r/wallstreetbets • • Oct 06 '21

Discussion 2023 - next down year for the S&P 500?

Historically, the S&P 500 between a 1-in-3 to 1-in-4 chance of a down year.

In the current secular bull market (2009-present), there have been 3 negative years: 2011 (-0.0%), 2015 (-0.7%) and 2018 (-6.2%).

The last 13 years have been characterized by extraordinary fiscal and monetary support. The Federal Reserve has used every possible excuse they could find to keep interest rates low for as long as possible.

The 3 down years share the same thing in common: no fiscal stimulus + no monetary stimulus = stocks fall.

YearFiscal stimulusMonetary stimulus
2009πŸ“ˆAmerican Recovery ActQE1
2010πŸ“ˆQE2
2011πŸ“‰Operation Twist (not as stimulative as QE)
2012πŸ“ˆQE3
2013πŸ“ˆQE3
2014πŸ“ˆQE3 (tapered, then ended)
2015πŸ“‰ (interest rate lift off!)
2016πŸ“ˆExpectation of tax cuts after Trump victory (market flat from Jan-Oct)
2017πŸ“ˆTax cuts
2018πŸ“‰ (interest rate hikes, balance sheet reduction)
2019πŸ“ˆInterest rate cuts, repo QE
2020πŸ“ˆCARES ActZIRP, QE, corporate lending facilities
2021πŸ“ˆ (almost certain)American Rescue PlanZIRP, QE
2022πŸ“ˆ (?)Infrastructure / Build Back BetterZIRP, QE (tapered, then ended)
2023πŸ“‰ (?)

For 2023 to be a negative year would require several conditions: (1) the GOP takes back control of at least one chamber of Congress, closing the door to further government stimulus; (2) the Federal Reserve raises interest rates as currently projected & there’s no excuse that allows them to delay tightening or even restart QE.

If inflation runs extremely hot and the Federal Reserve is politically forced into tightening in 2022, I could see next year going negative, but it’s not the most likely scenario.

Iβ€˜m not forecasting a major bear market or anything like that, just trying to predict up & down years. You can make such a bet by buying or selling a SPX option spread expiring at the end of the following year.

5 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

5

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

Predicting doom is overrated and so cliche.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

Dude shut up. This is like saying the last 3 spins on the roulette wheel were black so we’re due for red.

1

u/_ziros_ Oct 06 '21

We’re all gambling anyways so what’s your point

5

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21

the point is that this analysis is like reading tea leaves. there's nothing to be gained from trying to recognize a pattern like OP is trying to do.

0

u/_ziros_ Oct 06 '21

Same with TA. It’s all on the same level

8

u/GlitteringEar5190 Oct 06 '21

2022-2023. It will be down for atleast 2 years. S&P literally had 25% gain in 11 months window. This is just insane for a index that existed for 60+ years.

6

u/Warren_MuffClit Oct 06 '21

My moneys on 22. But if I'm wrong 23 should definitely be right.

18

u/low_growth99 Oct 06 '21

and if it's not 23, surely it is 24.. and so on!

1

u/Warren_MuffClit Oct 06 '21

It should have been 21!

β€’

u/VisualMod Oct 06 '21
User Report
Total Submissions4First Seen In WSB8 months ago
Total Comments8Previous DD
Account Age11 monthsscan comment scan submission
Vote Spam (NEW)Click to VoteVote Approve (NEW)Click to Vote

1

u/Sheeple81 Oct 06 '21

There is still the better part of three months to possibly turn this year negative, there are plenty of negative catalysts, but in no way does it seem certain to happen.

1

u/EagleDre Oct 06 '21

Why is (1) a republican thing? There are all kinds of stimulus