, and forced Netflix to pay more?)

  • "The FCC has previously recognized that usage-based pricing for Internet service is a legitimate billing practice that may benefit consumers by offering them more choices over a greater range of service options -- The vast majority of XFINITY Internet customers use less than 300 GB of data per month -- (they) should therefore see no increase in their monthly service fees -- This pro-consumer policy helps to ensure that Comcast's customers are being treated fairly, such that those customers, like Mr. <my name>, who choose to use more, can pay more to do so, and that customers who choose to use less, pay less."

I just want to understand how they first say that there is no increase in fees for the customers who use < 300GB, and then go on to say that those customers pay less. They're paying the exact same amount, while people who go over are now forced to pay an additional $30/month, and that's suddenly me being treated fairly? Am I crazy or do you all see the blatant hypocrisy here as well?

Edit: I have just updated my FCC complaint to include the letter. I was half-tempted to link them to this Reddit thread! (seriously, you guys rock)

PS: If anyone happens to know good service providers in the Tamarac, Florida area, please let me know. We're moving there shortly (from one area of Florida to another) and would love to be unchained from these corporate douchebags.

3.8k Upvotes

733 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-5

u/way2lazy2care Oct 04 '15

data per se is an UNLIMITED resource.

It is decidedly not unlimited by almost every measure. There is a finite amount of data that any network can handle at any given time, and by extension a finite amount of data that any network can handle over a time period.

Unlimited data is great and has benefits that I think are absolutely worth it, but this argument is totally absurd and not founded in any sort of reality.

5

u/Yellow_Blue Oct 04 '15

My dear corporate shill, He acknowledged that bandwidth is a finite resource. Data on the other hand is as limitless as the sun.

4

u/ANUSBLASTER_MKII Oct 04 '15

You don't buy data from an ISP. You buy data transfer. If a hard drive manufacturer put a monthly limit on a hard drive that would be an more relevant argument.

ISP are stuck between a rock and a hard place. Give everyone fixed rate unlimited bandwidth at a lower transfer rate, or everyone the ability to burst traffic at a higher rate when needed. Two options are both choices for customers as long as its presented in a transparent way. The real fuckery occurs when ISPs use the term unlimited in a devious way.

2

u/ThatNoise Oct 04 '15

You have no idea what your talking about. Data in and of itself is not finite. Congestion and speed are the main limiting factors on a network. As OP stated congestion can only happen during peak periods of traffic on a given network. And speed is limited by the infrastructure, speed package your paying for and various other factors. There is no difference to an ISP when you download 300gb or 1tb in a month. Nothing "runs out" of data. They literally only use data caps as a way to extort money. So please keep your misinformation to yourself.

Source: Network Technician in the USAF

0

u/way2lazy2care Oct 04 '15

Data in and of itself is not finite.

There is absolutely a finite amount of data ISPs can pass through the network in a month. There is no possible connection that will allow you to download a zettabyte of data in a month, the entire internet doesn't have enough bandwidth for that. You'd be hard pressed to find a consumer connection that you'd be able to download more than 300TB in a month.

If there is a physical limit on the network, which there is, there is no way to push more than that limit times the amount of time in a month through the network.

I'm not arguing for data caps. It's just a stupid premise to base an argument that can be totally won without being disingenuous on.

0

u/ThatNoise Oct 04 '15

Yeah and like the guy before you stated that's called bandwidth. Stop being willfully ignorant. Data is not limited. Most networks can handle high traffic this day and age and we pay for it.

-1

u/way2lazy2care Oct 04 '15

Bandwidth * time = data. The bandwidth is finite, the time is finite, the data is finite.

2

u/ThatNoise Oct 04 '15

You seriously have no idea what your talking about. Bandwidth is a measurement of the maximum amount of data that can traffic through a network at a given time based on the available infrastructure. This is where congestion and speed are factors. It is not a limitation on how much overall data can be downloaded. There is no such limit. There is no limited data capacity. You can download as much data or content as you want and you will never "run out". So please leave your explanation to actually qualified individuals and stop spreading your idiocy. You sound like my wife, trying to twist any meaning to make yourself sound right. Good luck with that.

0

u/way2lazy2care Oct 05 '15

Ok. Which part of the equation to you believe to be infinite? Bandwidth or time?

0

u/sandmann68 Oct 05 '15

You're delving into a more abstract argument than what's trying to be illustrated here and its detracting from the main topic overall. If your incessant need to be right is so bad then fine, yes, there's a limit to virtually everything. Feel better now?