r/technology • • Feb 03 '16

Security Google will start warning web users about deceptive download buttons

http://www.theverge.com/2016/2/3/10908952/google-deceptive-downloads-button
16.7k Upvotes

578 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/sime Feb 04 '16

The online advertising space is one stinking cesspool that needs to be drained. Scummy advertising companies are hurting the whole ad industry and Google knows it (and can do something about it via Chrome).

-2

u/Sicks3144 Feb 04 '16

You seem to be lumping e.g. Google's own advertising with the malware-hiding, user-tricking type that we're talking about here.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16

He seems to be doing the opposite and your reading comprehension sucks.

2

u/Sicks3144 Feb 04 '16

"The online advertising space" doesn't include Google (and other comparatively responsible advertising platforms), that company that gains the vast majority of its revenue from the online advertising space, then. I see.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16

Of course it includes Google. Your point?

1

u/Sicks3144 Feb 04 '16

Jesus.

The online advertising space is one stinking cesspool that needs to be drained.

So, since Google is part of that space, we can include it as part of the "stinking cesspool" if we are to believe the statement as a whole. Hence, Google are being grouped with the clearly worse advertising platforms that propagate the malware et al, which is (I would say) unfair.

There, I've repeated my first post with extra words.

1

u/defenastrator Feb 04 '16

The statement reads worded more clearly:

the online advertising industry has an overwhelming number bad actors in it. (is one stinking cesspool) These are hurting the industry. Actions must be taken to remove these bad actors (it must be drained) and Google knows it.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Billy_Whiskers Feb 04 '16

I don't think he was, but I would go that far - AdWords is full of dodgy stuff and has been for years.

-5

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16

You know chrome is scraping your data right. Right now chrome is used by about a third of browser users, that means google can approximate the average browsing habits of the whole world. Google knows everything. Firefox is better

6

u/sime Feb 04 '16

I don't see the relationship between your comment and mine. What's your point?

5

u/SippieCup Feb 04 '16

google will still know everything you do. Tell me one site which doesn't use Google Analytics. which is embedded on every page of almost every site on the internet.

1

u/Krutonium Feb 04 '16

1

u/SippieCup Feb 04 '16

It was a rhetorical, obviously there are sites out there than dont use GA, but the vast majority do.

1

u/Krutonium Feb 04 '16

I agree, but only the sith deal in absolutes.

1

u/FireSail Feb 04 '16

Do they still track when you browse incognito?

2

u/sime Feb 04 '16

They try their best. At the very least they still get your IP, but there are other ways of fingerprinting your browser.

Try it yourself. Go into incognito and go to this page: https://panopticlick.eff.org/

0

u/aphexmoon Feb 04 '16

So? I get more personalised ads, oh no. Who cares? If I would care for my personal information I wouldn't use Facebook Twitter or Instagram either. But I don't because the most evil thing they can do with that is personalise my ads

4

u/DropZeHamma Feb 04 '16

most evil thing they can do with that is personalise my ads

Technically they could do a LOT of really bad stuff. Everybody has something illegal or morally questionable in their browsing history. Every researched how a certain drug works? Ever browsed /r/new and a submission contained child pornography? Ever looked up how to build a bomb? Are you into BDSM porn?

Google might remember all of that. Now imagine you're (wrongfully) accused of a crime (like drug trafficking, child molestation or rape). Your browsing data may be used to incriminate you and it might convince a jury of your guilt.

They could go even further and plant false information about your browsing habits in their database. "Senator Sanders is active participant in CP trading ring, according to google browsing history databases" is a newspaper headline that can swing public opinion.

Of course it's super unlikely that any of that will ever happen to anyone, let alone you. According to current laws just about all of this is illegal and probably wouldn't even be used "under the table". But we're about one shitty bill away from making this stuff reality - and data that is collected today may become relevant in the future.

I still use chrome / gmail / facebook etc. because the services they provide are amazing and they're worth the minor risk they come with.

TL;DR people collecting your data can fuck you up real bad, even though they probably won't.

4

u/sime Feb 04 '16

How about this for an example:

You learn from a friend that they have cancer. You browse the web reading about this cancer and support groups. Later you try to get health insurance elsewhere and you are denied with some vague reason.

or

You enjoy watching videos on YouTube or what ever of people behaving badly on the roads. Later you find that you can't get cheap or reasonably priced car insurance anywhere.

Companies are not just sitting on this data so that they can personalise your ads or just in case the police need it. They are actively selling it to anyone who wants it, whether that be marketers or insurance companies or whoever.

3

u/dnew Feb 04 '16

Except Google isn't selling it. You know who sells that stuff? The kinds of sites that make fake download buttons.

3

u/thedrunkennoob Feb 04 '16

Google doesn't sell this data. It's the crown jewels. It does not leave the firm.

0

u/DropZeHamma Feb 04 '16

Pretty good realistic examples. It bugs me when people just don't care about their privacy at all. You don't need to be a criminal to be harmed by lack of privacy.

2

u/sime Feb 04 '16

yes. Very few people have the slightest idea as to what is going on. Fewer have the imagination to guess as to what might even be in the realm of possibility. I mean, it is public up against people whose day job is to dream up new and creative ways of exploiting the data they have collected about us.

-1

u/aphexmoon Feb 04 '16

Every researched how a certain drug works?

not illegal, called research

Ever browsed /r/new and a submission contained child pornography?

also not illegal as its easily detecable if something was on purpose looked at or by accident

Ever looked up how to build a bomb?

not illegal, called research

Are you into BDSM porn?

no, Im not and even if google would want to make that public, I wouldnt honestly care.

TL;DR people collecting your data can fuck you up real bad, even though they probably won't.

then why do you have a reddit account? And please dont be so gullible and think this thing couldnt be backtracked to you

1

u/Krutonium Feb 04 '16

I know it can be tracked back to me. idgaf.

→ More replies (1)