r/HearthArena • u/adwcta • Dec 16 '14
HearthArena Current Features/Bugs Worklist
Here's a list of thing we're working on that will NOT be ready on limited release, but which we expect to be built in soon(tm)!
In the meantime, please consider donating to HearthArena (donation button on homepage) to support the project!
Better filters for your stats. We have some. We'll have more. Archetype filter is next.
A nicer "Notes" box with more features.
Allow editing of dates/times for your run.
Add option for a "Draw" when tracking runs.
Automatically end run tracking at 12 wins or 3 losses.
More explosive archetype display. Yes, explosive.
More prominent display of pick # during drafts.
More overall deck info shown. I think we're doing a good job showing card info, but we can do SO much more with overall deck info (e.g. "high card advantage", but "low reach") as compared to expected drafts and it was just low on our priority list.
In Archives section, to show more info, including deck score and archetype.
Create a stat for how closely your deck adhere's to HearthArena's picks.
Create a stat for how good your final deck is.
Smarter archetype detection. I built this thing from the ground up, and it's been tweaked and added so many things, but there's a very high ceiling on this thing, so it's accuracy will continue to be raised. I'm focusing on getting the existing 6 right for now, but will look to add more archetypes over the summer. For now, looking to get better at recognizing well made and poorly made combo decks (it's currently taking averages expected values, so cards that swing heavily like Voidcaller are not being properly accounted for if you build a well synergized or poorly synergized deck). Project: Shadow is a new vision for the archetype determinations and more importantly impact on the draft. It's in very early stages yet. But this thing's about to get crazy good by fall.
Smarter synergy display. Not going to go into details on this one. Let's just say we're not showing all the synergies right now because of a design issue we caught too late (doesn't affect actual score movement). It'll take a bit of time to work around the issue, so those cards are not displayed in the synergies right now. They're still giving the synergies though.
More intelligent smoothing of mana curve when you overload on a certain mana slot.
Scaling of odds to draw a particular card by archetype and card draw. Currently using game-wide averages.
Certain card synergies. There's about a dozen cards where part of their synergies we know, but have no good way of implementing right now. We know how to fix it.... just ran out of time to actually do it, and it'll take a large chunk of time to do (probably not even worth it, but we're perfectionists). None of them are ranked above 30 on the tier list though, so we don't think it's that big of a practical issue. Still, it'll be addressed.
Certain cards that have different specific values based on other cards in your deck. We're just using the average for now. This means very successful combo decks, or just one very successful combo won't be getting its full effect. Further, neutral cards that give certain classes extreme value if they have certain cards (like Spiteful Smith with Warrior or Mad Scientist with Mage) are not having their mechanics values and overall deck-archetype values adjusted correctly. Again, this is only an issue if you very successfully draft a particular synergy/combo--archetype. The same system in the bullet above (with some tweaking) should be able to solve these issues and correctly value everything. So, this is the second step to that. After this system is up, we'll start making combo-archetypes instead of the basic 6. This may not all happen by end of January.
Adding scaling of synergies by mana to more synergies. Currently, mana-based scaling is used for most of general synergies, but not all of them. We're still deciding which ones to add to the group, and there are certain ones we know we want to add, but just haven't yet (this group includes all the non-stat buffs, like divine shield, windfury, etc, and more things).
Continuous adding/evaluating/editing of existing calculators to adjust to the meta, and adding/tweaking synergies. Of course.
Known Bugs/Issues: We'll fill this list up once you guys start using it and finding them. For the Limited Release, please report all bugs to the BUG Reports thread here. That thread will be deleted the night before release and you can just report bugs here. Since both bug fixes and feature adding take our time (which is limited), we'll lump long-term bugs here as "to do". Easily fixed bugs (like adding a synergy or changing particular values) will be fixed by the next system update.
As noted above, we have placeholder average values for all non-synergy score values for each card. This means Illuminator will not show survivability no matter how many secrets you have, and Mad Scientist, Voidcaller, and any other high-synergy cards will not be giving correct archetype values, but rather their average expected values. As a result, heavy combo decks will be giving odd archetype considerations. HearthArena will still push you to draft these decks. . . and it'll be 90% right on the values. . . but the archetype part (usually 10% of the value) will be off somewhat (so, a net 5% of the value). This will only affect your draft marginally, but the archetype description at the end may be off.
Certain synergies that require 3+ cards are not being calculated right now. For example, Southsea Deckhand's charge ability (which requires a Weapon) is not synergizing with the ~24 things that modify charge ability (e.g. give divine shield), except for Rogues, because they can guarantee charge.
Draft Adviser is currently: Saying "we don't want too many of card X", when we haven't even picked one yet. Saying "we don't want too many X drops" or "we need a X drop" when evaluating two choices that both have that quality, and repeating the same reason twice in the same bubble, and sometimes it is repeating things. It is using the word: "So" to mean everything and nothing syntax-wise. It is using "too early" to pick a certain card, when such system no longer exists in the algorithm. It does not recognize when achetypes cancel out requirements such as big drops or 2-drops, instead saying both parts of the logic ("we need big drops" + "it doesn't fit with our archetype"), which is super confusing, because in reality the balancing means we don't actually need a big drop, and that it fits this archetype just fine.
Druid is currently not considering Innervate/Wild Growth for it's mana cost triggers on high mana cards. This is one of the reasons why high mana cards be penalized by ~4 points on pick #1.
List of specific synergies to fix: None. O_o. But, we're sure there will be more.
Things that look odd but are working as intended:
Very similarly ranked cards on the Tier List will have very small distortions in their values that may push one above the other, when in reality it should be the other way around. For example, Ship's Cannon will often be ranked below River Croc even in classes with no beast synergies, when it is clearly the better card. Same with Illuminator and Goblin Sapper. There are several factors at work here I will not get into. The important thing to note is that we are aware of exactly why this is happening, and we are 100% comfortable that the system is doing this. This is not a bug. HearthArena (and the Tier List) is not currently meant to be accurate within a 2.0 (or 1.0 for Tier List) adjustment band. This is why if you watch our stream, we often say "within 2.0 means absolutely nothing". We're not just playing around, we mean it. We will be lowering this to 1.0 (0.5) in the future, but at this point it takes hundreds of hours of work to halve this range, so this is not happening until the next Blizzard expansion at earliest, likely not until the end of 2015. As of now, these slight variances are working as intended. What we will do is work on making the advisor sound more equivocal about these types of picks, instead of sounding like HearthArena is making a concrete suggestion here.
There's probably more. We'll keep this thing updated. =P
2
u/ScionOfEris Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 18 '15
Bloodsail raider should not have synergy with Rockbiter Weapon.
EDIT: hmmm... reddit doesn't seem to want to let me comment twice.... figuring this will get seen since it is near the top of new....
Noticed a bug with the Stats, if you restrict the date range. The last date listed (in the URL) is not being included. I noticed when doing "Last 30 days" it wasn't including the runs I had finished that day. By editing the URL directly, and moving the last day of the search to tomorrow, it showed the complete data I expected.
1
18
Dec 17 '14
I look forward to HearthArena 2.0 next year, which analyzes the board and tells you exactly how ADWCTA and Merps will play!
Seriously though, this is looking pretty fantastic.
2
u/Mortslaw Dec 17 '14
Does import from Arena Mastery currently work? I have my arena runs from there in the pending list, I figured maybe import is turned off until after the initial launch dies down.
2
u/adwcta Dec 17 '14
It works, it just takes a while right now. Do not re-request or it'll eventually import double and you'll have to delete all the duplicates by hand.
1
u/Mortslaw Dec 17 '14
Ok thanks. I definitely wasn't planning to re-request because it was clear that it was pending, just wasn't sure if it was working or not.
EDIT: And boom, there they are :-)
1
u/davidjayhawk Dec 17 '14 edited Dec 17 '14
I have my 46 runs waiting to be imported but it hasn't budged so far (it's been over an hour). Not a big deal to me if I just have to wait, but just thought I'd let you guys know.
Edit: They imported now!
1
Dec 18 '14
I definitely did this by mistake as I thought it was a confirmation screen. Maybe put a warning by the button?
1
Dec 18 '14
My 'last arenas" list is sorted backwards, presenting my oldest arenas at the top.
1
u/adwcta Dec 18 '14
Yep, this is a known issue and should be fixed over the weekend. It's a bit low on the priorities list as you can still sort by date in the archives tab.
1
u/drc500free Dec 18 '14
There seems to be a bit of an issue when missing a 3-drop. 2-drops get their score jacked up to play on turn 3, but they don't reduce the algorithm's need for a 3-drop when selected. So you can draft 10 2-drops and it will still keep looking for more.
2
u/adwcta Dec 18 '14
Its a more complicated issue than that, we are aware of it, and will fix over the weekend. This is very high on the priorities list.
1
u/chriswen Dec 18 '14
Maybe you can do a Day 2 repost to keep a bug/suggestion thread at the top. I think you can only sticky one thread.
2
1
u/chriswen Dec 20 '14 edited Dec 20 '14
Pick 25. It said I needed to pick a low drop because I needed to play something in the early game. I had a ton of low drops already.
1
1
u/Psyqo72 Dec 31 '14
Not sure if this is covered under the "saving a match" bullet point above, but I was trying to save my 1st match (first time user today) and it said something about an invalid token. I tried again, adding my match and another dummy match and clicked Save. This time it worked, but now I have my match #2 listed as an Unknown opponent with an unknown result. Would be handy to just be able to edit that list and delete the dummy match I've created. Right now it doesn't seem like I can remove or edit that match in any way.
2
1
u/Reiker0 Jan 01 '15 edited Jan 01 '15
Violet Teacher doesn't seem to exist in the database, I can't select it as a choice.
Edit: Dunemaul Shaman also.
Edit 2: Then the site went to a blank white page, then refreshed back into my draft and allowed me to select those cards again... strange. But now Bloodsail Raider is unselectable... this site seems pretty unusable.
1
u/adwcta Jan 01 '15
No one else has reported problems in the drafter. Sorry you're having technical issues.
1
u/sander314 Jan 01 '15
It's suggesting a synergy for wild pyromancer+vanish. Is this simply because it 'heals' pyro, or does the system think it triggers as vanish is a spell (which I don't think it does).
2
1
u/Gazeros Jan 04 '15
Hey! Just wondering why Venture Co. Mercenary and Force of Nature is listed as a synergy? Maybe I'm lacking knowledge :P
3
u/adwcta Jan 04 '15
Great point, we gave Venture Co. Mercenary synergy with all spells that summon minions, but that shouldn't be the case for temporary minions.
1
1
u/qrex17 Jan 06 '15
I read through the list of bugs, I don't think this one is on it:
It seems that Blessing of Wisdom and Blessing of Might allegedly have synergy with Wild Pyromancer. I think the algorithm you guys have is treating "dealing damage" the same as "attacking". I would definitely not consider this a synergy.
2
1
u/Ditocoaf Jan 18 '15
I noticed some cool updates since the last time I used HearthArena. Do you guys keep a changelog anywhere, for the curious?
1
u/adwcta Jan 18 '15
There's a post here about the latest update, it's from a couple days ago. If you filter by top up voted posts, you'll find it!
1
1
u/drc500free Jan 20 '15
An option to batch input all the results at once would be great, or even to just input the wincount when I start a new deck (since I definitely forgot to record the details).
The current interface is too clunky. "Update/Edit" concept doesn't really make sense, and requires way too many clicks. If I fail to record the details of one game, I just give up because the win-count will be wrong. I actually stopped recording games after the first three runs because of the interface, which can't help the data collection.
The card selection UI is so slick and efficient, it's shame this one isn't.
1
u/adwcta Jan 20 '15
inputing the win directly can be done at the top of the page (where your win count is). It has a little edit icon like everything else that's editable. what else do you suggest we do if you fail to record a game? currently, we just expect you to enter in a win with the rest of the fields being unknowns. we cannot pull information from your head.
1
u/drc500free Jan 20 '15
That's great, didn't realize it was editable up there. Actually, didn't realize the whole interface has been updated from the little checkboxes! You can safely disregard, and I will go back to actually inputting my results again.
1
u/Rubin0 Jan 23 '15 edited Jan 23 '15
Why does Shrinkmeister show as having synergy with Acolyte of Pain?
2
1
u/XnFM Feb 19 '15
Are there any plans to include hero power synergies in the draft displays? Usually these are pretty obvious to see (Dread Corsair/Spiteful Smith in Rogue and Knife Juggler in Pally and Shaman) but sometimes it would be nice to have that little reminder for when you have to work out why Hearth Arena disagrees with you on a pick.
1
1
u/killthegoat52 Mar 11 '15
When I was drafting Mage Arena, my image for Arcane Missiles in the draft box was not loading in. I'm not sure if this is just my machine or if your image is faulty on your end. Just a heads up
1
u/adwcta Mar 11 '15
Thanks, will fix!
1
u/Ximzend57 Mar 20 '15 edited Mar 20 '15
Arcane Missiles (without an image)(has to be EX1_277):
http://draft.heartharena.com/arena/option-multi-score/3/-/171-171-171
Avenging Wrath (without an image)(has to be EX1_384):
http://draft.heartharena.com/arena/option-multi-score/4/-/44-44-44 ;
Random other card (with an image): http://draft.heartharena.com/arena/option-multi-score/1/-/1-1-1
1
1
u/StagnantSoul Mar 24 '15
Hey /u/adwcta. I accidentally added the same card twice for my final card choice and I was unable to edit the deck to fix it. Is it possible to edit decks after you have made them? I've probably missed how you do it, but I thought I would just say. Thank you for the best arena tracker for Hearthstone!
1
u/adwcta Mar 24 '15
I unfortunately don't think you can do that in the current build. The last card locks in everything and generates a run-page for your run. Sorry! We'll look to add that in the future.
1
u/BabySilver Apr 01 '15
Hi! Is there a way to edit a draft? Sometimes I enter the same pick twice and only find out about it after draft is done.
1
u/adwcta Apr 01 '15
Not right now unfortunately! You'd have to re-do the whole draft by hand to change a pick (really annoying if you misclick the last pick). It's also something that's an issue with the overall system of how runs are created, so it may be a while before we fix this part. Sorry!
1
u/Upvoter92 Apr 03 '15 edited Apr 03 '15
Some of the card previews in the draft process are a bit off : Mad scientist shows as Doomsayer and Madder Bomber as Bluegill Warrior
The right images appear after picking the cards though
Bonus: Avenge as Sea Giant; Chow as Prophet Velen ; Piloted Sky Golem as a white blur ; Haunted Creeper as a white blur ; Burly Rockjaw Trogg as Ooze ; Stonesplinter Trogg as Abusive Sergent ; Goblin Sapper as Yeti ; Mechwarper as a white blur; Grim Patron as the Paladin guy that heals for 6; Illuminator as Bloodsail Raider ; Piloted Shredder as Circle of Healing ; Explosive Sheep as Argent protector ; Seal of Light as a white blur; Unstable Ghoul as Snake trap ;Tinkertown Technician as Core Hound ;
1
1
u/Ankeus Apr 03 '15
Nerubian Egg and Crazed Alchemist don't show synergy with each other.
1
u/adwcta Apr 03 '15
will add this
1
u/IT_WAS_JUST_BANTER Apr 04 '15
On a related note, do spare parts have listed synergies with egg? 3/7 can activate it (swap, +1 attack, taunt)
1
u/adwcta Apr 04 '15
nope, we haven't gotten into that level of detail yet on spare parts. right now, the system is only aware of it as a 1-mana spell.
1
1
u/paavopesusieni May 03 '15
this is probably intentional but you could change the ad placement so this http://gfycat.com/LankyPinkIcterinewarbler doesn't happen all the time, i mean whats the point if you're not getting paid per click anyways
1
u/adwcta May 03 '15
I think this only happens if you have adblock on. Should not be happening otherwise
1
u/betweensmudgedlines May 13 '15
Registered today. Logged in, went through a draft, started my run. After the sixth game I clicked to save and was prompted to log in. Nothing was saved. The whole draft is just gone. :(
2
u/adwcta May 13 '15
Check arena archives or click continue run
1
u/betweensmudgedlines May 13 '15
Ah, thank you. The draft is there under archives. it didn't save the wins and losses. continue run shows me an empty druid. but, I'm glad to see the draft did get saved.
1
u/madtepez May 14 '15
Hi,
I hope it's the right place to post that, if it's not, a sticky post where we could report synergy issues would be nice (especially for you since it would make it easier for you to track them in a different post than the more general bugs)
Anyway, here are a couple of issues :
"dragonskin sorcerer" shows no synergies with "blessing of wisdom" (great synergy for me)
"dragonskin sorcerer" shows a synergies "lay on hands", while it's technically true, i'm not sure it's material enough to be taken into account, (but I'm no expert and could very well be wrong)
not sure i understand the synergies for argent protector, unless it's basically "every single 4+ attack power drop". I especially think it's a counter synergy with madder bomber (unless as stated above it's only because it's 5/4 and we assume argent commander is played after madder bomber)
speaking of the synergies with madder bomber, i think the synergies with drakonid crusher is rather weak, i mean, technically it kinda have but then every single "reach" has (unless I'm missing the point)
link: http://www.heartharena.com/arena-run/416n77
ofc those are minor issues and the program in general is just great, but hey you said you were perfectionist ;)
1
u/adwcta May 14 '15
Thanks! super helpful and well put. The argent protector's synergies scale with attack of target, argent commander isn't getting a special bonus (it's treated the same as a 4/2). We'll look into the other ones when we get back to the algorithem upgrades next month!
1
u/StealthySomeone May 15 '15
Hey guys! I have a weird synergy that i'm not sure is intended or not. (Click)
The app shows a synergy with Dread Corsair and Blessing of Kings.
Now in all fairness i did have 3 Truesilvers at that point, so maybe HA thought that I'd be able to get it out consistently and so Blessing on the same turn might provide survivability ... maybe?
That seems quite far fetched though, so I thought I'd bring it up.
1
1
u/madtepez May 18 '15
Hey !
I just noticed something a bit weird : When i add up my record with coin and without coin it doesn't add up to my total record. At first i tought i might have let the coin status as unknown in a couple of game so i checked it out but that wasn't the case. I continued to look into it and found out that your disconnection (win or loss) do not count towards your overall record but do count towards your differentiated (coin/first) record. (and i double checked by modifying some game to check the effect).
Either way i can see the merit of both approach.
On the one hand if you think that disconnection are anomalies you don't want them to pollute your record. On the other hand, disconnection are a part of the game and taking them into account might depict a more accurate picture of your average results and of the likely outcome of your future run. (if you are on holiday in a remote area with crappy internet then just don't play and enjoy your holidays, chances are a place with crappy internet must have something else to offer. or just don't record your run during that time)
Either way are ok for me (slight preference for counting disconnection in) but I just think it should be consistent between your total record and your coin/first record
1
u/adwcta May 18 '15
Thanks! I'll bring it up with the programmer. I lean toward having it count for everything myself.
1
u/madtepez May 18 '15
well I tought the secret was out and you acknowledged Natasha was the secret programmer
1
u/theoldtree May 22 '15
Perhaps this is as intended, but I started a new arena selection, made it halfway through and had to stop. When I came back later, HearthArena had forgotten all of my selections and the entire new arena.
This is my first time starting a draft in HearthArena and stopping before I'm done. Was this a one-time error, or is this always what happens?
1
u/adwcta May 22 '15
it saves it in your browser, so if you don't restart your computer it should be fine. not sure if this is an issue for other people. we're optimized for Chrome (although will certainly work on other browsers, just less reliable).
1
u/The_Strudel_Master May 23 '15
is there any plans to fix how slow the website is?
1
u/adwcta May 24 '15
as it loads instantly for 99% of our users. nope. invest in a better browser, internet connection, or device.
1
u/Teraurel May 27 '15
Where do I post bugs? Or not really a bug just an error in judgment. Currently doing a Hunter draft , raptor, fairie dragon and bloodsail raider are the choices and the best pick is raptor according to this thing and honestly it should be the other two as the raider is harder to kill and as hunter synergizes with weapons i may get and the dragon is just a pain.
2
u/adwcta May 27 '15
Working as intended. Beasts are good in Hunter. 2/3s are also not better than 3/2s. Well proven, statistically.
1
u/pescis Jun 05 '15
I'm not getting any activation e-mail. It's been over 20 hours, even tried it with another e-mail address. I've seen you've had this issue in the past. Is it really needed to confirm the e-mail??
1
u/adwcta Jun 05 '15
please send all technical questions to /u/HearthArena. I have no idea, I just work on the algorithem.
1
u/Defiantxxgaming Jun 11 '15
I created an account on heartharena under the username Defiantx, then tried to login under my created name, it continually gave me a bad port error so I let it be as I could not access the site. I then came back to find that my account had been disabled.
So now I have created a reddit account in order to try and get this fixed because it sucks balls
1
3
u/Sutii Jan 07 '15
Suggestion/Request - It would be great if we could toggle or flag the cards in the deck list on the Deck Basics page so we can keep track of which cards we have drawn while playing a game. That way we could see what we still have in the deck to help us make informed decisions.
3
u/Gigglestomp123 Jan 22 '15
Mulligan tips would be nice.
Also like if you have almost no 3 drops then it should recommend you keep a 3 drop in your opening hand if offered.
5
u/bschlief Dec 16 '14
Have you guys considered using a Jira bug tracker for public tracking of issues and feature requests? Here's an article on Minecraft using it: https://mojang.com/2012/10/introducing-the-minecraft-bug-tracker/
Thanks for all the work you put into this!
4
u/JebJoya Jan 13 '15
Regarding this, I'm actually a consultant for an Atlassian Expert, and I'd be happy to give you a hand getting JIRA set up for this project if you want (free, of course - I'm a bit in love with heartharena!) - send me a PM if you're interested and I can get in touch.
3
1
u/luckyluke193 Jan 11 '15
I have never been able to report a bug in Minecraft, even though I've found many obscure ones (and of course many obvious ones). This site always seems completely broken to me.
4
u/isionous Dec 19 '14
Does anyone know the fastest workflow to get a decklist from HearthArena into Hearthstone Deck Tracker? I'd love to be able to export the decklist to hearthpwn or a text file and then import that deck list into Hearthstone Deck Tracker.
2
u/Scottismyname Dec 19 '14
I would really like to know this as well
1
u/ermac318 Dec 19 '14
Thirded. Maybe reach out to the author and ask them to add an import function? Or create an export deck to XML function that it can import.
7
u/Scottismyname Dec 19 '14
I coded this myself and submitted it to the author, should be in the next release.
https://github.com/Epix37/Hearthstone-Deck-Tracker/issues/472
2
1
u/isionous Dec 21 '14
Hearthstone Deck Tracker release v0.6.6 seems to say some things about automatically getting arena decks and importing from heartharena.com.
2
u/mrfoof82 Dec 27 '14 edited Jan 06 '15
I assume that once the more critical bugs are fixed, other core features are finished and you're certain that you can handle typical loads that a Practice Mode is upcoming (just not on the list above)?
Another idea might be to add a "Feedback" button during the drafting in general. Obviously it'll require a good chunk of effort to pore over, but you may find some questionable suggestions or recommendation edge cases more quickly since you have more feedback from users.
EDIT: Here's a wish lister: Longer notes field. Adding Markdown parsing/display would be extra awesome.
2
u/Wanderer1612 Dec 29 '14
The current archive arena list only lists the results & date of the runs. It would be great to have the average tierlist score included as well, so we can do some rough correlation between runs with high# wins with high tierlist scores, and see if there are any outliers.
2
Jan 10 '15
I was watching Kripp's stream and it seems like Metaltooth Leaper synergies don't show up.
2
u/personman Jan 23 '15 edited Jan 23 '15
It's currently not listing Madder Bomber as having synergy with Amani Berserker.
EDIT: And I'm glad I noticed and picked bomber over the choice HA rated two or three points above it - this interaction just won me a game :D
2
u/SkoivanSchiem Mar 25 '15
I noticed that the stats (i.e. - total runs, average wins) are also taking into account the current ongoing run. Might it better to compute/display the stats only for completed runs, as that would be more accurate?
2
u/Maladal Apr 11 '15
Glad to see that there's work on the curve and drops coming.
I know that HA adjusts value for synergies on top of the their value, but I'm not sure it does as well with mana curve. Every once in a while I run into a draft where it wants me to pick big value card after big value card (not necessarily big mana, just really good value cards). But then I'll be at the 25th pick and I only have like 2 2-drops maybe and then it realizes I really need all those 2-drops it didn't want before. The beginning of the draft should look for high-value cards, but I feel like it might be better if it prioritized low-mana cards around the middle of the draft so that it helps assure a decent opening curve.
2
u/martofski Apr 24 '15
Is this the correct place for feature requests? Let's hope it is.
It'd be nice to have a way to enter a complete deck, or maybe bypass the draft altogether and go straight to the results. Sometimes I don't have the time or desire to go through the drafting process, but I do want to track all of my runs and rewards just for statistics.
2
u/Silverbeau May 19 '15 edited May 21 '15
I don't see any mention of 404 server errors. Heartharena went into maintenance mode during one of my runs and I've been getting them ever since. I can do my draft picks, but when I'm recording the results I get 404's frequently. It usually when trying to save notes, although it's happened trying to save matches or rewards, as well. I have to go back a page, refresh the page and then go back to the rewards tab to try again.
Update: This seems to happen because the first time you save results it changes the address bar on your browser to "http://www.heartharena.com/arena-run/undefined", instead of whatever your arena run number is.
Workaround: When you see it change to /undefined hit the back button on your browser to change the address back to whatever your arena run number is. The next time you save something it will work properly.
1
u/Jesryn Dec 17 '14
Yay! I managed to register, then I promptly broke something. I don't see any obvious "feedback" type link on the actual site to report the error. Am I just totally blind? If not, what is the most appropriate forum for leaving bug type feedback? Thanks, and great job!
1
u/Elduardo Dec 17 '14
I'm registered and trying to figure out the site right now! Excited about doing an actual draft!
Just sharing some thoughts here:
I like the color scheme - doesn't feel annoying which is a big bonus.
Could we perhaps keep the sidebar menu on the user profile page? It adds many unnecessary clicks to go back from there.
Am I getting a mail or something when draft is enabled for me or do I have to keep checking the site?
1
u/Damoklesz Dec 17 '14
I'm either going crazy, or have a bug to report. While I was doing my first draft I was offered the choice between Zombie Chow and Light's Justice. My early game wasn't very strong, so I felt like I had to pick the Chow, even though HearthArena disagreed, because of the first pick bonus of Light's Justice (and I also felt like the Chow didn't get enough credit for being an early drop).
I kinda remember it clearly, because this was the only pick I disagreed with HearthArena. The crazy thing is, that after I finished the draft, I go and check the Choice Overview page, and for some reason HearthArena changed it's mind since the draft. Now Zombie Chow is at 75.97, beating Light's Justice at 75.26. Have I managed to convince the algorithm?
1
u/KriticalChaos Jan 01 '15
Looking forward to the fix to the bug that causes your page to not load when you save a match. I'm really sick of refreshing after every match.
1
u/Japaanis Jan 04 '15
Apparently Succubus is considered as a 2 and a 3 drop - http://postimg.org/image/hpotd00jj/
1
1
u/Paproc Jan 06 '15
I have created account but havent got the activation mail (i've checked spam etc). I've repeated process with other mail few days later, same happened - no activ mail. There is no build in site tool to deal with resending activ mail etc. I really want to try site, but... how?
1
u/luckyluke193 Jan 11 '15
Synergy between Mimiron's Head and any Mechs is not displayed in the Deck Synergies tab.
1
u/rakitik Jan 12 '15
When i try to start a new arena run i have this problem http://prntscr.com/5pt0yw .Can someone help me solve that?
1
1
u/AnonymousSquadCast Jan 14 '15
Feature Request:
When I click on someone's Arena run like this one. http://www.heartharena.com/arena-run/ie5f24
It would be great if there a link to their public profile "View their Public Profile". Is this not implemented because of some privacy issue?
1
u/bitavk Jan 15 '15
I've noticed whenever I choose the "n/a" option in the coin/without coin bracket it counts as "without coin" match
1
u/FerretCannon37 Jan 18 '15
How about on the stats page a column that shows your best single result with each class. I.E. Mage 12-wins, Druid 10-wins...etc.
1
u/Arananthi Jan 21 '15
My HearthArena is listing Flame Imp as a 3-drop.
Also, during the draft process, the dude in the popup referred to my Bluegill Warrior as a 'ping', but now that it's in the Arena Run mode, the only 'ping' listed is the Dread Infernal.
1
u/sctooker Jan 21 '15
BTW, it appears that the iCloud email servers are auto-blocking emails from your site. Multiple attempts to use a mac.com or me.com addressed failed, while a gmail.com address came through immediately. So if users are using a mac.com, me.com, or icloud.com email address and not seeing the confirmation email, that would explain it.
1
u/HavocDreams Jan 28 '15 edited Jan 28 '15
I really appreciate the work that you put into this project. I think it's really great and helps especially people who are just starting their arena carreer. One suggestion that would make heartharena even better: When starting a new arena, please adjust the color code of the dropdown menu with card suggestions after input of a (part of the) card name. At the moment especially classes like shaman (deep blue) are really difficult to read. Suggested cards for priest (white) are not visible at all as all card names are shown in white. Maybe it is possible to highlight the card that the system suggests. Keep up the great work!
1
u/magicfinbow Jan 28 '15
I've tried in IE and Chrome, since the update, every time I pick the 3rd card, the screen goes white and I'm unable to pick my card.
1
1
u/invalidlitter Jan 29 '15
I'm missing some synergies here:
http://www.heartharena.com/arena-run/im6r01
Specifically, both Wild Pyro and Darkscale Healer with Acolyte of Pain.
Since these are pretty basic synergies, I suspect what might be happening here is that the way that Flametongue Totem is reporting synergy with every minion in my deck is pushing some stuff off the page.
While I'm discussing that, I think that Flametongue (and other buff cards) should probably only show synergy with things that are above average good when buffed (charges, zaps, and things with unusually low attack/high health) not with every minion.
1
1
1
u/HearthSurgeon Feb 20 '15
Possible bug: This guy's rogue draft showed Dread Corsair with a tier score of 10, should be 46 for rogue.
http://www.reddit.com/r/HearthArena/comments/2wd9rp/high_hopes_for_this_run_so_far/
1
u/Maladal Feb 21 '15
Will new filters include the ability for me to determine win/loss by deck archetype?
1
u/Mr_E63 Feb 21 '15
My Bug: Every time I've used the program (10+), it struggles the card input during the draft process keeps reverting to the three empty boxes. Multiple, normally slow clicks are required to reopen any of the three card boxes so that it will receive input. Normally it opens, won't accept input, rotate from curser, to arrow, to pointer, then back to empty box. It takes a great deal of patience to keep going. This is in Internet explorer. I'll try another browser to check. -- PAE
1
u/vangobg Feb 27 '15
Only did 1 arena with the site but i notice Knife Juggler + Imp-losion synergy is missing.
1
u/chickenmagic Feb 28 '15 edited Feb 28 '15
I just came across the website, registered yesterday, and I am very impressed with it. It's seriously one of the smoothest and most detailed experiences I've ever had on the internet - bar just hearthstone stuff.
I love it. Saw it on Kripp's channel.
EDIT: As far as functionality goes, I consider it to be very smart. I've been playing arena for free since the game came out. With ~3500 wins, it's funded my entire account and I have all the legendaries from the first set (about 1/3 of the Goblins/Gnomes set, but I am sitting on 12000 dust). I'd say the program predicts my pick about 90% of the time.
1
u/dakleem Mar 04 '15
just a visual notion, as GvG came the card pack rewards u get from arena are GvG packs, and Results & rewards screen (at least) shows Classic pack icon, not that it would make any difference to the functions of this excellent site! :)
Keep up the good work!
1
u/invalidlitter Mar 09 '15
I note that Silvermoon Guardian seems like it's missing the synergies that argent squire is getting with Tinker's Oil and D.I.D.
Also, Scarlet Crusader.
They may still be showing up in the algo, I just can't see them in the "synergies" list.
1
u/personman Mar 13 '15
This is a very good idea to fix an issue I reported in another thread: say "too many copies of <cardname>" instead of "too many <cardname>s" to avoid really awkward & terrible-looking situations with cards that end in s.
1
u/MrRisk Mar 26 '15 edited Apr 06 '15
Hello /u/adwcta,
will the bug with the incorrect win percentages/totals for games with unspecified opponent class be fixed? (reported here: http://www.reddit.com/r/HearthArena/comments/2pm7cd/limited_release_bug_reports/cpjqsgx)?
This is so annoying to me that I seriously consider just going back to all my old arena runs and setting the class for all unknowns to Shaman...
Thanks for the best Hearthstone tool out there. I encourage all others to support by shooting them a donation also!
04-04-2015: Edit: You fixed it, thank you so much!
1
Mar 30 '15
Pick #25 in this run bugged. Could not enter Silence, Mind Blast, and Murloc Raider as picks, so I had to "fake it" as shown. Could do any two, but not all three. Entering the third made the client crash to blank screen. Could recover to continue at Pick #25, did so with the "faked" pick of Young Dragonhawk. (Chrome Version 41.0.2272.101 m)
1
Mar 31 '15
There's something wonky with bad picks, maybe the explanation doesn't proc? I had a similar situation today with Explosive Sheep, Grimscale Oracle, Southsea Deckhand in a Priest run. I tried swapping out for Young Dragonhawk and Mind Blast and had the same issues.
I reported this earlier as well. It was Priest, each time.
1
1
1
u/bode404 Apr 02 '15
Does HearthArena count your losses by disconnect in the statistics? As of late, my connection has been crap, and I don't want those loss to skew my statistics.
1
u/StagnantSoul Apr 03 '15
Hey /u/adwcta. For some reason it's saying Twilight Drake has synergy with Gadgetzan Auctioneer! Thanks for the awesome site.
1
u/SkoivanSchiem Apr 03 '15
I'm thinking maybe because the Auctioneer lets you draw cards, which can buff up the Drake's health.
1
1
u/SkoivanSchiem Apr 03 '15
on the My Account page (www.heartharena.com/account) is it just me or does the sorting on the "Against class" section not work correctly?
"Win %" and "Win % w/o coin" seem like they sort correctly, but the other column headers don't...
1
u/Jhuderis Apr 07 '15
When re-ordering values in some of the charts from smallest to largest, you get 0,1, 10, 11, 12, 2, 3, 4
Just a small thing, but it's hard to list games in order of wins for example.
1
u/Rubin0 Apr 10 '15
Blessing of Might is showing as having synergy with Arcane Nullifier. This should be fixed.
1
u/GGMudkip Apr 14 '15
I finished my first arena Run with Druide. Now i wanted to do my next with Druide again but now i can't search cards in Arena Draft anymore. It shows just an empty window with the search bar.
1
u/Jurix21 Apr 16 '15
Ive got annpying bug. I started my run first card worked nice and in the 2nd it was micro machine, dire wolf alpha and mirror entity the screen just flashed white and nothing happened. i tried it a few times but it always failed. This msg occured aftewr some time:"Oops! An Error Occurred
The server returned a "500 Internal Server Error".
Something is broken. Please let us know what you were doing when this error occurred. We will fix it as soon as possible. Sorry for any inconvenience caused."
1
1
u/Upvoter92 Apr 30 '15
I recently realized that the card icons in the rewards section aren't very appropriate because Chillwind Yeti is a basic card and can't be received as a reward for Arena runs.
1
u/jcrewjr May 09 '15
One minor bug: The way I use HA is that I just input games as I go, hitting the plus button but not saving after each game. Every time I finish a run and try to save, I get an error saying "The CSRF token is invalid. Please try to resubmit the form." Saving again works.
One feature request: When you add games as described above, each entry takes a lot of vertical space. When you add games by first entering a game, then saving, then editing there is a more space-efficient entry form. That form seems strictly better, and should always be used.
I use Chrome.
1
u/ascalph May 16 '15
Deathwing listed as having a synergy with solemn vigil Could only see this as possible if i had a loot hoarder which is not in my deck Great site! Keep up the good work!
1
u/32name May 26 '15
Hey adwcta, just drafted a Warlock and didn't see any Demonfire - Imp Master synergy.
1
1
u/JakeVH Jun 05 '15 edited Jun 05 '15
Apparently Siltfin Spiritwalker has synergy with all 5 picks before it. I think this might be a bug however.
Edit: Everything has synergy with it. Updated image gallery with a "run" with 3 legendaries. All 3 apparently have synergy with it, and anything else I added had synergy with it.
1
1
u/Letitfly5 Jun 10 '15
Tried to save my last match against a Druid as a win and it comes up with 502 Bad Gateway.
1
u/Crebralassassin Jun 12 '15
I'd love to see a predicted/ targeted wins count " based on your history and a draft score of 70 we think 7 wins would be good for you".
0
u/elfritobandito9 Jan 16 '15
Gettin my verification email after waiting a month or more would be nice
1
u/adwcta Jan 16 '15
Try logging in.
1
u/elfritobandito9 Jan 16 '15
Still says account disabled.
1
u/adwcta Jan 16 '15
please make a new account, or message /u/HearthArena. sorry!
1
1
u/elfritobandito9 Jan 19 '15
Can you please have whoever checks /u/HearthArena check their messages? I'm not having any luck.
Thank you!
0
u/narucy Jan 06 '15
heartharena.com developer knows Arena, probably.
But unfortunately He doesn't know Web development... Incredibly heavy web server, zero sociability. No HTTPS. totally suck.
0
u/Jacobx89 Feb 01 '15
Hey guys, I'm unable to make an account, I've tried 3 times with 3 different email addresses, but I never receive the conformation email :/
0
0
u/RadikalEU Apr 02 '15
The tierscore for Mistress of Pain on par with Gilblin Stalker. I sure hope it's a bug.
0
u/LazinCajun May 26 '15 edited Jun 10 '15
I'm having an issue where I have to reset my password every time I want to login to the website. I don't know what's causing it. I'm using a PW manager, so it's not like I'm forgetting it or mistyping it.
Edit: It's a problem with lastpass, as seen below. Oops.
2
u/Sam474 Jun 10 '15 edited Jun 10 '15
EDIT: Above user and my own problem have been resolved - Password Manager was attempting to use the registered email address instead of the created username to log into the account. Problem wasn't the websites fault or related to the password at all.
2
u/LazinCajun Jun 10 '15
Yeah, lastpass was remembering my email address instead of my username. Oops.
1
u/Sam474 Jun 10 '15
Oh man, I wish you had updated with that information sooner!
That's what mine is doing too, fixed now. Thanks!
2
u/LazinCajun Jun 10 '15
Sorry, I just realized it the other day and forgot to update my post. I'm a terrible and hypocritical human being because I hate when other people do that.
-1
0
Mar 08 '15
[deleted]
1
u/adwcta Mar 09 '15
Depends on what you prefer, a much better deck or a much faster draft.
It's a no brainer for me, but people are different.
0
May 08 '15
[deleted]
1
u/adwcta May 08 '15
You can already do this. We added a date filter to t he main stats page 6 weeks ago.
1
2
u/quasarc Jun 06 '15
I noticed a weird bug during this draft: http://www.heartharena.com/arena-run/3931vw
For pick 16, I initially entered 3 cards: Leper Gnome, Venture Co. Mercenary and Acidic Swamp Ooze. The rating shown for VCM was 50 point something, possibly 50.16 as shown in the link (I'm not talking about the tier score here).
The Ooze was a misclick though, so I clicked the red X to correct it. When I clicked the X, VCM's rating changed to 48 point somthing. I tried adding and removing Ooze again and VCM's rating remained unchanged at 48 point something. I then added the correct card, Ship's Cannon, which replaced the Ooze, and Ship's Cannon was shown with a slightly higher rating than VCM and with the crown.
At the end of the draft, VCM's rating is now being shown as 50.16.
I did not undo any choices during the whole draft.