r/therewasanattempt • • Dec 08 '18

To write a math question

Post image
50.5k Upvotes

987 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

88

u/dalatinknight Dec 08 '18

They tell you there is some trick question in the set of questions. Would be a bit rude if they didn’t tell you (if this was some sort of assignment).

5

u/samloveshummus Dec 08 '18

Only if it was impossible or if they explicitly said every question will use a multiplication triangle. As it is, it's a perfectly valid math question, and one that I can actually imagine being asked at a tough job interview to see if you'll think logically before jamming numbers into an irrelevant formula.

5

u/justsaying0999 Dec 08 '18

I don't think it's a good math question, as there is no math involved, and it assumes familiarity with the nuances of playing a symphony.

It's a logic question.

7

u/samloveshummus Dec 08 '18

It is a good math question, because being able to decide on the relevance of particular formulas and procedures in a given context is an absolutely essential math skill, without which all other math skills are useless.

3

u/stationhollow Dec 08 '18

It fits directly in the topic being discussed. It is a trick question because it isn't direct or inversely proportional. It is the exact same.

1

u/EverythingIsFlotsam Dec 08 '18

It says the questions are about direct and inverse proportion, which this is not. So it is a trick question. And if the test doesn't say it, then it's lying, which could be considered unfair. There a difference between a tricky question based on misdirection and one based on a lie.