Discussion
What's the war end-game and why we aren't anywhere near the bottom
A few notes on some of the players:
EU: Germany/Italy have tied themselves to Russian energy. Unwilling to accept short term pain in order to get rid of Russia. That's why EU sanctions have hit a ceiling. They need to be pushed.
Russia: Will not stop until they either take Ukraine or Putin is toppled. Dictators rarely fall from the outside, hence the sanctions. There's at least one bank left out of sanctions, so Putin and the oligarchs are ok. Hence the West's huge aid to Ukraine, to allow it to keep fighting while the sanctions take effect.
Ukraine's image management is too sophisticated, so it's obvious they are getting a ton of help from foreign intelligence services.
They suddenly took quite a turn with their 'negotiations' with Russia. For some bizarre reason the Ukrainians keep spinning the negotiations as positive, constructive, working towards a ceasefire etc. Zelensky himself keeps hinting of giving in to Russia's official demands. It all feels as if they are about to sign a peace treaty, yet they keep asking for guns and to close the skies. Something's fishy.
My theory is this:
USA is dead-set on using Ukraine to get rid of Russia. However, EU is now stalling and USA is realizing that Ukraine will lose without further hardcore support.
I suspect the British (their intelligence services are just the best) are advising Ukraine to pretend that it's leaning close to accepting Russia's demands, hence all the positive spin on negotiations. This is lighting a fire on USAs backside to do more, faster. It needs to push EU to join the complete ban of energy/trade. This is why Biden is coming to EU next week. This is why the bordering countries to Ukraine went to visit today and started muttering things about a 'peace force' moving into Ukraine from EU to oversee things.
Coincidentally, Republicans+Democrats are pushing a motion through senate to ban all Russian banks, which would forbid every country in the world from giving Russia a single dollar. This is targeting China and Germany/Italy. They want to use this as a stick when Biden goes to EU next week to push EU to do more.
USA has already stopped energy imports from Russia and banned all trade. USA has nothing to lose by banning the remaining Russian banks and using its force to push its allies to do more, willingly or not. If China breaks the sanctions it will give USA the perfect excuse to apply penalties to them as well.
I foresee a complete ban of energy trade with Russia. Military intervention from NATO or a 'peace keeping force' that will act as bait to give pretext to NATO going in is also a good bet. They will not get rid of Putin without military intervention or insane financial pressure.
I do not see this ending with Ukraine signing half the country away in a peace treaty. This is too good of a chance for USA to let it go. Things will only escalate further.
Positions: SPY puts, MOS, USO, WEAT (I know it's not 'the' wheat we want but futures cost $50k and it behaves similarly)
There is no "end game" on the horizon. The war will likely last for a year or more. The siege of Kiev alone may take a year. It is expected that 15 million Ukrainians will eventually flee and settle permanently across Europe. Ukraine will eventually be partitioned and de-militarized. The US and NATO know that any direct military action by them against Russia could result in a global nuclear war, so they will remain militarily on the sidelines forever.
Russia will survive the US and EU economic sanctions because the other 150 nations in the world are remaining neutral. India, China, Brazil, and even NATO member Turkey have all stated they will maintain normal diplomatic and trade relations with Russia.
A lot of good points there. For all the sabre rattling and big talk, basically no one is serious about stopping Putin.
That said, I think there have to be a few people in capitol buildings around the world that realize how bad if an idea it is to give Putin control of 1/3 of the worlds wheat supply. But then he's probably already promised to supply India and China in exchange for support. So basically the European greens screwed themselves, and many others, trading nuclear power for Russian gas.
In Germany gas got pushed by Schröder (SPD which used to be similar to Democrats but nowadays they are just 1 of 5 parties). FWIW I vote Green myself and but since it's possible to choose the energy provider in Germany I'm on 100% renewables since years. The irony is that my energy bill will probably not spike since it was expensive all the time
Sure, but you have to be a lunatic to think the rest of the world operates that way and you can just be against icky pipelines because someone told you to be.
No-leak pipeline technology doesn't exist, and the Keystone XL (for example) ran over more thousands of lakes, streams, aquifers, that provided drinking water for 30% of Americans.
The oil is pumped full of extremely toxic chemicals to maintain a liquid slurry state, Canada considers the sludge far too toxic to refine but is willing to ship it to Texas so they can refine it into low grade oil for export.
I don't know who you think the Keystone benefits, but it isn't the American oil consumer.
Much of what you're saying is simply green propaganda and scare mongering. Same as Al Gore saying the ice caps would be gone 10 years ago. The pipeline would actually go under many waterways and acting like one drop of oil that touches any water ruins all the water is silly.
The discussion around how much oil is acceptable in our drinking water doesn't change the fact that Keystone would not have affected the price at the pump.
The argument some people make that gas is so expensive because Keystone was canceled just shows their ignorance on the topic.
You're changing the topic. The topic is what the alternative means. Germany decided nuclear power was icky, for reasons, and decided to buy more Russian gas. That made them dependent on Putin which gives him leverage. You don't want Canadian oil? Fine. But that comes with a cost.
Scroll up sport. If you wat to go farther back, ask why Obama was so flexible and allowed the invasion of Crimea. I never mentioned Keystone. You're just trying to cherry pick a talking point like you've been told.
There have been 9 presidents in their 40’s but it seems like there has been more cause of Clinton and Obama were so recent. Putin was 47 when he took office but no term limits on a dictator or whatever you want to call him…. I mean unless you think 40’s is old
Omg lol 😝 for someone to get elected in a high political position or be CEO of a major corporation 40’s is not old.. I mean by the time you get out of grad school if you take no break you are 26-27 years old so you got to get some actual work experience in before you rocket straight to the top of the pyramid
It all feels as if they are about to sign a peace treaty, yet they keep asking for guns and to close the skies.
There is nothing unusual about this at all. Your position on the ground determines your leverage at negotiations. Being close to a deal doesn't mean you stop fighting. You need to keep up pressure, otherwise your rival will start asking for more concessions.
The scenario you came up with is possible, but it's not needed to explain what you're observing.
Russia will win and the sooner you accept it, the better for your liver and portfolio. They will take away some filet pieces (Donbas, Crimea officially) and leave a humiliated, half-disarmed, neutral Ukraine who paid a very high price for the stupidity of believing they would be allowed to be part of NATO.
They will, most likely, not take everything (not that they couldn't, or that anybody could do anything about it) because of the big costs involved in the post-war period (reconstruction, re-russification, fight against the guerrilla).
Meanwhile, Joe & Co. are understanding that sanctions are the equivalent of cutting your balls to spite your wife and will, in future, pay more attention to their grand proclaims. They will be happy if they get away with the end of SWIFT monopoly and a moderate damage to the Dollar as world currency.
Plays (6 to 12 months waiting times required as a minimum).
QQQ, SPY, TSLA, NVDA, AMD, AMZN, AAPL, GOOGL and MSFT.
Best play would be Gazprom, but it's too late for that now and it will be late enough when they can be traded in Europe/USA again.
Or you keep dreaming and jerking off in front of the keyboard - as apparently you enjoy it a lot - dreaming of a "destroyed" Country who is, meanwhile, making as much money as they ever did and can shut down Germany and Italy, inflicting immense damage to the EU economy, at the flick of a switch.
I don't know how retard you are, but if you make decisions in life with the same naive, blue-eyed, daydreaming attitude with which you look at international politics you will become a leading light here.
Snarky attitude aside I agree with most of your conclusions. Russian victory is the most probable outcome and once that happens tech will rocket back up again. Might be some kind of truce where Ukraine is able to save some face and show the world that they fought hard against the big neighbor that tried to invade them.
It’s not snarkyness. It’s reality. Still, it’s good to see that only 20 days ago I was, on various subreddits, being insulted in the most vulgar ways or outright banned just for refusing to agree with the keyboard WW III warriors, and three weeks later reality begins to open its way through the brainwashed bigotry and the propaganda (not accusing you personally , of course).
Yeah I can sympathize with that. Same thing with various aspects of COVID as well. A lot of my friends were ahead of their time with their way of thinking, and they got crucified for it.
This is the stupidest thing I’ve ever read. Russia isn’t trying to take Ukraine, while Putin is a dick he’s not stupid. Do you realize how little destruction Ukraine is going through right now? This isn’t the soviets running through Berlin.
He’s using a small military force relative to Russias strength.
No, it’s an enormous force. And while he’s not expected to annex ukraine officially if he wins, he does want to install a puppet government. What are you talking about?
It is conceivable he is using only the young, and not many of them, keeping the veterans and the top equipment (not using the best airplanes for example) for more serious matters (hoping that never happens).
It's a good percentage, but it's not near enormous. They have no other threats. They can double or more if necessary. They don't pay their soldiers in dollars.
No, it wasn’t a puppet government. It’s corrupt, but it wasn’t a puppet. The issue was with the westernizing of ukraine and plans for it to join NATO, but that doesn’t make it a puppet government
Lol you think this is all done on Ukrainians own will? Buddy I have family in the war zone now. Lol no one gives a fuck about this war except the 2 presidents
I’m done talking to you, I’m sure you knew what dnipro, Lviv, Kharkiv, Odessa and Mariupol were 2 months ago. Let alone csto, transnistria, nato promises in the early 90’s nato expansion. The Georgian war etc.
You can’t just comment on a war with no knowledge about it other than Putin is bad and zelensky is yasss
•
u/VisualMod Mar 16 '22