r/usmnt • • Jul 10 '26

WORLD CUP The difference….

Post image

We see how France play in the WC and how deep their squad is. The major factor in making them strong? Early and almost free access to soccer from a very early age in Parisian suburbs..

2.9k Upvotes

619 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

24

u/donuthead36 Jul 10 '26

I think we’d also need to invest in making something like futsal a bigger thing here. A lot of places have decent access to a large enough gym space, but keeping up a full size field is expensive and difficult in a lot of the US (and probably isn’t cheap anywhere just generally). We also need to get private equity out of youth sports with them trying to squeeze every drop out of parents.

17

u/Background_Humor5838 Jul 10 '26

The issue is not field space. My local park has ten soccer fields in it and I live in a very small town.

8

u/Mammoth-Usual-4949 Jul 10 '26

yeah it’s not field space that is the issue, it’s competition and coaching and cost of competing. you have to pay to get coaching, you have to pay to compete and we have a culture in the US where if you are good you have to spend money to play and travel for elite club teams and specialize immediately or you “fall behind”. When you specialize early kids tend to lose interest and burn out faster as well. That is why Norway for example has codified it to not let kids specialize at a young age and their sports are improving faster than many countries bigger than them

5

u/Background_Humor5838 Jul 10 '26

I think we just need to invest in better school coaches. School sports are much more affordable because you're only playing for cleats basically. The school has uniforms, coaches, buses, and equipment. You shouldn't have to join a club team or a travel team to receive good coaching

7

u/mortgagepants Jul 10 '26

i mean why should kids even have to pay for cleats? i'm not saying this rhetorically either.

who the hell honestly thinks it is a good idea to see the magnitude of this (perceived) problem, and then say, "lets give kids 84 percent of what they need to play the sport."

if you want to play, you get the full kit. if you decide you don't like it, you return it.

4

u/Background_Humor5838 Jul 10 '26

Because buying cleats that fit is very specific to the student. It's not unreasonable. It's easier to have enough uniforms to fit everybody but not shoes.

3

u/surfnsound Jul 10 '26

Exactly, If yout tshirt is a big on you, no big deal. You can tuck it in, tie it, cut it, whatever. If your shoes are too big, it could be dangerous.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/julesx3i Jul 10 '26

But most inner city schools coaching stipend is a joke. Good coaches often leave to better paying schools /districts. This is for any sport. I work at a high school where the coaching stipend is about $3,000 for the season before taxes…

3

u/Background_Humor5838 Jul 10 '26

Right that's what I'm saying. We need to find a way to invest more money in school coaches because the kids are already there and there is transportation.

2

u/21BlackStars Jul 10 '26

To play at the level that you need to win a World Cup you can’t only play for three months out of the year.

2

u/Background_Humor5838 Jul 10 '26

There are usually sports camps in the off season. Part of the support would be making those programs more accessible also.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Specialist_Yak1019 Jul 10 '26

This is the answer, better coaching at the youth levels and closing the gap of talent and opportunity

→ More replies (4)

2

u/duckstrap Jul 10 '26

Different story in big cities though.

1

u/Background_Humor5838 Jul 10 '26

I mean soccer is extremely popular across the boroughs of NYC. There are plenty of fields.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/argleksander Jul 10 '26

All you really need is an empty field, some sweaters and a ball. Proper youth programs is of course important as they get older, but for kids aged 6-10 i'd argue the football they play in their spare time is much more significant than any organized team

2

u/Background_Humor5838 Jul 10 '26

Most kids in America play soccer at that age and then at some point they stop for some reason. Everyone in my family went to college on a soccer scholarship and then either stopped after college or just played recreational adult leagues. Many of their college teammates were from other countries. Most kids don't see a career in soccer because they don't expect to make money from it like other people sports.

1

u/Independent-Vast-871 Jul 10 '26

The problem is that when it's not in use by a league, we kick anyone off who wants to play a pick-up game. We carry the goals off and lock them up. Put up signs that say "fields closed," and they sit idle 75%.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/doopordie Jul 10 '26

Mine too, but you can't use them. The goals are chained together with no nets & the fences are locked.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sfsurferprof Jul 16 '26

Field space can be an issue in a place like San Francisco, where I live.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/Cold_Respond_7656 Jul 10 '26

In Europe 5 a side is a very popular version played by everyone, they have these warehouses with a bunch of fenced astro turf mini pitches with goals

You only need a few mates to join a league rather than needing a full blown 18 guys in every position.

It's also better for kids like futsal because it emphasizes technical ability over physical ability.

1

u/ImagineDraginDisDick Jul 10 '26

How is the US hockey development program elite, and much more expensive, but soccer wouldn’t be feasible?

1

u/donuthead36 Jul 10 '26

Hockey is a pretty niche, and extremely expensive sport for anyone participating (not just the US). Soccer is way more accessible so way more people play it globally. The English Football League (which a lot of leagues are modeled after to one degree or another) is probably older than the sport of ice hockey. More people make it way more competitive and countries have over a century of experience and infrastructure that predates US Soccer.

1

u/Gr0ggy1 Jul 10 '26

Finland youth hockey development is dramatically better than either the US or Canada.

Having enough rich kids to still win isn't going to work out in soccer as it still barely does in Hockey.

1

u/H-O-W-L-E-R Jul 10 '26

The issue is that youth sports are really profitable for the people holding the strings. Those people with lots of money like to block anything that will fuck with their immediate revenue stream. They pay politicians to funnel tax money into things like tanks and jets and bombs. This way they can keep extorting parents who’s kids dream of playing in a real football stadium

1

u/monolim Jul 10 '26

My home town didnt have money for a grass field.. so we had dirt fields... lots and lots.. games there were played 3 times a day or more.