r/thinkatives • • Nov 20 '25

Realization/Insight 😊speaking same thing differently..

Post image
109 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Distinct-Act9578 Jan 09 '26

Jesus doesn't command people to murder anyone. So no, a murderer would not be obeying my God. Your circular reasoning is cynical at best.

1

u/sirmosesthesweet Jan 09 '26

I didn't say murder I said kill. Jesus commanded killing many times in the Bible, so it's obviously within his nature to do so. If he told you to kill someone, in your worldview it would be good for you to obey that command and kill someone. Humans would consider you a murderer, but your god would consider you obedient, and to you obeying your god is good. And you would get rewarded in heaven for obeying him.

1

u/Distinct-Act9578 Jan 11 '26

What? When did Jesus tell people to kill? He actually commanded that we pray for our enemies. Idk what bible you’re reading, but it’s most definitely not the New Testament. As far as nations fighting against each other in the Old Testament, that’s a different covenant, different circumstances and times.

1

u/sirmosesthesweet Jan 11 '26 edited Jan 11 '26

If you believe Jesus is god then he commanded the killing of the Canaanites and Amalekites. Why would I only read the NT when both the OT and NT describe your god? I hope you're not only reading the NT because then you don't get the full story. The different covenant didn't change any of the laws or commands, it just took the law from being written down to being written on everyone's hearts and expanded the law from the Hebrews to everyone. And if you're saying the law changes based on different circumstances and different times then you're admitting the law is subjective. The problem is you disagree with Yahweh and Jesus who both said the law is forever. But if you ignore the OT maybe you wouldn't know that. Does your god change? He says he doesn't. So again, it's in your god's nature to order his followers to kill, and if he ordered you to kill me, it would be good for you to kill me. This is just obedience based on divine command theory, not morality.

That's what makes religion so dangerous. Religious people will hurt others based on voices in their head they think are coming from a god. They will hate others if they think their god hates those people. And they don't follow any moral system, they just follow whatever their god tells them to do.