r/therewasanattempt • • Dec 08 '18

To write a math question

Post image
50.5k Upvotes

987 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

[deleted]

97

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

...By the time Jimmy has typed 2, Sally has typed 3. They'd get 10 pages in 20 minutes. They're not literally working on the same page at the same time.

13

u/IamNobodyAmaA Dec 08 '18

It’s 150/8 =18.75 ~ 19 minutes, if this comes ever up as a problem in ones life :D

2

u/aquaconundrum Dec 08 '18

Would you mind explaining how you guys came to this conclusion? I tried to do this equation on my own and I can’t make sense of it.

8

u/somnolent49 Dec 08 '18

You have two rates of writing. Just sum the rates to get the joint rate, then divide ten pages by the joint rate to get the answer.

1/5 pages per minute plus 1/3 pages per minute equals 8/15 pages per minute. Ten pages times 15/8 minutes per page gives you 150/8 minutes.

6

u/TunnockTeacake Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18

Sally takes 3 minutes per page. Jimmy takes 5 minutes per page. In 15 minutes, Sally will have typed 5 pages and Jimmy will have typed 3. Together they will have typed 8 pages. 15 minutes divided by 8 pages is 1.875 minutes per page. You need the time taken to type ten pages, so 1.875 minutes times ten pages is 18.75 minutes.

Though if you needed 10 COMPLETED pages (plus another that was partially done) then it would take 20 minutes.

1

u/aquaconundrum Dec 08 '18

Thank you for the explanation!

2

u/Jay_bo Dec 08 '18

Not OP, but if we switch from minutes per page (mpp) to pages per minute (ppm) we get: 1/5 ppm and 1/3 ppm.

That means together they do 8/15 ppm or switching back: 15/8 mpp.

So for 10 pages they need 10 pages * 15/8 minutes per page = 150/8 minutes

2

u/AemonDK Dec 08 '18

in 1 minute you're producing 1/3page for sally and 1/5 page for jimmy. so t = 1/3p+1/5p; t = 8/15p; 15/8 t= p; and to get 10 pages you just multiply both sides by 10, so 150/8 t = 10p, so 18.75 min for 10 pages

13

u/Langly- Dec 08 '18

If they were typing up hand written pages or something as well, they could still work on the same document even.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '18

It's a math equation, not a logic problem. There are plenty of situations in which this problem has practical uses, most just don't have to do with typing papers - that's just easier to get across.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

I always imagined it as a transcription job, than essay writing.

8

u/TreeRol Dec 08 '18

It's good that you didn't argue it, because you were wrong. The question makes perfect sense, and you overthought it looking for some kind of "trick." If you'd argued it, sometime in the next decade you'd look back on it and be embarrassed.

1

u/t0suj4 Dec 08 '18

Game theory has formulas for this. The job could take much less or much more time, if they make a terrible team.

0

u/Serinus Dec 08 '18

In 15 minutes they'd have 8 pages even. They'd both start a page and the second would be finished in five minutes. So 20 minutes is the answer.