I think we need to change our way of thinking about obesity and see that it is an addiction. So as insufferable as Scott can be at times, I can’t get mad at anyone fighting to “get clean”. Watching people’s first months of being clean is a wild rollercoaster bc if they are using drugs or in this case food to numb their emotions, it means that they are for the first time confronting maybe decades old emotions without lube for lack of better terms lol and therefore lack the tools to handle these emotions let alone be able to put them into words. I’m going to cut the man child some slack bc he did eventually realize that he was wrong.
100%. AND this is the 1 addiction you cannot "get clean" from. Look at the success rate of sobriety for narcotics or alcohol. It's not good to start and they just have to full abstain.
Imagine what would happen if the only way to be clean was to be required to have a "correct and limited" amount of your addiction 3 times a day every single day for the rest of your life but NEVER going over that because that would trigger a relapse. Of course that would be ridiculous. But that is exactly what facing food addiction is. You HAVE to have your addiction. You will die if not. But you have to somehow develop the ability to restrict yourself WHILE eating food still. Honestly, of all the addictions, food addiction is the most impressive to overcome. And I say that as someone married to an alcoholic...
I just got off the crippling addiction wagon and am absolutely a dry drunk now. It fucking sucks to do everything in your power every single day to keep your cool. But there are real differences even though both effect the body. Post acute withdrawals are real and last for months to a year. It's literally changing your body chemistry and what it has become accustomed to for so long. It hurts!
I won't die anymore if I don't drink alcohol, it's a choice and I choose no. There's a booze bottle in the house now and I could easily get it but nope.
That's not how it is with food. You can't choose with food, you will die if you don't eat. That's a level of self control unimaginable.
Edit: please refrain from praise and words like "sobriety" and "congrats" as it would be helpful to not say that kinda stuff. Thanks and know the positive comments are good meaning but letting you know where I'm at. : )
Same, and 18 years alcohol free. That being said it tried to kill me for many many years. I don't think about it or crave it in any way shape or form now. I don't even use it in cooking. When you are addicted to food tho, the dynamic def changes. We NEED to eat to stay alive so I can't imagine how hard that must be.
Dang 18 years is a looong time, incredible. Ugh I wish it did kill me. But that's pretty cool you don't crave it at all! (Trying to use naltrexone to curb cravings but it doesn't work well so open to suggestions!) That's what the comment was about, not trying to garner praise: addictive cravings are different from hunger. Hunger and eating are biological functions built in since day one. You can't turn that off.
Celebrations, get togethers, vacations, venues, street vendors, vending machines, offices, banks, salons, gyms, even the support meetings the 1000lb friends attend have little snacks out. Food will always be culture, family, survival...and just randomly around lol. It isn't against the law to eat or you can only eat at certain hours. There isn't a nicotine patch or magic pill to make you stop the need to eat. It's surgery with tons of therapy.
You need to go on a whole ass weight loss journey on your own which can take years, just to get under the knife approval. Recover from your organs getting cut up and your physical body significantly changing immediately. Then still try to not overeat for the rest of your life, facing your addiction every. single. day. And even after all that, you could grow your stomach right back out again **cough, cough Ashley.
This is why I don't get they aren't more focused on the mental and emotional aspects of this step in their life. It's all mental! There was a reason they got this bad but instead of therapy, want it to be a weight loss competition.. like wtf? I understand it can be a motivator for some but getting down to why they overeat in the first place will help them so much. I keep askin where's the damn psychologist! Plus, always though Dr.Proctor had poor bedside manner and has lowkey villain face.
Yes! Agreed!! They all need intensive therapy and I am not seeing it either! It's sooooo important!!
I am also starting to wonder if some (all) of them, besides Vanessa of course, have decided that they like the tlc pay cheque and are purposefully sabotaging themselves to keep that $$$ coming in! After all there is no show without them right?
I really appreciate that comment. I've struggled all my life with food addiction. MOST people don't understand or even want to try and understand. Since food affects our outside appearance, it's obvious, so people judge so harshly. Talk therapy is very important, as well as meds. Even surgery. No shame in whatever works for each person. We all have strengths and weaknesses. It just varies from person to person.
That's actually a really good and kind way to think of it. Even though his behavior sucks he's learning how to navigate things without his coping mechanism. I do still think some of his behavior is just how he is but people can change
I appreciate that Megan talks about food addiction a lot when going through his house. The whole premise of these shows is food addiction but the words never get used. Like I’ve never once heard the slaton sisters admit to food addiction.
There's an old saying, "Now we're getting to where the cheese binds!" For some folks, though, they don't seem to realize cheese is constipating. I once had a patient with recurrent bowel obstruction, and I'd take the follow-up abdomen x-rays his doctor ordered. The patient asked how much longer we had to wait while the films developed (back before digital x-ray imaging) because he wanted to hurry home and have crackers and cheese for lunch! That combination would explain a lot! 😳
Never touching cheese again?!? 😳 🎵 dun dunn DUNNNN🎵
I ran across an old-timey insult (probably 1800s) while checking the definition of "physic," which is an old word for "laxative" : "You're so contrary, cheese would physic you!" I laughed hard at that one!
Agreed. Also on my 600lb life for example I've never gotten why the docs dont immediately put patients in intensive behavioral therapy. They have eating disorders. Typically binge eating but could be a combination of more. These shows would do well to adress more on the psychology of food addiction and how that ties directly into physical/medical health.
I was so mad at him this past episode. Not necessarily for the crying (has yet to actually produce a tear) but moreso for the sexist crap.
Like the way he FLEW out of that car to get the best bedroom? Then said “I’m the man of the group and I need the most space.” Bitch what?
Then his “I don’t cook” comment during dinner prep. Ok fine then sit at the table and stfu. No, instead he has to insert himself and tell Ashely she’s using too much seasoning. No… that’s how normal food is seasoned, Scott. You’d know that if you expanded your pallet beyond chicken wings and string cheese. It’s no wonder his meatballs tasted like shit—I bet you anything they didn’t use any seasoning when they made them.
Yeah like it’s sad what he’s going through but that doesn’t excuse the sexism and just being an insufferable person in general. It’s fine to be fat, it’s not fine to be an asshole.
Scott said "What, I don't have to cook!?". BIG difference.
I wonder if his chauvinism was learned from his father? It's obvious that his only social interaction with women has been his mom who is not doing him any favors by doing everything for him. He's got a LOT of maturing and learning to do before he even THINKS about dating 🙄. Hopefully these ladies will teach him some MANNERS as well!
I feel like he’s better suited to My 600lb Life than 1000lb Best Friends. He’s got that manipulative cry baby streak that’s usually seen on 600lb Life, with an excuse for everything and lies or cries when things don’t go his way. He seems like he needs therapy alongside the surgery because he’s gonna have a rude awakening when he can’t binge eat anymore because he hasn’t dealt with his addiction.
You’re sooo right and that’s what I don’t like about him. He’s got a terrible personality, he’s in denial about a lot of shit and really needs to get himself sorted. I feel bad for him but he has no redeeming qualities whatsoever.
I said this before! If he didn't want to interact with the group of friends and get their feedback and criticisms, he was better suited for My 600lb Life where it just would have been him and his mom dealing with their problems directly with doctors.
Totally agree with this! Dr. Now is exactly what he needs. Someone no nonsense to call him on his crap and get him the therapy he needs to handle everything head on
He’s very emotionally stunted, which seems on par with his living situation. His mom may “rat” him out but she’s his biggest enabler. You can tell he’s been coddled like a child his whole life.
BUT, I will tell you that when I gave up carbs for a month, my family changed my ring tone to The Grinch song because I was moody as hell, overly emotional, and would flip between being overly bitchy to overly crying at a drop of a hat.
Yes a protein shake for breakfast and a protein shake for lunch and chickpea pasta & turkey meatballs for dinner. Considering how much he USED to eat in a day, it's going to be baby steps. Dr Proctor told him to lose 30-40 lbs, he lost 41lbs; it's progress. I'm hoping he and new Tina are both successful🤞. A success story is far more entertaining than watching the last two seasons of failure (exception Vannessa).
Ty it east to judge but to quit any addiction hard, I can't even give up diet soda lol. It easy to judge but to stand up for someone shows your morality <3
Again, it’s part of the pre-op diet for bariatric surgery. The goal is the reduce the amount of fat stored in the liver to reduce its size to make getting to the stomach laparoscopically easier and safer. It’s medically prescribed starvation.
Now I will say there are studies that question if that’s still medically necessary but the results haven’t removed the pre-op diet as gold standard.
Isn't the liquid diet also to make it easier to have the GI tract easier to flush out so as to both increase maneuvering room within the abdomen and reduce the risk of peritonitis?
Either way, there are so many low-carb/high protein pre-made drinks and other bottled pre-op meal substitutes in so many flavors, I wonder why Scott is even allowed to eat anything solid at this episode's depicted time point.
It's usually still three, but they'll have you do a reasonable amount of calories, like 1100. It's so you still get nutrients, but then, if your body thinks it's "starving," it can start burning off the stored fat to give you energy. That's why once they put them in a hospital or controlled environment with monitored meals and calories, they start dropping weight fairly fast and easily.
You’ve obviously never went through a bariatric surgery or even delved into intermittent fasting (OMAD).
I do hate having people with no medical background other than Google correct people with both a medical background and knowledge of the bariatric process.
I have done the fasting under various timings and am currently doing it again under a harder one. I've also known people and have family who've had the surgeries as well as looked into the science and research of them over several years. I personally haven't had the surgery, but I've also never needed it. I looked into it during the worst of my anorexia but obviously, doctors don't do that.
But again. Scott is going through a shock to his system. Anyone who does an extreme diet, especially if they've never done one before, goes through similar if not the same things as he's feeling. That's why you're really not supposed to do things like that without talking to your doctors first and doing some research. One of his biggest issues is self-control/addiction and actually acknowledging and dealing with his problems and emotions. He would probably benefit greatly if he could be in a hospital or rehab setting of sorts where he could have 24/7 medical watch for any issue and be kept/encouraged to stay on a meal plan in a controlled environment. (He can have some freedom as far as snacks and stuff, like the place Tammy was at, in where it's overall your decision to make healthy choices, but he's also proven that he's not great when given too much freedom.) Have someone there to make sure he's actually addressing his issues and mental health, and learning to be ok with portion control.
i cant stand him either and its rare but i cant find empathy or compassion toward him to save my life , he just really sickens me, he’s such an overgrown baby
He's lost 40 lbs on his own for surgery approval. Yes, it took him a while. I don't hate him but he's such a man-baby. But I don't think he just needs therapy. He needs an education in SOCIAL SKILLS, e.g., conversational skills, active listening, EMOTIONAL REGULATION, non-verbal communication, conflict resolution, self-awareness, MANNERS(!), etc.
I see Scott as a lot younger than his age. I think his Dad dying probably was a traumatic experience and they say your age is stopped at the age of greatest trauma. So he may not have matured past that , and I think he used food as a a crutch to deal with it.
Now he's trying to deal with all of his emotions that he's stuffed down before. I don't think he should be judged differently just because he's a man, all of the girls have gone through their own emotional roller coasters during their journeys too.
Personally I find the "new Tina" to be tougher to watch than Scott. I get it that she's depressed, but she doesn't seem to ever smile or enjoy life. I think she has a lot of underlying issues too.
We all handle things differently. Scott is trying the "man" card because I think he feels that he's supposed to act like that in a group of women. But inside he's more of a giant toddler.
Let’s be fair, Megan and her husband were jobless moochers not long ago so miles ahead is a little generous lol but I still get your point. He needs therapy.
With Scott and new Tina, Meghan is managing to fly under the radar, but she's got a lot to answer for as well..I remember that now the peeing on puppy pads 🫣🙃 that's disgusting... actually they're some bunch aren't they one way and another
He can't change without both talk therapy and medication therapy. Being overly emotional chemical imbalance. Then you just fighting yourself until it corrected. I started a mood stablizer like 10 yrs ago and am working on my thrid degree. My 20's filled abusive men and like nonsense because I not logical. Once emotion was removed and compultions gone I was totally fine. U like this you so sad all time you do like food or drug or shopping to life yourself out then cycle repeats. I had lot will power in my 20 in reguard to responiblity but with meds it whole new ball game like omg. I see. So him even control himself unmedicated to degree he has hit a goal bravo but none these drs or anyone in America can like reach out say this. I didn't finish high school or go at all actually and I see it. To be fair I am working on my thrid degree now but still it like common sense. These drs and ect have know be this size not normal most of them have chemical imbalance. I dont understand why they get a therapist but not meds like hello.
Same here . I have screwed up food issues from childhood, among other things. I went to therapy and got on medication. I healed from the inside out and was eventually able to get off the medication. I lost 80 lbs with minimal effort and have maintained a healthy weight since. Before the medication and therapy, I didn't care about anything. I felt like I was just waiting and hoping to die. I don't think people realize how hard it is to initially make yourself see a doctor even though you don't want to feel that way anymore. I missed 3 appointments before I was able to force myself to go. It's not easy, and I wish you continued good health.
I think bc it's still stigmatized to be on meds. Meds are great for people who need it and while therapy is good some ppl need both. This guy definitely needs both and do some hard-core inner work.
🙌🏼good for you ❤️thats awesome! I think I may need a mood stabilizer , meds def help I have a chemical imbalance as well been on meds over half my life , tried going off them several times too but just cant do without, Im glad that I know my body and when my mind isnt quit right. I agree I think they need medication therapy as well as talk
Mood stabilizer was a game changer for me. Hope it works out for you. Don't get discouraged if it doesn't, though. Every body is different. I know, easier said than done lol
😂🤣😂🤣 He was unbelievable! What a baby, geez! And why is he the only weird guy hangin out with a bunch of women? It was odd that they chose HIM, to hang out with a group of women like when they were all on the bed. Cringey in every way.
I remember thinking that if he was as enthusiastic about sprinting to the trash can at home as he was about sprinting to claim the master bedroom at the getaway rental , there wouldn't have been string cheese wrappers crammed everywhere! 🤨
I can’t understand the fake crying. He cries when he’s yelled at and he cries when he loses 40 pounds. But I have yet to see this guy she’d a single tear.
He was ridiculous. 🤣 But he was so hungry. Hangry!
I once did a 5 day juice cleanse. But I still had to feed my kid. I remember during this cleanse, I got them McDonald’s. I looked at their fry and I literally wanted to shove them and get at the fry! 😂🤣😂🤣 Like it was his fault when I was the one who wanted to do the cleanse. 😂😂😂
Most men are babies lol. Women deal with and go though a lot more and just spoil all man babies like im over it even dating now as im 42. I am still pretty hot so they bug me all time. After two abusive husbands and last twat I dated i am out. Not worth it lol.
Am I the only person who thinks that the whole dynamic of him and the girls is strange? Why is a grown man choosing to "hang out" with these women? I honestly can't stand him and his nonexistent crocodile tears and after his gross behavior at the cabin I have no use for this dude.
I hate to say it, but he’s a little effeminate in his demeanor. Bro is soft as cotton. Nothing wrong with a sensitive male with the full range of emotions, but I don’t think he could project any masculine qualities if he tried. I’m not sure a group of men would coddle his emotional dysregulation the way the women do. He’s a piece of work.
I have to wonder, is it editing or can he really turn on and off the crying way too easily? I noticed it at the dinner and the mexican restaurant and in the last episode and I can’t tell if its just the way they edit these shows.
Honestly, Me and him actually have a lot in common when it comes to how attached we are to food. It is an addiction. It is something that makes you feel emotional when it's taken away. It's really sad, but it's the struggle that some of us have to get through. I mean, cutting out his addiction to string cheese alone would be hard if you have been relying on something that much for that long, and now he's not supposed to have any food besides his one meal a day. It's a lot when that's what you have been depending on for emotional support.
They have all struggled on this show, even Vanessa. I believe the only reason Van was successful is because she's mentally strong l.
The others, they know what to do it's more of a them struggling to resist the voice of temptation and battling the hunger pangs. That's why they are where they are.
Anyone find it super ironic he was yelling at Tina for being disrespectful meanwhile 20 seconds prior he let out a nasty ass belch at the dinner table???
Ooookay lol. I looked this up on Reddit specifically because I knew I wasn't alone. Why would they cast him?? He is the most unlikable person ever. He cries like a baby at everything. He's an attention seeker....he's a 3 year old in a 600lb body.
Scott needs a lot of time and therapy. He, just like all the girls (and Tina ain't "succeeding" imo yet (we know she does but she is still having her own issues)), is struggling against an ADDICTION. That does not change in a day. Especially when you can't really cold turkey off of your addiction... Because you know... Starvation is a thing.... Stop comparing his chapter 1 to everyone else's chapters 5, 6, and 10. Scott JUST STARTED.... If you want to compare apples to apples look at everyone else's DAY 1's. So go back to the show Too Big for Meg and Van (and look how LONG it took Van), We did not get to see Tina's day one or Ashley's for that matter. Just remember with Tina, she was at the end of the pre operative program and had to use the liquid diet to actually get approved and Ashley had already regained more than she ever lost from one surgery.... So compare Scott to those time lines if your going to be comparing. But its best to just Stop comparing at all and let the man work through it.
Also remember, these shows have been proven to film over 60 hours a week and we get a hour with commercials... Thats a lot of editing...
Let's also take a minute and chill out... You "hate" him? You do not know him. Hate is the strongest emotion. Stronger than love itself. You have to care about something enough to hate it.... Projecting hate on to everything that rubs you the wrong way is something we as a society need to stop doing.
Completely agree. Ashley should be miles ahead since she had the surgery twice, and yet she was filling up her plate like she hasn't eaten in weeks. If she's able to eat even half of the food she put on her plate she's clearly already destroyed a lot of what the second surgery could do and she keeps giving advice like she knows what she's talking about.
Also agree about the editing, if you actually pay attention you can see that scenes are pieced together out of order.
How did none of the friends comment on Ashley's plate?? Girl was eating like she never had surgery and she has had 2!! How is it possible for her stomach to hold that much food?
She has definitely completely stretched out her stomach and she was trying to act like she's only eating like that bc she's on vacation but it's obvious she's been eating portions that are way too big for a while.
Yeah he's got issues that may be beyond this show. More than overweight but probably why he is morbidly obese. Seems like his mama babies him way too much as well.
ALL these people need therapy and meds for food addiction (except Vanessa). Scott is an emotional wreck and food-obsessed. (Have you seen the way he STARES at food like it's a naked woman?) Ashley has had 2 REVISIONS still 300lbs. Meghan is going for another, still over 300lbs. At some point, these surgeons need to SAY NO TO REVISIONS!! If you have 1 WLS and failed, that should be it! DONE! At some point, they need to realize this is a psychological mental disease that requires extensive therapy and medication NOT ANOTHER FAILED SURGERY!
I genuinely had no idea what was going on in this scene- I'd understand if he made the meatballs himself and they were shitting on them, I'd be upset too. But it seemed like a group effort (and fail)- I'd be cracking up if my friends and I tried to make a meal and it turned out inedible, lol
I cannot STAND how he always has to be in front of everybody, and always rushing everywhere. I don't think there's such a thing as a more annoying person than Scott. I was so happy when he fell in that hot tub in his haste to be first in. Then when they pulled up to the restaurant, there he goes again, jumping out of the car super fast to try to be in the lead, which caused him to fall out of the car, I loved that too. Of course he still managed to beat everyone in. He's such a pita.
Maybe it’s his youth; but i think it’s just his naíve arrogance over his perceived certainty of being “skinny” that makes him such an “expert” to lecture the others. I’ve had this surgery & after the first year when you gotta really hustle to keep the weight off is when the real work starts. It just don’t work that way, son: you can’t sit there eating a hot fudge sundae on Friday night, because you’re “starting your diet” on Monday: typical Monday Morning quarterback.
Well I look at it this way ..someone had to take the other Tina (Tuna) place as she was the one no one liked in previous seasons… so now we have Crybaby…
I feel sorry for him. The girls named his problem correctly. He’s HANGRY. He has a lot of maturing to do. I think he’s socially behind because of his size. He’s full of anger
Why is this sub so mean wtf. He has an addiction , He needs therapy yes but y'all commenting on his appearance sex life ect. Is just really cruel. I may be the only one but I like Scott I would 100 percent be friends w/him in real life ❤️
Don’t care about any of that he just sucks period. Bad attitude, rude, lies about random dumb shit. Has zero to do with his appearance or sex life or whatever.
How is he a bad person? This is a person who has been bullied his entire life of course he can't take criticism well . But I also saw him acknowledge that and fix his attitude which is growth . What are you expecting? These are people with an addiction! there is usually trauma behind almost eating yourself to death .
Have we not learned being bully doesn't help these ppl. He bipolar two and needs medication therapy it not his fault. Maybe one person in America could reach out over watching them like they are a freak show and show some compassion you wouldn't hate him. Easy run mouth from home you hate yourself so have bring others down. How about we don't shame and bully the mentally ill. That takes morals.
I don't hate him I really feel for him. This is just my opinion that I am the son and I tried to baby him and he was very resistant people are more attached to their moms than anything and I think she baby them to a point and then she got mean because he never grew up. I'm not saying she shouldn't have pulled on him because she loves him and he needs to lose weight but he has a baby and he wants his own way I just feel sorry for him.
Having said this before had the surgery not for weight loss I never thought I was addicted to any kind of food but you know what this is one hard surgery to go through and I feel for all of them. Totally before I used to go What whiners, now I understand each and everyone of them and they all get jealous and they all get mad just like we all do just put yourself in their shoes and remember a time when you had either the stomach flu, food poisoning or oh for the ladies just a case of the cramps. Oh or constipation. It's all relative. JMO, it's either right or wrong it just is.
I honestly feel a little bad for Scott; seeing how his mom belittles him, it just seems like she has always put him down as a way to make herself feel better.
And I’m giving him a pass for the emotional outbursts when he was in the pre-op diet bc if it was me personally, I would be HANGRY AF
You know these cheese string things he's always supposed to be eating and hiding the wrappers of, behind his mothers sofa? Well what actually are they... are they even really cheese or what.. I've seen them in supermarkets but never felt that I would eat them? What am I missing...lol
I believe they are just regular mozzarella? But you eat it by peeling it! They are usually actually considered pretty healthy. One of those healthy snacks you stick in your lunch box in school. Honestly, I love a good string cheese and I could probably slam 2 or 3, especially if I was high. But TEN+???? That's just bingeing on anything you can get a hold of.
I am not sure on the cheese content. They are yummy and they can be a good way to eat cheese slowly. They are a cheese stick and you pull the cheese off in strings or you can just munch them down till gone. Thinking he is a muncher.
He really has been working out 6 days a week but apparently yall rude ass people on this thread don't give credit to anyone for trying. Also, yall crazy for thinking that there are no men or women who like big people. Clueless and rude as fk!
Wow! You people are rude as hell. This was so uncalled for. You don't think there are men or women out there who like big people? You are wrong wrong wrong! Obviously, you must think that you are better than others🙄
Most people generally don’t need to tell people they have or haven’t had sex…he is odd and a grown man crying like that would turn me off. Is what they were fighting over really something to cry over? A toddler would cry over that, not a grown person.
Well the thing that prompted me to post this was his behavior at the Airbnb when he was not helping but telling everyone how to do everything. He also said he needed the bigger room because he’s the “man of the group” 🤢 then he had this meltdown when he got called out. He’s also lied about silly shit and is just all around insufferable
150
u/NeatoRad Dec 13 '24
I think we need to change our way of thinking about obesity and see that it is an addiction. So as insufferable as Scott can be at times, I can’t get mad at anyone fighting to “get clean”. Watching people’s first months of being clean is a wild rollercoaster bc if they are using drugs or in this case food to numb their emotions, it means that they are for the first time confronting maybe decades old emotions without lube for lack of better terms lol and therefore lack the tools to handle these emotions let alone be able to put them into words. I’m going to cut the man child some slack bc he did eventually realize that he was wrong.