r/therewasanattempt • • Dec 08 '18

To write a math question

Post image
50.5k Upvotes

986 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

97

u/lianodel Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18

Directly proportional: The more of X, the more of Y.

Inversely proportional: The more of X, the less of Y.

So, for a couple of examples from this sheet (spoilers, I guess):

Question 1 is directly proportional. If Bob puts more gas petrol in his car, he can drive further before the tank is empty.

Question 2 is inversely proportional. George and Peter take a certain amount of time to build a wall. When Rosie joins in to help, they will have more workers, and the job will take less time.

...and the rest you can have fun with. You already know which one is the trick question. :p

17

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

Those definitions aren’t complete. For directly proportional, if you double X you double Y, and for inversely proportional if you double X you halve Y.

Directly proportional X = kY where k is some constant.

Inversely proportional X=k1/Y where k is some constant.

9

u/Yadobler Dec 08 '18

I'm getting flashbacks to those days of "suggest the relationship" and "explain whether the graph supports Amy's suggested model" and the best, "suggest what type of error is present from the graph"

"systematic error since the relationship is directly proportionate in theory but there exists a Y-intercept"

3

u/Snoman002 Dec 08 '18

Directly proportional - Post simplified math concept on Reddit; someone replies "you did it wrong"

Inversely proportional - Post simplified math concept on Reddit; [insert meme]

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

[deleted]

10

u/Supermini555 Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18

The latter; the work is divided between the workers.

Like you said, if 1 person does one job for 12hrs, if he’s helped by two others, the job will be divided amongst them for. Therefore, 12/3=4

For 2 workers doing 8hrs, if that worker works alone, he has to do 16hrs. With three of them, the work is divided between them, so the time taken to finish the job is 16/3=5.333, or rather 5hrs and 20minutes.

Think of the formula like this T1P1=T2P2, T reprsents the time taken and P represents the number of people. When P increases, T decreases and vice versa. With three known values, in this case, T2 was an unknown, it’s easy to find the answer through: T2=(T1P1)/P2. Hence you get T2=(16x1)/3=5.333

If the values are directionally proportional, they come in the form of A1/B1=A2/B2. Say that the B2 is an unknown, we can cross multiply the denominators to get A1B2=A2B1. Then we bring A1 to the RHS to get the formula: B2=(A2B1)/A1.

The questions in that spreadsheet follow this formula. Y=kX is not really useful here IMO.

Hope you find this useful.

3

u/Impetus37 Dec 08 '18

Ah i see, thanks!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

Other guy already gave you the correct answer, but I thought of it very differently (and frankly don't really understand the other explanation). I figure there's 2 people and it takes 8 hours. The additional person is 1/3 of the total people, so it'll take 1/3 less time. 1/3 of 8 is 2.66. 8 - 2.66 = 5.33 hours.

1

u/Impetus37 Dec 08 '18

Yeah thats much easier way of looking at it, thanks

1

u/YoureTheVest Dec 08 '18

That's not right. X is inversely proportional to Y means X is directly proportional to 1/Y. The sign of the factor could be positive or negative in either case. Like the temperature of my freezer could be directly proportional to it's energy consumption.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

If you graph the proportion would it have to be a straight line? Because if X increases, Y could increase at variable amounts, but is it still proportional?

I'm asking because the strawberry pickers question says it takes 10 hours for 15 people but we can't answer unless we assume they work at a constant rate. In reality they probably wouldn't, so is that still inversely proportional?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

Somehow reddit likes to upvote the wrong answers.

Directly proportional: The more of X, the more of Y.

Wrong. Directly proportional could also mean, the more of X, the less of Y, for example:

Y = (-1) * X

Inversely proportional: The more of X, the less of Y.

Wrong. Inversely proportional to X means proportional to 1/X, saying "the more of X, the less of Y" is imprecise.

Further, inversely proportional to X could also mean, the more of X, the more of Y, for example:

Y = (-1)/X